Ward v Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read
61 CLR 120

CORRIMAL-BALGOWNIE

COLLIERIES LIMITED

RESPONDENT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Workers' Compensation-Injury-" Total and permanent disablement Contributing

factors-Relation to employment or injury-Workers' Compensation Act 1926- 1927 (N.S.W.) (No. 15 of 1926-No. 32 of 1927), sec. 9 (3). SYDNEY, Nov. 10, 11;

Sec. 9 (3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.) provided Dec. 23.

that 'the total liability of an employer in respect of compensation under this Latham C.J.,

section shall not, except in the case of a worker whose injury results in total and permanent disablement, exceed one thousand pounds in any one case."

Held, by Latham C.J., Rich and Dixon JJ., that where a worker receives an injury within the meaning of the Act which results in partial incapacity, and other causes not associated with the injury later bring about total dis- ablement, the worker is not entitled to the benefit of the exception contained in the sub-section.

Held, further, on the facts of the case, by Latham C.J., Rich and Dixon JJ. (McTiernan J. dissenting), that, in view of the findings, the conclusion was justified that the injury, within the meaning of the Act, suffered by the claimant worker had not resulted in his total and permanent disablement but had only partially contributed thereto.

Decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales (Full Court) affirmed.

61 CLR 121

61 C.L.R.]

OF AUSTRALIA.

APPEAL from the Supreme Court of New South Wales.

A case stated by the Workers' Compensation Commission of New South Wales, at the request of the applicant, Thomas Ward. for the determination by the Supreme Court of New South Wales of certain questions, was, as amended, substantially as follows:

1. This case is stated at the request of the respondent under the provisions of sec. 37 (4) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1929 (N.S.W.), and refers for the decision of the Supreme Court certain questions of law which arose in proceedings before the Workers' Compensation Commission of New South Wales.

2. The applicant, Thomas Ward, was employed as a coal-miner at the respondent colliery, and claimed that the inhalation of dust at such work had resulted in his becoming incapacitated for work on 17th April 1929, by pneumoconiosis or other injury to his lungs.

3. On 22nd December 1930, the commission made an award in his favour, which, omitting formal parts, is as follows: Having duly considered the matters submitted, the commission, on the facts, finds :-(i) That the above-named applicant received injury in the course of his employment as a coal-miner through contracting pneumoconiosis to which his employment with the above-named respondent was a contributing factor. (ii) That the fibrosis of the applicant was a result of exposure to dust in his employment. There- upon the commission orders and awards as follows :-(a) That the respondent do pay to the applicant the weekly sum of 4 17s. as com- pensation for personal injury by disease received by the applicant on 17th April 1929, in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ward v Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1938] HCA 70
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Ward v. Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd* involved an appeal to the High Court of Australia from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The appellant, Thomas Ward, a former coal miner, claimed compensation for total and permanent disablement due to pneumoconiosis contracted during his employment. The dispute centred on the interpretation of section 9(3) of the *Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927* (N.S.W.), which limited an employer's total liability to £1,000, except in cases where a worker's injury resulted in total and permanent disablement. Ward had already received £1,000 in compensation, and his claim for further payments hinged on whether his disablement qualified for the exception in section 9(3).

The legal issues before the High Court were whether the Workers' Compensation Commission and the Supreme Court had erred in law regarding the applicant's entitlement to compensation beyond the £1,000 limit. Specifically, the court had to determine if the applicant's injury, a lung condition (pulmonary fibrosis), had resulted in his total and permanent disablement, as required by the exception in section 9(3), or if other, unrelated causes had contributed to his disablement to such an extent that the exception did not apply. The court also considered the extent to which an injury must cause disablement to fall within the exception, and whether partial contribution from an employment-related injury, when combined with other causes, qualified for the exception.

The High Court, by a majority, affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court. The Court reasoned that section 9(3) of the Act required the injury itself to be the cause of the total and permanent disablement for the exception to apply. If an injury contributed to a worker's disablement, but other, independent causes were also responsible for the total and permanent disablement, then the exception did not apply. In this case, the Commission had found that Ward's total and permanent disablement was due to two concurrent causes: pulmonary fibrosis (20% incapacity), which was employment-related, and arteriosclerosis and myocardial degeneration (80% incapacity), which were not associated with his employment. Consequently, the Court held that the injury had not *resulted* in his total and permanent disablement, but had only partially contributed to it, meaning the exception in section 9(3) was not met.

The High Court dismissed the appeal. The decision meant that Ward was not entitled to compensation beyond the £1,000 limit as his disablement was not solely caused by the injury sustained in his employment, but was also due to unrelated medical conditions.

