Wong (Trustee), in the matter of Mackellar (Bankrupt) v Mackellar

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Wong (Trustee), in the matter of Mackellar (Bankrupt) v Mackellar [2020] FCA 1151

File number: QUD 186 of 2020
Judgment of: DERRINGTON J
Date of judgment: 12 August 2020
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – application for recognition of a foreign proceeding as a foreign main proceeding or foreign non-main proceeding pursuant to the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) and the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law – Hong Kong proceedings – respondent filed no evidence in opposition and did not oppose orders – individual’s centre of main interest in Hong Kong despite having departed that country and not returned – absence of evidence of habitual residence

BANKRUPTCY – ancillary relief sought under Art 21 of the Model Law – orders made staying any proceedings against the debtor or any of his assets, a stay on enforcement of judgments or orders, and suspension of dealings in his property granted – order made that the administration and realisation of the debtor’s assets located in Australia be entrusted to the foreign representatives – order made that all powers normally available to a trustee in bankruptcy under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) be made available to the foreign representatives

Legislation:

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth)

Federal Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2016 (Cth)

Convention on the Civil Aspects of International Child Abduction

European Union Convention on Insolvency Proceedings 1995

Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law

Cases cited:

Ackers v Saad Investments Company Ltd (in liq) (2010) 190 FCR 285

Akers v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (2014) 223 FCR 8

Aquino (Trustee), in the matter of McGowan (Bankrupt) v McGowan [2020] FCA 221

BHP Billiton Iron Ore Pty Ltd v National Competition Council (2007) 162 FCR 234

Cooper as liquidator of Wanted World Wide (Australia) Ltd (in liq) v Commissioner of Taxation (2004) 139 FCR 205

Directors of Rizzo-Bottiglieri-De Carlini Armatori SpA v Rizzo-Bottiglieri-De Carlini Armatori SpA [2018] FCA 153

Farah Constructions Pty Ltd v Say-Dee Pty Ltd (2007) 230 CLR 89

Frugtniet v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2017) 255 FCR 96

Gainsford v Tannenbaum (2012) 216 FCR 543 at 554

Hicks v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural & Indigenous Affairs [2003] FCA 757

Jong (Trustee) v Au, in the matter of Au [2020] FCA 585

Kapila, in the matter of Edelsten (2014) 320 ALR 506

La Macchia v Minister for Primary Industries and Energy (1992) 110 ALR 201

LK v Director-General, Department of Community Services (2009) 237 CLR 582

Pink v MF Global UK Limited (In Special Administration) [2012] FCA 260

Raithatha v Ariel Industries PLC (2012) 212 FCR 139

Re ABC Learning Centres Ltd 728 F (3d) 301

Re Eurofood IFSC Ltd [2006] Ch 508

Senvion GmbH, in the matter of Senvion GmbH (No 2) [2019] FCA 1732

Division: General Division
Registry: Queensland
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Number of paragraphs: 69
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Wong (Trustee), in the matter of Mackellar (Bankrupt) v Mack... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] FCA 1151
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Wong (Trustee), in the matter of Mackellar (Bankrupt) v Mackellar involved an application for recognition of a foreign proceeding as a foreign main proceeding or foreign non-main proceeding under the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) and the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. The proceeding in question was a bankruptcy proceeding in the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. The respondent, Mr Mackellar, filed no evidence in opposition and did not oppose the orders sought by the applicants, the trustees in bankruptcy.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Hong Kong proceeding should be recognised as a foreign main proceeding or a foreign non-main proceeding, and whether appropriate ancillary relief should be granted under Art 21 of the Model Law. The court considered the evidence and submissions of the trustees and found that Mr Mackellar's centre of main interests was in Hong Kong, despite his physical presence in Australia due to the current Covid-19 pandemic. The court also found that the Hong Kong proceeding should be recognised as a foreign main proceeding.

The court granted the orders sought by the trustees, including a stay on proceedings against the debtor or any of his assets, a stay on enforcement of judgments or orders, and suspension of dealings in his property. The court also ordered that the administration and realisation of the debtor’s assets located in Australia be entrusted to the foreign representatives and that all powers normally available to a trustee in bankruptcy under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) be made available to the foreign representatives.

In summary, the court recognised the Hong Kong proceeding as a foreign main proceeding and granted the ancillary relief sought by the trustees. The court also made orders for the respondent to be examined and to pay the applicants' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to section 6 of the Cross-Border Insolvency Act 2008 (Cth) (the CBI Act), Articles 15 and 17 of the Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency of the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law (the Model Law) and rule 14.03 of the Federal Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2016 (Cth), the proceeding in the High Court of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region, Court of First Instance in bankruptcy proceedings number 7321 of 2017, Re: Mackellar Wolfgang Frank William, relating to the respondent (the Foreign Proceeding), in which the applicants were appointed jointly and severally as the trustees in bankruptcy for the estate of the respondent, be recognised as a foreign proceeding, within the meaning of Article 2(a) of the Model Law.

