Williams v Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council

Link copied
Case Copied 83 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
BELL, GAGELER, KEANE, NETTLE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ

GLEN RICHARD WILLIAMS  APPELLANT

AND

WRECK BAY ABORIGINAL COMMUNITY
COUNCIL & ANOR  RESPONDENTS

Williams v Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council

[2019] HCA 4

13 February 2019

C5/2018

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the order in paragraph 2 of the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory made on 23 October 2017 and, in its place, order that the order in paragraph 1 of the order of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory made on 25 August 2016 be set aside, and, in its place, order that questions 3 and 4 in the amended special case be answered as follows:

Question 3

[I]s the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in whole or in part, a law which is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?

Answer

Yes, the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in part, is a law that is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth).

Question 4

If the answer to Question 3 is "yes", to what extent does the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?

Answer

The Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) does not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) to the extent that s 8(1)(a) read with Sch 1, cl 72 and further read with s 9 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) would prohibit subletting, and ss 54 and 128 operate upon that prohibition, on Aboriginal Land.

On appeal from the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory

Representation

G R Kennett SC for the appellant (instructed by Clayton Utz)

J K Kirk SC with R J Arthur and P D Herzfeld for the first respondent (instructed by Ken Cush & Associates)

P J F Garrisson SC, Solicitor-General for the Australian Capital Territory, with P M Bindon for the second respondent (instructed by ACT Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Constitutional law (Cth) – Powers of Commonwealth Parliament – Territories – Inconsistency between Commonwealth and Territory laws – Where Council empowered under Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) ("Land Grant Act") to grant leases over certain land within Jervis Bay Territory ("JBT") – Where Land Grant Act does not affect application of other laws to extent other laws "capable of operating concurrently" with Land Grant Act – Where Residential Tenancies…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Williams v Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] HCA 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia considered a dispute between Mr Williams and the Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council (the Council) concerning the application of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) to land within the Jervis Bay Territory. The Council, empowered by the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) (the Land Grant Act) to grant leases over this land, argued that certain provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act were not capable of operating concurrently with the Land Grant Act.

The central legal issue before the High Court was to determine whether, and to what extent, the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) was a law that was not capable of operating concurrently with the Land Grant Act, as provided for by section 46 of the Land Grant Act. This section stipulates that the Land Grant Act does not affect the application of other laws to the extent that those other laws are capable of operating concurrently with the Land Grant Act. The specific question was whether the imposition of statutory obligations, such as a lessor's duty to maintain premises in a reasonable state of repair, would "alter, impair or detract from" the scheme established by the Land Grant Act.

The High Court reasoned that the Land Grant Act did not contemplate that leases granted to registered members of the Council might provide premises with a lower standard of maintenance than leases granted to non-members. The Court found that the Residential Tenancies Act, in part, was not capable of operating concurrently with the Land Grant Act. Specifically, the Court determined that the Residential Tenancies Act does not apply to Aboriginal Land to the extent that its provisions prohibiting subletting, and related sections, would operate on Aboriginal Land.

The appeal was allowed, and the orders of the Court of Appeal were set aside. The High Court answered Question 3 of the amended special case in the affirmative, finding that the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in part, is a law not capable of operating concurrently with the Land Grant Act. In response to Question 4, the Court clarified that the Residential Tenancies Act does not apply to Aboriginal Land to the extent that certain provisions concerning subletting would be operative.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order in paragraph 2 of the order of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory made on 23 October 2017 and, in its place, order that the order in paragraph 1 of the order of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory made on 25 August 2016 be set aside, and, in its place, order that questions 3 and 4 in the amended special case be answered as follows:

Question 3

[I]s the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in whole or in part, a law which is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?

Answer

Yes, the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in part, is a law that is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth).

Question 4

If the answer to Question 3 is "yes", to what extent does the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?

Answer

The Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) does not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) to the extent that s 8(1)(a) read with Sch 1, cl 72 and further read with s 9 of the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) would prohibit subletting, and ss 54 and 128 operate upon that prohibition, on Aboriginal Land.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ BELL J GAGELER J EDELMAN J (dissent)
This consideration has no application in relation to leases to persons who are not registered members of the Council. Such leases may be granted under s 38(2)(d), (e) and (f). The notion of membership control of the Council affords no protection at all to these classes of lessee. The self‑interest of Council members could not be relied upon to guarantee that the terms and conditions of these leases would be fair and just. Further, to the extent that the general law is available to protect these classes of lessee, nothing in the Land Grant Act suggests that the protection afforded to lessees by the general law should be available to lessees other than registered members but not to registered members. There is no reason to suppose that the Land Grant Act contemplates that leases to registered members might provide premises with a lower standard of maintenance, in terms of human habitability, than is required in leases to persons who are not registered members.Conclusion and orders For these reasons, the appeal should be allowed. The questions posed by the amended special case should be answered in the terms proposed by the Attorney‑General for the ACT, as follows:Question 3:"[I]s the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in whole or in part, a law which is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?"Answer: "Yes, the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT), in part, is a law that is not capable of operating concurrently with the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) within the meaning of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)."Question 4:"If the answer to Question 3 is 'yes', to what extent does the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth)?"Answer:"The Residential Tenancies Act1997 (ACT) does not apply to Aboriginal Land for the purposes of s 46 of the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) to the extent that s 8(1)(a) read with Sch 1, cl 72 and further read with s 9 of the Residential Tenancies Act1997 (ACT) would prohibit subletting, and ss 54 and 128 operate upon that prohibition, on Aboriginal Land." The parties have agreed to bear their own costs. I gratefully adopt the facts and procedural history set out in the joint reasons. The Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council ("the Council") conceded before the primary judge that the Aboriginal Land Grant (Jervis Bay Territory) Act 1986 (Cth) ("the Land Grant Act") and the Residential Tenancies Act 1997 (ACT) are capable of simultaneous obedience. It did not put its case below, or in this Court, on the basis that the Land Grant Act "cover[s] the field"[67]. The case on which the Council succeeded before the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory is that the provisions of the Residential Tenancies Act on which Mr Williams relies[68] are not capable of concurrent operation with the Land Grant Act because, relevantly, the imposition of a statutory obligation of repair on the Council would "alter, impair or detract from" the scheme of the Land Grant Act[69].[67]Wreck Bay Aboriginal Community Council v Williams (2016) 312 FLR 60 at 63 [25].[68]Residential Tenancies Act, ss 8, 9 and cl 55 of Sch 1.[69]Australian Mutual Provident Society v Goulden (1986) 160 CLR 330 at 337; [1986] HCA 24, citing Victoria v The Commonwealth (1937) 58 CLR 618 at 630 per Dixon J; [1937] HCA 82.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, NETTLE AND GORDON JJ, BELL J, GAGELER J,

Full text does not contain this section.