Sahar and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

Sahar and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 1232 (7 June 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:           2018/2620

Re:Mr Jahad Sahar

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member Linda Kirk

Date:7 June 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside on the basis that the Tribunal finds that the Applicant qualifies under s 21(3)(d) of the Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

............................[sgd]............................

Senior Member Linda Kirk

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship test exemption – whether applicant suffers from a permanent or enduring mental incapacity – medical evidence considered – chronic conditions – applicant diagnosed with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and Depressive Disorder – causal connection established between the applicant’s mental incapacity and his inability to demonstrate a basic knowledge of the English language – decision under review set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) ss 21, 23A,

CASES

Re ER Aston and Y Aston and Secretary, Department of Primary Industry [1985] AATA 306; (1985) 8 ALD 366

Butrus and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239
Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] AATA 179; (1979) 2 ALD 634
Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499

Skaf v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] AATA 429

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Citizenship Policy, 1 June 2016

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Linda Kirk

7 June 2019

APPLICATION FOR REVIEW

  1. Mr Jahad Bachay Sahar (‘the Applicant’) was born in 1963 and is a citizen of Iraq.[1] He arrived in Australia on 16 April 2011.[2] On 15 May 2015, the Applicant applied for Australian citizenship by conferral under section 21 of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) (the Act).[3]

    [1] Section 37 T-Documents, T04, p.111.

    [2] T04, p. 113.

    [3] T04, p. 111.

  2. On 29 March 2018, the application was refused by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (‘the Respondent’) as the delegate was not satisfied that the Applicant met the criteria under s 21(3)(d) of the Act (‘the Reviewable Decision’).[4]

    [4] T08, p. 167.

  3. On 7 May 2018, the Applicant applied to the General Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) for review of the Reviewable Decision.[5]

    [5] T01, p. 1.

  4. The matter was heard in Sydney on 1 April 2019. The Applicant attended the hearing in person and was self-represented.  The Applicant gave evidence with the assistance of an Arabic language interpreter. Dr Hecham Alhajali, Consultant Psychiatrist, also gave evidence at the hearing by phone.

    LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

    Australian Citizenship Act 2007

  5. The criteria for general eligibility requirements for the conferral of Australian citizenship are set out in section 21 of the Act. The provisions relevant to the determination of this application are as follows:

    Application and eligibility for citizenship

    (1)  A person may make an application to the Minister to become an Australian citizen.

    General eligibility

    (2)  A person is eligible…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sahar and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 1232
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, Sahar, sought review of a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs concerning his eligibility for Australian citizenship. The core of the dispute revolved around whether Sahar qualified for an exemption from the citizenship test due to a permanent or enduring mental incapacity. The matter was heard by Linda Kirk SM in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether Sahar suffered from a permanent or enduring mental incapacity at the time of his citizenship application, and if so, whether there was a clear causal connection between this incapacity and his inability to demonstrate a basic knowledge of the English language, as required by section 21(3)(d) of the *Citizenship Act 2007* (Cth). The Tribunal also needed to consider the weight to be given to various medical reports submitted by the applicant.

The Tribunal found, based on the evidence of Consultant Psychiatrist Dr. Hecham Alhajali, that Sahar did indeed suffer from a permanent and enduring mental incapacity with cognitive deficits, which was chronic and unlikely to improve. This finding was supported by Dr. Alhajali's reports and his oral evidence, and the Tribunal was satisfied that Sahar had been seen by Dr. Alhajali on a regular basis, as anticipated by the Citizenship Policy. The Tribunal concluded that the evidence established a causal connection between Sahar's mental incapacity and his inability to demonstrate a basic knowledge of the English language.

Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the decision under review and substituted a new decision finding that Sahar qualified for an exemption from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test under section 21(3)(d) of the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant’s former wife, son and daughter live in Sydney. He also has two brothers and one sister who live in Australia. He sees his family from time to time. He currently lives with his nephew. He has problems with his family and he wants to travel to Sweden where two of his sisters live and spend time with them there. He is unable to travel to Europe on his Iraqi passport.Medical Evidence The Applicant submitted to the Tribunal numerous medical reports from a variety of medical practitioners: Reports by Dr Hecham Alhajali, Consultant Psychiatrist, dated 14 July 2012[9], 31 October 2015[10], 7 November 2015[11], 21 July 2018[12] and 19 January 2019[13]; Report by Onsy Mattar, Consulting Psychologist, undated;[14] Report by Walid Ahmad, Psychologist, dated 14 June 2011;[15] Report by Dr Ishrat Ali, Consultant Psychiatrist, dated 24 February 2012;[16] Report by Dr Ibrahim Hanna, Consultant Psychiatrist, dated 21 March 2012;[17] STARTTS letter from Dr Tajana Opacic, Clinical Psychologist, dated 25 May 2012;[18] Report by Dr Bassel Hassan, Consultant Neurologist, dated 28 December 2013;[19] Letter from Dr Raiz Ismail, Consultant Psychiatrist, dated 17 August 2018;[20] Report by Dr Zaha Kalid, General Practitioner, dated 15 April 2015,[21] 4 November 2015,[22] 6 August 2018[23] and 7 February 2019;[24] Report of Dr Kasim Abaie, Registered Psychologist, dated 8 January 2017[25] and 13 August 2018.[26][9] T06, p. 151.[10] T06, p. 158.[11] T06, pp. 161-163.[12] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Hecham Alhajali dated 21 July 2018.[13] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Hecham Alhajali dated 19 January 2019.[14] Exhibit A1.[15] Exhibit A2.[16] T06, pp. 146-147.[17] T06, p. 148.[18] T06, pp. 149-150.[19] T06, pp. 152-155.[20] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Raiz Ismail dated 17 August 2018.[21] T06, pp. 156-157. [22] T06, p. 160.[23] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Zaha Kalid, dated 6 August 2018.[24] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Zaha Kalid dated 7 February 2019.[25] T06, pp. 164-165.[26] Applicant’s documents, Report of Dr Kasim Abaie dated 13 August 2018.Dr Hecham Alhajali, Consultant Psychiatrist The bulk of the evidence in relation to the Applicant’s mental health is contained in written reports from Dr Hecham Alhajali, MBBS, MD Psych, FRANZCP, a consultant psychiatrist who also gave evidence to the Tribunal by telephone, at the request of the Respondent. Dr Hecham Alhajali provided reports for the purposes of the Applicant's citizenship application dated 7 November 2015 and 19 January 2019. In his report dated 7 November 2015, Dr Alhajali stated that the Applicant:… has not been able to improve his English language skills … due to the effects of mental illness in addition to several other reasons, including limited cognitive abilities and a limited education and school history, exposure to stress and inability to cope with psychological stressors… has a permanent and enduring mental incapacity with cognitive deficits.… is incapable of demonstrating a basic knowledge of the English language and also incapable of demonstrating an adequate knowledge of Australian history and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.[27] [27] T06, p. 163.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Having made this finding, it is unnecessary for the Tribunal to consider whether there is the requisite link between the Applicant’s permanent or enduring mental incapacity and his inability to understand the nature of his citizenship application or his inability to demonstrate an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.DECISION The decision under review is set aside on the basis that the Tribunal finds that the Applicant qualifies under s 21(3)(d) of the Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth) to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Respondent submits that no weight should be given to the reports of Mr Mattar and Mr Ahmad, as they do not appear to hold the specialist qualifications required under the Citizenship Policy.CONSIDERATION AND REASONS The Tribunal is required to determine whether or not the Applicant qualifies under s 21(3)(d) of the Act to be granted an exemption from having to undertake the Citizenship Test. As Senior Member Puplick observed in Butrus and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239 at [61]: in order for the requirements of s 21(3)(d) to be satisfied, there must be established a ‘clear causal connection’ between a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity at the time of the citizenship application and one of the three requirements in s 21(2)(d), (e) and (f) termed by Senior Member Taylor in Khodeir as awareness, English and knowledge. The evidence must support a finding that the Applicant has a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity, and that there is a direct causal link between this incapacity and his lack of understanding of the nature of the citizenship application (‘awareness’), or his lack of a basic knowledge of the English language (‘English’), or his lack of an adequate knowledge of Australia and of the responsibility and privileges of Australian citizenship (‘knowledge’).Did the Applicant have a permanent or enduring mental incapacity at the date of his citizenship application? On the basis of the evidence before it, the Tribunal is satisfied that, at the date of his application for citizenship in May 2015, the Applicant suffered a permanent and enduring mental incapacity. It makes this finding on the basis of the evidence provided by Dr Hecham Alhajali, a consultant psychiatrist, and fellow of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. Dr Alhajali holds the required qualifications recognised in the Citizenship Policy to provide an opinion in relation to the Applicant’s mental incapacity.[58] The Tribunal notes that the Citizenship Policy recognises that evidence provided by one relevantly qualified medical practitioner is sufficient to satisfy its requirements.[59][58] Australian Citizenship Policy, pp. 71-74.[59] Ibid. The Tribunal notes that the Citizenship Policy anticipates that the person claiming a permanent or enduring incapacity ‘will have been seeing a specialist on a regular basis.’ The evidence before the Tribunal is that the Applicant has seen Dr Alhajali on five occasions on 16 June 2012, 14 July 2012, 31 October 2015, 21 July 2018 and 19 January 2019. On the basis of this record of appointments, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Applicant has seen Dr Alhajali ‘on a regular basis’. The evidence provided by Dr Alhajali in relation to the Applicant’s mental incapacity is that he ‘has a permanent and enduring mental incapacity with cognitive deficits’ and his condition is ‘chronic’ and ‘unlikely to improve’. This opinion was provided by Dr Alhajali in his written report on 7 November 2015, six months following the Applicant’s citizenship application, and confirmed in his subsequent report in January 2019 and in his oral evidence at the Tribunal hearing. The Tribunal is therefore satisfied that the Applicant has a mental incapacity that is ‘either permanent or sufficiently long-term as to be enduring’ and ‘one for which there cannot be a predicted recovery’ as contemplated by the Citizenship Policy.