Howell v the Uniting Church and C E Heath

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

Serial No 8/1990
List "A"

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION                 Howell v The Uniting Church and C E Heath [1990] TASSC 14; A8/1990

PARTIES:  HOWELL
  v
  UNITING CHURCH
  C E HEATH (THIRD PARTY)

FILE NO/S:  WC 53/1990
DELIVERED ON:  6 April 1990
JUDGMENT OF:  Underwood J

Judgment Number:  A8/1990
Number of paragraphs:  30

Serial No 8/1990
List "A"
File No WC 53/1989

HOWELL v THE UNITING CHURCH and C E HEATH (THIRD PARTY)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  UNDERWOOD J

6 April 1990

  1. The plaintiff was employed by the defendant as a trained auxiliary nurse at the Strathaven Lodge, a home for aged people. For some time prior to 17 February 1985 she had been working from 11pm to 7am every Saturday and Sunday. Occasionally, she worked on other shifts when required. The plaintiff was and is a married woman, now aged 46. She lives with her husband and two children.

  1. About 6am on 17 February 1985, in the course of her duties, the plaintiff went into the laundry at the Lodge and was there suddenly confronted by two young male intruders. They attacked her. One of them kicked her in the leg and hit her across the mouth. The plaintiff screamed. The other intruder exposed his penis to the plaintiff and at the same time the one who assaulted her pushed her towards the exposed penis. She continued to scream. One of the men then hit her across the face. She fell to the floor, "blacking out". The intruders escaped and the plaintiff was found by another employee of the defendant, dazed and bleeding. She was taken to the Royal Hobart Hospital where she remained for the day. Following her discharge home she was greatly shocked and distressed by the incident. She suffered from headaches, shaking and uncontrollable crying. After consulting her general practitioner, she saw Mr Liddell, the neurosurgeon, and by his arrangement was admitted to St Helens Hospital. Although the physical injuries to the plaintiff were not extensive, she was so shocked by the traumatic episode that Mr Liddell asked Dr Burgess, a consultant psychiatrist, to see her. This he did for the first time in St Helens Hospital on 21 February 1985.

  1. The plaintiff remained in hospital for a few days and was then discharged home. She was still shocked and manifested symptoms of shaking, crying, violent nightmares and disturbed sleep, nausea and skin rash. In Dr Burgess' opinion, all these symptoms were consistent with the existence of a post–traumatic stress disorder directly caused by the assault in the laundry.

  1. The plaintiff continued to consult Dr Burgess on a fairly regular basis. He counselled her and prescribed an anti–depressant, an anti–emetic and a night–time sedating agent. The plaintiff experienced depression, lack of confidence, agoraphobia and anxiety. Her pre–morbid personality was robust. She was a well organised and energetic woman who cared for her family capably and worked two nights a week. Between the date of the assault and 17 July 1985 she remained at home. During this…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Howell v the Uniting Church and C E Heath and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1990] TASSC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Howell was employed by the Uniting Church as a trained auxiliary nurse at Strathaven Lodge, a home for the aged. The dispute arose from two incidents occurring during her employment, specifically an assault by intruders and a subsequent fall that resulted in a wrist fracture. The primary issue for the court was to determine which of these incidents resulted in Howell's total incapacity for work. The court needed to ascertain whether the assault or the fall caused the total incapacity, as this would determine the extent of the Uniting Church's liability and the third party's indemnity obligations under the insurance policy.

The court considered the evidence presented by Dr Burgess, a consultant psychiatrist, who diagnosed Howell with a post-traumatic stress disorder following the assault. Although Howell had been partially incapacitated since the assault, her symptoms persisted and worsened after the fall. Dr Burgess testified that the fall acted as a significant psychological stressor, exacerbating Howell's condition and leading to her total incapacity for work. The court found that the fall on 16 February 1986 resulted in a total incapacity for work, as the evidence showed that without this event, Howell might not have become totally incapacitated. The court accepted that the fall was the direct cause of the chronic and severe symptoms leading to her total incapacity, aligning with the principles of causation in workers' compensation law.

Based on the findings, the court ruled that Howell's total incapacity for work resulted from the fall on 16 February 1986, not the assault. The court ordered the Uniting Church to pay Howell weekly compensation totaling $54,135.70. The court also dismissed the Uniting Church's claim against the third party, CE Heath Underwriting and Insurance (Australia) Pty Ltd, as the liability arose after the insurance policy's coverage period ended.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.