SZJSS v Minister for Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZJSS v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

[2009] FCA 1577

MIGRATION –– protection visa –– jurisdictional error –– applicant for protection visa provided 2 letters, from a former employer and headmaster of his children's school, from home country in support of his claim of persecution by Maoist insurgents –– DFAT investigated the letters, at the request of an earlier tribunal, and found them to be genuine –– tribunal member accepted that letters were bona fide –– tribunal gave the letters "no weight" because applicant had "solicited" them in support of his claim –– giving no weight constituted a failure to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to the objective, credible, third party material corroborating the applicant's claim of the applicant's claim and thus fell into jurisdictional error

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW –– bias –– apparent bias –– applicant for protection visa provided 2 letters, from a former employer and headmaster of his children's school, from home country in support of his claim of persecution by Maoist insurgents –– tribunal member described the applicant's evidence as "back-tracking" and a "baseless tactic" –– the claim and evidence in support was made consistently throughout the application and review process –– characterisation of applicant's claims as "baseless tactic" was made without evidence and conflicted with the objective evidence –– a fair minded lay observer or properly informed law person would regard the tribunal's characterisation of the applicant's claims as apparently biased

Anderson v Director-General of the Department of Environmental and Climate Change (2008) 251 ALR 633 discussed
Lafu v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] FCAFC 140 applied
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Rajamanikkam (2002) 210 CLR 222 applied
NAIS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 228 CLR 470 discussed
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs;  Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 (2003) 198 ALR 59 applied
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Durairajasingham (2000) 168 ALR 407 cited
Re Refugee Review Tribunal; Ex parte H (2001) 179 ALR 425 applied
Secretary of State for Education and Science v Tameside Metropolitan Borough Council [1977] AC 1014 applied
SZIIF v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 102 ALD 366 cited
Telstra Corporation Limited v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2008) 176 FCR 153 applied
Telstra Corporation Ltd v Australian Competition Tribunal (2009) 175 FCR 201 cited

SZJSS and SZLFG v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP and REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

NSD 1085 of 2009

RARES J
24 NOVEMBER 2009
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1085 of 2009

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA
BETWEEN:

SZJSS
First Appellant

SZLFG
Second Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

RARES J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 NOVEMBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal is allowed.

2.The orders of Federal Magistrates Court made on 11 September 2009 be set aside, and in lieu thereof it be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZJSS v Minister for Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1577
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of SZJSS v Minister for Immigration involved a husband and wife who sought refugee status in Australia. They claimed that they had been persecuted in their home country due to their political affiliations and the actions of Maoist insurgents. The primary dispute was whether the tribunal had correctly assessed the credibility of the husband's evidence and the impact of the delay in processing their application on the consistency of his testimony.

The central legal issues revolved around the proper evaluation of the husband's credibility and the effect of the significant delay in processing their claims on the consistency of his evidence. The court needed to determine if the tribunal had erred in its assessment of the husband's testimony and whether the delay and the necessity for him to recount his experiences multiple times to different tribunals had been adequately considered.

The court found that the tribunal had failed to appropriately consider the effects of the delay and the requirement for the husband to repeat his evidence on multiple occasions. It was noted that human memory is not infallible and that it was unreasonable to expect identical recounts of past events over time. The tribunal also incorrectly dismissed the husband's claims without adequately addressing the evidence provided, including three corroborative letters from the schools. The High Court held that these letters provided significant support for the husband's claims of persecution and that the tribunal's approach to the evidence was flawed.

The outcome of the case was that the appeal was allowed, and the decision of the tribunal was quashed. The Minister for Immigration was directed to review the application for refugee status according to law. The court also ordered that the Minister pay the costs of the applicants and the appellants. These orders were to be implemented once the revised reasons for judgment were made available.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The orders of Federal Magistrates Court made on 11 September 2009 be set aside, and in lieu thereof it be ordered that:

2.1 a writ of certiorari in the first instance issue quashing the decision of the second respondent signed on 15 October 2008.

2.2 the second respondent hear and determine the application for review of the decision of the delegate of the first respondent according to law.

2.3 the first respondent pay the applicants' costs.

