George Maalouf and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

[2015] AATA 461  

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/2801

2013/5338
2014/3193
2014/5785
2015/2059

2015/2358

Re

George Maalouf

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member

Date 30 June 2015  
Place Melbourne

1.          The decisions in relation to each application are as follows:

(a)        2013/2801 – the reviewable decision made on 10 May 2013 is set aside and in substitution it is decided:

(i)          the normal weekly hours of the applicant has not been 39 hours and 55 minutes per week; 

(ii)        the normal weekly hours of the applicant is 36 hours and 45 minutes plus overtime hours; 

(iii)        the applicant has been incapacitated from working overtime from 13 March 2012 and is entitled to compensation for the consequent lost income; and

(iv)       the applicant has had a capacity to work 25 hours per week only from 25 February 2014 and is entitled to compensation for lost salary of 11 hours and 45 minutes and overtime.

(b) 2013/5338 and 2015/2059 – both reviewable decisions are set aside and in substitution it is decided the respondent is liable pursuant to section 16 of the Act for the reasonable cost of physiotherapy treatment from 8 August 2013 in respect of the right shoulder and from January 2014 in respect of the left shoulder. The treatment shall be in the form of undertaking a program of home-based exercise as devised, monitored and supervised by a physiotherapist with whom the applicant shall personally consult once every three or four weeks as the physiotherapist shall determine.

(c)        2014/3193 – the decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided the applicant is entitled to compensation in respect of an aggravation of his right shoulder injury arising out of work undertaken by him on 29 January 2014.

(d) 2014/5785 – the decision under review in so far as it decided the applicant was entitled to an award of compensation in respect of a 13% permanent impairment pursuant to section 24 of the Act in relation to the right shoulder is affirmed. The remainder of the decision concerning the applicant’s entitlement to compensation pursuant to section 27 of the Act is set aside and in substitution it is decided the applicant is entitled to the following scores:

Pain

3

Suffering

2

Mobility

1

Social relationships

2

Recreation and leisure activities

3

Other loss

1

The application is remitted to the respondent for calculation of the quantum of entitlement to compensation pursuant to sections 24 and 27 in accordance with this decision.

(e) 2015/2358 – the decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided the applicant is entitled to an award of compensation pursuant to section 24 of the Act in respect of a 13% permanent impairment of his left shoulder. The applicant is also entitled to an award of compensation pursuant to section 27 in respect of the following scores:

Pain

3

Suffering

2

Mobility

1

Social relationships

2

Recreation and leisure activities

3

Other loss

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read George Maalouf and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 461
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

George Maalouf and the Australian Postal Corporation were involved in a dispute before the Workplace Injury Rehabilitation and Compensation Appeals Tribunal in Australia. The dispute centred on the extent of injuries sustained by Mr Maalouf and the resultant compensation he was entitled to. Mr Maalouf claimed he was unable to perform certain tasks due to injuries and sought compensation for lost income and treatment costs. The tribunal was tasked with determining the severity of Mr Maalouf's injuries, the impact these had on his ability to work, and the appropriate compensation he was entitled to under relevant legislation.

The tribunal had to decide several key legal issues. First, it needed to assess the severity of Mr Maalouf's injuries and classify them according to the criteria set out in the legislation. Second, it had to determine the extent to which these injuries affected his capacity to work, both in terms of normal hours and overtime. Third, the tribunal had to decide whether the injuries warranted specific types of compensation, including for lost income, treatment costs, and any aggravation of injuries. Finally, it had to decide on the appropriate amount of compensation based on the classification and impact of the injuries.

The tribunal concluded that Mr Maalouf's injuries were significant but not as severe as marked under the legislative criteria. It found that his injuries caused moderate disadvantages, particularly in his ability to dress and bathe independently. The tribunal set aside previous decisions and ruled that Mr Maalouf was entitled to compensation for lost income due to his inability to work overtime and reduced capacity to work. Additionally, it ordered that the respondent cover the cost of physiotherapy treatments for both shoulders, to be conducted through a home-based exercise program. The tribunal also found that Mr Maalouf was entitled to compensation for the aggravation of his right shoulder injury and awarded him compensation for permanent impairment related to that injury.

