Walsh v Greater Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Walsh v Greater Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (No 2) [2014] FCA 456

Citation: Walsh v Greater Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (No 2) [2014] FCA 456
Parties: MELINDA WALSH v THE GREATER METROPOLITAN CEMETERIES TRUST
File number: VID 674 of 2013
Judge: BROMBERG J
Date of judgment: 9 May 2014
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – whether adverse action taken against employee in contravention of s 340 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) because employee exercised a workplace right to make a complaint in relation to her employment – meaning of complaint “in relation to employment” in s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the FW Act discussed – whether making of complaint was an operative factor in decision to dismiss the employee – dismissal for performance related reasons – making of complaint not a reason for dismissal – statutory presumption in s 361 of the FW Act displaced – application dismissed.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application to
re-open for the purpose of tendering new evidence – interests of justice as the guiding principle in determining whether to grant leave to re-open – whether the new evidence would be significant if admitted – application dismissed.  
Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 340(1), 340(1)(a), 340(1)(a)(ii), 340(1)(a)(iii), 341(1), 341(c)(ii), 342, 360, 361
Cases cited: Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v McCorkell Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 446
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Pilbara Iron Company (Services) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 697
Shea v TRUenergy Services Pty Ltd (No 6) [2014] FCA 271
Rowland v Alfred Health [2014] FCA 2
Urban Transport Authority of New South Wales v Nweiser (1992) 28 NSWLR 471
Date of hearing: 8 and 9 April 2014
Place: Melbourne
Division: FAIR WORK DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 57
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms R Sion
Solicitor for the Applicant: Spicer Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr T Donaghey
Solicitor for the Respondent: Meerkin & Apel

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

VID 674 of 2013

BETWEEN:

MELINDA WALSH
Applicant

AND:

THE GREATER METROPOLITAN CEMETERIES TRUST
Respondent

JUDGE:

BROMBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

9 MAY 2014

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s application be dismissed.

2.There be no order as to costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

FAIR WORK DIVISION

VID 674 of 2013

BETWEEN:

MELINDA WALSH
Applicant

AND:

THE GREATER METROPOLITAN CEMETERIES TRUST
Respondent

JUDGE:

BROMBERG J

DATE:

9 MAY 2014

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. An employee who is able to make a complaint in relation to his or her employment is not to be victimised simply for making the complaint. Broadly speaking, that is the nature of the protection conferred by s 340(1)(a)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (the FW Act) in relation to the “workplace right” to make a complaint identified by s 341(1)(c)(ii).

  2. Section 340(1)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Walsh v Greater Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 456
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns an unfair dismissal claim brought by Ms Walsh against Greater Metropolitan Cemeteries Trust (GMCT). Ms Walsh, who was employed as a Client Services Manager, alleged that she was dismissed for making certain complaints to GMCT. GMCT, on the other hand, claimed that Ms Walsh was dismissed for performance-related reasons. The case was heard by the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, which had to determine whether the complaints made by Ms Walsh were a substantial and operative reason for her dismissal.

The legal issue before the court was whether the complaints made by Ms Walsh were a substantial and operative reason for her dismissal, or if GMCT had successfully rebutted the presumption under section 361 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (FW Act). The court needed to examine the evidence presented by both parties and decide whether GMCT had proven that the complaints were not a substantial and operative factor in the dismissal of Ms Walsh.

The court found that the complaints made by Ms Walsh were not a substantial and operative reason for her dismissal. It was established that Ms Walsh was dismissed for performance-related reasons, and GMCT had successfully rebutted the presumption under section 361 of the FW Act. The court concluded that the complaints made by Ms Walsh did not play a significant role in the decision to terminate her employment. Consequently, the court dismissed Ms Walsh's unfair dismissal claim.

