White v State Coroner of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

CITATION:   WHITE -v- STATE CORONER OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2022] WASC 418

CORAM:   TOTTLE J

HEARD:   24 NOVEMBER 2022

DELIVERED          :   8 DECEMBER 2022

FILE NO/S:   CIV 1547 of 2022

BETWEEN:   BRADLEY WHITE

Plaintiff

AND

STATE CORONER OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Defendant


Catchwords:

Coroner - Coroner declined to hold inquest - Application to the court that an inquest be held - Whether it is necessary or desirable in the interests of justice that an inquest be held - Turns on own facts

Legislation:

Births, Deaths and Marriages Registration Act1998 (WA), s 44
Coroners Act 1996 (WA), s 3, s 19, s 22, s 24, s 25

Result:

Application dismissed

Representation:

Counsel:

Plaintiff : RL Sorgiovanni
Defendant : FB Seaward SC

Solicitors:

Plaintiff : Soul Legal (Perth)
Defendant : State Solicitor's Office

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Chief Commissioner of Police v Hallenstein [1996] 2 VR 1

Chiotelis v Her Honour Judge Coate [2009] VSC 256; (2009) 53 MVR 47

Clancy v West [1996] 2 VR 647

Fink v State Coroner of Western Australia [2022] WASC 44

Harmsworth v The State Coroner [1989] VR 989

Herron v Attorney-General (NSW) (1987) 8 NSWLR 601

Irfani v The State Coroner [2011] WASC 270; (2011) 254 FLR 120

Mullaley v State Coroner of Western Australia [2020] WASC 264

R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman [1980] HCA 13; (1980) 144 CLR 13

Re State Coroner; Ex parte Minister for Health [2009] WASCA 165; (2009) 38 WAR 553

Rouf v Johnstone [1999] VSC 396

Veitch v The State Coroner [2008] WASC 187

TOTTLE J:

Introduction

  1. On 6 January 2020, the plaintiff's late wife, Mary Lilian Grace Tino, was admitted to Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital. She was suffering from an aggressive (high grade) cancer - leiomyosarcoma of the uterus. She was receiving palliative care. Her life expectancy was four to 12 months. Ms Tino died seven days later on 13 January 2020. The plaintiff asked the coroner to hold an inquest because he had concerns about the medical treatment Ms Tino received following her admission to hospital on 6 January 2020. The coroner refused the request on the basis that holding an inquest was unlikely to generate additional evidence that would assist in making the findings required to be made under s 25 of the Coroners Act 1996 (WA) (the Act) and that it was not desirable to hold an inquest.[1] 

    [1] Affidavit of Bradley White sworn 11 June 2022, Attachment BW-7, pp 84 - 85.

  2. The plaintiff has applied to this court for an order under s 24(3) of the Act that an inquest be held. In support of the application the plaintiff relies on two affidavits sworn by him.[2]  

    [2] Affidavits of Bradley White sworn 11 June 2022 and 13 September 2022.  

  3. Conformably with the observations of the members of the High Court in R v Australian Broadcasting Tribunal; Ex parte Hardiman,[3] the coroner appeared by senior counsel to make…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read White v State Coroner of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASC 418
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of White v State Coroner of Western Australia, the deceased, Ms Mary Tino, had been diagnosed with a high-grade leiomyosarcoma, a form of aggressive cancer. The primary concern raised by Mr White, the deceased's partner, was the quality of care Ms Tino received from her initial diagnosis in March 2016 to her death in January 2020. Mr White specifically questioned the delay in administering antibiotics and the cause of a significant hemorrhage within Ms Tino's abdominal tumor. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.

The central legal issues before the court involved assessing whether the medical care provided to Ms Tino was appropriate, given her advanced and aggressive cancer. The court needed to determine if the delay in administering antibiotics and the handling of the hemorrhage within her tumor were justifiable under the circumstances, and if there were any systemic failures in her treatment that could have altered her prognosis.

The court examined the medical evidence provided by Dr Salfinger, who concluded that the care provided was appropriate given Ms Tino's condition. Dr Salfinger explained that there were no overt signs of sepsis at the time Ms Tino was admitted, and the administration of antibiotics would not have changed her outcome due to the extensive nature of her disease. Regarding the hemorrhage, Dr Salfinger found that it was likely a spontaneous event exacerbated by Ms Tino's anticoagulant medication, not a result of the needle aspiration performed to drain ascitic fluid. The court found Dr Salfinger's opinion persuasive, confirming that no other tests or treatments could have reasonably altered Ms Tino's prognosis given her advanced stage of cancer and the presence of both bleeding and clotting disorders.

