Idem and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Idem and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Citizenship) [2025] ARTA 68 (6 February 2025)

Applicant/s:  Wansa Idem

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/0183

Tribunal:General Member M. Carey

Place:Melbourne

Date:6 February 2025

Decision:The Tribunal sets aside the Minister’s decision of 12 December 2023 under review and remits the matter for reconsideration in accordance with the following Direction:

At the time of the decision of 12 December 2023, and all times subsequent, the Applicant suffered and continues to suffer from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity that means she is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship or a basic knowledge of the English language within the meaning of s 21(3)(d)(ii) and (iii) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth).

................................[sgd]........................................

General Member M. Carey

Catchwords

CITIZENSHIP – application for conferral of Australian citizenship – permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity – incapacities both physical and mental to be considered – whether incapacity means applicant for citizenship is not capable of demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language – whether incapacity means applicant for citizenship is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship – section 21(3)(d) Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) – decision under review is set aside and remitted for reconsideration

Legislation

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)

Cases

Butrus v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
FFFL v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2021] AATA 394

Kalali and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] AATA 1209
Ward v Corrimal-Balgownie Collieries Ltd (1938) 61 CLR 120

Secondary Materials

Department of Immigration and Border Protection, Australian Citizenship Procedural Instructions – CPI 2 – Australian Citizenship by Conferral – Permanent or Enduring Physical or Mental Incapacity

Statement of Reasons

  1. Ms Wansa Idem is a 55 year old woman from Iraq who arrived in Australia in April 2017 as the holder of a Global Special Humanitarian (subclass 202) visa granted a little time earlier. She was then living in Syria as a refugee from Iraq. Ms Idem left Iraq in early 2007.

  2. Having lived in Australia for 6 years, Ms Idem made an application for Australian citizenship by conferral on 3 January 2023. That application was lodged with the Department of Home Affairs on 13 January 2023.

  3. Her application was rejected by the Minister's delegate on the grounds that she did not satisfy s 21(3)(d) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Citizenship Act). She was advised of the Minister's decision by letter sent on 12 December 2023 attaching a decision record.[1] The reasons for decision explained:[2]

    I am not satisfied that the information in the reports provided by Dr Samir Ibrahim and psychologist Stevie Marcus are sufficient to demonstrate that your incapacity was present at the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Idem and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 68
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Idem, a citizen of another country, challenged the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs' decision to refuse his application for Australian citizenship under section 21(3)(d) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth). The Minister's decision hinged on the assertion that Idem's physical and mental incapacities prevented him from demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language and an adequate knowledge of Australia and the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship. Idem argued that his incapacities did not preclude him from meeting these requirements. The matter was brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) for review.

The primary legal issue before the AAT was whether the Minister's decision correctly interpreted and applied section 21(3)(d) of the Citizenship Act. Specifically, the court needed to determine if Idem's incapacities rendered him incapable of demonstrating the required knowledge of English and Australian citizenship, as per the statutory criteria. Another significant aspect was the interpretation of the term "permanent or enduring" in the context of mental incapacity, and whether it could be satisfied by a temporary incapacity at the time of application.

The AAT examined the legislative history and the intent behind the amendment of section 21(3)(d), referencing the Australian Citizenship Test Review Committee's (Woolcott Committee) report. The AAT found that the Minister's decision failed to adequately consider Idem's specific circumstances and the broader legislative intent to support vulnerable applicants. The Tribunal highlighted that the Committee's recommendations aimed to prevent disadvantaging individuals with severe and chronic symptoms from experiences such as torture and trauma. The AAT concluded that the Minister had not properly applied the law in light of these considerations and thus set aside the decision, remitting it for reconsideration.

