Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 723

Citation: Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd (No 2) [2011] FCA 723
Appeal from: Blueprint Printing Pty Ltd v Winn [2010] FMCA 951
Parties: JULENE WINN v BLUEPRINT INSTANT PRINTING PTY LTD (ACN 005 267 096) and GARLAND HAWTHORN BRAHE
File number: VID 1039 of 2010
Judge: DODDS-STREETON J
Date of judgment: 24 June 2011
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – Appeal – Federal Magistrate made sequestration order against appellant based on non-compliance with bankruptcy notice – Federal Magistrate refused appellant appearance by audio link – Whether denial of procedural fairness – Whether apprehended bias – Whether Federal Magistrate erred in failing to consider appellant’s submissions, failing to give reasons, permitting breaches of court rules and referring to materials adverse to the appellant – Whether appellant could rely on alleged erroneous date of act of bankruptcy
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 40(1)(g), 41(7)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24(1)(d)
Federal Magistrates Act 1999 (Cth) ss 13(2), 67, 68, 75(2)
Federal Magistrates Court Rules 2001 (Cth)
Federal Magistrates Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2006 (Cth) rr 4.04, 4.05, 4.06
Cases cited: Abeyesinghe v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs [2004] FCA 1558 cited
Blueprint Printing Pty Ltd v Winn [2010] FMCA 951 affirmed
British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd v Laurie (2011) 85 ALJR 348 cited
Coulton v Holcombe (1986) 162 CLR 1 cited
Cumins v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 172 FCR 425 cited
Eastman v Director of Public Prosecutions (ACT) (2003) 214 CLR 318 cited
Ebner v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337 cited
Gas and Fuel Corporation of Victoria v Wood Hall Ltd & Anor [1978] VR 385 cited
Glew v Harrowell of Hunt & Hunt Lawyers (2003) 198 ALR 331 cited
Guss v Johnstone [2000] FCA 1455 considered
House v R (1936) 55 CLR 499 cited
Hunter v Transport Accident Commission [2005] VSCA 1 cited
Jensen v Queensland Law Society Incorporated (2006) 154 FCR 525 considered
Kuligowski v Metrobus (2004) 220 CLR 363 cited
Lansen and Ors v Minister for Environment and Heritage and Anor (2008) 174 FCR 14 cited
Makhoul v Barnes (1995) 60 FCR 572 applied
Moran v Lydiard Financial Services Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 872 considered
National Australia Bank Ltd v Westbrook [2000] FCA 246 distinguished
Re JRL; Ex parte CJL (1986) 161 CLR 342 cited
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs & Anor; Ex parte Miah (2001) 206 CLR 57 cited
Richmond v BMW Australia Finance Limited (No 2) (2009) 174 FCR 232 cited
Trustees of the Franciscan Missionaries of Mary v Weir (2000) 98 FCR 447 cited
Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 522 cited
Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2008] FMCA 1430 cited
Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 292 considered
Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 293 considered
Worchild v The Drink Night Club (Qld) Pty…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 723
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd (No 2), the appellant, Winn, appealed against the Federal Magistrate’s decision to make a sequestration order against her estate. The respondents were the petitioning creditor, Blueprint Printing Pty Ltd, and the supporting creditor, Garland Hawthorn Brahe. The legal issues involved the Federal Magistrate's refusal to allow Winn to appear by audio link, the denial of procedural fairness, the question of apprehended bias, and whether the Federal Magistrate erred in various respects including failing to consider submissions, not giving reasons, permitting breaches of court rules, and referring to materials adverse to Winn. Additionally, the court had to determine if Winn could rely on an alleged erroneous date of the act of bankruptcy.

The Federal Magistrate found that Winn had not provided sufficient justification for her inability to appear in person or by counsel, and therefore, the refusal to allow her to appear by audio link did not amount to a denial of procedural fairness. The court rejected the claim of apprehended bias, holding that there was no basis for such a claim. The Federal Magistrate's decision not to consider Winn's submissions, the lack of detailed reasons, and the references to adverse materials were scrutinized. The court concluded that these actions did not undermine the fairness of the proceedings. Furthermore, the alleged erroneous date of the act of bankruptcy did not affect the validity of the sequestration order.

The court ultimately found that the Federal Magistrate had correctly proceeded to hear the creditor’s petition and make the sequestration order based on the evidence presented. The reasons provided by the Federal Magistrate were deemed adequate, and the order was upheld. The appeal was dismissed, and the matter was fixed for hearing on the costs and any application for a stay of orders.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be fixed for hearing at 1.15pm on 30 June 2011 for a duration of one hour, with time to be equally divided between the appellant and the respondents, in relation to costs and any application for a stay of orders.