2. Pursuant to section 6 of the Act and Articles 17(2)(b) of the Model Law, the Foreign Proceeding be recognised as a foreign main proceeding.

3. Pursuant to section 6 of the Act and Article 21(1)(a)-(c) of the Model Law, except with the leave of the Court or with the applicants’ written consent:

(a) the commencement, continuation of enforcement of any individual action or legal proceeding (without limitation, any arbitration, mediation, or any judicial, quasi-judicial, administrative action, proceedings or process whatsoever) against the respondent or any of his assets, rights or obligations be stayed;

(b) the enforcement or any execution of judgment, order or award against the respondent or his assets be stayed;

(c) the right to transfer, encumber, or otherwise dispose of any of the respondent’s property be suspended;

to the same extent that would apply if each such stay or suspension arose under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

4. Pursuant to section 6 of the Act and Article 21(1)(g) of the Model Law, all powers available to a trustee in bankruptcy appointed under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) be made available to the applicants until each ceases to be a foreign representative in relation to the Foreign Proceeding.

5. Pursuant to section 6 of the Act and Article 21(1)(d) of the Model Law, the respondent to be examined so as to provide evidence on oath, as well as delivering up all documents in his power or possession concerning the respondent’s assets, affairs, rights, obligations or liabilities (the Examination).

6. The respondent pay the applicants’ costs.

7. Subject to order 6, the costs of the applicants be costs of the bankruptcy of the respondent, and accorded the same priority as costs of the proceedings incurred by a trustee in bankruptcy appointed under the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