In summary, the tribunal ruled in favour of Mr Maalouf, setting aside previous decisions and awarding him compensation for lost income, physiotherapy costs, and aggravation of his right shoulder injury. The tribunal also affirmed his entitlement to compensation for permanent impairment of his right shoulder. The tribunal ordered the Australian Postal Corporation to cover the costs of the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

George Maalouf, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, sustained injuries while working that resulted in a series of claims for workers' compensation. The injuries included impairments to both shoulders, which affected his ability to perform daily activities such as dressing, tying shoelaces, and bathing. He was unable to work overtime from 13 March 2012 and had a reduced capacity to work from 25 February 2014. Maalouf sought compensation for lost income, physiotherapy treatment costs, and an aggravation of his injury. He also contested the assessment of his permanent impairment.

The case involved multiple applications for review of decisions made by the Australian Postal Corporation concerning Maalouf's workers' compensation claims. The applications were heard and determined by a relevant tribunal. Prior to this, Maalouf had engaged in proceedings to challenge the initial decisions made by the Australian Postal Corporation regarding his entitlement to compensation and the level of permanent impairment assessed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I am satisfied that the level of effect upon the applicant by his injuries is greater than minimal and less than marked (but only by regard to the tenor of the criteria against a score of 2). I am satisfied the Other loss(es) suffered by the applicant are best described as moderate disadvantages. The examples given attracting a score of 1 should be understood as examples only to which the applicant is not confined. I am satisfied that each injury, which has caused the applicant to need assistance with dressing, tying shoelaces and his impediment with bathing attracts a score of 1 for each shoulder. The limitations on his dexterity must be numerous as obvious by the two examples recorded above observed during the hearing. The inability of an adult to dress, on occasions, unassisted and be unable to bathe unrestrained is more than a minimal disadvantage. Decision For the reasons expressed above, the decisions in relation to each application are as follows:(a)2013/2801 – the reviewable decision made on 10 May 2013 is set aside and in substitution it is decided: (i)the normal weekly hours of the applicant has not been 39 hours and 55 minutes per week; (ii)the normal weekly hours of the applicant is 36 hours and 45 minutes plus overtime hours; (iii)the applicant has been incapacitated from working overtime from 13 March 2012 and is entitled to compensation for the consequent lost income; and (iv)the applicant has had a capacity to work 25 hours per week only from 25 February 2014 and is entitled to compensation for lost salary of 11 hours and 45 minutes and overtime. (b)2013/5338 and 2015/2059 – both reviewable decisions are set aside and in substitution it is decided the respondent is liable pursuant to section 16 of the Act for the reasonable cost of physiotherapy treatment from 8 August 2013 in respect of the right shoulder and from January 2014 in respect of the left shoulder. The treatment shall be in the form of undertaking a program of home-based exercise as devised, monitored and supervised by a physiotherapist with whom the applicant shall personally consult once every three or four weeks as the physiotherapist shall determine.(c)2014/3193 – the decision under review is set aside and in substitution it is decided the applicant is entitled to compensation in respect of an aggravation of his right shoulder injury arising out of work undertaken by him on 29 January 2014.(d)2014/5785 – the decision under review in so far as it decided the applicant was entitled to an award of compensation in respect of 13% permanent impairment pursuant to section 24 of the Act in relation to the right shoulder is affirmed. The remainder of the decision concerning the applicant’s entitlement to compensation pursuant to section 27 of the Act is set aside and in substitution it is decided the applicant is entitled to the following scores: The applicant is entitled to an award of his costs and disbursements pursuant to paragraph 6.10 of the Guide to the Workers Compensation Jurisdiction practice direction issued by the Tribunal in September 2013.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court's decision was based on a thorough analysis of the applicant's injuries and their impact on his ability to work. It began by examining the applicant's normal weekly hours and found that the evidence did not support the claim of 39 hours and 55 minutes per week but rather 36 hours and 45 minutes plus overtime. The court concluded that the applicant's incapacity to work overtime from 13 March 2012 and his reduced capacity to work from 25 February 2014 warranted compensation for lost income. The court also addressed the applicant's entitlement to physiotherapy treatment, noting that the treatment should be reasonable and home-based, with periodic consultations with a physiotherapist. Regarding the aggravation of the right shoulder injury, the court found that the applicant's work on 29 January 2014 contributed to the aggravation and thus he was entitled to compensation. The court affirmed the award of compensation for 13% permanent impairment of the right shoulder but set aside the remainder of the decision concerning the applicant's entitlement to compensation under section 27 of the Act, substituting a new decision based on the correct assessment of the applicant's entitlement to compensation for permanent impairment. The court's ratio decidendi lies in its detailed examination of the applicant's injuries and their impact, leading to specific conclusions on compensation and treatment costs, reflecting a nuanced understanding of the statutory provisions and the applicant's circumstances.