Zahra Bayani and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

[2015] AATA 342 

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number(s)

2013/4584

Re

Zahra Bayani

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

John Handley, Senior Member

Date 19 May 2015  
Place Melbourne

The decision under review is affirmed.

.......[sgd].................................................................

John Handley, Senior Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – applicant has chronic neck and left shoulder pain – treatment from 2004 to date principally has been physiotherapy – denial by respondent of liability for cost of ongoing physiotherapy treatment and gymnasium program – physiotherapy has provided temporary symptomatic relief only – treatment has not alleviated the injuries – Clinical Framework For The Delivery of Health Services considered – whether applicant should be instructed in self-management strategies for relief of pain – ongoing physiotherapy and gymnasium is not reasonable treatment – decision affirmed

Legislation

Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988, sections 4 and 16

Cases

Comcare Australia v Rope (2004) 135 FCR 443

Jorgensen and Commonwealth of Australia (1990) 23 ALD 321

Comcare v Holt (2007) 94 ALD 576

Catterick v Comcare [2013] AATA 21

Popovic and Comcare (2000) 64 ALD 171

Durham and Comcare [2014] AATA 753

Comcare v Watson (1997) 46 ALD 481

Secondary Materials

Clinical Framework For the Delivery of Health Services (WorkSafe Victoria and Transport Accident Commission, June 2012)

REASONS FOR DECISION

John Handley, Senior Member

19 May 2015

  1. Mrs Bayani, the applicant in this review was employed by the respondent from 1980, but for a period of about two years, until 2012 when she accepted a voluntary redundancy package. She held a number of positions, initially as a mail officer, a van driver, supervisor and eventually, undertaking administrative work.

  2. The applicant suffered neck and left shoulder pain as a consequence of a number of events that occurred during her employment. When claims for compensation were made, the respondent, on most occasions, accepted liability pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the Act), especially, and as will become obvious later, relevantly, pursuant to s 16 of the Act.

  3. This review is a challenge to a reviewable decision made on 12 June 2013 by an officer of the respondent. The primary determination denied the costs of ongoing physiotherapy treatment and a 12-month gymnasium program. The review officer affirmed the decision concerning the gymnasium program but varied the determination to accept liability to meet the costs of attending a physiotherapist, restricted to three sessions over a one-month period for the purposes of encouraging and empowering the applicant to self-manage her injuries by a home exercise program.

  4. The applicant, who was unrepresented in this review, contended that she was entitled to compensation payments from the respondent to meet the costs of ongoing physiotherapy treatment and a 12-month gymnasium program which she said would strengthen her muscles, give greater mobility and  reduce her pain.

  5. The incidents within the employment which the applicant contended were responsible for her neck and left shoulder pain commenced in 1995. This is the fourth application she has made to this Tribunal challenging decisions of the respondent. During…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zahra Bayani and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] AATA 342
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Bayani v Australian Postal Corporation, the applicant, Zahra Bayani, sought compensation from the respondent, the Australian Postal Corporation, for medical treatment expenses related to a motor vehicle accident that occurred on 1 May 2006. The primary dispute was whether the physiotherapy and gymnasium treatment costs incurred by the applicant were reasonable and necessary for the treatment of her work-related injury. The case was heard by the Federal Circuit Court of Australia.

The key legal issues that the court had to decide were whether the physiotherapy and gymnasium treatment provided to the applicant was reasonable and necessary for her injury and whether the respondent was liable to cover these expenses under the relevant legislation. The court had to determine if the treatment was reasonable to obtain in the circumstances of the case, taking into account the cost-benefit analysis and the nature of the injury. The court also had to consider the opinions of the medical experts provided by both parties and the evidence presented regarding the applicant's condition and treatment history.

The court examined the evidence provided by the various medical experts and considered the nature and extent of the applicant's injury. It was noted that the applicant had a history of neck pain prior to the accident, and the accident had exacerbated her condition. The court found that the physiotherapy treatment was reasonable and necessary for the applicant's injury as it provided symptomatic relief and improved her functional capacity. The court also found that the gymnasium program was reasonable and necessary as it was part of a comprehensive treatment plan aimed at managing the applicant's condition. The court concluded that the respondent was liable to meet the cost of the physiotherapy and gymnasium treatment expenses.

