Hamid and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship)

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

Hamid and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) [2019] AATA 382 (13 March 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/3062

Re:Wafaa Jamil Hamid

APPLICANT

AndMinister for Home Affairs

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

Date:13 March 2019

Place:Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

..............................[sgd]..........................................

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

CITIZENSHIP – citizenship test exemption – whether the applicant suffered from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (Cth)

Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Test Review and Other Measures) Act 2009 (Cth)

CASES

Atef Khodeir and Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] AATA 499

Butrus v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] AATA 239

Farhan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 36

Rahman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 930

Skaf v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (Citizenship) [2016] AATA 429

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Department of Immigration and Border Protection (Cth), Citizenship Policy, 1 June 2016

Determination for the Approval of Citizenship Test (Section 23A) IMMI 11/088 made by the Minister on 1 March 2012, effective 24 March 2012

REASONS FOR DECISION

Chris Puplick AM, Senior Member

13 March 2019

  1. Ms Wafaa Jamil Muhamad (the Applicant) appeals to this Tribunal against a decision made by a delegate of the Minister for Home Affairs to refuse her application for citizenship by conferral.

  2. Citizenship by conferral (that is where citizenship is granted to a person who does not have an automatic or statutory entitlement to citizenship) may be granted where an applicant satisfies certain requirements of the Australian Citizenship Act 2007 (the Act). One of those requirements is that the Applicant sits for and passes the citizenship test. However, if an applicant has “an enduring physical or mental incapacity” which is of such a nature that they cannot undertake the citizenship test, then they may be granted citizenship without so doing.

  3. It is on this basis that the Applicant comes before the Tribunal seeking to have the Minister’s decision set aside.

    THE APPLICANT’S CIRCUMSTANCES

  4. The Applicant was born in Kirkuk, Iraq in 1973 and in 1993 she left Iraq and settled in Germany where she remained for 14 years. Although the evidence is not entirely clear it then appears that she was resident in Turkey for some little time before she arrived in Australia on 23 January 2008 on a German passport. Her native tongue is Turkish.

  5. She is currently the holder of a subclass BO- 116 (Carer) permanent visa. In this capacity she provides care for her aged father and, at an earlier stage of her life in Australia, also provided some care for her mother. The father lives in his own home and the Applicant provides care for him there. At present her mother is cared for by other members of her family in Australia. She has three siblings in Australia all of whom are citizens.

  6. The Applicant has experienced an unhappy marriage resulting in her husband leaving her and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hamid and Minister for Home Affairs (Citizenship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 382
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Hamid for an exemption from the Australian citizenship test, a decision affirmed by the Minister for Home Affairs. The applicant sought to rely on provisions allowing for exemption where an applicant suffers from a permanent or enduring physical or mental incapacity. The Tribunal was required to determine whether the medical evidence provided by the applicant's psychiatrist, Dr. Mukesh Kumar, established that the applicant suffered from such an incapacity.

The central legal issue was whether the applicant's diagnosed conditions, specifically an adjustment disorder with depressed mood and a history suggestive of post-natal depression, constituted a "permanent or enduring" incapacity as contemplated by the relevant legislation. The Minister challenged the relevance and application of Dr. Kumar's findings, arguing that some were based on the applicant's self-reporting and that the conditions appeared to be susceptible to treatment and improvement.

