Butrus v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

Butrus and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 239 (28 February 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/0177

Re:Najeeb Abdo Butrus

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Immigration and Border Protection

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:28 February 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

..........................[sgd]..............................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship test exemption – whether the applicant suffered from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity – evidence of mental incapacity – tribunal not satisfied that there is evidence of mental incapacity – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Test Review and Other Measures) Act 2009 (Cth)

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)

CASES

Farhan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 36

Khodeir v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 499

Laalaa v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 579

Rahman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 930

Ravichandran v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 463

Shao v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] AATA 709

Skaf v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 429

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Citizenship Policy, 1 June 2016

Determination for the Approval of Citizenship Test (Section 23A) IMMI 11/088 made by the Minister on 1 March 2012, effective 24 March 2012

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5) (American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C. 2013)

Australian Citizenship Test Review Committee, Moving forward…improving pathways to citizenship (R Woolcott, chair), Australian Citizenship Test Review Committee, 2008.

Kim Rubenstein: Australian Citizenship Law (Lawbook, 2017, second edition)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

28 February 2019

  1. Mr Najeeb Abdo Butrus (the Applicant) appeals to this Tribunal to review a decision made by a Delegate of the Minister (the Respondent) to deny his claim for citizenship by conferral under the provisions of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act).

  2. The Applicant’s application for citizenship was made on 29 December 2016 and refused by the Delegate on 8 January 2018.  On 16 January 2018 the Applicant lodged his appeal with this Tribunal which heard his case on 22 February 2019.

  3. The basis upon which the Delegate refused the application was that the Applicant failed to pass the citizenship test as required by s 21(2A) of the Act.

  4. The Applicant’s response to this determination has been to advance his claim for citizenship by reliance upon s 21(3)(d) of the Act which establishes eligibility for citizenship where an applicant  “has a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity, at the time the person made the application” and is thus not otherwise able to meet the general requirements which are related to the taking and passing of the citizenship test.

  5. The Respondent contests that the Applicant does not have this degree of incapacity.

  6. It is unfortunate, especially given the nature of the claims advanced by the Applicant that he was unrepresented at the Tribunal hearings, although assisted…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Butrus v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 239
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an exemption from the Australian citizenship knowledge test, brought by Mr Butrus against the Minister for Immigration and Border Protection. The applicant sought this exemption on the basis that he suffered from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal was required to determine whether the evidence presented established such an incapacity that would prevent the applicant from acquiring the necessary English language skills or understanding the nature of Australian citizenship and its associated responsibilities and privileges.

The Tribunal was tasked with assessing the medical evidence to ascertain if the applicant's alleged Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and major depression constituted a permanent and enduring mental incapacity that would preclude him from meeting the citizenship requirements. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider whether the applicant's condition prevented him from acquiring sufficient English language skills or understanding the nature of his citizenship application and the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship. The Tribunal also considered other factors, including the applicant's ability to learn other languages, his understanding of the value of citizenship, and his possession of an Australian driver's licence.

The Tribunal found that while the applicant presented evidence from Dr Abu-Arab suggesting PTSD and major depression, this diagnosis was called into question by the expert evidence of Mr O’Neill. The Tribunal preferred Mr O’Neill's evidence, which concluded that the applicant's difficulties, whatever their nature, did not prevent him from acquiring at least sufficient language and literacy skills to understand the citizenship application and the privileges and obligations of citizenship. The Tribunal noted that the applicant had learned other languages and that his reasons for not persisting with English language study were unpersuasive. Crucially, the Tribunal found no clear causal connection between any diagnosed incapacity and the applicant's inability to acquire basic English skills or understand the nature of Australian citizenship.

