Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation & Compensation Commission

[2008] FCAFC 140

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – construction of provisions of Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (Act) – employee suffering injury to left knee and on a later occasion an injury to her right knee – “Guide to the Assessment of the Degree of Permanent Impairment” (Guide) made under s 28 of the Act – whether employee entitled to compensation in respect of permanent impairment resulting from second injury.
Held: she was not, because her degree of impairment was still only in the category “Can rise to a standing position and walk but has difficulty with grades and steps” signifying no change to her 10% whole body impairment for purposes of Act and Guide.

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) s 28

Comcare v Van Grinsven (2002) 117 FCR 169 followed
Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 distinguished

ROBYN CHRISTINE FELLOWES v MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION

QUD 330 OF 2007

FRENCH, MOORE AND LINDGREN JJ
4 AUGUST 2008
SYDNEY (HEARD IN BRISBANE)


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 330 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY A PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER

BETWEEN:

ROBYN CHRISTINE FELLOWES
Applicant

AND:

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGES:

FRENCH, MOORE AND LINDGREN JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

4 AUGUST 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN BRISBANE)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal brought by the application be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

QUD 330 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM THE ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL CONSTITUTED BY A PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER

BETWEEN:

ROBYN CHRISTINE FELLOWES
Applicant

AND:

MILITARY REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION COMMISSION
Respondent

JUDGES:

FRENCH, MOORE AND LINDGREN JJ

DATE:

4 AUGUST 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY (HEARD IN BRISBANE)

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

FRENCH AND LINDGREN JJ:

INTRODUCTION

  1. This appeal from the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) raises a question as to whether the decision of a Full Court of this Court in Comcare v Van Grinsven (2002) 117 FCR 169 (Van Grinsven) can be regarded as correctly decided in the light of the subsequent decision of the High Court in Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535 (Canute).

  2. For the applicant (Ms Fellowes) who suffered an injury to her left knee, and on a later occasion an injury to her right knee, her appeal raises the question whether the respondent (Commission) is liable to pay her compensation arising out of her second injury beyond that which it became liable to pay to her arising out of her first injury.

  3. The statute under which the issues are to be determined is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the Act). The legislative provisions by which the Commission, rather than either “Comcare” or the “Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission”, is the relevant body liable are a little…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commissi... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCAFC 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter under consideration is Fellowes v Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission, where Ms Fellowes, a serving member of the Australian Army, has challenged a decision regarding compensation for her permanent impairments resulting from two separate knee injuries. The legal issues revolve around the interpretation of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) and its application to the assessment of compensation for multiple injuries leading to the same level of impairment. Specifically, the court must determine whether the injuries should be assessed individually or as a combined impairment.

The court examined the statutory framework and relevant case law, particularly the High Court's decision in Canute v Comcare and the Full Court's decision in Van Grinsven v Comcare. The Deputy President highlighted that the Act requires a two-step inquiry: first, whether an injury has occurred, and second, if a permanent impairment results from that injury, the degree of impairment is assessed. The court emphasised that the Act compensates for injuries based on the extent of the permanent impairment, as measured by the Guide. The Deputy President concluded that the statutory scheme is not about compensating for injuries that cause permanent impairment but rather compensating for injuries to the extent of the permanent impairment.

