Cato v Manaia Media Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV 2017-404-3091

[2021] NZHC 2696

UNDER The Defamation Act 1992

BETWEEN

KRISTIN PIA CATO

Plaintiff

AND

MANAIA MEDIA LIMITED

First Defendant

ROWAN DIXON
Second Defendant

JANE THOMPSON

Third Defendant

On the papers

Counsel:

S J Mills QC and E D Nilsson for the Plaintiff S A McKenna and R G Scott for the Defendants

Judgment:

8 October 2021


JUDGMENT OF CAMPBELL J

(Application for leave to serve replacement brief)


This judgment was delivered by me on 8 October 2021 at 3:00pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

CATO v MANAIA MEDIA LIMITED [2021] NZHC 2696 [8 October 2021]

[1]                 In my judgment dated 2 September 2021, I ruled that the expert brief of evidence by Paul Collins, which the plaintiff had served in advance of trial, was not admissible. My judgment dealt with several other admissibility challenges made by the parties.

[2]                 Two days before I delivered that judgment, I vacated the jury trial that had been scheduled to commence 6 September 2021. That reflected the inability to conduct a jury trial under a COVID-19 lockdown. A new trial has been scheduled for 1 August 2022.

[3]                 By memoranda dated 22 and 24 September 2021, the plaintiff applies for leave to serve another brief of evidence by Mr Collins. The plaintiff proposes the replacement brief would comply with observations made in my judgment about Mr Collins’ earlier brief and therefore be admissible. The plaintiff accepts the defendants should then have an opportunity to serve a brief in response to the replacement brief.

[4]The defendants oppose the application.

Submissions

[5]                 The plaintiff sought leave under r 9.8, or alternatively r 1.19, of the High Court Rules 2016. Rule 9.8 provides that a party wishing to offer a supplementary brief must serve it as soon as possible. The acceptance and use of the supplementary brief is at the discretion of the trial judge. Rule 1.19 allows the court, in its discretion, to extend the time for any step in a proceeding, on such terms as the court thinks just.

[6]                 Mr Mills QC, for the plaintiff, submitted I should exercise my discretion to grant leave allowing service of a supplementary brief by Mr Collins because:

(a)Granting leave will not cause material prejudice to the defendants. They will have ample time to consider the replacement brief and to prepare any brief in response, given the trial is not until August 2022;

(b)That the replacement brief might improve the plaintiff’s case is not, without more, a basis on which to decline leave.

[7]                 Mr McKenna, for the defendants, submitted the plaintiff was attempting to work around my ruling that Mr Collins’ brief is inadmissible. He said any replacement brief would be artificially produced.

Decision

[8]                 Rule 9.8 is not applicable. To engage that rule a party must serve the supplementary brief. The trial judge then decides, by reference to the content…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cato v Manaia Media Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZHC 2696
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cato v Manaia Media Limited involves a dispute under the Defamation Act 1992. The plaintiff, Kristin Pia Cato, is suing the defendants Manaia Media Limited, Rowan Dixon, and Jane Thompson for defamation. The central issue in this case pertains to the admissibility of expert evidence in the form of a brief submitted by Paul Collins, an expert witness for the plaintiff. In a previous judgment, the court had ruled that Mr Collins' initial brief was inadmissible, prompting the plaintiff to seek leave to serve a replacement brief that would comply with the court's observations on admissibility. The defendants opposed this application, arguing that it was an attempt to circumvent the previous ruling.

The court considered the application under the relevant rules of the High Court Rules 2016, specifically rules 9.8 and 1.19, which govern the supplementation of briefs and the extension of time for procedural steps, respectively. The court noted that while rule 9.8 is not applicable in this instance since the replacement brief has not yet been served, rule 1.19 allows the court to extend time for procedural steps. The court applied the principles guiding the exercise of discretion under rule 9.8, emphasizing the interests of justice, balancing the potential prejudice to the defendants against the benefit to the plaintiff, and considering the ample time available before the rescheduled trial date. The court decided that the application for leave should be granted, allowing the plaintiff to serve a replacement brief and the defendants to respond, thereby avoiding substantial prejudice to the plaintiff while mitigating potential prejudice to the defendants through appropriate timing and cost orders.

The court granted the plaintiff's application for leave to serve a replacement brief by Mr Collins, extending the time for the parties to serve their briefs of evidence. The plaintiff must serve the replacement brief by 5 November 2021, and the defendants must serve any response by 17 December 2021. The court made no order as to costs on the application, reserving the matter for potential consideration following the trial. This decision ensures that the proceedings can continue with the inclusion of the expert evidence, subject to any admissibility challenges that may arise upon the serving of the replacement brief.