Orders
Orders of the court
1. By 30 November 2015, the applicant serve upon the respondent and lodge with the Associate to Foster J a draft of the declarations, injunctions and other orders which it considers appropriately reflect the decisions explained in Reasons for Judgment published this day by Foster J (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jetstar Airways Pty Limited [2015] FCA 1263).
2. By 7 December 2015, the respondent inform the applicant and the Associate to Foster J whether the respondent agrees that the declarations, injunctions and orders proposed by the applicant accurately and adequately reflect Reasons for Judgment of Foster J published this day (Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Jetstar Airways Pty Limited [2015] FCA 1263).
3. The question of costs be reserved.
4. Each party have liberty to apply on three (3) days’ notice or on such shorter notice as a Judge might allow.
5. The proceeding be adjourned to a date to be fixed after 7 December 2015 for the purpose of making final orders and determining the question of costs.
Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.
Background
Background to the litigation
The characterisation of Jetstar’s conduct urged upon the Court by the ACCC was not accepted by Jetstar. Jetstar argued at trial that it did not make the representations which the ACCC suggested should be teased out of Jetstar’s conduct and that, in any event, the disclosures made by it as to the nature and quantum of the booking and service fee were sufficient to dispel any misunderstandings on the part of some consumers concerning that fee. The Primary Facts In this section of these Reasons, I set out my findings as to the primary facts.Jetstar Website Conduct The ACCC chose to prove the primary facts relating to the Jetstar website by tendering in evidence a number of video captures taken by officers of the ACCC or consultants to it. On a number of occasions, an officer or consultant of the ACCC went to the Jetstar website and navigated that website in order to simulate the booking process that would be undertaken by a prospective customer of Jetstar who wished to make an online flight booking and, while moving through that process, took a video capture of all of the screens or webpages that presented themselves during that process. In this way, the Court was provided with evidence of:(a)The configuration and layout of the website at the particular dates referred to in the Amended Fast Track Statement filed on 24 November 2014 in the Jetstar proceeding (Jetstar AFTS);(b)The precise format of each screen or webpage presented to the consumer at each stage of the process including where relevant links, hyperlinks, font size and print colours; and(c)A clear exposition of the steps involved in making an online booking via the Jetstar website. I am satisfied that the video captures tendered in evidence by the ACCC provide a comprehensive, accurate and fair depiction of the online booking process using the Jetstar website at each of the times referred to in the Jetstar AFTS. I shall now address the specific contraventions alleged against Jetstar by reason of its conduct in configuring its website in the manner in which it did as at the specific dates referred to in the Jetstar AFTS. First Alleged Contravention (14 May 2013) The first website contravention alleged against Jetstar relates to its conduct on 14 May 2013. The relevant allegations are made in pars 14 and 15 of the Jetstar AFTS. The evidence of the primary facts is found in the video capture of the booking process recorded on the DVD which is Ex JFC-1 to the affidavit of John Frederick Cream affirmed on 17 June 2014. At the time when he affirmed that affidavit, Mr Cream was the ACCC’s Assistant Director, Enforcement Group – Queensland. The booking process revealed by Ex JFC-1 was as follows:(a)A potential customer would go to the home page on the Jetstar website. Once the customer had the home page on the screen, the customer would see near the top of the home page a number of links displayed across the page. One such link or banner of interest was the banner on the far left of the page called “Flights”. Associated with that banner and already displayed immediately under it was a rectangular box headed “Book flights”. There was an opportunity to use the links provided in that box to navigate to the next webpage (“Select Flights”). Other links were provided under the headings “Planning & booking” and “What we offer”; (b)Also on the home page, commencing at approximately one third of the way down that page, various “Hot Fares” were listed. These fares were shown as relating to specifically identified journeys and were always expressed as “From” a particular dollar figure. They were generally displayed in bold and large font. The dollar figure was in orange and the text in dark blue; (c)In a rectangular box to the immediate right of the “Book flights” box, a number of special offers would appear in a rotating display; (d)Once at the home page, the customer would be taken to the webpage entitled “Select Flights”. Generally, the customer would be taken to that webpage by inserting certain details of the desired flight into the rectangular box on the home page headed “Book flights” and by then clicking his mouse cursor on the link “Search for flights”. The details entered by the customer in the box on the home page were the origin and destination of the desired flights, the date of each flight and the number of adults and children (including infants) who would be travelling. Once those details were entered, the customer would click on the icon “Search for flights”. The customer would then be taken to the “Select Flights” webpage; (e)Once at the “Select Flights” webpage, the customer would then be required to choose the most desired flights (forward and return) from a number of specific flights listed on that webpage which met the original criteria inserted into the box on the home page and which