Voxson Pty Limited v Telstra Corporation Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Voxson Pty Limited v Telstra Corporation Limited [2015] FCA 1490

Citation: Voxson Pty Limited v Telstra Corporation Limited
[2015] FCA 1490
Parties: VOXSON PTY LIMITED (ACN 005 291 458)
v TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556), SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LIMITED (ACN 052 833 208), OPTUS MOBILE PTY LIMITED (ACN 054 365 696), SINGAPORE TELECOMMUNICATIONS LIMITED (ARBN 096 701 567) and VODAFONE HUTCHINSON AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 096 304 620)
File number(s): NSD 2436 of 2013
Judge(s): BENNETT J
Date of judgment: 23 December 2015
Catchwords: PATENTS – applications to strike out amended statement of claim – process of iterative proposed amendments – claims of infringement of a “system” being a product or method – whether strike out or leave to amend
Legislation: Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 117, 117(1), 117(2)(b) and (c)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M and 37N
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.21 and 16.45
Cases cited: Caason Investments Pty Ltd v Cao [2015] FCAFC 94
Nokia Corporation v Liu (2009) 179 FCR 422
SNF (Australia) Pty Ltd v Ciba Speciality Chemicals Water Treatments Ltd (No 4) [2013] FCA 845
White v Overland [2001] FCA 1835
Date of hearing: 4 – 5, 10, 25 February 2015, 19, 25 August 2015,
29 – 30 September 2015
Date of last submissions: 30 September 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 108
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms KJ Howard SC with Mr JS Cooke and Mr DB Larish
Solicitor for the Applicant: DibbsBarker
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr NR Murray
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Davies Collison Cave Law
Counsel for the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents: Mr RC Macaw QC and Mr S Burley SC with Mr AR Lang
Solicitor for the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents: Baker & McKenzie
Solicitor for the Fifth Respondent: Mr PJ Kerr of Allens

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 2436 of 2013

BETWEEN:

VOXSON PTY LIMITED (ACN 005 291 458)
Applicant

AND:

TELSTRA CORPORATION LIMITED (ACN 051 775 556)
First Respondent

SINGTEL OPTUS PTY LIMITED (ACN 052 833 208)
Second Respondent

OPTUS MOBILE PTY LIMITED (ACN 054 365 696)
Third Respondent

SINGAPORE TELECOMMUNICATIONS LIMITED
(ARBN 096 701 567)
Fourth Respondent

VODAFONE HUTCHINSON AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 096 304 620)
Fifth Respondent

JUDGE:

BENNETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

23 December 2015

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Leave be granted to the applicant to file an amended Vox 1 Statement of Claim in the form provided to the Court and the respondents on 3 September 2015, together with the Vox 1 Amended Originating Application, by 18 January 2015.

2.The parties confer to discuss the further conduct of the proceeding and notify my associate of the proposed orders by 27 January 2015.

Note:    Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Voxson Pty Limited v Telstra Corporation Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1490
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Voxson Pty Limited filed a claim against Telstra Corporation Limited in relation to patent infringement. Voxson alleged that Telstra infringed its patent by using a system for location determination that was protected by a patent. Telstra sought to strike out Voxson's amended statement of claim on the basis that it was not sufficient in law and should be struck out. The central issue before the court was whether leave should be granted to Voxson to amend its statement of claim, and if so, whether the amendments were minor or substantial. The court considered whether the amendments were reasonable given the iterative process of amendments that had occurred up to that point and the respondents' conduct.

The court found that the amendments were substantial but necessary to accurately plead the case. The court noted that the iterative process of amendments had been driven by the respondents' need for clarity and particulars. While the respondents had argued that the amendments were minor, the court found that the proposed amended pleading had significantly changed the case being made. The court was satisfied that the amendments were not an abuse of process and that the respondents had not been prejudiced by the amendments. The court also found that the respondents' conduct had been unreasonable, as they had not raised certain issues until late in the proceedings. The court concluded that leave should be granted to Voxson to amend its statement of claim, and that appropriate costs orders could be made without a successful strike out application.

The court ordered that leave be granted to Voxson to file an amended statement of claim by a specified date. The court also ordered that the parties confer to discuss the further conduct of the proceeding and notify the court of the proposed orders. The court's decision highlights the importance of allowing parties to amend their pleadings where necessary to accurately plead their case, particularly where the respondents' conduct has driven the need for amendments. The court also emphasised that appropriate costs orders can be made without a successful strike out application.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave be granted to the applicant to file an amended Vox 1 Statement of Claim in the form provided to the Court and the respondents on 3 September 2015, together with the Vox 1 Amended Originating Application, by 18 January 2015.

2. The parties confer to discuss the further conduct of the proceeding and notify my associate of the proposed orders by 27 January 2015.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Voxson Pty Limited, the applicant, has filed a number of amended statements of claim against Telstra Corporation Limited, Optus, and Vodafone, the respondents. The central issue revolves around whether Voxson's claims of infringement of a "system" being a product or method should be struck out or if leave to amend should be granted. Voxson has engaged in an iterative process of amending its pleadings in response to specific issues raised by the respondents. The respondents argue that certain aspects of the amended pleadings, particularly the concept of "dumb pipes," were not adequately addressed in the original pleadings. The "dumb pipes" scenario refers to the use of Telstra's 2G GERAN network and external location services, which was not explicitly acknowledged by Voxson initially. Voxson maintains that the concept was implicitly present in its initial pleadings, although it was not fully understood at the time.

