Commerce Commission v Vodafone New Zealand Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CRI-2022-404-000157

[2023] NZHC 2149

BETWEEN

COMMERCE COMMISSION

Appellant

AND

VODAFONE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Respondent

CRI-2022-404-000162

BETWEEN

VODAFONE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED
Appellant

AND

COMMERCE COMMISSION

Respondent

Hearing: 13 to 15 March 2023

Appearances:

Nick Flanagan, Ben Hamlin and Chloe Fleming for the Appellant/Respondent

Fletcher Pilditch KC, Allison Ferguson and Karl van der Plas for the Respondent/Appellant

Judgment:

11 August 2023


JUDGMENT OF MOORE J

[Appeal against conviction and sentence]


This judgment was delivered by me on 11 August 2023 at 3:00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/ Deputy Registrar Date:

COMMERCE COMMISSION v VODAFONE NEW ZEALAND LIMITED [2023] NZHC 2149 [11 August 2023]

Contents

Paragraph Number

INTRODUCTION................................................................................................... [1]

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Overview of broadband network....................................................................... [6]

Government’s FTTH network......................................................................... [15]

Vodafone’s HFC network................................................................................. [19]

Branding and marketing of FibreX................................................................ [25]

Availability checker tool................................................................................... [28]

Wider reporting on FibreX.............................................................................. [30]

The Commission’s investigation....................................................................... [36]

The charges........................................................................................................ [43]

PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND...................................................................... [51]

CONVICTION APPEAL

District Court decision...................................................................................... [56]

Legal principles on conviction appeals........................................................... [73]

Grounds of appeal............................................................................................. [76]

Ground 1.1(e): Failure to address the relevant consumer group[78]

Ground 1.1(f): The Judge erred by disregarding other aspects of

Vodafone’s advertising conduct and in applying the relevant law.............. [100]

Ground 1.1(b): Erroneous finding that consumers had been conditioned

to ascribe FTTH as a secondary meaning to the word “fibre”.................. [120]

(a)What “fibre” meant to the consumer?............................................. [133]

(b)Whether “FibreX” was liable to mislead the consumer.................. [152]

Ground 1.1(c): Failure to address admissibility of consumer complaints

table............................................................................................................. [157]

Ground 1.1(a): Erroneous finding as to characteristic of service................ [169]

Ground 1.1(d): Reversal of burden and standard of proof........................... [177]

Ground 1.1(g): Failure to properly consider and weigh all admissible

evidence....................................................................................................... [186]

Conclusion on conviction appeal................................................................... [197]

SENTENCE APPEAL........................................................................................ [198]

District Court decision.................................................................................... [199]

Legal principles on sentence appeals............................................................. [212]

Application of s 40(2) of the FTA.................................................................. [214]

Commission’s sentence appeal....................................................................... [224]

Ground (a)(i): Error as to Vodafone’s state of mind[226]

Ground (a)(ii): Error as to significance of commercial gain[244]

Ground (a)(iii): Error as to assessment of harm to consumers[256]

Ground (a)(iv): Failure to follow approach in Steel v Tube[272]

Ground (b): Manifestly inadequate uplift..................................................... [282]

Ground (c): Departure from accepted sentencing methodology[291]

Conclusion on Commission’s sentence appeal............................................. [295]

Vodafone’s sentence appeal............................................................................ [300]

Departure from accepted sentencing methodology[303]

Errors relating to adjustments for personal culpability factors[306]

(a)Improperly penalising Vodafone for offending that occurred at

the same time as the present offending[307]

(b)Uplift for previous convictions[310]

(c)Discount for co-operation[313]

(d)Discount for reducing trial time[315]

Means adjustment......................................................................................... [320]

Manifestly excessive starting point.............................................................. [324]

Conclusion on Vodafone’s sentence appeal.................................................. [329]

RESULT............................................................................................................... [330]

INTRODUCTION

[1]    On 16 November 2018, Vodafone New Zealand Ltd (“Vodafone”) pleaded guilty to nine representative charges of misleading conduct in relation…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commerce Commission v Vodafone New Zealand Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2149
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Vodafone New Zealand Limited ("Vodafone") was convicted on nine charges of misleading conduct under section 11 of the Fair Trading Act 1986 ("FTA") relating to the availability of fibre-to-the-home broadband services. Vodafone was also convicted on nine further charges of misleading conduct relating to the branding and advertising of its Hybrid Fibre Coaxial network ("HFC network") as "FibreX". The Commerce Commission ("Commission") cross-appealed the sentence on the basis of manifest inadequacy. Vodafone appealed both its conviction on the branding charges and the sentence. The High Court dismissed both appeals. In relation to the conviction appeal, the Court was satisfied that the District Court Judge had correctly identified the relevant consumer group, had not erred in finding that consumers had been conditioned to ascribe fibre as a secondary meaning to FTTH, and had not disregarded other aspects of Vodafone's advertising conduct. The Court found that the branding and promotion of FibreX was liable to mislead the public into believing that the service was a FTTH broadband service, and that this conduct was in relation to the characteristics of Vodafone's broadband service. In relation to the sentence appeal, the Court found that the District Court Judge's starting point of $2,100,000 was manifestly inadequate. The uplift applied for Vodafone's financial means was also found to be manifestly inadequate. The uplift was increased to $700,000, or 25 per cent of the new global starting point of $2,800,000. The total fine was increased to $3,675,000.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established