Consequently, the Tribunal could not make a finding that the applicant suffered from a permanent and enduring mental incapacity that would prevent him from acquiring basic English language skills or understanding the nature of Australian citizenship. The decision under review, which affirmed the refusal of the exemption, was therefore affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In order to demonstrate this, the applicant must, in line with the Citizenship Policy, produce evidence from a qualified medical practitioner which shows that the enduring incapacity is one for which there can be no predictable recovery, or where that recovery would not reasonably be expected to take place before the applicant becomes otherwise eligible for a grant of citizenship.Evidence from Dr Abu-Arab[19][19] Applicant’s Submission. Report dated 22 March 2018. In summary, Dr Abu-Arab makes the following findings in relation to the Applicant:1)He needs support and assistance with matters of self-care and personal hygiene which is provided by his daughter;2)He avoids social contacts, no longer going to Church, leaving home or exchanging visits with friends and family;3)He drives locally to familiar places but cannot use public transport;4)He has poor (and confrontational) relationships with family members who he tends to avoid;5)He is unable to concentrate even watching television, has only attended 10 hours of English classes and finds that he gains no benefit from (attempted) study;6)He is unable to participate in any meaningful decision-making activities; and7)He has no capacity to undertake meaningful employment or work of any kind. From these findings and observations, Dr Abu-Arab concludes that the Applicant suffers from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD), largely occasioned by his traumatic experiences in Iraq and further that he has a secondary diagnosis of major depression. He concludes:“I believe that his psychiatric condition as well as his illiteracy problem would affect his ability to concentrate on tasks and retain new learnt material. The patient’s condition is chronic and long lasting because it has been present for many years. I do not expect significant improvement even with thorough and extensive training.…..I believe that his current psychiatric condition following the numerous traumatic events he experienced in the past and his illiteracy problem would affect his ability to learn and retain new material/information. Therefore, I recommend exempting him from the knowledge test for new citizens.Based on my observations, I am satisfied that Mr Butrus’ condition is permanent and long lasting. Therefore, I am confident it is unlikely that with further training his condition may change.In my view, he doesn’t have the basic knowledge of the English language to enable him to learn and retain information, such as the information required to pass the Citizenship exam. I further believe he is unable to demonstrate an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.” Dr Abu-Arab also provided a letter to the Tribunal dated 4 February 2019 in which he states:“I supported (Mr Butrus) in his application because he suffers with PTSD, The condition of PTSD is associated with worsening in memory and concentration. Therefore his condition would be an obstacle for him to learn and retain huge amount of information such as learning a new language and learning information required to pass the Citizenship Test.”[20][20] Tribunal Evidence at [A1].

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal thus cannot make a finding to the effect that the Applicant suffers from a permanent and enduring mental incapacity, or at least one that would prevent the Applicant from either acquiring some basic English language skills and/or some understanding of the nature of Australian citizenship.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

This leads the Tribunal to adopt Mr O’Neill’s expert evidence to the effect that whatever difficulties the Applicant may be suffering (and noting his conclusion that no conclusive diagnosis of these can be made), none of them are such that they would preclude or prevent the Applicant from acquiring language and literacy skills at least sufficient to be able to understand both the nature of the application for citizenship which he has made and the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.OTHER CONSIDERATIONS Among the factors taken into account by the Tribunal, in addition to the medical evidence, the following may be highlighted:·The Applicant may be functionally illiterate in his native language (Arabic) but he has nevertheless been able to learn and be fluent in at least two others: Kurdish and Chaldean.·In making the point to the Tribunal that one of the reasons he wanted Australian citizenship was that he would acquire an Australian passport which would somehow make it easier for him to visit his brother in Germany, and that he “would be like everyone else in this country”, he displays some understanding of the value of citizenship. Similar findings in relation to travel rights on an Australian passport were held to be an important element in denying s 21(3)(d) claims in Ravichandran[29], Khodeir,[30] Farhan[31] and Rahman.[32]·The Applicant obtained an Australian drivers’ licence[33] and continues to drive, so that the Tribunal presumes that he possesses at least some ability to understand road signs and directions.[29] Ravichandran v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 463 at [5] and [9].[30] Khodeir v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2015] AATA 499 at [18].[31] Farhan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 36 at [7].[32] Rahman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 930 at [13].[33] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [31].CONSTRAINTS V CAUSATIONS There is no doubt that the Applicant suffers under a number of constraints in terms of his ability to meet the requirements of Australian citizenship. However these constraints derive primarily from his illiteracy in either Arabic or English. He has learned to speak other languages, albeit as a child (or at least younger person) rather than as an adult where learning is recognised to be more difficult. He started to learn English on his arrival in Australia but his reasons for not persisting with this effort are unpersuasive given his then situation and circumstances. In order to meet the requirements of s 21(3)(d) what needs to be established is the clear causal connection between a significant physical or mental incapacity and the inability to understand either the nature of the citizenship application or the privileges and obligations of citizenship and the ability to demonstrate a basis knowledge of the English language. The diagnosis of PTSD and severe depression from Dr Abu-Arab has been called into question by the diagnosis of Mr O’Neill whose evidence the Tribunal finds to be the more impressive. It also accepts Mr O’Neill’s evidence to the effect that neither of those conditions, in and of themselves, prevents the acquisition of language or literacy skills.