University of Sydney v Objectivision Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 33 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

University of Sydney v Objectivision Pty Ltd
[2015] FCA 1528

Citation: University of Sydney v Objectivision Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1528
Parties: THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY ABN 15 211 513 464 v OBJECTIVISION PTY LIMITED ACN 090 253 697; OBJECTIVISION PTY LIMITED ACN 909 253 697; THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY ABN 15 211 513 464 and VISIONSEARCH PTY LTD ACN 150 067 271
File number: NSD 385 of 2014
Judge: RARES J
Date of judgment: 7 December 2015
Catchwords: COSTS – security for costs – applicant/cross-respondent sought security for costs where respondent/cross-claimant was impecunious – respondent/cross-claimant resisted orders on grounds security for costs would stultify litigation and amounts claimed were excessive – security for costs ordered as respondent/cross-claimant was offered a lesser amount without justification and directors were not prepared to pay security from behind the corporate veil
Cases cited: Australian Equity Investors, an Arizona Limited Partnership v Colliers International (NSW) Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 57
Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1
Madgwick v Kelly (2013) 212 FCR 1
ObjectiVision Pty Ltd v Visionsearch (2014) 108 IPR 244
P S Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co (1991) 102 ALR 321
Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (In Liq) v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group (2007) 65 ACSR 383
Port of Melbourne Authority v Anshun Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 589
Top Stuff 4 Business Holdings Pty Ltd v Vodafone Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 645
Willey v Synan (1935) 54 CLR 175
Yandil Holdings Pty Ltd v Insurance Co of North America (1985) 3 ACLC 542
Date of hearing: 7 December 2015
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 55
Counsel for the Applicant/First Cross ‑Respondent: PW Flynn
Solicitor for the Applicant/First Cross‑Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Respondent/Cross‑Claimant: R Lancaster SC
Solicitor for the Respondent/Cross‑Claimant: Marque Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Cross‑Respondent: C Stomo
Solicitor for the Second Cross-Respondent LaneLaw

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 385 of 2014

BETWEEN:

THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY ABN 15 211 513 464
Applicant

OBJECTIVISION PTY LIMITED ACN 909 253 697
Cross-Claimant

AND:

OBJECTIVISION PTY LIMITED ACN 090 253 697
Respondent

THE UNIVERSITY OF SYDNEY ABN 15 211 513 464
First Cross-Respondent

VISIONSEARCH PTY LTD ACN 150 067 271
Second Cross-Respondent

JUDGE:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

18 DECEMBER 2015

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

Security for costs

1.ObjectiVision provide security for the University of Sydney's and the Visionsearch's costs of and incidental to the claim pleaded in paragraphs 60 to 91 of the Third Further Amended Statement of Cross-Claim dated 21 September 2015 (Copyright Infringement and Breach of Confidence Cross-Claims), payable in the tranches set out in orders 2 and 3.

2.ObjectiVision pay the following into an interest-bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for the University of Sydney and the solicitors for ObjectiVision:

(i)$200,000 by way of security for the University…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read University of Sydney v Objectivision Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 1528
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The University of Sydney, along with Visionsearch, sought security for costs against Objectivision Pty Ltd in the Federal Court of Australia. The University and Visionsearch were seeking substantial amounts of security for costs in relation to cross-claims made by Objectivision regarding copyright infringement and breach of confidence. Objectivision, on the other hand, resisted the application for security for costs, arguing that such an order would stymie litigation and that the amounts claimed were excessive.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the University and Visionsearch were entitled to security for costs against Objectivision, given the latter's financial situation. Objectivision argued that the University and Visionsearch would also benefit from its success in the case, and that the amount of work necessary to defend the claims had decreased. The court considered the principle that a party who is a defendant or respondent must bring a cross-claim that is substantively defensive, and that the responding party is not in the same position as a person who brings a cross-claim that is independent.

The court found that Objectivision was required to provide security for costs, as the directors were not prepared to pay security from behind the corporate veil, and the company had been offered a lesser amount without justification. The court ordered that Objectivision provide security for the University of Sydney's and Visionsearch's costs of and incidental to the claim pleaded in paragraphs 60 to 91 of the Third Further Amended Statement of Cross-Claim dated 21 September 2015 (Copyright Infringement and Breach of Confidence Cross-Claims), payable in the tranches set out in orders 2 and 3. The court also ordered that in default of compliance with any of the steps for the provision of security, the proceeding against the University of Sydney in respect of the Copyright Infringement and Breach of Confidence Cross-Claims be stayed until further order.

In conclusion, the court granted the University of Sydney and Visionsearch's application for security for costs against Objectivision, and ordered that Objectivision provide security in the amounts and within the timeframes specified in the orders. The court also ordered that in default of compliance with any of the steps for the provision of security, the proceeding against the University of Sydney and Visionsearch be stayed until further order.

