Hurley and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Hurley and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 2450 (8 August 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):    2016/3093

Re:Jennifer Hurley

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Capital Territory

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President John Sosso           

Date:8 August 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal:

(a)sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the ACT is liable to pay compensation to the Applicant pursuant to section 14 of the Act in respect of an aggravation of her pre-existing PTSD and major depression with the date of injury as 2010;

(b)remits the matter to the ACT to give effect to the decision in accordance with the reasons outlined in this decision; and

(c)orders that the ACT pay the Applicant’s costs of this application pursuant to section 67 of the Act as agreed, or taxed.

............................................................

Deputy President John Sosso

Catchwords

COMPENSATION – ailment – major depression – whether claimed condition significantly contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment – presence of employment and non-employment factors – whether Respondent exposed to unacceptable degree of prejudice in relation to how the Applicant’s claim was particularised and the delay involved – requirements of s 53 of the Act considered – requirements of s 53 of the Act are met – decision under review set aside and substituted

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – nature of the Tribunal’s practice in workers’ compensation matters – scope of inquisitorial nature – whether Respondent was “surprised” or “ambushed” at the Hearing

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2007

Work Safety Act 2008 (ACT)

Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (ACT)

Cases

Abrahams v Comcare (2006) 93 ALD 147

Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey (2001) 32 AAR 508

Australian Postal Commission v Hayes (1989) 23 FCR 320

Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535

Re Carson and Telstra Corporation (2001) 33 AAR 351

Casarotto v Australian Postal Commission (1989) 17 ALD 321

Comcare v Luck (1999) 29 AAR 403

Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285

Comcare v Muir [2016] FCA 346

Commonwealth v Smith (1989) 18 ALD 224

Farrell v Comcare [2015] FCA 1337

Federal Broom Co Pty Ltd v Semlitch (1964) 110 CLR 626

Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (2009) 240 CLR 28

Frosch v Comcare [2004] FCA 1642

Havnen and Comcare [2010] AATA 535

Kelson v Forward (1995) 60 FCR 39

Kennedy v Comcare [2014] FCA 82

Lees v Comcare [1999] FCA 753; 56 ALD 84

Mellor v Australian Postal Corporation [2009] FCA 504; 108 ALD 159

Mifsud and Comcare (1994) 33 ALD 376

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May (2016) 257 CLR 468

Ogden Industries Pty Limited v Lucas (1967) 116 CLR 537

Pacific Manning Company Pty Ltd v Barton [2003] FCA 498

Prain v Comcare [2017] FCAFC 143

Renouf and Comcare [2004] AATA 525

Re Deveson and Comcare (1999) 53 ALD 794

Re Durham and TNT Australia Pty Ltd (2011) 124 ALD 136

Scutts and Department of Defence [1998] AATA 527

Szabo…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hurley and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 2450
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by the Applicant, Hurley, against a decision of the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) regarding compensation for a major depressive illness. The core dispute revolved around whether the Applicant's employment had contributed to a significant degree to the aggravation of a pre-existing mental health condition, and whether the ACT had been prejudiced by the manner in which the claim was particularised and the delay involved. The case was heard by Deputy John Sosso P.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included determining whether the Applicant's claimed condition was significantly contributed to by her employment, considering both employment and non-employment factors. Additionally, the Tribunal had to assess whether the respondent, the ACT, was exposed to an unacceptable degree of prejudice due to the particularisation of the Applicant's claim and the delay in its presentation. The Tribunal also considered the scope of its inquisitorial nature in workers' compensation matters and whether the respondent had been "surprised" or "ambushed" at the hearing.

The Tribunal reasoned that while both employment and non-employment factors contributed to the aggravation of the Applicant's pre-existing mental health condition, the employment factors played a significant role. The Tribunal acknowledged that it was not bound by strict rules of evidence but was obligated to accord parties natural justice, ensuring they had a reasonable opportunity to present their case and test the opposing evidence. The Tribunal found that the respondent had not been denied procedural fairness, despite the Applicant's initial lack of specific details and varying dates for the claimed injury, as the concept of "injury" and its date are central to the Act's scheme.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted its own decision, finding the ACT liable to pay compensation to the Applicant for an aggravation of her pre-existing PTSD and major depression, with a date of injury in 2010. The matter was remitted to the ACT for implementation of this decision, and the ACT was ordered to pay the Applicant's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal is satisfied having regard to the matters previously discussed that although there were both employment and non-employment factors at play causing an aggravation in the Applicant’s pre-existing mental health condition, that the employment factors contributed to, to a significant degree, the aggravation of that condition.DECISION The Tribunal:(a)sets aside the decision under review and in substitution decides that the ACT is liable to pay compensation to the Applicant pursuant to section 14 of the Act in respect of an aggravation of her pre-existing PTSD and major depression with a date of injury of 2010;(b)remits the matter to the ACT to give effect to the decision in accordance with the reasons outlined in this decision; and(c)orders that the ACT pay the Applicant’s costs of this application pursuant to section 67 of the Act as agreed, or taxed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Full Court held that the Tribunal only had jurisdiction under s 64 for decisions which have been reconsidered under s 62. In so finding, the Full Court said:“[50] The only issues under s 24 of the Act which required determination in Ms Lees’ case were the issues of whether she had a permanent impairment and, if she did, the amount of compensation payable under the section in respect of that impairment. Neither of these issues had been determined at the first tier decision-making stage. Necessarily, in the circumstances, there had been no reconsideration under s 62 of the Act of a determination on these issues. Consequently there was no reviewable decision touching on these issues to found an application to the AAT under s 64 of the Act.”CONSIDERATIONIntroduction The Hearing of this matter lasted for three days, and, in addition, the Tribunal has received detailed written submissions from the legal representatives of the parties. Much of the Hearing and the written submissions have focused on procedural issues rather than the substance of the Applicant’s claim. Nonetheless, as the issues raised concern threshold matters that go to the jurisdiction of the Tribunal they necessarily must be addressed before the Tribunal proceeds further.Denial of Procedural Fairness The Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence but may inform itself on any matter in such manner as it thinks appropriate – s 33(1)(c) Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. However, even though the Tribunal is not bound by the rules of evidence and is given much leeway in determining the procedure to be adopted in reviewing a decision, it is bound to accord the parties natural justice. Central to this principle is that both parties must be given a reasonable opportunity to present their case. That right necessarily includes the ability to test the other party’s evidence in a logical and informed manner – see Australian Postal Commission v Hayes (1989) 23 FCR 320 at 326 – 327 and Comcare v Maganga [2008] FCA 285 at [26]. There may be circumstances where one party is, for example, “surprised” or “ambushed” at a Hearing. In such a case, where the Tribunal allows the proceedings to be conducted so that the aggrieved party is placed at a disadvantage, the aggrieved party has not been accorded procedural fairness – see Kelson v Forward (1995) 60 FCR 39. Comcare contends that it has been denied a fair and reasonable opportunity to present its case because the Applicant declined to provide essential details of her claim prior to Hearing and then propounded a variety of different dates for the claimed injury: 2015, then 2013 and finally 2010 – CCS para 1. Quite correctly, Comcare submits that the concept of “injury” under the Act is central, and the importance of fixing a date of injury in respect of diseases (even those of gradual onset or development) is underscored by the High Court in Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 and in Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (2009) 240 CLR 28. Furthermore, the scheme of the Act was held by the High Court in Canute to proceed from the occurrence of an “injury” in the defined sense, that is, it is the occurrence of an injury which both actuates and defines the scope of liability – CCS para 3.