Atiya and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

Atiya and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 415 (18 March 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/4172

Re:Sennan Atiya

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:18 March 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is set aside on the basis that the Tribunal finds that Mr Atiya qualifies under s 21(3)(b) of the Citizenship Act to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship test exemption – whether the applicant suffered from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity – decision set aside

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007

Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Test Review and Other Measures) Act 2009

CASES

Atef Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499

Butrus v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239

Skaf v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 429

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Citizenship Policy, 1 June 2016

Determination for the Approval of Citizenship Test (Section 23A) IMMI 11/088 made by the Minister on 1 March 2012, effective 24 March 2012

Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders Fifth Edition (DSM-5) (American Psychiatric Association, Washington, D.C. 2013

REASONS FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

18 March 2019

  1. Mr Sennan Khazal Atiya (the Applicant) appeals to this Tribunal against a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs (the Respondent) to refuse his application for citizenship by conferral.

  2. Citizenship by conferral (that is where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act). One of those requirements is that the Applicant sits for and passes the citizenship test. However, if an applicant has “an enduring physical or mental incapacity” which is of such a nature that they cannot undertake the citizenship test, then they may be granted citizenship, all other things being equal and all other requirements being satisfied, without so doing.

  3. It is on this basis that the Applicant comes before the Tribunal seeking to have the Minister’s decision set aside.

    APPLICANT’S CIRCUMSTANCES

  4. The Applicant was born in Iraq in August 1982. He arrived in Australia in February 2009 from Syria where he had fled as a refugee from his homeland. He holds a Global Special Humanitarian visa subclass 202.

  5. According to a statement rendered under his name,[1] although written apparently by either, his carer, his brother-in-law or a deceased friend, his mother died while the family were in Syria in 2006 awaiting the granting of refugee status and his father died in 2013 in Australia. Apparently one of his sisters arrived in Australia at the same time as did he and his father. One other sister and two brothers (who now have families) have since arrived here. According to the Applicant at least three of his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Atiya and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 415
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr Atiya (the Applicant) to the Tribunal for review of a decision by the Minister for Home Affairs (the Respondent) to refuse to grant him Australian citizenship. The Applicant sought an exemption from the Australian Citizenship Test, which requires a score of 75% and cannot have its threshold varied. The Applicant's claim for exemption was based on allegations of a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the Applicant suffered from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity that would prevent him from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test. This involved assessing the medical evidence presented by the Applicant, including reports from his general practitioner, a psychologist, and specialist medical practitioners, and considering the Respondent's objections to certain evidence. The Tribunal also had to consider whether the Applicant understood the nature and meaning of his application, his prospect of acquiring English language competence, and his understanding of the privileges and responsibilities of Australian citizenship.

The Tribunal accepted the medical evidence, particularly from a consultant neurologist and a psychologist, that the Applicant suffered from an enduring mental incapacity. While acknowledging the Respondent's concerns regarding the formal qualifications of the psychologist, the Tribunal found the diagnosis and prognosis credible. The Tribunal concluded that this incapacity prevented, and would continue to prevent, the Applicant from undertaking the citizenship test. Consequently, the Tribunal found that the Applicant qualified for an exemption from the test under section 21(3)(b) of the *Citizenship Act*.

