Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 293

Citation: Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 293
Appeal from: Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2009] FMCA 1074
Parties: JULENE WINN v BLUEPRINT INSTANT PRINTING PTY LTD
File number(s): VID 817 of 2009
Judge: RYAN J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2011
Date of hearing: 9 April 2010
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Appellant: The appellant appeared in person
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr T J Scotter
Solicitor for the Respondent: Herbert Geer Rundle

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 817 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

JULENE WINN
Appellant

AND:

BLUEPRINT INSTANT PRINTING PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE OF ORDER:

31 MARCH 2011

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal from the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court of 30 October 2009 be dismissed

2.The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal, such costs to be taxed in default of agreement.

3.The costs referred to in paragraph 2 of this order form part of the petitioning creditor’s costs if a sequestration order be made, or has been made, as a result of the appellant’s non-compliance with Bankruptcy Notice VN 358 of 2009.

Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
The text of entered orders can be located using Federal Law Search on the Court’s website.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 817 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

JULENE WINN
Appellant

AND:

BLUEPRINT INSTANT PRINTING PTY LTD
Respondent

JUDGE:

RYAN J

DATE:

31 MARCH 2011

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. On 20 February 2009 the abovenamed respondent, Blueprint Printing Pty Ltd (“Blueprint”) issued a second bankruptcy notice No. 358/2009 (“the second bankruptcy notice”) based on the same orders of 9 November 2005 of the Taxing Master of the Supreme Court of Victoria which had been identified in my separate reasons published today, in proceedings in this Court No. VID 921 of 2008 (“the first reasons”).

  2. On 30 October 2009 Phipps FM in the Federal Magistrates Court ordered;

    1.The application filed 20 July 2009 to set aside Bankruptcy Notice VN 358 of 2009 is dismissed.

    2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.  The costs in this application be also creditors costs in any creditors petition brought based on Bankruptcy Notice VN 358 of 2009.

  3. On 12 November 2009, Julene Winn (“the appellant”) filed a notice of appeal from the orders set out at [2] above.  On 12 March 2010 the appellant sought leave to amend that notice.  I shall deal with the appeal on the basis that it is brought on the following grounds set out in the proposed amended notice of appeal;

    1.        The Court erred in failing to find that the bankruptcy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd, the appellant, Winn, sought to appeal various orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court concerning bankruptcy notices issued by the respondent, Blueprint. The primary focus of the appeal was on the validity of the bankruptcy notices and the associated costs orders. Winn argued that the bankruptcy notices were invalid due to various alleged errors and misrepresentations, and that the costs orders were unjust. The respondent, Blueprint, defended the validity of the notices and the orders, arguing that Winn had no valid grounds for her claims.

The court examined several grounds of appeal raised by Winn, including claims that the bankruptcy notices misstated the debt and interest claimed, and that the Federal Magistrates Court had improperly obtained material outside the hearing. The court found that none of these grounds had merit. It concluded that the notices were properly issued and that the claims for costs were not substantiated. The court also noted that Winn had not been able to demonstrate any abuse of process by the respondent in issuing the notices.

The court ultimately dismissed the appeal and ordered Winn to pay the respondent's costs. It was further ordered that the costs of the appeal would form part of the petitioning creditor's costs if a sequestration order were made due to Winn's non-compliance with the bankruptcy notice. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to legal processes and the consequences of failing to do so, particularly in the context of bankruptcy proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal from the orders of the Federal Magistrates Court of 30 October 2009 be dismissed

2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal, such costs to be taxed in default of agreement.