had seats available on them as at the date of the relevant inquiry. On the “Select Flights” webpage, there was specified against each identified flight a dollar figure under a heading in a box: StarterEconomy cabinWhat is included? Each dollar figure listed on this webpage signified the fare for the particular flight to which it related and had a blank circle next to it (called a “radio button”) upon which the customer might choose to click his mouse cursor. If the customer clicked on any radio button, two things would happen more or less simultaneously. The first thing which would happen was that a side panel entitled “Booking Summary” would appear on the right-hand side of the screen. The first item in that side panel was headed “Total AUD” and showed the fare which the customer had chosen by clicking on the radio button adjacent to the particular fare. That fare was expressed as a specific dollar figure not as “from” a specific dollar figure. If, for example, the customer chose a flight which showed a dollar figure next to it of $139, the fare that would be shown in the Booking Summary side panel was that figure or that figure multiplied by the number of persons travelling. Under the heading “Fees & taxes”, $0.00 appeared. This made clear that “Fees & taxes” were included in the fare displayed in the Booking Summary side panel under the heading “Total AUD”. The other thing that would happen when a customer clicked on any radio button was that three vertical rectangular boxes would come onto the screen. Two of those boxes contained a list of extra services. One box contained a description of the services provided as part of the Starter fare. The Starter fare was the most basic (and thus the cheapest) fare on offer. The services provided as part of the Starter fare were the seat on the aircraft and the right to bring on board a small piece of cabin luggage. Each of the other two boxes contained a list of bundled services that might be provided by Jetstar at the election of the customer in each case for an extra payment in each case (Value Bundles). One or other of these Value Bundles might be added to the booking at this stage at the election of the customer. On the “Select Flights” webpage as at 14 May 2013, there was a note under the table of available flights in the following terms:Prices quoted are per adult passenger, in AUD and include airfare related surcharges, fees and taxes. Unless otherwise stated, fares are non refundable, limited changes are permitted charges apply. Starter fares include 10kg carry-on baggage. Additional fees apply for checked in baggage, which will be available for purchase on the next page. Adding checked baggage after booking costs more at the airport, over the phone and on our web site. 7kg per item cabin baggage limit applies on Qantas flights.The same process would occur when the customer selected his return flight.After the customer had made his choices in respect of each flight (including choices of extras in accordance with the Value Bundles offered), those choices would then be reflected in the Booking Summary side panel on the “Select Flights” webpage. As a minimum, the price shown for the Starter fare for each chosen flight would populate that Booking Summary side panel. In addition, any selected bundled extras would be included.The total price for the chosen fares reflected in the Booking Summary side panel would also be prominently displayed outside the Booking Summary side panel at the bottom of this webpage in large coloured font immediately above the “Continue” link; (f)The customer would then be directed to the webpage headed “Passengers”. On that page, the customer was required to enter the name, address and contact details of each passenger who was to travel on that booking. After that task was completed, the Booking Summary side panel would reflect all of the information inserted as a result of the choices made by the customer up to that point. However, the Booking Summary side panel would reflect only information of that kind. As at this point in the booking process, it would contain no reference to the booking and service fee. The Booking Summary side panel by now also would include a reference to “Additional Extras” which were to be addressed in detail by a later webpage. No amount for those items would be included at this stage. In addition, at the point when the customer left the “Passengers” webpage, the Booking Summary side panel would be populated with details of the customer’s baggage choice if that customer chose to pay for the right to check in his baggage; (g)The customer would then be directed to the webpage headed “Seats”. On that webpage, the customer would be invited to indicate his seating preferences. The Booking Summary side panel would then expand as necessary so as to include the cost of seating choices (if any) made by the customer. Baggage and seating choices would appear under a heading “Optional Extras”; (h)The customer would then be directed to the “Extras” webpage. On this webpage the customer would be offered a number of additional services not already covered by the choices offered earlier (travel insurance, hotels, rent-a-cars and other activities). If any of those “Extras” were selected, they would be added to the items listed in the Booking Summary side panel and the costs thereof factored into the specified cascading list of charges set out in that Booking Summary side panel. They would all appear under the heading “Additional Extras” and be individually itemised; (i)The customer would then be directed to the “Payment” webpage. It is at this point in the booking process, for the very first time, that the customer would be apprised of the existence and quantum of the booking and service fee. When the customer left the “Extras” webpage, there was added to the Booking Summary side panel as the very last entry before the total an item:Booking and Service Fee$0.00So, when the Booking Summary side panel first appeared on the “Payment” webpage, that item was already shown in that side panel although no amount would be specified until the customer had moved through all but the last step required to be taken on the “Payment” webpage; (j)On this webpage, under a heading in bold font: “How would you like to pay?”, the following text appeared:Please select a payment method below. Please note that payment cannot be split between different payment methods except for voucher and credit card; and voucher and POLi in Australia and New Zealand, for Jetstar Airways (JQ) and Jetstar Asia (3K) bookings in AUD or NZD.We charge a Booking and Service Fee for some bookings completed online. The options below indicate whether a booking and service fee applies. Jetstar waives this Booking and Service Fee for all bookings paid for using a Jetstar MasterCard, Jetstar Platinum MasterCard, Jetstar Vouchers and some other forms of payment (as indicated below). We actively encourage our customers to pay using one of the payment methods for which no Booking and Service Fee applies. As I have already mentioned, when the customer was first taken to the “Payment” webpage, the Booking Summary side panel had added to it as the very last item prior to the total the following text:
Decision
Reasons for decision
The terms of the V-mails relied upon by the ACCC in its case against Virgin require consumers who are on the V-mail subscription list to make their bookings via the Virgin website. For those reasons, the complaints made by the ACCC against Virgin in respect of the V-mails fall with the complaints made in respect of the Virgin website.CONCLUSIONS I have found a contravention against Jetstar in respect of its website as configured on 14 May 2013. In respect of that contravention, I propose to make an appropriate declaration. I have also found contraventions against both Jetstar and Virgin in respect of the booking processes required to be undertaken by consumers who navigate the mobile site of each of them. In respect of those contraventions, I propose to make declarations and grant appropriate injunctive relief. For the above reasons, I will require the ACCC to formulate the declaratory and injunctive relief which I have indicated I am prepared to grant. The balance of both sets of proceedings will be dismissed. I propose to hear the parties on costs. There will be orders accordingly.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
These general figures were used by Virgin to support the submissions which I have extracted at [153] above. In particular, it was submitted that these statistics supported the third of those submissions. CONSIDERATIONSome Common Features The ACCC’s case against each of Jetstar and Virgin begins with its allegation, repeated throughout the Jetstar AFTS and the Virgin AFTS, to the effect that, by the conduct identified in those documents, each of those airlines made representations that:(a)The price displayed for the specific flights identified in the pleadings in every case would be the actual price of the passenger carriage services to which that displayed price related;(b)Those passenger carriage services could be purchased for that price regardless of the payment method used; and(c)Those passenger carriage services were not subject to a condition which would alter the price depending upon the payment method used. I shall refer to these representations collectively as “the representations”. It is then argued that the representations were false because:(a)The displayed prices were only available if the passenger carriage services were paid for using POLi, airline branded credit cards or airline vouchers;(b)The relevant passenger carriage services were subject to the payment of a booking and service fee if payment was made using other credit cards, certain debit cards or PayPal; and(c)The provision of such services was subject to the booking fee condition. In each case, three modes of communication were identified as the media by which Jetstar and Virgin made the representations. In each case, these media were the airline’s website, the airline’s mobile site and the airline’s email subscription list. Notwithstanding that three modes of communication are identified, it is the use of the internet and the online booking process enabled by the internet which is at the heart of all three relevant modes of communication. In particular, it is the availability through the airlines’ website and mobile site of the instantaneous provision of information and the immediate opportunity to book passenger carriage services by air hopefully at a cheap price that has proven attractive to consumers. What then is the appropriate description of the relevant class of consumers in relation to the acquisition of passenger carriage services by air in Australia by means of these online booking facilities and what are the characteristics of that class? The ACCC contended that the relevant class of consumers is the public at large. Jetstar accepted that proposition. Virgin took a slightly different approach. It submitted that its conduct did not consist of advertising thrust upon the public at large but rather was conduct which engaged only with those members of the public who had already made a deliberate choice to navigate to the Virgin website or to the Virgin mobile site or to subscribe to its V-mail service. In my judgment, while the impugned conduct on the part of both airlines is capable of engaging with any member of the public, it does not do so unless and until a member of the public chooses to navigate to the particular airline’s website or mobile site or to subscribe to the airline’s email subscription service. Such persons would be accessing those sites and that service in order to “price” a particular journey which they have in mind or to book such a journey. They may be interested in accessing multiple sites for that purpose. In the present case, the multiple sites would be those of Jetstar, Virgin and Tiger Airlines, and perhaps Qantas.