University of Sydney v ObjectiVision Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

University of Sydney v ObjectiVision Pty Limited [2016] FCA 1199

File number: NSD 385 of 2014
Judge: BURLEY J
Date of judgment: 10 October 2016
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for leave to file further amended notice of cross-claim – application to lift stay of proceedings against second cross-respondent – whether leave should be granted in accordance with the purpose in section 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether proposed amendments would be struck out – whether proposed misleading and deceptive conduct pleadings largely duplicate contractual promises – whether proposed pleadings impose a condition of mind on a company – whether adequate explanation was provided for delay in providing security for costs – whether conditions should be imposed on the lift of stay

COSTS – application for security for costs – costs of, occasioned by and incidental to applications – whether party seeking an indulgence should pay the costs of doing so

Legislation:

Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2 s 18

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 37M, 37N, 37P, 56

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 1.32 – 1.35, 8.21, 16.41, 16.43, 16.51. 16.53, 19.01

Cases cited:

Aon Risk Services Australia Limited v Australian National University (2009) 239 CLR 175

Australian Competition & Consumer Commission v Jutsen (No 2) [2010] FCA 982

Bowen Energy Limited v 2KD Drilling Pty Ltd [2012] FCA 275

Campbell v Backoffice Investments Pty Ltd (2009) 238 CLR 304

Carey v Freehills [2014] FCA 788

Cement Australia Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2010) 187 FCR 261

Coles Supermarkets Australia Pty Ltd v FKP Limited & Anor [2008] FCA 1915

Concrete Construction Group v Litevale Pty Limited [2002] NSWSC 670; (2002) 170 FLR 290

Dye v Commonwealth Securities Limited (No 2) [2010] FCAFC 118; (2010) 63 AILR 101

Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management and Marketing Pty Limited (2013) 250 CLR 303

GAIN Capital UK Limited v Citigroup Inc (No 3) [2016] FCA 582

Golski v Kirk (1987) 14 FCR 143

Lane Cove Council v Michael Davies & Associates and Others [2012] NSWSC 727

Lee v Westpac Banking Corporation [2015] FCA 467

Luck v Chief Executive Officer of Centrelink [2015] FCAFC 75

McGrath; in the matter of Pan Pharmaceuticals Ltd (in liq) v Australian Naturalcare Products Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 2; 165 FCR 230

O’Neil v T D Williamson Aust Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 398

Raphael Shin Enterprises Pty Limited v Waterpoint Shepherds Bay Pty Limited [2014] NSWSC 743

Research in Motion Ltd v Samsung Electronics Australia Pty Limited (2009) 176 FCR 66

Suzlon Energy Ltd v Bangad (2011) 196 FCR 259

Tamaya Resources Limited (in liq) v Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu (A Firm) [2016] FCAFC 2; 332 ALR 199

Truth about Motorways Pty Limited v Macquarie Infrastructure Investment Management Limited [2001] FCA 1603

University of Sydney v Objectivision Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1528

University of Sydney v ResMed Limited (No 5)

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read University of Sydney v ObjectiVision Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The University of Sydney and ObjectiVision Pty Ltd are parties to a legal dispute concerning patent, copyright, and confidential information claims. The case has proceeded to the Federal Court of Australia, where ObjectiVision has sought leave to file further amended notices of cross-claim and to lift the stay of proceedings against Visionsearch. The University has opposed the application, arguing that the proposed amendments are duplicative and would add unnecessary complexity to the proceedings. The court was required to determine whether leave should be granted in accordance with the purpose outlined in section 37M of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and whether the proposed amendments would be struck out. Additionally, the court had to consider whether adequate explanation was provided for the delay in providing security for costs and whether conditions should be imposed on the lift of stay.

The court found that the proposed amendments to the Fourth Cross-Claim contained significant deficiencies, including the lack of articulation of the basis for pleading a continuing representation by the University to honour its obligations under the identified agreements. The court was also concerned that the introduction of the misleading and deceptive conduct case would significantly add to the cost and complexity of the proceedings, as it would duplicate contractual promises that ObjectiVision could have relied upon. The court found that the additional complexity was not warranted given the apparently insignificant additional benefit that the pleading would provide to ObjectiVision. The court also noted that the proposed amendments to the copyright and misuse of confidential information parts of the third further amended cross-claim might clarify ObjectiVision's existing case, and if ObjectiVision wished to persist in making those amendments, it should serve its proposed amendments pleading expeditiously.