2. On or before 4.00pm on 29 June 2011, all the parties file and serve any affidavit and any outline of submissions (not to exceed five pages) on which they intend to rely.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

The respondents to the appeal are the petitioning creditor, Blueprint Printing Pty Ltd (“Blueprint”) and the supporting creditor, Garland Hawthorn Brahe. At the hearing of the appeal, Garland Hawthorn Brahe objected to its joinder as a respondent to the appeal. The appellant conceded that Garland Hawthorn Brahe was not “technically” a respondent to the appeal although “someone has put them on as respondents but I don’t see them as that”. Blueprint relied on written submissions dated 2 May 2011 and Garland Hawthorn Brahe relied on written submissions dated 3 May 2011.BACKGROUND The background to the appeal appears in the Reasons for Judgment of Hartnett FM published on 8 December 2010, and submissions and materials filed by the parties. The history of the matter is complex, as it involves numerous proceedings, including appeals, in different courts or tribunals in protracted litigation over a number of years. The facts may be summarised as follows. On 20 February 2009, Blueprint issued a bankruptcy notice (VN 358/09) against the appellant. The schedule to the bankruptcy notice required the debtor to pay the debt shown in the schedule of $21,655.63 (comprising a debt of $17,139.20, interest of $6,265.43 and a payment or credit of $1,750.00) within 21 days after service of the bankruptcy notice or to make an arrangement to the creditor’s satisfaction for settlement. The bankruptcy notice attached a copy order of taxation of legal costs in proceeding 4215 of 2002 made by Taxing Master Bruce of the Supreme Court of Victoria on 9 November 2005 which, in “other matters”, stated “taxation pursuant to the order of the Honourable Justice Byrne made 2 August 2002” and ordered that “the costs of Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd are taxed and allowed in the sum of $17,139.20”. On 20 July 2009, following the service of the bankruptcy notice on 17 July 2009, the appellant filed an application to set the bankruptcy notice aside and to extend the time for compliance until the determination of the application. On 20 July 2009, the Court, inter alia, adjourned the hearing of the application to set aside the bankruptcy notice and extended the time for compliance until 4.30pm on 7 September 2009. On 7 September 2009, Riley FM, who had already determined a matter relating to an earlier bankruptcy notice issued by Blueprint based on the same orders of Taxing Master Bruce made on 9 November 2005, disqualified herself from determining the appellant’s application to set aside the bankruptcy notice. Riley FM listed the appellant’s application for hearing before Phipps FM but did not extend the time for compliance with the bankruptcy notice. On 12 October 2009, Phipps FM heard the appellant’s application to set aside the bankruptcy notice. On 30 October 2009, his Honour dismissed the application. On 12 November 2009, the appellant filed an appeal from Phipps FM’s decision. On 25 January 2010, Blueprint (then Blueprint Proprietary Limited) filed a creditor’s petition against the appellant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