3. The first respondent pay the appellants' costs.

4. These orders not be taken out until the revised reasons for judgment are made available.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The third tribunal also said that it gave no weight to his claims because it found that the husband had only recently claimed that the local Maoist insurgents had treated pro and anti-Maoist teachers the same. However, the material in the record demonstrated that this was not a recent assertion by the husband at all; it had always been his claim. The husband resented being required to do what all the other teachers were being made to do. And, as the tribunal found, he was entitled to think that was conduct persecutory of him.THE EFFECTS OF DELAY AND THE REQUIREMENT TO REPEAT EVIDENCE I am also of opinion that the third tribunal’s reasons do not recognise expressly the effects of the delay that had been occasioned in the determination of the appellants’ claims through no fault of their own and the consequential need for the husband to repeat his evidence on at least three occasions to the three differently constituted tribunals. This was a factor that Weinberg J noted could have significance in the evaluation of whether the tribunal had made a jurisdictional error in particular circumstances: SZIIF v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2008) 102 ALD 366 at 380 [83]. Here the husband had been required to give his evidence orally to three different tribunals. It would scarcely be surprising for him to have diverged in the expression of his claims or his recollections of some events, including ones such as the provenance of, or circumstances surrounding how, the letters came to be written by the school principals. In such circumstances it is important for decision makers to have regard to the fact that human memory is not the same as a tape recording or a photocopy of a document. It cannot be expected, and indeed, it would be remarkable for witnesses to give their evidence some time apart, in exactly the same terms, or to remember events verbatim. This is so even when witnesses have given their evidence as honestly as possible, with the same degree of care and precision on each occasion. Weinberg J discussed in SZIIF 102 ALD 336 the position of a third tribunal assessing evidence where the appellant had given seven different accounts. He held that the decision-maker had to take particular care to ensure that it did not overlook, in assessing the witness’ overall consistency, the combined effect of delay and the disadvantage to the appellant of having to repeat on several occasions a detailed account of past mistreatment. He was also mindful of the fact that there had been, as the third tribunal in this case also found, persecutory treatment of the appellant. And, as Gleeson CJ observed in NAIS v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 228 CLR 470 at 475 [8] people who claim to fear for their lives admit to having told lies in an attempt to advance their claims for protection, but that did not necessarily destroy their credibility. He observed that that might simply demonstrate their fear. There, his Honour noted that the tribunal had rejected evidence that was not inherently improbably or contradicted by objective facts as “implausible”. The High Court overturned the decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

RARES J
The husband claimed that once they had left their village they could not go back because this would “be big issue for Maoists, as well as royal army”. He and his wife obtained a visa and travelled here ostensibly to visit his sister, who lived in Sydney and had just given birth to twins. They left their children in Kathmandu. He claimed that he and his wife had left for Kathmandu in around November 2005 and stayed there. THE DELEGATE’S DECISION The delegate rejected the husband’s claims on the basis that Kathmandu was not then an area under Maoist control and independent country information did not suggest that in Kathmandu, particularly during the post-ceasefire period, businesses and residents had been forced to donate money to the Maoists. The delegate noted that the appellants had not provided an explanation of why they would be unable to live in Kathmandu free from systematic persecution, and that he had left Nepal three weeks after their visas had been granted.THE THREE CORROBORATIVE LETTERS Prior to the hearing before the first member, the husband provided the tribunal with a number of documents, including newspaper accounts and, critically, three letters. There were two letters from his school and one from his daughters’ school. The first letter from the husband’s school was in English, dated 20 March 2006 and signed by the headmaster. It read as follows: “Subject – about information. Dear sir, [Husband’s name]Having been unsatisfied with the social work and teaching you had been performing in VDC, Turang Majuwa Gulmi. We hereby inform you that, the place you have been hiding can be protective.After your leave acceptance, too, they have been searching through dictators and some times by arm forces. Therefore we would like you not to come out and just stay at where you are. The second letter from his school was dated and written in Nepalese but an accredited translation was provided to the tribunal. The letter, as translated, read: “18 May 2006Subject: Information [husband’s name] [school address]This is to inform you [husband] that your position as a teacher in [the school] is no longer exist as you have not joined the school after taking leave for three months until … 16 February 2006 … due to your safety reason and various threats given to you. You are not required to come back and continue your job as a teacher in this school.” The third letter from the daughter’s boarding school, Polaris Secondary Boarding School, was dated 20 March 2006 and read: “Subject: For not been able to serve your kids.Dear [Husband]We had been teaching your kids for nine years long period. [The three children] who had been studying at this institution for 9, 7 and 6 years accordingly. We are now unable to be accepted as the boarders students for Maoists, the terrorists, have been challenging us time and again not to admit in this institution. Therefore, we hereby request you to manage your children wherever you feel comfortable and safe.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: RARES J

Full text does not contain this section.