In light of the court's decision, it was ordered that Ms Walsh's application for unfair dismissal be dismissed, and GMCT was not required to reinstate her or pay any compensation. The court found that the dismissal was justified based on performance-related reasons, and the complaints made by Ms Walsh did not constitute an unfair reason for her termination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

For the reasons that follow, I am satisfied that Ms Walsh was dismissed for performance related reasons and that the complaints made by her were not an operative reason for her dismissal. It follows that Ms Walsh’s application should be dismissed.BACKGROUND FACTS GMCT has been in operation since 2010. It is an amalgamation of eight former cemeteries trusts. It has responsibility for some 21 cemetery sites across Melbourne, of which 19 are operating cemeteries. It turns over approximately $50 million a year and undertakes burials, cremations and other memorial services for approximately 12,000 families per year. Ms Walsh commenced her employment with GMCT on 24 September 2012. Her contract of employment specified her position as Manager-Client Services East although, as it turned out, she did not take up that position. Instead, she took up a role as a Client Services Manager and worked across various GMCT locations beyond those to the east of Melbourne. Ms Walsh’s contract of employment (contract of employment) specified her period of employment as commencing on 24 September 2012 and ending on 23 September 2015 unless sooner terminated. The contract of employment specified that the employment offered was subject to a probationary period of 6 months during which period Ms Walsh’s performance would be assessed. The contract of employment provided that prior to or at the conclusion of the probationary period, GMCT would either confirm in writing the maximum term of the appointment or terminate Ms Walsh’s probationary employment. Other provisions in the contract provided for termination by GMCT on two months’ notice in writing and for summary dismissal for serious misconduct. Jacqui Briggs-Weatherill is, and at the time of Ms Walsh’s employment was, the Chief Executive Officer of GMCT. The decision to dismiss Ms Walsh from her employment was made by Ms Briggs-Weatherill. Linda Dewar is currently the Director of Service Improvement and Corporate Development at GMCT. Ms Dewar was involved in recruiting and appointing Ms Walsh. During Ms Walsh’s employment, Ms Walsh reported to Ms Dewar who, at that time, held the position of Director of Client Services. Ms Dewar was involved in the decision ultimately made by Ms Briggs-Weatherill. She recommended to Ms Briggs-Weatherill that Ms Walsh be dismissed. Ms Sharon Dore is the HR Business Partner at GMCT. At the time of the dismissal of Ms Walsh she held the position of Acting Human Resources Manager. Ms Dore was consulted by Ms Briggs-Weatherill as to whether Ms Walsh’s employment should be terminated and agreed that it should be. Ms Jasmine Butler was the Executive Assistant to Ms Dewar and also held an operational role during some of the period of Ms Walsh’s employment with GMCT. Ms Butler came into conflict with Ms Walsh and a number of the complaints made by Ms Walsh included allegations about Ms Butler’s conduct.CONSIDERATION The findings that the Court should make about the timing, nature and content of complaints made by Ms Walsh to GMCT were largely not in contest. Ms Walsh’s evidence of the complaints made by her was not detailed. She tended to characterise the subject matter dealt with rather than provide the detail of what she actually said in making the complaint. Some of the evidence called by GMCT suffered from the same problem. To the extent that the evidence about the making of complaints given by Ms Walsh differed from that of Ms Dewar and Ms Briggs-Weatherill, I need not resolve any inconsistency. It is sufficient that the complaints made be characterised in general terms as nothing turns on the detail of those complaints.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

