Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

ROBYN CHRISTINE FELLOWES  APPELLANT

AND

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION
COMMISSION  RESPONDENT

Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission
[2009] HCA 38
23 September 2009
B8/2009

ORDER

1.      Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 4 August 2008 and, in their place, order that:

(a)     the appeal to that Court be allowed with costs;

(b)the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 7 September 2007 be set aside and, in its place, there be a direction that the respondent determine the amount payable to the applicant for review by the Tribunal assessed under ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of an injury, being a right knee condition resulting in a degree of permanent impairment of the applicant of 10% as assessed under Table 9.5 of the applicable Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment; and

(c)the respondent pay the applicant's costs of the review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

P J Hanks QC with R F King-Scott for the appellant (instructed by Slater & Gordon Lawyers)

T M Howe QC with L A Walker for the respondent (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ.   The appellant enlisted in the Australian Army on 11 November 1986.  In 1986, she suffered a left knee injury.  As a result of work‑related factors, the left knee injury left the appellant with no loss of range of movement of the left knee but with permanent difficulty with grades and steps, as distinct from distances.  In 1987, the appellant suffered a right knee injury.  As a result of work‑related factors, the right knee injury left the appellant with no loss of range of movement of the right knee but with permanent difficulty with grades and steps, as distinct from distances.

  2. Is the appellant entitled to compensation for each injury?  Or, because the second injury does not affect her ability to walk to any significantly greater extent than the first injury, is she not entitled to compensation for the second injury?  These reasons will show that she is entitled to compensation for each injury.

  3. In December 2005, the appellant applied to the respondent, the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission ("the Commission"), for compensation for each injury under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ("the SRC Act"). The claims made by the appellant related to injuries sustained in connection with defence service before the commencement of the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 2004 (Cth). That Act did not govern the appellant's claims. It was common ground that the appellant's claims are governed by the SRC Act. The Commission had to determine the claims…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] HCA 38
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal to the High Court of Australia by Ms Fellowes against the Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission. The dispute centred on whether Ms Fellowes was entitled to compensation for a permanent impairment to her right knee, given that she had previously been compensated for a similar impairment to her left knee, and the assessment method under the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) stipulated that only a single rating should be given where two or more injuries give rise to the same impairment.

The High Court was required to determine the meaning of "degree of permanent impairment" within the context of the Act and the *Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment*. Specifically, the Court had to decide whether this phrase referred to the impairment of the whole person or the impairment of a particular part of the body, and whether compensation was payable for a subsequent injury to the right knee if it did not increase the overall degree of permanent impairment already assessed from a prior injury to the left knee.

The Court reasoned that the *Guide* assesses impairment by measuring the effect on an employee's ability to function, and that the statutory scheme requires the degree of permanent impairment to be "resulting from" the injury in question. In this instance, the appellant's injury to her right knee did not increase the 10% loss of function in her lower limbs, which had already been assessed following her left knee injury. Therefore, the Court concluded that the degree of impairment did not result from the second injury as required by section 24(5) of the Act. The Court also overruled the Full Court of the Federal Court's decision in *Comcare v Van Grinsven*, which had been relied upon by the lower courts.

The appeal was allowed with costs. The orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court were set aside, and in their place, the High Court ordered that Ms Fellowes' appeal to that Court be allowed with costs. The decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal was also set aside, with a direction that the respondent determine the amount payable to the applicant under sections 24 and 27 of the *Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988* (Cth) in respect of the right knee condition, assessed as a 10% degree of permanent impairment. The respondent was also ordered to pay the applicant's costs of the review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 4 August 2008 and, in their place, order that:

(a) the appeal to that Court be allowed with costs;

(b) the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 7 September 2007 be set aside and, in its place, there be a direction that the respondent determine the amount payable to the applicant for review by the Tribunal assessed under ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of an injury, being a right knee condition resulting in a degree of permanent impairment of the applicant of 10% as assessed under Table 9.5 of the applicable Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment; and

(c) the respondent pay the applicant's costs of the review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ KIEFEL J
It also follows that the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court in Comcare v Van Grinsven[22], upon which both the Tribunal and the Full Court relied in the present matter, was wrongly decided and should be overruled.[22](2002) 117 FCR 169.Conclusion and orders For these reasons, the appeal to this Court should be allowed with costs. The orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court made on 4 August 2008 should be set aside. The appellant submitted, and the respondent did not submit to the contrary, that in these circumstances the appropriate consequential orders were to order that in place of those orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court there be orders that:(a) the appeal to that Court be allowed with costs;(b)the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal dated 7 September 2007 be set aside and in its place there be a direction that the respondent determine the amount payable to the applicant for review by the Tribunal assessed under ss 24 and 27 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) in respect of an injury, being a right knee condition resulting in a degree of permanent impairment of the applicant of 10% as assessed under Table 9.5 of the Guide;(c)the Commission pay the applicant's costs of the review by the Tribunal. The facts and the statutory provisions relevant to this appeal are set out in the reasons of the majority. I regret that I am unable to agree with those reasons. Section 24(5) is central to the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ("the SRC Act") concerning the compensation of employees[23]. The sub‑section requires Comcare to determine "the degree of permanent impairment of the employee resulting from an injury" (emphasis added). That determination is to be undertaken under the provisions of a Guide prepared pursuant to the SRC Act. No question arises on this appeal as to the validity of the Guide in question[24]. It is to be read with the SRC Act, as part of a statutory scheme[25].[23]Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 at 539 [6]; [2006] HCA 47.[24]Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment, 1st ed (1989).[25]Deputy Federal Commissioner of Taxation (SA) v Ellis & Clark Ltd (1934) 52 CLR 85 at 89; [1934] HCA 54; Master Education Services Pty Ltd v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101 at 110 [19]; [2008] HCA 38. The method employed by the Guide in assessing the degree, or level, of impairment is to determine the effect of the permanent impairment upon the employee's ability to function. The provisions of the Guide will be discussed later in these reasons. The particular type of impairment suffered by the appellant was assessed as producing a loss of 10 per cent of the function of her lower limbs. The appellant had previously been assessed as having that loss of function and that level of impairment after she had suffered an injury to the left knee, for which she was compensated, and before the injury in question, that to her right knee. The injury in question did not increase her loss of function as measured by the Guide. A conclusion that the degree of impairment found resulted from the second injury, as s 24(5) requires, is therefore not possible. As a result, no compensation is payable, as the Full Court of the Federal Court held[26].[26]Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission (2008) 170 FCR 531 at 539 [33] and 540 [39] per French and Lindgren JJ.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN AND BELL JJ, KIEFEL J