Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE

CIV-2016-404-000779

[2017] NZHC 2717

BETWEEN

STEPHEN PATRICK FITZGERALD, NICOLA MARY FITZGERALD AND HAMISH ALEXANDER SCOTT

Plaintiffs

AND

IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 2 November 2017

Appearances:

S P Rennie and R Harris for Plaintiffs C Jamieson and M Gall for Defendant

Judgment:

6 November 2017


JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J


FITZGERALD v IAG NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2017] NZHC 2717 [6 November 2017]

[1]        This judgment relates to an application by the defendant in this proceeding for leave to offer a supplementary brief of evidence of Craig Brian Lewis.

[2]        Argument on this application together with a further application for leave regarding a brief of evidence of a geotechnical engineer, Mr Bruggers, who the defendant  proposed  to  introduce  in  this  proceeding,  was  heard  before  me  on   2 November 2017. At that point I gave my oral decision with respect to the leave application relating to Mr Bruggers’ evidence but I reserved my decision with respect to the supplementary brief of evidence from Mr Lewis. I now give that decision with respect to the evidence of Mr Lewis.

[3]        As I noted in my oral judgment of 2 November 2017, Mr Lewis is a structural engineer who, some time ago was engaged by the defendant in this proceeding. He provided a joint report with a structural engineer engaged by the plaintiff to assist the parties in this proceeding and, in addition, he has provided an initial brief of evidence for the hearing of this matter.

[4]        The supplementary brief of evidence from Mr Lewis proposes to introduce a portion of a Christchurch City Council property file relating to this matter. The file relates to a proposed addition to the house in question in 2015 which, I understand, did not proceed. Although this addition obviously included foundation design, the plaintiffs’ initial position was that it was difficult for the Court to say this was relevant to the determination at issue here as to whether the original foundation of the dwelling should be repaired or rebuilt.

[5]        Notwithstanding this, the defendant contends that the plaintiffs’ objection to Mr Lewis’ supplementary brief of evidence which is confined to questions of admissibility cannot succeed here. The defendant says this material which had been omitted earlier must be admissible as it relates to matters at the heart of this proceeding, whether the foundation of the dwelling can be repaired or rebuilt. It seems it includes a producer statement from a recognised firm of engineers relating to a design for foundations it is said to extend and alter the existing foundations of the dwelling and for which the Christchurch City Council was prepared to issue the plaintiffs with a building consent for that particular form of design.

[6]        As I note in my 2 November 2017 oral judgment in this proceeding, the admission of a supplementary brief of evidence must be at the discretion of the Court and leave is required.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NZHC 2717
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Fitzgerald v IAG New Zealand Limited, the plaintiffs, Stephen Patrick Fitzgerald, Nicola Mary Fitzgerald, and Hamish Alexander Scott, brought a case against the defendant, IAG New Zealand Limited, in the High Court of New Zealand Christchurch Registry. The dispute revolves around the defendant's application for leave to offer a supplementary brief of evidence from Craig Brian Lewis, a structural engineer who had been engaged by the defendant. The plaintiffs objected to the admission of this supplementary evidence, which pertained to a proposed addition to the house in question that did not proceed in 2015. The key legal issues before the court were whether the supplementary brief of evidence could be admitted under Rule 9.8 of the High Court Rules, and whether its admission would be in the interests of justice.

The court considered the principles relevant to granting leave for a supplementary brief of evidence, including the particular facts and circumstances of the case, the balance of prejudice to the parties, and whether the supplementary brief improves the evidential case of the party seeking to offer it. Given that the supplementary evidence related to issues within the plaintiffs' knowledge and ample time was available for them to respond, the court was satisfied that leave should be granted for the admission of the supplementary brief of evidence. Additionally, the trial of the matter had already been vacated and rescheduled to 2018 to allow the plaintiffs time to consider the new evidence.

The court granted the defendant's application, allowing the supplementary brief of evidence from Craig Brian Lewis to be admitted in the trial of the proceeding. The costs were reserved.