In relation to the lift of stay application, the court found that ObjectiVision had failed to make its first payment of $200,000 as security for the costs of Visionsearch, leading to the stay of proceedings against Visionsearch. The court considered the University's contention that the misleading and deceptive conduct amendments would cause prejudice due to the need to investigate factual matters concerning the negotiation and performance of the Heads of Agreement in January 2010 and the performance of that agreement in 2010. The court found that the proposed amendment to plead misleading and deceptive conduct should not be allowed due to the late filing of the amended pleading, the substantial overlap between the contracts entered into by the parties and the misrepresentation case, and the requirement for additional expert evidence going to the scope of the exclusive licence.

The court dismissed the interlocutory application filed by ObjectiVision on 27 July 2016 (amendment application) and ordered that ObjectiVision pay $200,000 into an interest-bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for ObjectiVision and Visionsearch by way of security for Visionsearch’s costs incurred to date and in respect of costs to be incurred in relation to Visionsearch’s evidence in answer. The court also ordered that the stay of the cross-claim against Visionsearch be lifted upon the making of the payment. Additionally, the court ordered that ObjectiVision pay the University of Sydney’s costs of the amendment application and the lift of the stay application assessed at $90,000, as well as Visionsearch’s costs of the amendment application and the lift of stay application in a lump sum amount to be assessed by the Court or agreed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed by respondent/cross-claimant (ObjectiVision) on 27 July 2016 (amendment application) be dismissed.

2. On or before seven (7) days from the date of these orders, ObjectiVision pay $200,000 into an interest bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for ObjectiVision and the second cross-respondent (Visionsearch) by way of security for Visionsearch’s costs incurred to date and in respect of costs to be incurred in relation to Visionsearch’s evidence in answer.

3. The stay of the cross-claim against Visionsearch be lifted upon the making of the payment in order 2.

4. ObjectiVision pay the University of Sydney’s costs of the amendment application and the lift of the stay application assessed at $90,000.

5. ObjectiVision pay Visionsearch’s costs of the amendment application and the lift of stay application in a lump sum amount to be assessed by the Court or agreed.

6. ObjectiVision pay the amount specified in order 4 into an interest bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for the University of Sydney and the solicitors for ObjectiVision within twenty-one (21) days.

7. In default of compliance with order 6, or with any of the steps set out in order 2(ii) – (iv) of the orders made in these proceedings on 18 December 2015, the proceeding against the University of Sydney in respect of the copyright infringement and breach of confidence cross-claims be stayed.

8. In default of compliance with order 2, or with any of the steps set out in order 3(ii) – (iv) of the orders made in these proceedings on 18 December 2015, the proceeding against Visionsearch in respect of the copyright infringement and breach of confidence cross-claim be stayed.

9. The solicitors acting for Visionsearch provide an affidavit setting out its estimated lump sum costs likely to be recovered on taxation in respect of each of the amendment application and the lift of stay application within seven (7) days.

10. ObjectiVision and Visionsearch endeavour to agree on an estimate of costs recoverable on a taxation of Visionsearch’s costs in the amendment application and the lift of stay application within fourteen (14) days and, failing which, each file and serve a submission of no longer than two (2) pages (and ObjectiVision file such affidavit as it considers appropriate) within seven (7) days thereafter.

11. ObjectiVision has leave to serve any proposed amendments to the copyright and misuse of confidential information parts of the third further amended cross-claim within fourteen (14) days.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