The appeal was dismissed, and costs were awarded to the respondent. The court found that the reasoning in Van Grinsven was consistent with the statutory framework and the High Court's decision in Canute. The decision underscores the importance of assessing each injury separately and determining the extent of impairment resulting from each injury, in line with the statutory criteria and the Guide.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal brought by the application be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the respondent’s costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The statute under which the issues are to be determined is the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (the Act). The legislative provisions by which the Commission, rather than either “Comcare” or the “Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission”, is the relevant body liable are a little complex. We need not explain those provisions. It is not in dispute that the Commission is the body answerable in the case of Ms Fellowes. However, for consistency with the legislative provisions set out below, we will, generally speaking, refer to “Comcare”. Those references, and the references in the Act to “Comcare”, are to be read as if they referred to a liability of the Commission.FACTS Before the Tribunal there was a Statement of Agreed Facts which, omitting “T” references, was as follows:1.The Applicant is 38 years of age, having been born on 20 February 1969. She enlisted in the Army on 11 November 1986 and is currently a serving member.2.In 1986 the Applicant suffered a left knee injury which, as a result of work-related factors, resulted in a condition known as left chondromalacia patellae (the left knee condition).3.The left knee condition is permanent.4.The left knee condition does not result in loss of range of movement of the left knee under Table 9.2 of the Guide.5.As a result of the left knee condition the Applicant can rise to a standing position and walk but she has difficulty with grades and steps (not distances).6.If the Applicant suffered from no other permanent impairment apart from that which is attributable to the left knee condition, she would be entitled to compensation in respect of a 10% level of impairment under Table 9.5 of the Guide.7.In 1987 the Applicant suffered a right knee injury which, as a result of work-related factors, resulted in a condition known as right chondromalacia patellae with medial meniscus tear (the right knee condition).8.The right knee condition is permanent.9.The right knee condition does not result in loss of range of movement of the right knee under Table 9.2 of the Guide.10.As a result of the right knee condition the Applicant can rise to a standing position and walk but she has difficulty with grades and steps (not distances).11.If the Applicant suffered from no other permanent impairment apart from that which is attributable to the right knee condition, she would be entitled to compensation in respect of a 10% level of impairment under Table 9.5 of the Guide.12.On 14 December 2005, the Applicant lodged a claim for compensation in relation to the left knee condition. This claim for compensation included a claim for permanent impairment for the left knee condition.13.On 14 December 2005, the Applicant lodged a claim for compensation in relation to the right knee condition. This claim for compensation included a claim for permanent impairment for the right knee condition.14.On 14 June 2006, a determination rejected liability for the left knee condition.15.On 27 June 2006, a determination rejected liability to pay a lump sum payment for permanent impairment arising from the left knee condition.16.On 27 June 2006, the Applicant through her solicitors requested a review of the determination dated 14 June 2006.17.On 11 August 2006, the Applicant through her solicitors requested a review of the determination dated 27 June 2006.18.On 22 January 2007, a reviewable decision revoked the determination dated 14 June 2006 and accepted liability for the left knee condition.19.On 22 January 2007, a further reviewable decision revoked the determination dated 27 June 2006 and accepted liability to pay lump sum compensation for the left knee condition on the basis that the Applicant has a 10% whole person impairment under Table 9.5. As a consequence of this decision, the Applicant was paid lump sum compensation totalling $26,679.96 in respect of the impairment to the left knee.20.On 22 February 2007, a determination accepted liability for the right knee condition.21.On 3 March 2007, the Applicant through her solicitors requested that she be assessed for permanent impairment in relation to the accepted right knee condition.22.On 22 March 2007, a determination rejected liability to pay a lump sum for permanent impairment in relation to the right knee condition on the basis that the Applicant had already been compensated for a 10% impairment under Table 9.5.23.On 14 April 2007 the Applicant requested a review of that decision.24.A reviewable decision dated 22 May 2007 affirmed the determination dated 22 March 2007. [our emphasis]LEGISLATION

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH, MOORE AND LINDGREN JJ
It will be clear from what we have said above that we do not think that the Full Court decision in Van Grinsven was plainly wrong and in our view this Court should follow it.CONCLUSION For the above reasons, the appeal brought by the application should be dismissed with costs. I have had the benefit of reading the reasons for judgment of French and Lindgren JJ in a draft form. It is unnecessary to repeat their Honours' account of the facts and the relevant legislation. The applicant has argued it is difficult to reconcile the judgment of the Full Court of this Court in Comcare v Van Grisven (2002) 117 FCR 169 with the subsequent judgment of the High Court in Canute v Comcare (2006) 226 CLR 535. I agree. As French and Lindgren JJ have explained, the facts in Canute were not the same as the facts in the present case. Indeed, they are only similar at a high level of abstraction, in the sense that both cases concerned two injuries. In Canute, the two injuries were markedly different in the sense that the first was an injury to the body (the appellant's back) and the second injury was psychiatric. Both injuries arose from the one event. In the present matter, both the first injury and second injury were to the appellant's lower limbs, with the first occurring after the second. However, these dissimilarities should not, in my opinion, distract attention from the reasoning of the High Court in its analysis of the operation of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth). As the Court pointed out at [8], the concept of "an injury" is of pivotal importance. The Court went on to note at [10] that Comcare's liability is to pay compensation in respect of "the injury", and not in respect of an mpairment. The High Court also noted that the definition of "injury" is expressed in terms of the resultant effect of an incident or ailment upon the employee's body. The High Court rejected at [11], the contention that the notion of "the degree of permanent impairment" reflected an approach of assessing impairment on a "whole person" basis. Of central importance are the following observations of the High Court at [14]:However, it is important to remember that recourse to the criteria and methodologies set out in the Guide is only necessary once the key statutory criterion of the occurrence of "an injury" (which resulted in at least one permanent impairment) has been fulfilled. The Guide is to be approached through the prism of each "injury". The terms of s 24(5) are quite clear; Comcare is to assess the degree of permanent impairment of the employee "resulting from an injury". Similarly, in s 24(7), the threshold permanent impairment of the employee of 10 per cent affects the amount of compensation payable "under this section"; that is, "in respect of the injury" (s 24(1)).[emphasis in original] It seems to me that this passage should be taken to indicate that the Act requires a series of questions to be asked and answered. The first is whether the employee has suffered an "injury". In respect of any (and each) "injury" the employee has suffered, the further question is whether a permanent impairment has resulted from that "injury". An affirmative answer to that question then leads to the enquiry concerning the "degree of permanent impairment" contemplated by s 24(5), which the High Court described in Canute at [6] as the "central provision" of the legislative scheme.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH, MOORE AND LINDGREN JJ