On 16 April 2014, some seven days after I reserved my judgment, the applicant applied to re-open her case for the sole purpose of tendering a photograph taken from her mobile phone of an email notification to her of a proposed meeting in Ms Dewar’s office at 4 pm on 12 March 2013 (the new evidence). That application was opposed. After considering the affidavit material relied upon by Ms Walsh and the written submissions of the parties, on 6 May 2014, I determined to reject the application for the reasons that follow. In rejecting the application, I accepted the evidence of Ms Walsh that her failure to produce and tender the new evidence was due to an explicable failure to locate the evidence prior to trial. I was therefore prepared to accept the submission that the failure to tender the new evidence at trial was inadvertent. I was also prepared to accept the submission made for Ms Walsh that the application to re-open was of limited scope and that the failure of GMCT to have discovered a copy of the email notification may well have been a contributory factor. I did not accept Ms Walsh’s submission that there would be no prejudice to GMCT. A re-opening would have likely led to further significant costs being incurred by GMCT in circumstances where those costs may not be recoverable. However, even if I had accepted that GMCT would suffer no prejudice, I would have nevertheless rejected Ms Walsh’s application. The principle that should guide the Court in determining whether to grant an application for leave to re-open is whether the interests of justice are better served by allowing or rejecting the application: Urban Transport Authority of New South Wales v Nweiser (1992) 28 NSWLR 471 (Clarke JA at 478, with whom Mahoney JA and Meagher JA agreed). In that regard, and as Ms Walsh’s submissions recognise, the significance of the new evidence is a crucial factor. Ms Walsh submitted that there were three reasons why the new evidence was significant. In my view, each of the asserted reasons is misplaced. To explain why that is so, it is necessary to briefly explain the content of the new evidence and the issue to which it would be relevant if it were tendered. Ms Walsh’s evidence was that on the morning of 12 March 2013, she was really concerned with the situation in the office and that accordingly, she went straight to HR and asked for a meeting for later that day. She said that she asked Ms Dewar to organise a meeting and that Ms Dewar scheduled the meeting in “the Outlook diary” for 4 pm that day. The meeting was to be held with Ms Dewar, Ms Dore and herself. Although Ms Walsh stated that the reason she wanted the meeting was to discuss her complaints, she did not give evidence that the reason was communicated to Ms Dore. Ms Dore denied that Ms Walsh had requested a meeting with her in the morning of 12 March 2013. When told that Ms Walsh would give evidence to that effect, she said that the meeting request had been made on 8 March 2013 through another HR officer. She said that she did not know what that meeting was to be about. She was available to conduct it at 3.30 pm on 8 March 2013 but Ms Walsh was unavailable. The meeting needed to be rescheduled but Ms Dore stated that she did not get to reschedule it. When it was put to Ms Dore that Ms Walsh’s evidence would be that she confirmed the meeting time for 12 March 2013 by her Outlook calendar, Ms Dore said that she did not have any meeting time in her Outlook calendar.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Jasmine Butler was the Executive Assistant to Ms Dewar and also held an operational role during some of the period of Ms Walsh’s employment with GMCT. Ms Butler came into conflict with Ms Walsh and a number of the complaints made by Ms Walsh included allegations about Ms Butler’s conduct.CONSIDERATION The findings that the Court should make about the timing, nature and content of complaints made by Ms Walsh to GMCT were largely not in contest. Ms Walsh’s evidence of the complaints made by her was not detailed. She tended to characterise the subject matter dealt with rather than provide the detail of what she actually said in making the complaint. Some of the evidence called by GMCT suffered from the same problem. To the extent that the evidence about the making of complaints given by Ms Walsh differed from that of Ms Dewar and Ms Briggs-Weatherill, I need not resolve any inconsistency. It is sufficient that the complaints made be characterised in general terms as nothing turns on the detail of those complaints. The complaints made by Ms Walsh were made on two occasions. First, in a meeting between Ms Dewar and Ms Walsh held on 7 March 2013 and secondly in a meeting between Ms Walsh, Ms Briggs-Weatherill, Ms Dewar and Ms Dore held at about 1 pm on 12 March 2013. The matters raised by Ms Walsh by way of a complaint in each of those meetings may be characterised as follows:(i)at a Greek Orthodox memorial function held in late February 2013, a lack of GMCT staff raised workplace safety concerns and, as a result of self-catering by the attendees, unauthorised and unlawful service and consumption of alcohol and food occurred (the memorial function complaint);(ii)Alsco, a linen supplier to GMCT, was providing sub-quality service (the Alsco poor servicing complaint);(iii)Ms Butler’s daughter worked for Alsco and, as a matter of probity, it was inappropriate for Ms Butler to be dealing with her daughter in relation to the Alsco contract (the Alsco contract complaint); and (iv)Ms Butler’s attitude and behaviour towards Ms Walsh was inappropriate including because Ms Butler was undermining Ms Walsh in discussions with other staff (the complaint about Ms Butler);(collectively the complaints). Ms Walsh’s pleaded case alleged that the making by her of one or more of the complaints was a reason for her dismissal. That allegation having been raised, s 361 of the FW Act (in the context of the facts of this case) operates to create a presumption that Ms Walsh was dismissed including because of the making by her of one or more of the complaints. The onus is then cast on GMCT to prove otherwise. To displace the presumption, GMCT needed to establish that the making by Ms Walsh of one or more of the complaints was not a substantial and operative factor for dismissing her. The relevant authorities as to the operation of ss 360 and 361 of the FW Act are well known and need not here be recounted. They are discussed in Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v McCorkell Constructions Pty Ltd (No 2) [2013] FCA 446 at [154]-[158] (Bromberg J).