Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Cavalier Bremworth Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA564/2013
[2014] NZCA 418

BETWEEN

GODFREY HIRST NZ LIMITED
Appellant

AND

CAVALIER BREMWORTH LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

17 June 2014

Court:

Stevens, Wild and Miller JJ

Counsel:

JCL Dixon and J B Hamlin for Appellant
S E Fitzgerald and J Edwards for Respondent
V E Casey and M M Borrowdale for Commerce Commission as Intervenor

Judgment:

27 August 2014 at 11 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

BInsofar as it is inconsistent with this judgment, the judgment of the High Court is set aside.

CThere is no order as to the costs of the appeal.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Wild J)

Table of Contents

Para No
Introduction [1]
Background [6]
The law [12]
Who is the consumer? [17]
What standard of care is to be expected of the consumer? [51]
Did the High Court impose on the consumer too high a standard?
           Limits on our consideration [55]
           The representations on the website [57]
           The principles in considering headline representations with qualifying information [59]
           Did the High Court apply these principles? [60]
           The dominant message conveyed by the website [71]
           Was that dominant message misleading? [73]
Was the qualifying information on the website sufficiently prominent? [83]
Tendency to entice consumers into the “marketing web”? [84]
The carpet labels [85]
Relief [90]
Costs [94]
Result [97]

Introduction

  1. “Fly to Sydney for $50”.  “Hire a car for only $20 a day”.  Consumers are familiar with such offers.  Sometimes scrutiny of the conditions attaching to the offer shows it is not what it seems.  For example, the $20 per day rate is available only if the car is hired for at least a week during certain off-peak periods.[1]  Such offers or representations are sometimes called “headlines”, and the terms and conditions attaching to them “qualifiers”.  We adopt that convenient, if somewhat jargonistic, terminology.

    [1]Roughly the fact situation in Commerce Commission v Leisure Rentals Ltd [2002] DCR 69 (DC).

  2. This case concerns headline representations made by the respondent (Cavalier).  In the judgment under appeal Gilbert J held the qualifiers to those representations meant the representations breached ss 9 and 13(i) of the Fair Trading Act 1986 (the Act) in some of the many respects alleged by the appellant (Godfrey Hirst).[2]  Prior to the hearing in the High Court Cavalier had altered the representations and, following the hearing, gave the Court an undertaking not to repeat them.

  3. Counsel for Godfrey Hirst opened their argument to us by accepting Godfrey Hirst had largely achieved success in the High Court, obtaining most of what it had sought either through the judgment or through Cavalier’s earlier withdrawal of the representations and subsequent undertaking.  Counsel claimed this appeal was brought in the public interest, motivated by an altruistic desire to “clean up” the carpet manufacturing industry, so there was a “level playing field” for carpet manufacturers in terms of the representations they…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Cavalier Bremworth Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 418
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an appeal from Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd (the appellant) against a decision of the High Court which found that Cavalier Bremworth Ltd (the respondent) had made misleading and deceptive representations in advertising its Habitat Collection range of synthetic carpets. The appeal was heard by the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, and the final judgment was delivered by Wild J. The court allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment of the High Court, and declined to grant declaratory relief. The court found that the respondent's website representations were misleading and had the potential to entice consumers into the "marketing web". The court emphasized that the dominant message of the website representations was misleading and not corrected by the qualifying information. The court concluded that the representations on the website had the tendency to entice consumers into the "marketing web" by the erroneous belief it engendered. The court also found that the representations on the carpet labels were misleading in some respects. The court declined to grant declaratory relief, stating that the contents of the judgment should provide sufficient guidance to the carpet industry. No order for the costs of the appeal was made.

Background

Background to the litigation

This case concerns representations made by Cavalier Bremworth Ltd regarding warranties for its Habitat Collection range of synthetic carpets. In mid-March 2013, Cavalier launched its new range of synthetic carpets supported by warranties from INVISTA (Australia) Pty Ltd. Cavalier posted marketing material about these warranties on its website, in a letter sent to retailers, and on labels affixed to the carpet samples distributed to retailers. Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd, a competitor, became aware of Cavalier's imminent launch and expressed concerns about the representations regarding the warranties. Godfrey Hirst applied to the High Court seeking an order restraining Cavalier from engaging in conduct that breached the Fair Trading Act 1986. The High Court found in favour of Godfrey Hirst, and Cavalier appealed.

The case originated in the High Court of New Zealand where Godfrey Hirst sought an injunction against Cavalier for misleading representations about the warranties for the Habitat Collection range. The High Court found that Cavalier's representations breached the Fair Trading Act 1986. Cavalier appealed to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand. The appeal was heard on 17 June 2014 by Stevens, Wild, and Miller JJ, and the judgment was delivered on 27 August 2014.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Who constitutes the consumer for the purposes of determining whether representations are misleading or deceptive under the Fair Trading Act 1986?
2. What standard of care is to be expected of the consumer when evaluating representations?
3. Did the High Court impose too high a standard on the consumer in its assessment of whether the representations were misleading or deceptive?

Held
1. The appeal is allowed, and the judgment of the High Court is set aside insofar as it is inconsistent with this judgment.
2. No order as to the costs of the appeal is appropriate.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This case involved an appeal from Godfrey Hirst NZ Limited (Godfrey Hirst) against Cavalier Bremworth Limited (Cavalier) regarding misleading representations made by Cavalier in advertising its Habitat Collection range of synthetic carpets. The primary issues addressed by the Court of Appeal were: (1) the identification of the consumer for the purposes of determining whether representations are misleading or deceptive under the Fair Trading Act 1986, (2) the standard of care expected of the consumer when evaluating representations, and (3) whether the High Court imposed too high a standard on the consumer in its assessment of whether the representations were misleading or deceptive.

On the issue of who constitutes the consumer, the Court held that "the consumer" encompasses all the consumers in the class targeted by the allegedly misleading representations, except the outliers. These outliers are consumers who are unusually stupid or ill-equipped, or whose reactions are extreme or fanciful. This formulation aligns with the tests adopted in various Australasian cases, including Commerce Commission v Adair and Unilever New Zealand Ltd v Cerebos Gregg’s Ltd.

Regarding the standard of care expected of the consumer, the Court determined that consumers must exercise a degree of care which is reasonable, having regard to all the circumstances including the characteristics of the target group of consumers. This standard of care is to be expected of reasonably careful consumers, excluding those who fail to take reasonable care of their own interests.

In assessing whether the High Court imposed too high a standard on the consumer, the Court of Appeal found that the High Court did not correctly apply the principles for evaluating headline representations with qualifying information. Specifically, the Court of Appeal held that the High Court did not consider the dominant message or general thrust of the advertisement, the overall impression it created, or whether the qualifying information sufficiently drew the attention of targeted consumers. Consequently, the Court of Appeal concluded that the High Court's approach did not align with the established principles and that the dominant message conveyed by Cavalier's website advertisement was indeed misleading.