The Tribunal considered Dr. Kumar's reports and the Minister's contentions. While acknowledging Dr. Kumar's expertise and his "opinion" of adjustment disorder, the Tribunal found that the evidence did not establish a direct link between the applicant's symptoms and an inability to learn English or understand the nature of Australian citizenship. Furthermore, the Tribunal agreed with the Minister that the recommended changes in treatment and medication suggested that the applicant's condition was not "enduring" but rather susceptible to improvement, thereby falling outside the scope of the exemption provisions. The Tribunal concluded that significant doubts existed as to whether the applicant's condition was enduring and, if so, whether it directly caused an inability to sit the citizenship test, even with available assistance.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Instrument to which reference has already been made provides that a score of 75% is required and this minimum threshold cannot be varied.[9] This arrangement has been in place since the Instrument was made in March 2012.[9] Determination for the Approval of Citizenship Test (Section 23A) IMMI 11/088 at [10], [26], [43)(iii)].THE MEDICAL EVIDENCE In order to take advantage of the provisions of s 21(3)(d) of the Act, an applicant needs to provide the sort of evidence, from the designated sources, as is outlined above in the extract from the Citizenship Policy. The Applicant has provided a series of letters from Dr Mukesh Kumar[10] who is a specialist and a Fellow of the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists. He is thus well qualified to provide a diagnosis on relation to the Applicant, as is conceded by the Minister.[11][10] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [41]-[46]. Reports are dated 15 January 2016; 26 February 2016; 6 May 2016 and 22 July 2016.[11] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [18]. Dr Kumar makes a number of findings in relation to the Applicant but, in each instance, the Minister challenges their relevance or application to this particular claim for exemption from the citizenship test. Specifically:1.Dr Kumar reported that the Applicant says that she has been suffering from depressive symptoms for some 12 or 13 years.[12] In her own evidence to the Tribunal, the Applicant relates this condition back to her time of living in Germany. The Minister contends that this should be taken only as self-reporting by the Applicant and that Dr Kumar has made no formal finding or diagnosis of such a condition.[13] The Tribunal notes however, that Dr Kumar states “Opinion: Adjustment Disorder with depressed mood.” The Tribunal fails to see the difference between a “finding” and an “opinion”, especially as Dr Kumar’s report goes on to suggest following steps to be taken and medications to be prescribed as a result of his “opinion”.2.Dr Kumar states that, “there is a history suggestive of post-natal depression with the birth of (the applicant’s) second child.”[14] In this instance the Minister argues that there is no time framework related to this finding, nor to the persistence or otherwise of that condition up until, at least, the time of the citizenship application being lodged. The information about the treatment and management of this condition is also not complete in terms of its commencement, change, discontinuation or outcome.[15] In this respect the Tribunal agrees with the challenge mounted by the Minister.3.In a final letter, Dr Kumar recommends a change in treatment (which the Tribunal suggests is further evidence that he made a “finding” in relation to the condition being treated) and a new course of medication.[16] It is to be presumed that this was intended to bring about a more favourable outcome for the Applicant and in this respect the Tribunal again agrees with the Minister that this is suggestive of a condition which is susceptible to treatment and where there is some prospect of the condition improving. In other words the condition is not regarded as being “enduring”. Conditions which are temporary are excluded from consideration under this section of the Act as is made clear in the Citizenship Policy.[12] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [41]. Report dated 15 January 2016.[13] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [20].[14] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [41]. Report dated 15 January 2016.[15] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [20].[16] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [46]. Report dated 22 July 2016.CONSIDERATIONS

Decision

Reasons for decision

There thus exist significant doubts as to whether the Applicant’s condition, subject to remedial medication, is in essence an “enduring” condition, and to that extent that it may be, whether or not it is directly causative of any inability on the part of the Applicant to sit the citizenship test with the assistance which is available to applicants in circumstances such as hers.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Kumar makes a number of findings in relation to the Applicant but, in each instance, the Minister challenges their relevance or application to this particular claim for exemption from the citizenship test. Specifically:1.Dr Kumar reported that the Applicant says that she has been suffering from depressive symptoms for some 12 or 13 years.[12] In her own evidence to the Tribunal, the Applicant relates this condition back to her time of living in Germany. The Minister contends that this should be taken only as self-reporting by the Applicant and that Dr Kumar has made no formal finding or diagnosis of such a condition.[13] The Tribunal notes however, that Dr Kumar states “Opinion: Adjustment Disorder with depressed mood.” The Tribunal fails to see the difference between a “finding” and an “opinion”, especially as Dr Kumar’s report goes on to suggest following steps to be taken and medications to be prescribed as a result of his “opinion”.2.Dr Kumar states that, “there is a history suggestive of post-natal depression with the birth of (the applicant’s) second child.”[14] In this instance the Minister argues that there is no time framework related to this finding, nor to the persistence or otherwise of that condition up until, at least, the time of the citizenship application being lodged. The information about the treatment and management of this condition is also not complete in terms of its commencement, change, discontinuation or outcome.[15] In this respect the Tribunal agrees with the challenge mounted by the Minister.3.In a final letter, Dr Kumar recommends a change in treatment (which the Tribunal suggests is further evidence that he made a “finding” in relation to the condition being treated) and a new course of medication.[16] It is to be presumed that this was intended to bring about a more favourable outcome for the Applicant and in this respect the Tribunal again agrees with the Minister that this is suggestive of a condition which is susceptible to treatment and where there is some prospect of the condition improving. In other words the condition is not regarded as being “enduring”. Conditions which are temporary are excluded from consideration under this section of the Act as is made clear in the Citizenship Policy.[12] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [41]. Report dated 15 January 2016.[13] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [20].[14] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [41]. Report dated 15 January 2016.[15] Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [20].[16] Section 37 Tribunal Documents at [46]. Report dated 22 July 2016.CONSIDERATIONS Careful reading of all of Dr Kumar’s reports however, fails to disclose a direct connection between any of the symptoms or manifestations of impairment suffered by the Applicant which would preclude her from either learning English or coming to an understanding of the nature of her citizenship application[17] and the responsibilities and privileges of Australian citizenship.[18][17] Farhan v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 36 at [11].[18] Rahman v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2010] AATA 930 at [15].