8. The remainder of the application be adjourned until 9:30am on 12 October 2020.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The evidence before the Court establishes that Mr Mackellar was served with the application and that he has entered an appearance by his solicitors. Orders were made on 21 July 2020 that he file and serve any affidavit material on which he intended to rely at the hearing of the application by 28 July 2020. No material was filed in accordance with that order. Mr Mackellar appeared at the hearing by his solicitor but did not advance any submissions and did not oppose the making of the orders sought by the trustees. The unfortunate consequence was that the court did not, therefore, have an effective contradictor in relation to some of the more difficult questions in issue.Relevant facts There is no need to detail the circumstances which led to the Hong Kong Court making a sequestration order in respect of the estate of Mr Mackellar. It suffices to observe that judgment was entered against him in the Hong Kong District Court on 22 September 2017 for an amount of HK$973,145 (approx AUD $175,000) by BOC Credit Card (International) Ltd (BOC). The judgment debt was not paid and BOC eventually commenced the bankruptcy proceedings against him which resulted in the making of the sequestration order. The Hong Kong Official Receiver was initially appointed as Mr Mackellar’s trustee in bankruptcy by the original court order, however, that entity was replaced by the trustees following a resolution of creditors. The resolution was formally filed with the Hong Kong Court. The trustees have deposed that Mr Mackellar has failed to respond to their requests for information about his assets, affairs, rights, obligations and liabilities. He has further failed to comply with his obligation to file a completed statement of affairs. None of this is disputed. As a result of Mr Mackellar’s failure to comply with his obligations under the Hong Kong bankruptcy laws, the Official Receiver and the trustees applied to the Hong Kong Court for orders extending the period of bankruptcy. Orders were made on that application to the effect that the relevant period of bankruptcy, within the meaning of that term as it is used in the Bankruptcy Ordinance (Chapter 6) (the Ordinance), be deemed not to have commenced to run from the date of the sequestration order, namely 31 January 2018, but from when Mr Mackellar complies with his obligations under the Ordinance, including that he attend an interview and provide certain information to the trustees. The effect is that Mr Mackellar’s bankruptcy will not lapse until four years from the date on which he complies with the obligations imposed on him by Hong Kong insolvency laws. The trustees have deposed that they are unaware of any assets or other property owned by Mr Mackellar in Hong Kong. In the incomplete statement of affairs which Mr Mackellar delivered to the trustees, he nominated his present address as being in Brookfield in Queensland and that is consistent with his having instructed the Brisbane firm of solicitors, Hopgood Ganim, in relation to the present application. It was submitted on behalf of the trustees, and it is accepted, that in the current Covid-19 pandemic circumstances it is not foreseeable that Mr Mackellar will be able to reside anywhere other than in Queensland or, at least, Australia for the foreseeable future. That would seem to be true despite Mr Mackellar’s identified occupation as airline pilot.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Here it might possibly be discerned that Mr Mackellar presently resides in Australia. However, there is no evidence as to the duration of his residency, the permanence or otherwise of it, his modality of living or of his intentions. The reality is that all that is known is that he is physically located here at the present time and that he probably will not depart in the near future given the current pandemic. His directorship of a company called “Mackellar Industries Pty Ltd” adds very little to the issue. In these circumstances, it is not possible to find that he is “habitually resident” here with the result that the presumption in Art 16(3) is of no application in this matter. Conclusion on Mr Mackellar’s centre of main interests Despite the paucity of evidence, that which is available is sufficient to disclose objective and ascertainable indicators which reveal that Mr Mackellar conducts the administration of his interests on a regular basis in Hong Kong. The evidence of the existence of his sizeable debts and his attempts to reach a compromise with his creditors suggest the conduct of continual business activity there, albeit that it takes place in the context of the winding up of his affairs. In the context of his present circumstances the conduct is relatively substantial. In the absence of any evidence that he undertakes any activities in any other location, Mr Mackellar’s activities remain centred in Hong Kong. Had there been some evidence that he was habitually resident here, the presumption in Art 16 might have displaced the otherwise slim evidence as to Mr Mackellar’s activities, however, there was none and Mr Mackellar did not oppose the making of the orders. Albeit not without a degree of hesitation, it can be concluded that the trustees have established that the Hong Kong Proceedings be recognised as a “foreign main proceeding”. A foreign non-main proceeding In the alternative, the trustees submitted that the Hong Kong Proceedings were a foreign non-main proceeding. That would necessitate a finding that Hong Kong was a place where Mr Mackellar had an “establishment”, being any place of operations where the debtor carries out a non-transitory economic activity with human means and goods or services. If it had not been determined that the proceedings were a foreign main proceeding, the evidence might have established that it was a foreign non-main proceeding for the reasons referred to above. That is, on the only available evidence, it might have been concluded that whatever activities Mr Mackellar carries out, even if they are only in the finalisation of his financial affairs, they are carried out in Hong Kong. Ultimately, however, there is no need to reach any final conclusion on this issue. Appropriate orders In the light of the foregoing it is appropriate to recognise the Hong Kong Proceedings as being a foreign proceeding within the meaning of Art 2(a) of the Model Law and, further, that it be recognised as a foreign main proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Additional procedural requirements on the making of an application for recognition are imposed by r 14.03 of the Federal Court (Bankruptcy) Rules 2016 (Cth) (Federal Court Bankruptcy Rules) which provide:(1) An application by a foreign representative for recognition of a foreign proceeding under article 15 of the Model Law must be made by filing an application in accordance with Form B2.(2) The application must:(a) be accompanied by the statements mentioned in article 15 of the Model Law and in section 13 of the Cross‑Border Insolvency Act; and(b) name the foreign representative as the applicant and the debtor as the respondent; and(c) be accompanied by an affidavit verifying the matters mentioned in paragraphs 2 and 3 of article 15 of the Model Law and in section 13 of the Cross‑Border Insolvency Act.(3) When filing the application, the foreign representative must file, but need not serve, an interim application seeking directions as to service, and the Court may give any directions about service, and make any incidental orders, that it thinks just.(4) The applicant must serve a copy of the application and the other documents mentioned in subrule (2):(a) unless the Court otherwise orders—on each respondent (if any) to the proceeding as soon as practicable after filing an application and, in any case, at least 5 days before the date fixed for hearing; and(b) on any other persons the Court may direct at the hearing of the interim application.(5) A person who intends to appear before the Court at the hearing of an application for recognition must file and serve the documents mentioned in rule 2.04.Consideration Service and compliance with procedural matters There is no doubt that the present application and supporting materials were served on Mr Mackellar. Not only is that deposed to in the affidavit of Mr Darrin Costello, but on 17 July 2020 Mr Mackellar, by his solicitors Hopgood Ganim, entered an appearance. The proceedings have been commenced by and in the correct form being Form B2 as prescribed by the Federal Court Bankruptcy Rules. Service was effected at least five days prior to the hearing as required by r 14.03(4)(b). The application has also been made to the correct court as required by Art 4, being the Federal Court. The trustees have deposed to all of the matters required to be stated in the material, being the verification of the matters in Art 15 of the Model Law and s 13 of the CBI Act:(a)A certified copy of the decision making the sequestration order is before the Court as is a copy of the document initiating the proceedings in Hong Kong and these satisfy the requirements of Art 15(2). By Art 16 the Court is entitled to presume the authenticity of the documents exhibited in support of the truth of the trustees’ assertions in this respect. (b)Mr Wong has stated in his affidavit that he is not aware of any proceedings in Hong Kong involving Mr Mackellar and is not aware of any other proceeding in Australia or elsewhere involving Mr Mackellar under the Bankruptcy Act to appoint a receiver or controller or managing controller in relation to his property, pursuant to the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) or in any respect whatsoever. These statements satisfy Art 15(3) and s 13 of the CBI Act.