Background

Background to the litigation

Thomas Ward, a coal miner, was employed by Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd. On 17 April 1929, Ward contracted pneumoconiosis while working at the colliery. Pneumoconiosis is a lung disease caused by inhaling dust, in this case from the coal mine. The disease led to pulmonary fibrosis, which is the scarring of lung tissue. Ward claimed that his employment was a contributing factor to his pneumoconiosis and the resulting pulmonary fibrosis. On 22 December 1930, the Workers' Compensation Commission awarded Ward compensation for his injury, finding that his employment was a contributing factor to his condition. The compensation payments continued until 18 July 1933, when the total amount paid to Ward reached £1,000, the maximum liability of the employer under the Workers' Compensation Act 1926 (N.S.W.). Ward then sought further compensation, claiming that his pulmonary fibrosis had resulted in total and permanent disablement. The Workers' Compensation Commission found that Ward was indeed totally and permanently disabled, but this disability was due to two causes: the pulmonary fibrosis from his employment, which contributed to 20% of his incapacity, and arteriosclerosis and myocardial degeneration, which contributed to 80% of his incapacity. The Commission concluded that Ward's injury had not resulted in his total and permanent disablement. Ward appealed this decision to the High Court of Australia.

The matter came before the High Court of Australia on appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The case involves a dispute regarding workers' compensation for Thomas Ward, who claimed total and permanent disablement due to pneumoconiosis caused by his employment as a coal-miner. Initially, Ward was awarded compensation by the Workers' Compensation Commission of New South Wales, which was later affirmed by the Supreme Court. Ward subsequently appealed to the High Court, arguing that his injury should result in full compensation under Section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.). The appeal was heard by the High Court, which considered the legal question of whether Ward's total and permanent disablement resulted from his injury. The High Court ultimately affirmed the decision of the Supreme Court, finding that Ward's disablement was due to two concurrent causes, only one of which was his injury, and thus did not qualify for the exception in Section 9(3).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the total and permanent disablement of the worker resulted from the injury sustained in the course of employment.
2. Whether the injury sustained by the worker contributed to the total and permanent disablement.
3. Whether the injury received by the worker falls within the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.).
4. Whether the commission erred in law in awarding compensation at the rate of 17s. 9d. per week from 19th July 1933 to 19th October 1935, and 16s. per week from 20th October 1935.
5. Whether the injury to the worker resulted in his total and permanent disablement.

Held
1. Whether the total and permanent disablement of the worker resulted from the injury sustained in the course of employment.
The court concluded that the worker's total and permanent disablement did not result from the injury sustained in the course of employment, but rather from the combination of the injury and other independent causes. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed.

2. Whether the injury sustained by the worker contributed to the total and permanent disablement.
The court concluded that the injury sustained by the worker contributed to the total and permanent disablement but did not solely result in it. Therefore, the worker was not entitled to the benefit of the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.).

3. Whether the injury received by the worker falls within the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.).
The court concluded that the injury received by the worker did not fall within the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.). Therefore, the worker was not entitled to the benefit of the exception.

4. Whether the commission erred in law in awarding compensation at the rate of 17s. 9d. per week from 19th July 1933 to 19th October 1935, and 16s. per week from 20th October 1935.
The court concluded that the commission did err in law in awarding compensation at the mentioned rates. The award should have been for either the full amount payable for total incapacity or nothing at all under section 9(3). Therefore, the decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales was affirmed.

5. Whether the injury to the worker resulted in his total and permanent disablement.
The court concluded that the injury to the worker did not result in his total and permanent disablement. The total and permanent disablement was due to two causes operating concurrently, one of which was the injury. Therefore, the worker was not entitled to the benefit of the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia, in Ward v Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd, addressed several key legal issues regarding workers' compensation. The central issue was whether the worker's total and permanent disablement resulted from the injury sustained in the course of employment. The Court held that if a worker receives an injury within the meaning of the Act that results in partial incapacity and other causes, not associated with the injury, later bring about total disablement, the worker is not entitled to the benefit of the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.).

The Court applied the legal principle that compensation under the Act is not paid in respect of the injury itself but in respect of death or total or partial incapacity resulting from an injury. The Court emphasized that the injury is the element that completes the tale of circumstances which constitutes the cause of the incapacity. However, the incapacity which results from the injury is distinct from the incapacity caused by other factors. If total incapacity results from an injury, it is immaterial that total incapacity may subsequently be brought about by a new cause.

In this case, the Court found that the worker's total and permanent disablement was due to two causes operating concurrently: pulmonary fibrosis and arteriosclerosis and myocardial degeneration. The Court concluded that the pulmonary fibrosis, which was the result of the worker's employment, did not alone result in total and permanent disablement. The total and permanent disablement resulted from the combination of the pulmonary fibrosis and the other independent causes.

The Court further held that the commission erred in law in awarding compensation at the rate of 17s. 9d. per week from 19th July 1933 to 19th October 1935, and 16s. per week from 20th October 1935. The Court found that the injury to the worker did not result in his total and permanent disablement.

The Court distinguished prior authority by clarifying that the term "results" in the exception of section 9(3) must mean that the total and permanent disablement is solely caused by the injury, not partially caused by it in combination with other independent causes. The Court emphasized that if total incapacity results from independent causes that are not associated with the injury, the employer is not liable for that additional incapacity under the Act.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a worker's total and permanent disablement is due to the combination of an injury and other independent causes, the worker is not entitled to the benefit of the exception in section 9(3) of the Workers' Compensation Act 1926-1927 (N.S.W.). The total and permanent disablement must result solely from the injury, not partially from it in combination with other factors.