3. The costs referred to in paragraph 2 of this order form part of the petitioning creditor’s costs if a sequestration order be made, or has been made, as a result of the appellant’s non-compliance with Bankruptcy Notice VN 358 of 2009.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As explained at [43] of the first reasons, there cannot be imputed to the Federal Magistrates Court any error by way of misapprehension of the Taxing Master’s allegedly mistaken aggregation of the costs payable to Blueprint and to Goodwin respectively.Ground 2(f) - that Goodwin had given sworn evidence that Blueprint had paid his costs and claimed them as part of its own against the appellant This sub-ground falls with sub-ground 2(e) for the reasons explained at [43] of the first reasons as adopted at [42] above.Ground 2(g) - that the Taxing Master is obliged by O 63 r 56.1(5) of the Supreme Court Rules to review Blueprint’s bill of costs and vary or affirm the order of 9 November 2005. This ground is fully answered by the matters canvassed at [39] above which precluded the appellant, after 28 November 2008, from agitating between herself and Blueprint her claim for a review of the Taxing Master’s order of 9 November 2005.Ground 2(h) - that the Supreme Court has failed since 13 December 2005 to review the Taxing Master’s order and since 1 May 2006 to hear an appeal in relation to that failure. The considerations noted in relation to sub-ground 2(g) have similarly precluded the appellant, since 28 November 2008, from asserting that this issue should be resolved differently between herself and Blueprint and from seeking curial relief to that effect.Ground 2(i) - the sworn statements of Mr. Lassen and Terry that the appellant paid $1,750 in respect of the order of the Taxing Master of 9 November 2005 are false; This complaint by the appellant is answered by the considerations summarised at [30] and [31] above.Ground 2(j) - in the circumstances of (d), (e), (f), (g) and (h) the Taxing Master’s order of 9 November 2005 was obtained by dishonesty and a miscarriage of justice; Since none of the complaints or criticisms discussed in relation to sub-grounds 2(d), 2(e), 2(f), 2(g) and 2(h) has been made out, this compendious sub-ground of appeal also fails.Ground 2(k) - Blueprint’s conduct in (i) claiming Goodwin’s costs of 4216 and 4217 of 2002 as Blueprint’s costs in 4215 of 2002 to defeat the appellant’s counterclaim against Goodwin, and (ii) repeatedly issuing (4) bankruptcy notices that are invalid and / or not pursued for the collateral purpose of frustrating the review of taxation costs is an abuse of process; This sub-ground is answered in part by the matters canvassed at [60] of the first reasons. In addition, the only bankruptcy notices which Phipps FM had to consider were that numbered VN 1372 of 2008, which was the subject of Riley FM’s orders, and that numbered VN 358 of 2009, which was the subject of the immediate application to set it aside which his Honour was hearing.Ground 3 - that the Federal Magistrates Court failed to hold that the issue of two bankruptcy notices based on the same judgment debt was an abuse of process requiring it to “stay” the second bankruptcy notice As noted at [38] above, the first bankruptcy notice ceased to have any effect on 24 November 2008 when O’Dwyer FM made his order dismissing the creditor’s petition which had been founded on the first bankruptcy notice. The second bankruptcy notice was not issued until 20 February 2009. There can be no suggestion that the issue of more than one bankruptcy notice based on the same judgment debt is an abuse of process. Such a course was expressly contemplated as being regular by a Full Court of this Court in Abignano & Anor v Wenkart [1998] FCA 1468. See also Romano v Peldan [2003] FCA 767 where Dowsett J observed, at [17];Thirdly, it is submitted that the issue of a second bankruptcy notice was an abuse of process. Counsel conceded in the course of argument that this may simply be another way of ventilating the broader construction point to which I have referred. In any event, it is not a complaint which can be made out. It is quite clear from [Re] Fredericke [and Whitworth Ex parte Hibbard [1927] 1 Ch. 253] and Abignano that the issue of a second bankruptcy notice is not an abuse of process per se although, in appropriate circumstances, it may be necessary for the judgment creditor to make an election. The second notice was not issued in bad faith or to embarrass the debtor. It was issued for the proper purpose of advancing the bankruptcy process, given that the appellant was complaining about the inclusion of a relatively small amount of interest in the first bankruptcy notice. Ground 4 - that the Federal Magistrates Court erred in independently procuring material outside the hearing

Decision

Reasons for decision

I agree with the learned Federal Magistrate that this issue has been conclusively resolved against the appellant by Smith J in the Supreme Court of Victoria in proceedings between the same parties entitled Winn v Blueprint Instant Printing Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 522. In reasons published on 28 November 2008, his Honour concluded, at [30];I proceed on the basis that, there being no time limit in his Honour’s order for payment of the $1750.00, the fact that Ms Winn waited 15 months to pay the amount of $1750.00 does not prevent the payment complying with the order. But she has the difficulty that she did not appropriate that payment expressly as a payment pursuant to the relevant order. There were in fact other orders which required payments of the same amount. Not having appropriated the payment to a particular order, she cannot now complain that Blueprint did not appropriate that payment to the order which she now seeks to have lifted to have a review conducted of the original taxation decision.Ground 1(g) - that the bankruptcy notice misstated the claim as a judgment debt. I do not understand this ground and have been unable to relate it to any part of the learned Federal Magistrate’s reasons which has not been canvassed elsewhere in these reasons. It is clear from the terms of the bankruptcy notice that it claimed a debt of $21,655.63 “as shown in the Schedule” and recited that “a copy of the judgments or orders relied on by the creditor is attached.” I cannot discern any respect in which the claim was misstated as a judgment debt unless the appellant is referring to the contention discussed above that the Taxing Master’s order was not a final order or a final judgment of the kind which could found a bankruptcy notice.Ground 1(h) - that the bankruptcy notice overstated the interest claim In support of this ground, the appellant contended only that;The interest is overstated because it is claimed beyond the six year limit and is claimed on a judgment debt that does not exist.In the particulars of interest claimed in Item 3 of the Schedule to the bankruptcy notice it was recited:Interest is claimed pursuant to section 101(1) of the Supreme Court Act 1985 (Vic) at the rate for the time being fixed under section 2 of the Penalty Interest Rates Act 1983 (Vic) as follows: This ground of appeal fails for the reasons explained at [61] of the first reasons.Ground 1(j) - that the bankruptcy notice was invalidated by each of sub-grounds 1(a) to 1(i). This compendious assertion of invalidity of the bankruptcy notice could only be made out if one or more of the preceding sub-grounds (a) to (i) had been upheld. For the reasons outlined above, that has not occurred.Ground 2(a) - that the appellant had a counterclaim in excess of the amount claimed in the bankruptcy notice. The appellant appears to rely in support of this ground on two alleged actual or contingent liabilities of Blueprint to her.(i) The joint liability of Blueprint and GoodwinThis contention has been considered and rejected at [61] of the first reasons.(ii) The contingent liability of Blueprint to pay the appellant’s costs at first instance in proceedings MLG 1351 of 2007 and on the appeal to this Court numbered VID 921 of 2008.As appears from the first reasons and the orders made today in VID 921 of 2008 the appellant has not obtained an order for payment by Blueprint of her costs in either proceeding. This contended counterclaim, therefore, cannot be established.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.