The Deputy President stated that the effect of the Guide was that two or more separate injuries that give rise to the same impairment result in a single rating of impairment (at [34]). He said (at [35]) that to view the matter in this way was not to “disentitle” Ms Fellowes to compensation or to fail to apply s 24 of the Act, but rather to give:primacy to the notion that the scheme of the … Act is not one that involves, relevantly, compensation for injuries that cause permanent impairment [but] provides compensation for injuries to the extent of the permanent impairment. The fact of permanent impairment creates a liability in the Commission to pay compensation but the amount of that liability is determined by reference to the extent of that permanent impairment having regard to the Guide. [emphasis in original]CONSIDERATION It is first necessary to refer to Van Grinsven and then Canute.Van Grisven In Van Grisven the respondent (Mr Van Grinsven) suffered an injury to his left knee and on a later occasion an injury to his right knee. As in the present case there was a statement of agreed facts. The only difference between Van Grinsven and the present case is that the whole body impairment in Van Grinsven was that described on the second line of Table 9.5 (set out at [15] above), whereas in the present case it is that described on the first line. Thus, in Van Grisven, the description of level of impairment was “Can rise to standing position and walk but has difficulty with grades, steps and distances” and the percentage of whole body impairment was therefore 20%. In Van Grinsven a Full Court of this Court distinguished between the approaches taken in Table 9.2 and Table 9.5. The Full Court stated (at [4]) that Table 9.2 is one of the Tables dealing with impairments falling within the words “the loss of the use, or the damage or malfunction, of any part of the body” in the definition of impairment. (We set out the definition of impairment in the Act at [7] above, and referred to the definition of impairment in the Guide at [14] above.) The Full Court pointed out that Table 9.5, on the other hand, evinced a different approach in that it was directed primarily to the loss of bodily function part of the definition of “impairment”. The Full Court stated (at [16]):It is clear that for the purpose of Table 9.5 the respondent does not suffer from more than one impairment. He may suffer from two knee injuries, but for the purpose of Table 9.5 these only give rise to the one impairment – that is, ‘Can rise to standing position and walk but has difficulty with grades, steps and distances’. The Full Court rejected a submission of Mr Van Grinsven that the reference in the singular to “Limb Function” and “Lower Limb” in the heading to Table 9.5 indicated an entitlement in respect of each lower limb. In their reasons, their Honours referred (at [7]) to two statements in the section of the Guide entitled “Principles of Assessment”. The first statement is under the heading “Impairment and Non-Economic Loss” within that section:Impairment is measured against its effect on personal efficiency in the ‘activities of daily living’ in comparison with a normal healthy person. The measure of ‘activities of daily living’ is a measure of primary biological and psychosocial function such as standing, moving, feeding and self care.The second statement is under the heading “The Impairment Tables” within that section:Evaluation of a whole person impairment is a medical appraisal of the nature and extent of the effect of an injury or disease on a person’s functional capacity and activities of daily living.Canute