The case involves applications by the respondents to strike out amended statements of claim filed by Voxson. The matter came before the court on the basis of these applications. Prior to this, Voxson had filed several amended statements of claim in response to the respondents' contentions. The court has considered the material submitted by both parties, including standards and claim charts provided by Voxson well before the commencement of the proceedings. The court's decision focused on whether the pleadings could be amended to address the respondents' concerns or if they should be struck out entirely.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In essence, Voxson says:·Optus only raised the “dumb pipes” issue on the second day of the hearing, on 5 February 2015. Any reference in earlier documentation was no more than a “footprint” that did not reveal the true issue.·Vodafone indicated on 4 February 2015 that it was in the same position as Telstra before adopting the dumb pipes position on 5 February 2015 and providing a letter identifying a third party provider on 23 February 2015 and an unsigned affidavit in August 2015, with the signed affidavit on 16 September 2015.·Telstra did not raise the dumb pipes position on its 4G network until 5 February 2015. Although it did not provide an affidavit from an appropriately qualified person, Voxson accepted the position and served the proposed March pleading.·The respondents’ conduct was unreasonable in light of material forwarded by Voxson, including standards and claim charts well prior to the commencement of proceedings.CONCLUSION If the pleading can be cured by amendment, amendment ought to be permitted. Voxson has at all times attempted to respond to points raised by the respondents in the answering of questions and the provision of particulars. In this case there has been an “iterative process” of serial amendments to rectify specific matters raised by the respondents. This has resulted in the proposed amended pleading which has, as already observed, changed significantly the case being made. It cannot be said that the amendments to the pleading are minor. Parts of the pleading have now been abandoned, further information included and amendments proposed. The respondents may complain of certain parts of the proposed amended pleading, or the absence or inadequacy of particulars but they do not say that they cannot plead to them, with the possible exception of the alleged exploitation of the claimed system characterised in the alternative as a product or a process. Voxson argues that the only reason that the respondents want to succeed in the strike out applications is to get costs, and that this should not justify the making of such orders. Appropriate costs orders can be made without a successful strike out application. Voxson points out that, as it is an early stage of the proceedings and no respondent has filed a defence or, it says, prepared evidence, there can be no prejudice if Voxson is granted leave to amend the pleading. Voxson maintains that the case made out in the proposed amended pleading was encompassed in the pleading. The pleading originally provided for three alternatives, including an external location server, which was not linked to the assertion that that server was operated by or on behalf of Optus. Voxson says that that was a “dumb pipes” pleading, even if not appreciated or known by Voxson. Voxson says that the concept of “dumb pipes” was encompassed by the pleading and points to a number of paragraphs which, when read together can, Voxson submits, be said to plead the use of the Optus network and a third party operated external location server. Voxson does not suggest that this was intentional, as it did not know the factual situation at the time but says that it was present in the pleading, although the SUPL location platform server was ‘confusingly defined as an Optus SLP’. However, Voxson says that it was clear that it was the Optus 2G GERAN and/or external location services. Voxson does not suggest that Optus appreciated that the pleading raised the “dumb pipes” scenario.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the appropriateness of the iterative process of amendments that Voxson undertook in response to specific issues raised by the respondents. The court noted that while the respondents objected to the amendments, they did not argue that they could not plead to them, except possibly in relation to the characterisation of the claimed system. The court concluded that the amendments were significant and necessary to accurately reflect the case being made, and that it was still early in the proceedings with no prejudice to the respondents. Consequently, the court granted Voxson leave to amend its pleading, setting a deadline for the filing of the amended statement of claim.

In addressing the issue of whether the claims of infringement should be struck out, the court examined the nature of the claims and the respondents' arguments that they were unclear and should be struck out. The court found that the claims, while not perfectly drafted, were not so unclear that they could not be understood and defended against. The court emphasised the importance of allowing parties the opportunity to amend their pleadings to ensure clarity and fairness in the proceedings, and thus granted leave for Voxson to amend its pleading.

Finally, the court assessed the reasonableness of the respondents' conduct in raising the "dumb pipes" issue late in the proceedings. The court acknowledged that the respondents had acted unreasonably by not raising the issue earlier, but found that this did not justify striking out the claims. The court reasoned that the issue could be addressed through appropriate costs orders, and that the primary concern should be ensuring the proceedings are conducted fairly and efficiently.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while parties should strive to raise significant issues early in the proceedings, the court will permit iterative amendments to pleadings to ensure clarity and fairness, and will not strike out claims merely because they were raised late if the lateness does not prejudice the opposing party. The court also emphasised the importance of allowing parties the opportunity to amend their pleadings where necessary, even at an early stage of the proceedings.