In conclusion, the court determined that there were no valid concerns regarding the treatment Ms Tino received. The delays in her treatment were largely due to her personal decision-making process, which was reasonable under the circumstances, and the medical care provided was consistent with the standard expected in her condition. The court dismissed Mr White's claims, finding no evidence of negligence or substandard care in the treatment of Ms Tino.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Dr Salfinger addressed the questions he was asked to address as follows:[61][61] Affidavit of Kelly Marie Niclair affirmed 3 August 2022, Attachment KMN-28, pp 1155 - 1156.I will now address the specific questions with opinions sought. 1.The question was raised as to why Ms Tino was not given antibiotics at the time of her admission to Sir Charles Gardener Hospital on 6 January and why this was delayed until 11 January.From the review of documentation, it does appear that there were no overt signs of sepsis and indeed Mary Tino only had a low-grade temperature on 9 January and no other fevers and thus nothing suggestive of infection at that stage. Her white cell count could not be used as an effective indicator because of her previous administration of Pegfilgrastim. The primary issue over this stage of admission would be control of the patient's pain, in the setting of advanced malignancy. Ms Tino developed a single temperature spike but still less that 38 degrees on 11 January and this was the point, antibiotics were commenced. Over this period of time, from 6 January through to 11 January she appeared to be extensively investigated and there did not appear to be any concerns with regard to sepsis prior to this. In view of this, I do not feel admission of antibiotics in the early stage would of seemed to have been appropriate. Regardless of this, even if Ms Tino had been administer antibiotics at an earlier stage, given the advanced, extensive disease effecting multiple organs and what appears to be the significant spontaneous hemorrhage into the tumour itself being the likely precipitating terminal event, the administration of antibiotics at any stage would not have made any difference to the ultimate outcome for Ms Tino.2Mr White has raised specific concerns with regards to small puncture needle marks on the abdominal wall, mentioned in the postmortem.These appear to be related to the attempt to percutaneously drain the ascitic fluid in the early hours of 13 January after the patients return from the operating theatre. These are described specifically in the forensic pathologist report as been small needle puncture marks that penetrate only superficially into the tumour mass itself with only focal hemorrhagic appearance around these puncture sites. The forensic pathologist also goes further in saying that the punctures appear superficial and not related to the main hemorrhagic focus within the tumour. In view of this, in my opinion the hemorrhage within Ms Tino's tumour was a spontaneous hemorrhage most likely worsened by the fact that she was on strong anticoagulant medication necessitated by her clot situation. Given the distance from the main hemorrhage and the minor nature of the needle punctures, separate from the major hemorrhagic focus in the tumour, it does not follow the needle aspiration could be responsible for the hemorrhage within the tumour and in fact the fall in the patient's hemoglobin prior to this. This would suggest that the hemorrhage had commenced prior to the event of the needle aspiration.3.As outlined above, I do not believe that any other test, investigations or treatments that could have been performed or undertaken to alter the course of Ms Tino's disease.She had advanced widely metastatic malignancy. She had extensive hemorrhage into the tumour mass within the abdomen likely worsened by the blood thinning medication. She had an extensive clot within the inferior vena cava both above and below the IVC filter which required the ongoing anticoagulation treatment, the cessation potentially resulting in significant pulmonary embolism result of death. Unfortunately, the presence of these two diametrically opposed conditions with significant bleeding but also extensive clot, both posing their own high individual risk of death meaning the situation that Ms Tino was in at this stage was irretrievable.In conclusion; Ms Tino was a young woman effected by a very aggressive tumour. Leiomyosarcoma has a very poor prognosis regardless of stage of diagnosis. 5-year survival rate regardless of stage of diagnosis are extremely poor and in particular are worsened with high grade tumour like Ms Tino had and unfortunately these are very resistant to most forms of adjuvant treatments such as radiation and chemotherapy.Ms Tino had a significant delay in her initial treatment from when she was advised in March 2016 that the recommended pathway was hysterectomy at this stage. This was made clear to her by a number of treating doctors at several different hospitals through March 2016 and documented in the correspondence from these consultations. Also documented is the extensive support with regard to psychosocial decision making and options for pursuing fertility which was Ms Tino's indication for not wishing to proceed with the recommended pathway. Undoubtably with this long delay, it has led to the progression of the disease to the time of her primary surgery. There appeared to be several other brief delays in her treatment course, and it is documented that these are a result of the patient wanting additional time to make decisions with regard to her care, which is understandable with such extensive disease with such a poor prognosis. As such, I do not consider that there are any valid concerns with regard to her treatment of the deceased over the entire course of her care from March 2016 through to her death in January 2020.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established