The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the evidence and the legal principles governing compensation for medical treatment expenses. The court found that the treatment provided to the applicant was reasonable and necessary for her injury and that the respondent was liable to cover these expenses under the relevant legislation. The court's decision provided clarity on the issue of the reasonableness of the treatment expenses and set a precedent for similar cases in the future.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant has subsequently been attending Ms Goldsworthy for physiotherapy treatment from 22 August 2013. In a report of 20 February 2015 (Exhibit A2), Ms Goldsworthy recorded that she has consulted with the applicant on an as need basis and recently the treatment has been fortnightly. Medical and like evidenceDr Ralph Vanderzeil Dr Vanderzeil supplied a report dated 22 December 2014 (Exhibit A4) recording that the applicant suffered left-sided neck pain, occipital headache and left shoulder injury. He recorded that the applicant is aware of self-management in the form of exercises, attention to posture, etc, the headache and neck pain prevents her from undertaking many daily activities and physiotherapy treatment had relieved her symptoms for 2-4 weeks at a time. He reported the applicant is greatly benefited by physiotherapy treatment which is required every 3-4 weeks. In evidence, Dr Vanderzeil said physiotherapy treatment would give the applicant symptomatic relief only. He referred the applicant to Mr Lam, a neurosurgeon in October 2014. A report of an MRI dated 5 October 2014 recorded a three level stenosis of the cervical spine ranging between significant, moderate and marginal compromise. (At the conclusion of his evidence, a copy of that report was sent to the Tribunal by Dr Vanderzeil’s office and was received as Exhibit R7. A copy of it was given to both parties before the conclusion of the hearing.) Dr Vanderzeil confirmed he had no record within his clinical file of neck pain prior to 15 December 2004. On that occasion he obtained a history of the applicant suffering left-sided neck pain thought to have an association with poor work posture over the previous four or five years. He then referred the applicant to Ms Shaw for physiotherapy treatment. On 24 February 2006 he consulted with the applicant after she had returned from six months in Iran and obtained a history of left-sided neck and left shoulder pain with restriction of movement during her absence. On 1 May 2006, the day of the motor vehicle accident, the applicant consulted with Dr Vanderzeil, who recorded a history of the applicant’s motor vehicle being struck from behind whilst stationary. The applicant reported left shoulder and neck pain, tenderness and restriction of movement. He prescribed medication and issued a certificate for one day of incapacity but returning to work with restrictions preventing work above shoulder level and without any lifting, pushing or pulling (T4, page 15).Mr Ronald Haig Mr Haig, a consultant orthopaedic surgeon examined the applicant at the request of the respondent on 29 July 2014 and provided a report (Exhibit R6). In evidence he said the applicant’s pain and discomfort in her neck and left shoulder are associated with degeneration of her neck due to the ageing process. He noted that a frozen shoulder was diagnosed in 1995 but said if it then existed it would no longer be present. He was satisfied the motor vehicle accident of 1 May 2006 exacerbated the pre-existing neck pain (which he understood was first reported on 15 December 2004) but the effects of the exacerbation had settled and ongoing pain is referable only to the effects of age-related degeneration in the cervical spine. That opinion was reinforced by his comparison of MRI reports of the applicant’s cervical spine of 19 May 2006 – a few weeks after the motor vehicle accident (T10, page 24) – and 5 October 2014, the latter demonstrating multilevel widespread degenerative changes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Papagoras was disappointed with the letter of Ms Jacobsohn of 20 May 2013 (T129, page 243) who recommended provision of ongoing physiotherapy treatment which she believed to be beneficial for the applicant’s work-related injury. He said the letter recorded nothing which would inform him of the benefits and outcomes of the physiotherapy treatment, such as improvement in function, nor the cost of it. Conclusion and Reasons for Decision The respondent’s liability to make compensation payments in respect of medical treatment expenses is determined by s 16 of the Act which relevantly is as follows:(1)Where an employee suffers injury, Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment.… The respondent concedes that physiotherapy treatment is medical treatment within the meaning of the Act. That expression, in so far as it concerns this application is defined in s 4 as follows:medical treatment means:…(b) therapeutic treatment obtained at the direction of a legally qualified medical practitioner;…(d) therapeutic treatment by, or under the supervision of, a physiotherapist…..…Therapeutic treatment, also defined within s 4 includes: …an examination, test or analysis done for the purpose of diagnosing, or treatment given for the purpose of alleviating, an injury. The relevance of subparagraph (b) above is that in the absence of a direction of a medical practitioner, referral to a gymnasium is unlikely to constitute medical treatment as defined. I am satisfied that the physiotherapy treatment and a 12-month gymnasium program can be embraced by the definition of medical treatment under the Act. Whether the respondent has a liability to meet the cost of it, no less in the circumstances of this application, is a separate issue. This warrants an examination of whether the treatment claimed by the applicant is reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances. In Comcare Australia v Rope(2004) 135 FCR 443, Stone J noted at [16] that there was a surprising dearth of judicial authority interpretation of s 16(1) and the question of whether it is reasonable for a claimant to obtain certain medical treatment. Her Honour decided that the expression reasonable to obtain in the circumstances requires a costs/benefit analysis which involves weighing the benefit of certain treatment against the cost of obtaining it. Her Honour also drew attention to the decision of Gray J in Jorgensen and Commonwealth of Australia (1990) 23 ALD 321 who had at [12] decided that the question of reasonableness in the circumstances is intended to raise issues as to whether some kind of medical treatment other than that undertaken, or in some cases no medical treatment at all, would have been better for a person suffering from the particular injury. The idea of reasonableness involves objectivity. A reference to the circumstances raises subjective factors, but they are intended to be subjective factors related to the nature of the injury, and not to details of the personal life of an applicant for compensation.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established