No facts, matters or circumstances are pleaded whereby it is said that a continuing representation was made by the University to honour its obligations under the identified agreements. If such a representation were made, the basis for it is not set out in the pleading; either in the general sense pleaded in the introduction to [31.2] or the particular sense (which are said to be included within the general) in [31.2(1)(a) – (f)]. In my view, the basis for pleading this representation has not been articulated and would be liable to be struck out.Conclusion in relation to the proposed amendments I have identified above a number of significant deficiencies in the proposed amendments to the Fourth Cross-Claim. The various deficiencies that I have identified are sufficient to warrant refusal of the application. Further, I am concerned that the introduction of the misleading and deceptive conduct case would significantly add to the cost and complexity of the proceedings in circumstances where the representations alleged simply duplicate contractual promises that ObjectiVision could have, and to large extent has, relied upon. I find that the additional complexity includes the requirement for the University to undergo significant effort to track down and interview a large number of witnesses whose recollection going back over six years will be called upon. It is also likely, in my view, that aspects of the misrepresentation case will invite questions of patent construction to be introduced into the hearing of the separate question, which would undermine the basis upon which the proceedings have been conducted since 2015, namely that the patent case is separate from other issues in the case. In my view, quite separately from the pleading deficiencies, the additional complexity added to the case by the pleading is not warranted given the apparently insignificant additional benefit that the pleading would provide to ObjectiVision. The position is different for the proposed amendments to the copyright and confidential information pleading. ObjectiVision has foreshadowed amendments to those pleadings that might clarify its existing case. If it wishes to persist in making those amendments, it should serve its proposed amendments pleading expeditiously. For the present, however, in the absence of a draft pleading, the appropriate course is to disallow the currently proposed amendments.THE LIFT OF STAY APPLICATION The lift of stay application was filed eight months after ObjectiVision was required to make its first payment of $200,000 as security for the costs of Visionsearch, for costs incurred to date and in respect of costs to be incurred in relation to Visionsearch’s evidence in answer (security for costs’ order 3(i) in the orders of Rares’ J dated 18 December 2015). Since ObjectiVision failed to makes that payment, the proceedings against Visionsearch have been stayed (order 5 in the orders of Rares’ J dated 18 December 2015) but the proceedings against the University have continued.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The University contends, supported by the affidavits of its solicitor Mr Bouvier, that if the misleading and deceptive conduct amendments are allowed, the University will have to investigate factual matters concerning the negotiation of the Heads of Agreement in January 2010 and the performance of that agreement in 2010. This will involve interviewing at least 11 witnesses, many of whom are no longer University employees. The University points to the prejudice of diminished recollection; Tamaya at [90] and [91]. The University submits that as the pleading raises “freedom to operate” questions within the context of the breadth of the exclusive licence conferred under the Heads of Agreement, additional expert evidence will be required going to the scope of the exclusive licence where the licence provides for that scope by reference to “the invention” as claimed in the Patents. This will involve issues of patent construction and breadth which will call for technical evidence that otherwise would have not arisen in the controversy until after the separate question had been heard.Consideration – the misleading and deceptive conduct amendments In my opinion, the proposed amendment to plead misleading and deceptive conduct should not be allowed. My reasons for forming this view are set out below. I first address matters applicable to the entirety of the proposed pleading and then refer to difficulties that I perceive arise in relation to each of the specific representations pleaded.General problems with the pleading First, the amended pleading has been brought very late in the day. In February of this year, ObjectiVision had sought a hearing date for the cross-claim in August. Evidence has been filed by the parties in relation to the contract claim. Secondly, the manner in which the misrepresentation case is pleaded indicates that there is a very substantial overlap between the contracts entered into by the parties and the misrepresentation case. Indeed, the misrepresentations arise exclusively from the terms of contracts between the parties. The misleading and deceptive conduct case proposed relates to the contract claim. There is authority for the proposition that where representations do no more than mirror contractual terms, it may be that the appropriate consequences stemming from a breach of those terms is damages for breach of contract rather than a claim under the Trade Practices Act or the Australian Consumer Law; Concrete Construction Group v Litevale Pty Limited [2002] NSWSC 670; (2002) 170 FLR 290 (Mason P) at [152], [167] – [169]. The position as pleaded in the present case is identified by Allsop J (as he then was) in McGrath; in the matter of Pan Pharmaceuticals Ltd (in liq) v Australian Naturalcare Products Pty Ltd [2008] FCAFC 2; 165 FCR 230 (McGrath) at [138], where his Honour said (emphasis added):I do not think that the comments of the majority of the High Court in Effem Foods Pty Ltd (t/as Uncle Ben's of Australia) v Lake Cumberline Pty Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 599 at [34] or of Tamberlin J at first instance assist. The representation there asserted, arising from the entry into the contract, was quite different. Nothing said in Futuretronics International Pty Ltd v Gadzhis [1992] 2 VR 217 at 233-241; Wright v TNT Management Australia Pty Ltd (t/as Comet Overnight Transport) (1989) 15 NSWLR 679; Wheeler Grace & Pierucci Pty Ltd v Wright (1989) 16 IPR 189; or Adelaide Petroleum NL v Poseidon Ltd [1988] ATPR 49,695 (40-901) requires any different conclusion. Without setting any artificial constraints on the operation of ss 51A and 52 and the balance of Div 1 of Pt V, it is appropriate to say that the divining of representations from the making of contractual promises and the entry into contracts is a task to be approached with caution and with an eye to all the facts and not by reference to implying representations mechanistically from equivalent promises: see Concrete Constructions Group v Litevale Pty Ltd (2002) 170 FLR 290 at [156]–[168] per Mason P.