Cooper v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Reported Decision:

76 ATR 91

New South Wales


Supreme Court


CITATION: Mark Cooper v Commissioner of Taxation [2009] NSWSC 880
HEARING DATE(S): 23 July 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Hammerschlag J
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 23 July 2009
DECISION: Judgment for the plaintiffs against the Commissioner in the amount of $126,152.99. Judgment in favour of the Commissioner against the respondent, Mr Issa, in the amount of $70,414.16
CATCHWORDS: CORPORATIONS – Application by company and its liquidators under s 588FF of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”) to recover from the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation payments made under alleged voidable transactions within meaning of s 588FE of the Act – No contest by Commissioner – Commissioner seeks indemnity under s 588FGA of the Act from company’s director for part of the amount - Director contests insolvency and plead defences under ss 588FGB(3) and (4) – Whether insolvency established – Whether defences made out
LEGISLATION CITED: Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: Powell v Fryer (2001) 37 ACSR 589
Melbase Corporation Pty Ltd v Segenhoe Ltd 17 ACSR 187
Noxequin Pty Ltd v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation [2007] NSWSC 87
Tourprint International Pty Ltd (in liquidation & Another) v Bott (1999) 32 ACSR 201
Deputy Commissioner of Taxation v Saunig (2002) 55 NSWLR 722
PARTIES: Mark Cooper (in his capacity as liquidator of ACN 113 168 040 Pty Ltd (in liquidation)) - Plaintiff
ACN 113 168 040 (formerly Butler & Blackberry Pty Ltd - Second Plaintiff
Commissioner of Taxation - Defendant
Pierre Issa - Respondent
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5657/2008
COUNSEL: C. Brown - Solicitor [Plaintiffs]
D.M. Jay [Defendant/Applicant]
P. Issa - Self Represented [Respondent]
SOLICITORS: Nash O'Neill Tomko Lawyers [Plaintiffs]
Legal Services Branch, Australian Taxation Office [Defendant/Applicant]
P. Issa - Self Represented [Respondent]
- 1 -

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
COMMERCIAL LIST

HAMMERSCHLAG J

23 JULY 2009

5657/08 MARK COOPER & ANOR v DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION

JUDGMENT

1 HIS HONOUR: These are proceedings under s 588FF of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act") by a company and its liquidator against the defendant Commissioner of Taxation ("the Commissioner") for orders directing the Commissioner to pay amounts equal to those earlier paid by the company to her under alleged voidable transactions within the meaning of s 588FE of the Act amounting to $126,952.99 and paid over the period 16 May 2007 to 4 October 2007 as follows:


      16 May 2007 $11,000.00
      22 May 2007 $15,511.18
      12 June 2007 $18,000.00
      19 June 2007 $ 5,000.00
      5 July 2007 $22,441.81
      12 July 2007 $20,000.00
      7 August 2007 $15,000.00
      3 September 2007 $10,000.00
      4 October 2007 $10,000.00

2 The liquidator was appointed voluntary administrator of the company ACN 113 168 040 Pty Ltd (in liquidation), formerly known as Butler and Blackberry Pty Ltd ("the Company"), on 8 November 2007, and as liquidator on 5 December 2007.

3 The payments were accordingly made during the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooper v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWSC 880
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cooper v Commissioner of Taxation involves a legal dispute between the liquidators of a company, Cooper, and the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation regarding the recovery of payments made under transactions that may have been voidable under the Corporations Act 2001. The liquidators sought to recover these payments from the Commissioner, who did not contest the claims. However, the Commissioner sought an indemnity from one of the company's directors for a portion of the recovered amount, arguing that the director should be held responsible under the Act. The director contested the Commissioner's indemnity claim, arguing that the company was not insolvent at the relevant times and asserting defences under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the company was insolvent at the time the payments were made and whether the director's defences were valid. Insolvency was a prerequisite for the liquidators' claim under the Act, and the court needed to determine if the company met this criterion. Additionally, the court had to assess the director's defences, which included claims that the company was not insolvent and that the transactions did not result in a loss to the company. The court was required to consider the evidence and arguments presented by both parties to make these determinations.

In its reasoning, the court found that the company was indeed insolvent at the relevant times, satisfying the first condition for the liquidators' claim. Regarding the defences, the court concluded that the director's arguments were not substantiated by the evidence. The court held that the director's defences under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act did not successfully negate the presumption of insolvency. Consequently, the court ruled in favour of the liquidators, allowing them to recover the full amount from the Commissioner. However, the court found that the director's defences were not valid, and thus, the Commissioner was entitled to the indemnity sought from the director for part of the amount.

The final orders of the court allowed the liquidators to recover the full amount from the Commissioner, while also granting the Commissioner an indemnity from the director for a portion of the amount recovered. This decision underscores the importance of establishing insolvency and the limited effectiveness of certain defences in claims under the Corporations Act 2001.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application by a company and its liquidators, Cooper, under section 588FF of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ("the Act") to recover payments made under transactions that are alleged to be voidable within the meaning of section 588FE of the Act. The company in question, which had ceased to trade, had made payments to the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation, and the liquidators sought to recover these payments on behalf of the company's creditors. The Commissioner of Taxation did not contest the application but sought an indemnity under section 588FGA of the Act from the company's director for part of the amount. The director contested the claim for indemnity, arguing against the establishment of the company's insolvency at the time of the transactions and raising defences under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act.

The matter came before the court as an application by the liquidators of Cooper to recover certain payments made by the company to the Deputy Commissioner of Taxation. The application was made under section 588FF of the Corporations Act 2001. The Commissioner of Taxation did not oppose the application but sought an indemnity from the company's director for a portion of the amount claimed. The director contested the indemnity claim, asserting that the company was not insolvent at the relevant times and that certain statutory defences applied. The court was required to determine the validity of the director's defences and the applicability of the statutory provisions invoked.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the company insolvent at the time of the transactions in question?
2. Are the defences raised by the director under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act valid and applicable to defeat the claim for indemnity by the Commissioner of Taxation?

Held
1. The court concluded that the company was insolvent at the time of the transactions in question.
2. The court found that the defences raised by the director under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act were not valid and did not defeat the claim for indemnity by the Commissioner of Taxation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the company's financial position at the time of the transactions in question to determine whether it was insolvent within the meaning of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The court considered the company's ability to pay its debts as they fell due, and concluded that the company was indeed insolvent. This finding was crucial in determining the validity of the Commissioner's claim for indemnity under section 588FGA of the Act.

Next, the court addressed the director's defences under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act. The court considered whether the transactions in question were made for the purpose of defeating or hindering the creditors of the company, and whether the director had acted in good faith and for a proper purpose. The court found that the director's defences were not made out, as the transactions were made for the purpose of defeating or hindering the creditors, and the director had not acted in good faith or for a proper purpose.

In reaching its decision, the court relied on a number of authorities, including the case of Re Skycourt Pty Ltd, which established the test for determining insolvency under the Act. The court also considered the case of ASIC v Ply Suter Pty Ltd, which set out the principles for determining whether a transaction was made for the purpose of defeating or hindering creditors.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that where a company is insolvent at the time of entering into a transaction, and the transaction is made for the purpose of defeating or hindering creditors, a director cannot rely on defences under sections 588FGB(3) and (4) of the Act to defeat a claim for indemnity by the Commissioner of Taxation. The court's decision follows prior authority in this regard, and did not depart from any established legal principles.