Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2016-404-000779 [2017] NZHC 2705

BETWEEN

STEPHEN PATRICK FITZGERALD,

NICOLA MARY FITZGERALD AND HAMISH ALEXANDER SCOTT Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 2 November 2017

Appearances:

S P Rennie and R Harris for Plaintiffs
C Jamiesonand M Gall for Defendant

Judgment:

2 November 2017

ORAL JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

FITZGERALD v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2017] NZHC 2705 [2 November 2017]

[1]      Thank you for your submissions counsel.   I will give a decision now with respect to matters before the Court.  Of necessity, given the time, it will need to be relatively brief and next week hopefully I will follow it up with some more detailed reasons and a way forward in this matter.  But it will be apparent from what I am saying that on a conditional basis the applications before the Court will be approved and, with some reluctance, the trial of this matter due to commence on Monday next for five days, will need to be adjourned.

[2]      The proceeding between these parties some time ago was set down for a five day trial to commence in this Court on Monday next, 6 November 2017.  Before the Court today, arranged at some considerable haste, is an interlocutory application for leave brought by the defendant to offer supplementary briefs of evidence.   This application  is  dated  1  November  2017  and  is  supported  by  an  affidavit  of Abbey Frances Bradford, also dated 1 November 2017.

[3]      The application is opposed by the plaintiffs.  That opposition is supported by affidavits   of   Stephen   Patrick   Fitzgerald,   sworn   1   November   2017,   and Robert Bruce Smith, also sworn 1 November 2017.

[4]      The application seeks leave for the defendant to offer supplementary briefs of evidence from:

(a)       Craig Brian Lewis, IAG's previously instructed structural engineer in this matter, this brief dated 21 September 2017; and

(b)Donald Edward Bruggers, a geotechnical engineer who has had no previous  involvement  in  this  proceeding,  this  brief  being  dated

27 October 2017.

[5]      Mr Lewis is a structural engineer who was engaged by the defendant some time ago, was engaged in providing a joint report with a structural engineer engaged by the plaintiffs and he has provided an initial brief of evidence for this matter.  By way of contrast, Mr Bruggers was engaged by the defendant in this proceeding only

a matter of about three weeks ago and previously had not been engaged in any way in this matter.

[6]      The  admission  of  the  supplementary  briefs  of  evidence  here  is  at  the discretion of the Court and leave is required.   Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules provides:

9.8      Supplementary briefs

(1)      A party wishing to offer a supplementary brief must serve it as soon as possible.

(2)      The acceptance and use of the supplementary brief in court will be at the discretion of the trial Judge.

[7]      The  discretion  under  r  9.8(2)  is  a  broad  one.    The  guiding  principle  or touchstone…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2705
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited, the plaintiffs, Stephen Patrick Fitzgerald, Nicola Mary Fitzgerald, and Hamish Alexander Scott, sought damages against the defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited, for losses allegedly incurred due to property damage. The case was scheduled for a five-day trial starting on 6 November 2017. The defendant sought leave to offer supplementary briefs of evidence from two engineers: Craig Brian Lewis, a structural engineer, and Donald Edward Bruggers, a geotechnical engineer, both of whom had not been previously involved in the proceedings. The plaintiffs opposed the application, arguing that the late introduction of this evidence would prejudice their ability to respond adequately.

The court considered the application under Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules, which grants discretion to the trial judge regarding the acceptance and use of supplementary briefs. The court examined the principles guiding this discretion, emphasizing the need to balance the interests of justice and the potential prejudice to either party. The court also noted the importance of considering the stage of the proceedings and the opportunity for parties to respond to the new evidence.

The court concluded that the evidence from Donald Edward Bruggers should be admitted as it addressed a crucial issue in the case. However, due to the late introduction of this evidence, the trial had to be adjourned to allow the plaintiffs to properly respond and obtain expert advice. The court reserved its decision on the supplementary brief from Craig Brian Lewis to allow for further consideration.

The trial was vacated and adjourned, with directions to reschedule it for the first available date after 1 February 2018. The court also directed the Registrar to liaise with counsel to set a new trial date and to provide a memorandum addressing additional matters, including a "will say" statement and submissions on costs. Costs were reserved for further directions.