The AAT ordered that the Minister reconsider Idem's application for Australian citizenship, ensuring that all relevant factors, including the legislative intent and Idem's specific circumstances, were appropriately considered. The decision underscored the importance of a nuanced approach to interpreting and applying the provisions of the Citizenship Act, particularly in cases involving vulnerable applicants.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 24 of the Citizenship Act, so far as is relevant to this review, states:24 Minister's decision(1)If a person makes an application under section 21, the Minister must, by writing, approve or refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen.Note: The Minister may cancel an approval: see section 25.(1A)The Minister must not approve the person becoming an Australian citizen unless the person is eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 21(2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7) or (8).(2)The Minister may refuse to approve the person becoming an Australian citizen despite the person being eligible to become an Australian citizen under subsection 21(2), (3), (4), (5), (6) or (7). Section 21(3) of the Citizenship Act states:(3)A person is eligible to become an Australian citizen if the Minister is satisfied that the person:(a) is aged 18 or over at the time the person made the application; and(b) is a permanent resident:(i) at the time the person made the application; and(ii) at the time of the Minister's decision on the application; and(c)satisfies the general residence requirement (see section 22) or the special residence requirement (see section 22A or 22B), or satisfies the defence service requirement (see section 23), at the time the person made the application; and(d)has a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity, at the time the person made the application, that means the person:(i)is not capable of understanding the nature of the application at that time; or(ii)is not capable of demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language at that time; or(iii)is not capable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time; and(e)is likely to reside, or to continue to reside, in Australia or to maintain a close and continuing association with Australia if the application were to be approved; and(f)is of good character at the time of the Minister's decision on the application. The Minister’s decision noted that all other requirements save for subsection (3)(d) were satisfied, though no assessment was made of the ‘good character’ requirement at s 21 (3)(f) of the Citizenship Act. The Minister’s representative referred me to various decisions of this Tribunal in relation to the manner in which this section had been construed in the past. In one decision by Senior Member Puplick, Butrus and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239 (Butrus), there was a helpful discussion of the background to s 21(3)(d) of the Citizenship Act which I reproduce:25.This section of the Act resulted from the government’s consideration of the Australian Citizenship Test Review Committee (Woolcott Committee) report, Moving Forward …Improving Pathways to Citizenship which reported in August 2008.26.Prior to that date s 21(3)(d) established citizenship eligibility where the person had“a permanent physical or mental incapacity, at the time the person made the application, that means the person is not capable of understanding the nature of the application at that time.”27. The Woolcott Committee recommended as follows:In looking closely at the legislation, the Committee believes that there is scope for improving the exemption provisions regarding “mental incapacity”. For survivors of torture and trauma, the use of a formal test which requires a high level of English proficiency, a large amount of study and familiarity in the use of a computer, significantly disadvantages them. There are many people who come to Australia under the Humanitarian Program who fall into this category.The Committee considers the current exemption criteria do not take into consideration the effect of severe and chronic symptoms resulting from the experience of torture and trauma. These may include strong anxiety associated with learning difficulties, and while some symptoms are permanent, others, though severe, are not necessarily permanent.Section 23A sets out the process for a citizenship test and it states in the note that the test must be related to the eligibility criteria referred to in paragraphs 21(2)(d) understanding the nature of the application, (e) a basic knowledge of the English language and (f) an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.Therefore, “mental incapacity” is only being used as an exemption in relation to section 21(2)(d) (understanding the nature of the application) but is not included in section 21(2)(e) and (f) which require a basic knowledge of the English language and an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship. However, they are all relevant to citizenship testing.Moreover, permanent physical and mental incapacity uses the words “at that time” in relation to when an application for Australian citizenship is lodged. The Committee considers that the use of “permanent” and “at that time” are contradictory when discussing mental incapacity, and in light of the consultations, is of the view that the physical and mental incapacity may not need to be permanent to satisfy the principle underpinning this exemption.The Committee believes there will be people in this enlarged group who may never fit into the suggested alternative pathways discussed earlier in this report because their past traumatic experiences affect their ability to retain the necessary information required to pass a test. 28.It is suggested that section 21(3)(d) could be amended in the spirit of the existing Act to read:“has a physical or mental incapacity at that time means the person is not capable due to the physical or mental incapacity of:· understanding the nature of the application at that time; or· demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language at that time; or· demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship at that time.” 29. In specific reference to the citizenship test, the Committee recommended:Section 21(3)(d) of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 be amended in the spirit of the Act to include an inability to demonstrate a basic knowledge of English and an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship due to mental incapacity, resulting in those individuals not being required to sit a test. 30.The Government accepted the recommendations of the Committee agreeing to amend section 21(3)(d) to“ensure that the test does not disadvantage vulnerable people who most need our support.” 31.The change to the legislation was effected by passage of the Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Test Review and Other Measures) Act 2009.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established