The decision under review was set aside, and the Tribunal found that Mr Atiya qualified for an exemption from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Instrument to which reference has already been made provides that a score of 75% is required and this minimum threshold cannot be varied.[14] This arrangement has been in place since the Instrument was made in March 2012.[14] Determination for the Approval of Citizenship Test (Section 23A) IMMI 11/088 at [10], [26], [43)(iii)].THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE The Applicant submitted several medical reports, from a variety of health practitioners, to the Tribunal. These relate both to the Applicant’s mental health and also to a physical problem with his wrist. It is not necessary to discuss the issues with the Applicants wrist or developing arthritis. The Tribunal accepts the evidence from the consultant neurologist (Dr Ibrahim Hanna)[15] and Dr Niranjan Ganeshan (at Rayscan Imaging),[16] among others, to the effect that such conditions exit. However none of the Applicant’s reported physical conditions would preclude him from physically sitting for the test which does not require written answers, and, to that extent, they are not relevant to this application.[15] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [15-17], [20-22] and [24].[16] Ibid at [19], [27], [29-33]. The matter which is relevant, relates to the Applicant’s mental health. There are three sets of reports which go to this question. Dr Adel Zaki is the Applicant’s regular General Practitioner and has commented upon the Applicant’s mental health in a series of letters by way of referrals to other (specialist) practitioners.[17][17] Letters dated 15 June 2018 and 23 November 2018 are included in the Applicant’s Submissions. Ms Sana Zaarour is a psychologist working at the Liverpool Healthcare Medical Centre. She is a Member of the Australian Psychological Society (MAPS). She has submitted reports on the Applicant’s mental health dated 11 July 2018 and 27 November 2018.[18][18] Respectively at Applicant’s Submission and at Section 37 tribunal Documents at [8-9]. The Respondent objects to these reports especially that of Ms Zaarour, being taken into account by the Tribunal or, in the event that they are, urges that they should be given little weight. This is because the Australian Citizenship Policy which is issued by the Department to guide decision-makers in the interpretation of the provisions of the Act states:“Applicants claiming permanent or enduring mental incapacity may provide evidence from a·psychiatrist who is a fellow of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists or·medical practitioner who is a fellow (sic) of the Australian Society of Psychological Medicine or ·psychologist who is registered with the Psychology Board of Australia, has a practice endorsement in an area relevant to the problem, and is registered with Medicare for these purposes. ….”[19][19] Australian Citizenship Policy (effective 1 June 2016) at [72]-[73]. In support of this proposition the Respondent states in its Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions (at paragraph 24):“In regards to this last requirement, the Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency’s (AHPRA) register of practitioners in relation to Ms Zaarour shows ‘none’ next to the term ‘endorsements’.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is clear to the Tribunal that the Applicant does have an enduring mental incapacity and that this incapacity prevents him now and will prevent him in the future from being in any position to undertake the Australian Citizenship Test. In Senior Member Taylor’s formulation he has none of the awareness, English or knowledge to which the test is directed.DECISION The decision under review is set aside on the basis that the Tribunal finds that Mr Atiya qualifies under s 21(3)(b) of the Citizenship Act to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It must be acknowledged that all this information was self-reported and that there were no other people, including his carer, invited to give evidence, by either party, apart from that taken from Dr Alhajali.CONSIDERATIONS The Applicant’s situation is one which evokes sympathy on the basis that he is a relatively young man, aged 36 years. He can expect to live for many decades into the future but it appears that that will be in a situation of social isolation and dependency. He is also suffering, apart from his mental health condition, from an increasingly disabling set of physical conditions. In response to questions it was quite clear that the Applicant had little or no idea why he wanted to become and Australian citizen or what the benefits of citizenship might be. All he could relate to was the concept of physical security which is hardly surprising given his reported traumatic experiences in Iraq and his refugee status in Syria. What the Tribunal has to decide is whether or not the Applicant qualifies under s. 221(3)(d) of the Act to be granted an exemption from having to undertake the Australian Citizenship Test. Is the Applicant capable of understanding the nature and meaning of his application; does he have or has the prospect of acquiring any degree of competence in the English language and does he understand the privileges and responsibilities of Australian citizenship? If he does not, then the question is, is this as a result of his having any enduring physical or mental incapacity at the time the application was made? One issue which was not explored in the hearing was whether or not his carer could play any sort of role in helping the Applicant to learn English. The Tribunal presumes that a full-time live-in carer would be a person who, in this instance, is fluent both in Arabic and English and who is spending almost all their time with the person in question. It is unknown if this possibility of acquiring any English language skills exists or whether the degree of cognitive impairment which has been diagnosed is such as to make this an unrealistic assumption. Despite the Respondent’s concerns about the lack of formal and programmatic testing of the Applicant by Dr Alhajali, the Tribunal has no difficulty in accepting his diagnosis of the Applicant’s current position and his prognosis for the future. It is clear to the Tribunal that the Applicant does have an enduring mental incapacity and that this incapacity prevents him now and will prevent him in the future from being in any position to undertake the Australian Citizenship Test. In Senior Member Taylor’s formulation he has none of the awareness, English or knowledge to which the test is directed.DECISION The decision under review is set aside on the basis that the Tribunal finds that Mr Atiya qualifies under s 21(3)(b) of the Citizenship Act to be exempted from undertaking the Australian Citizenship Test.