Orders

Orders of the court

Security for costs

1. ObjectiVision provide security for the University of Sydney's and the Visionsearch's costs of and incidental to the claim pleaded in paragraphs 60 to 91 of the Third Further Amended Statement of Cross-Claim dated 21 September 2015 (Copyright Infringement and Breach of Confidence Cross-Claims), payable in the tranches set out in orders 2 and 3.

2. ObjectiVision pay the following into an interest-bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for the University of Sydney and the solicitors for ObjectiVision:

(i) $200,000 by way of security for the University of Sydney's costs incurred to date and in respect of costs to be incurred in relation to the University of Sydney's evidence in answer, prior to 22 January 2016;

(ii) $30,000 by way of security for the University of Sydney's costs to be incurred in respect of the preparation of an expert joint report, within 28 days of the University of Sydney serving its expert evidence in answer;

(iii) $120,000 by way of security for the University of Sydney's costs to be incurred in respect of its preparation for trial, not less than 60 days before the date on which the matter is fixed to commence for hearing; and

(iv) $100,000 by way of security for the University of Sydney's costs to be incurred in respect of the hearing, not less than 7 days before the date on which the matter is fixed to commence for hearing.

3. ObjectiVision pay the following into an interest-bearing account operated jointly by the solicitors for the Visionsearch and the solicitors for ObjectiVision:

(i) $200,000 by way of security for the Visionsearch's costs incurred to date and in respect of costs to be incurred in relation to Visionsearch's evidence in answer, prior to 22 January 2016;

(ii) $30,000 by way of security for Visionsearch's costs to be incurred in respect of the preparation of an expert joint report, within 28 days of Visionsearch serving its expert evidence in answer;

(iii) $120,000 by way of security for Visionsearch's costs to be incurred in respect of its preparation for trial, not less than 60 days before the date on which the matter is fixed to commence for hearing; and

(iv) $100,000 by way of security for Visionsearch's costs to be incurred in respect of the hearing, not less than 7 days before the date on which the matter is fixed to commence for hearing.

4. In default of compliance with any of the steps for the provision of security set out in order 2 above, the proceeding against the University of Sydney in respect of the Copyright Infringement and Breach of Confidence Cross-Claims be stayed until further order.

5. In default of compliance with any of the steps for the provision of security set out in order 3 above, the proceeding against Visionsearch be stayed until further order.

6. The parties have liberty to apply at any time to review the amounts of security awarded in orders 2 and 3.

7. ObjectiVision pay:

(i) the University of Sydney's costs of its interlocutory application for security for costs filed 23 September 2015; and

(ii) Visionsearch's costs of its interlocutory application for security for costs filed 2 October 2015 (and amended with leave on 7 December 2015).

Evidence and critical documents

8. Orders:

(i) 8 to 10 and 14 to 17 of the orders made in this proceeding on 21 September 2015;

(ii) 3 of the orders made in this proceeding on 2 October 2015; and

(iii) 1 of the orders made in this proceeding on 22 October 2015,

be vacated, and in lieu thereof, order as follows:

9. On or before 18 December 2015, the parties file the amended statement of agreed principal issues.

10. On or before 21 December 2015, the University of Sydney serve on the parties:

(i) a list of the documents which:

10.a.i.1 it is aware of at that date; and

10.a.i.2 it understands the case (in relation to the separate question with the exception of the matters pleaded at paragraphs 60 to 91 of the 3FASOC) will turn on, both for and against its interests; and

(ii) copies of the documents identified in accordance with 10(a) above.

11. On or before 21 December 2015, ObjectiVision serve on the parties:

(i) a list of the documents which:

11.a.i.1 it is aware of at that date; and

11.a.i.2 it understands the case (in relation to the separate question) will turn on, both for and against its interests; and

(ii) copies of the documents identified in accordance with 11(a) above.

12. On or before 18 December 2015, ObjectiVision:

(i) serve any written outlines of evidence of lay witnesses; and

(ii) file and serve any independent expert evidence;

in support of its 3FASOC and which is in addition to the evidence already served.