By a notice of motion dated 10 December 2010, the appellant sought a stay of the sequestration order, which was refused by Gray J on 23 December 2010.Outcome of appeal from decision refusing to set aside bankruptcy notice On 31 March 2011, Ryan J dismissed the appellant’s appeals from the decisions of Phipps FM and Riley FM with costs: Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 292 and Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 293. His Honour comprehensively considered, and in my view, persuasively analysed and dismissed, the many bases on which the appellant alleged that the bankruptcy notice was invalid. In particular, Ryan J held that:(a)the bankruptcy notice was not issued out of time because it related to Byrne J’s judgment or order, rather than that of Taxing Master Bruce.(i)His Honour analysed in detail a number of relevant authorities dealing with the nature of costs certificates and orders of a Taxing Master of the Supreme Court of Victoria under the rules of the Court and legislation applicable from time to time.(ii)His Honour, (having noted the conflicting views expressed by Finkelstein J in Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Horvath (Junior) (1999) 161 ALR 441 and Hansen J in Scott v Evia Pty Ltd; Scott v Charitopoulos [2008] VSC 324) concluded at [21]:As a result of Finkelstein J’s characterisation, even if only for reasons of comity, of the order of a taxing master of the Supreme Court of Victoria as a final order for the purposes of s 41(3) of the Bankruptcy Act, I am obliged to come to the same conclusion in respect of the Taxing Master’s order of 9 November 2005 unless I am persuaded that Finkelstein J’s approach was clearly wrong; see Hicks v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 757 per French J, at [76] and Cooper v Cmr of Taxation (2004) 139 FCR 205, per Lander J, at [46]. I am not so persuaded.(iii)Ryan J’s view that the Taxing Master’s order was a final order was fortified on the further ground that otherwise, it would not be possible to give a debtor notice of how the amount set out in the schedule to a bankruptcy notice had been calculated as the amount owing, so as to give effect to an acknowledged purpose of the Act.(iv)His Honour held that grounds 1(b) to (e) were restatements of, or dependent on, the success of ground 1(a), and also failed.(b)The bankruptcy notice did not overstate the amount of the judgment debt by including the appellant’s payment of $1,750 which Blueprint wrongly applied to her liability for its costs.(c)The bankruptcy notice did not misstate the claim as a judgment debt or overstate the interest claim (which could only be the case if, contrary to Ryan J’s holding, the appellant had successfully established that the bankruptcy notice were out of time).(d)The bankruptcy notice was not issued by only one of two joint creditors, being Blueprint and Mr Goodwin.(e)The bankruptcy notice was not invalidated on compendious grounds.(f)The appellant did not have a counterclaim in excess of the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice.(g)Blueprint and Mr Goodwin did not have joint liability.(h)The appellant did not have a counterclaim based on a contingent liability of Blueprint to pay the appellant’s costs at first instance in MLG 1351 of 2007 or on an appeal to the Federal Court numbered VID 921 of 2008 and no other basis for asserting a counterclaim had been articulated, let alone established. (i)There had never been two operative and effective bankruptcy notices before the Federal Court or the Federal Magistrates’ Court at the same time.(j)The costs assessment was not in dispute.(i)Ryan J stated at [39] that “[t]he appellant has exhausted all avenues for obtaining a review in the Supreme Court of Victoria of the Taxing Master’s order of 9 November 2005”, as Smith J’s order of 28 November 2008 made clear.(ii)Ryan J concluded at [40] that:It is therefore no longer accurate or realistic to assert that the costs assessment which underlay the bankruptcy notice is still in dispute or even that it was in dispute when the learned Federal Magistrate made his order of 30 October 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Magistrate concluded that “importantly”, there was a “lack of sufficient material” in the appellant’s facsimile to justify departure from the Court’s usual procedure, no explanation of why solicitors or counsel could not appear on instructions and no proper explanation of why the appellant could not have appeared in person at the hearing of the creditor’s petition, which had been pending since January 2010.Sequestration order On 26 November 2010, following her refusal of leave for the appellant to appear by telephone, the Federal Magistrate proceeded to hear the creditor’s petition. At the conclusion of the hearing, she made a sequestration order against the appellant’s estate and a consequential costs order. On 26 November 2010, her Honour delivered ex tempore reasons for her decision, which were subsequently revised as written reasons dated 8 December 2010. In her reasons for judgment, the Federal Magistrate found that:(a)Paras 1, 2 and 3 of the creditor’s petition filed by Blueprint on 25 January 2010 were verified by the affidavit of Christopher Terry sworn 22 January 2010. Paragraph 4 of the creditor’s petition was supported by the affidavit of Alexandra Madeleine Santamaria sworn 22 January 2010, deposing to the commission of an act of bankruptcy on 7 September 2009.(b)There was an affidavit of debt sworn by Christopher Terry on 25 November 2010, an affidavit of search sworn by Alexandra Madeleine Santamaria on 26 November 2010 and a supporting creditor’s affidavit of debt sworn by Robert Lane on 25 November 2010. Hartnett FM stated: The court must be satisfied of the matters required to be proven at a hearing of a creditor’s petition as set out in section 52 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Act”). The court is so satisfied with respect to the affidavits verifying the petition, paragraphs 1 to 4 inclusive. The court is further satisfied that there has been service of the petition in accordance with the order for substituted service made by Registrar Pringle on 13 April 2010. The evidence of service is contained in the affidavit of Ms Santamaria sworn 20 April 2010. Ms Winn has also appeared subsequently. The court is further required to be satisfied that the debt or debts on which the petitioning creditor relies is or are still owing. The court is so satisfied on the basis of the affidavit material referred to in paragraph 2 of these reasons. Section 52 of the Act provides that if the court is satisfied with the proof of those matters (as the court is) then the court may make a sequestration order against the estate of the debtor. The Federal Magistrate also observed that the court could, pursuant to s 52 of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Act”), dismiss the petition in the specified circumstances. The appellant, as debtor, bore the onus to establish solvency or some other sufficient cause for dismissal of the petition. The Federal Magistrate held that the appellant had not established her solvency. Further, the Federal Magistrate did not consider that the matters in the appellant’s “grounds of opposition” notice dated 4 June 2010 constituted a sufficient reason not to make the sequestration order. Her Honour observed that the grounds largely comprised an attack on the bankruptcy notice which was issued after Taxing Master Bruce of the Supreme Court of Victoria made orders on 9 November 2005, following taxation of the costs of Byrne J’s judgment given on 2 August 2002 (which dismissed with costs a proceeding the appellant had issued in the Supreme Court of Victoria).