Other

13. The proceeding be listed for directions at 9:30am on 12 February 2016.

14. The parties have liberty to apply on 3 days' notice.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The University sought orders that, in effect, require a total of $360,000 to be paid by way of security for costs already incurred up to 30 January 2016 and then $50,000 after the University serves its expert evidence on the cross-claim with further tranches of $150,000 not later than 60 days before the trial date, and $140,000 not later than seven days before the trial date. Visionsearch, in substance, seeks the provision of about $300,000 by way of security for the costs incurred to date, albeit it is prepared to wait until 30 June 2016 for that to be provided. It also sought that security totalling $869,631 be provided in similar stages.The commercial background Until the global financial crisis loomed in early 2007, the major shareholder of ObjectiVision, MOD Resources Limited, a public listed company, had been providing it with funding. In early 2007 MOD indicated that it was no longer prepared to fund the development of a second version of the means of exploiting the University’s patents. As a result, there was a capital restructuring of ObjectiVision in circumstances which I will explain shortly, under which MOD became a 14% shareholder instead of the majority shareholder. Hamisa Investments Pty Limited maintained a 15% shareholding, and Arthur Cheng, ObjectiVision’s chief executive officer, and his company OV2 Pty Limited acquired a 70 % shareholding. Two other members of ObjectiVision, namely, the University and Prof Alexander Klistorner, had shareholdings of 0.74% and 0.07% respectively. In its audited accounts dated 16 October 2007, ObjectiVision recorded a net loss of about $405,000 for the financial year ended 30 June 2007. In the preceding financial year it had made a loss of about $410,000. Its balance sheet showed accumulated losses as at 30 June 2007 of about $11.7 million, which it had funded substantially by contributed equity of $11.9 million. Its total equity as at 30 June 2007 was recorded as about $173,000 in the audited accounts. The notes to those accounts indicated that they had been prepared on a going concern basis but that the ability of the company to continue as a going concern was dependent upon two factors: first, the remittance of a research and development tax offset from the Australian Taxation Office, and, secondly, the ability of ObjectiVision to raise sufficient additional working capital by way of an equity issue. That unpromising qualification to the accounts matured into worse news. The draft minutes of the directors meeting held on 9 August 2007 recorded Mr Cheng, as chief executive, reporting to the board about ObjectiVision’s financial position. The draft minutes recorded that the board resolved that, until further funding had been secured, the cash flow forecast from August to December 2007 be updated for actual cash flows on a monthly basis and circulated to the board. The draft noted that the company had not been able to present the new AccuMap 2 prototype to the World Glaucoma Congress in Singapore in July 2007 due to its funding constraints, and that the directors were considering approaching a potential investor for funding.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

ObjectiVision argued that the University and Dr Klistorner will also benefit from ObjectiVision’s success in the case that ObjectiVision wishes to make against the University in respect of its allegations of breach of copyright and misuse of confidential information. It also argued that the degree of work necessary to be done in defending the latter claims had been significantly reduced by the provision of Dr Ziedman’s report since the solicitors’ estimates of costs had first been formulated.Consideration The courts have long recognised that there can be circumstances in which a party who is a defendant or respondent must bring a cross-claim that is substantively defensive, and, in that situation, the responding party is not in the same position as a person who brings a cross‑claim that is independent. The principle initially was developed in cases involving foreign defendants who brought cross-claims for which the plaintiff sought security. Thus, in Willey v Synan (1935) 54 CLR 175 at 184, Dixon J, with whom Rich J expressly agreed, said:The principle is that a party to judicial proceedings, who resides beyond the jurisdiction, should not be required to give security for costs unless, however the parties are arranged upon the record, he is the person invoking or resorting to the jurisdiction for the purpose of establishing rights or obtaining relief. If he does avail himself of the remedies the jurisdiction provides in order to obtain affirmative relief or redress, he may be ordered to give security, although he becomes a defendant in the action. (emphasis added) Importantly, Dixon J held that this principle extended to all classes of case, not merely those involving a party who did not reside in the jurisdiction. In Bell Wholesale Co Ltd v Gates Export Corporation (1984) 2 FCR 1 at 4, Sheppard, Morling and Neaves JJ said:In our opinion a court is not justified in declining to order security on the ground that to do so will frustrate the litigation unless a company in the position of the appellant here establishes that those who stand behind it and who will benefit from the litigation if it is successful (whether they be shareholders or creditors or, as in this case, beneficiaries under a trust) are also without means. It is not for the party seeking security to raise the matter; it is an essential part of the case of a company seeking to resist an order for security on the ground that the granting of security will frustrate the litigation to raise the issue of the impecuniosity of those whom the litigation will benefit and to prove the necessary facts. (emphasis added) In Australian Equity Investors, an Arizona Limited Partnership v Colliers International (NSW) Pty Ltd [2012] FCAFC 57 at [30], Jacobson, Besanko and Perram JJ said that this passage was not to be read like a statute so as to ossify the discretion, but that the “principle at play is a simple one: those who stand to share the benefits of the litigation cannot shirk its burdens”. They said that they did not think that, in Bell Wholesale 2 FCR at 4 the Full Court meant to say any more, and that each case depended on its facts. In P S Chellaram & Co Ltd v China Ocean Shipping Co (1991) 102 ALR 321 at 323, McHugh J applied the same principle. And, in Madgwick v Kelly (2013) 212 FCR 1 at 20 [83], Allsop CJ and Middleton J held that it was open to a judge exercising the discretion whether to order security to take into account the unwillingness of people to contribute as a relevant factor, albeit that they were considering the different position of members of a class in a class action, who may or may not have been willing to contribute.