SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 600

MIGRATION – judicial review – protection visa – where appellant worked for migration agent as a nanny – where agent told appellant to work rather than go to Tribunal hearing – where appellant did not understand English – whether invitation in English to attend hearing was “real and meaningful” – whether Tribunal failed to undertake a reasonably open and regular administrative procedural step – where appellant subsequently gave false information to the Federal Magistrate – allegation of third party fraud on Tribunal – leave sought to adduce further evidence explaining failure to attend hearing

WORDS AND PHRASES – fraud on the Tribunal

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 27
Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 425, 426A

Arnotts v Trade Practices Commission (1990) 97 ALR 555 cited
CDJ v VAJ (No 1) (1998) 197 CLR 172 followed
Greater Wollongong City Council v Cowan (1955) 93 CLR 435 cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v SZFDE (2006) 236 ALR 42 cited
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZLIX [2008] FCAFC 17 followed
Murdaca v Accounts Control Management Services Pty Ltd [2007] FCA 577 cited
Orr v Holmes (1948) 76 CLR 632 cited
SZFDE v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 237 ALR 64 distinguished
SZFNX v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1980 cited
SZGWH v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 543 cited
SZHBC v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1310 cited
SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FMCA 1200 affirmed
SZHZT v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FCA 1661 cited
SZICU v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCAFC 1 cited
SZIVK v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2008] FCA 334 distinguished
SZJBA v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2007) 164 FCR 14 distinguished

SZHVM v MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP AND REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
NSD 1566 OF 2007

MIDDLETON J
7 MAY 2008
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1566 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

SZHVM
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 MAY 2008

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be dismissed.

2.The appellant pay the costs of the first respondent.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

NSD 1566 OF 2007

ON APPEAL FROM THE FEDERAL MAGISTRATES COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:

SZHVM
Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP
First Respondent

REFUGEE REVIEW TRIBUNAL
Second Respondent

JUDGE:

MIDDLETON J

DATE:

7 MAY 2008

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is an appeal from orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 11 July 2007 in SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FMCA 1200.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 600
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, an Indonesian citizen, appealed against the Federal Magistrates Court's decision in SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship, which affirmed the Minister for Immigration and Citizenship's decision to refuse her application for a protection (class XA) visa. The appellant had claimed that she witnessed electoral fraud during the Indonesian presidential election of 2004, which led to her being threatened with death and subsequently assaulted. She argued that she would suffer serious harm if returned to Indonesia and that the authorities would not protect her. The delegate of the Minister found that the appellant's fears were not well-founded based on the latest US State Report for Indonesia, which indicated that the elections were largely free and fair.

The legal issues in this case centred on whether the Federal Magistrates Court erred in finding that the Refugee Review Tribunal did not commit jurisdictional error in proceeding with the hearing in the appellant's absence. The appellant argued that she was not provided with adequate notice of the Tribunal's intention to proceed without her presence, and she was not given a reasonable opportunity to make submissions in response. The court needed to decide whether the Tribunal's decision to proceed without the appellant was lawful and whether the appellant's rights were adequately protected under the Migration Act 1958.

The court examined the procedural fairness of the Tribunal's decision to proceed in the appellant's absence. It noted that the Tribunal had sent multiple letters to the appellant, including a notice of the hearing and a further notice indicating the Tribunal's intention to proceed without her. The court found that the Tribunal had exercised its discretion appropriately and that the appellant had not demonstrated any jurisdictional error in the Tribunal's decision. The court held that the Tribunal's decision to proceed without the appellant was lawful and that the appellant's rights were adequately protected.

The appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the costs of the first respondent. The court concluded that there was no jurisdictional error on the part of the Tribunal, and the decision affirming the delegate's refusal of the protection visa must stand.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be dismissed.

2. The appellant pay the costs of the first respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from orders made by the Federal Magistrates Court of Australia on 11 July 2007 in SZHVM v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2007] FMCA 1200.BACKGROUND The appellant is a citizen of Indonesia and arrived in Australia on 23 November 2004. On 22 December 2004, the appellant lodged an application for a protection (class XA) visa. The appellant claimed that she had witnessed electoral fraud during the Indonesian presidential election of 2004. She reported what she saw to the Komiti Pemilihan Umum (‘the KPU’), the Indonesian National Elections Commission, in her local area. She claimed that the following day she was threatened with death if she ‘did not keep quiet’. Days after that she was assaulted by young men. She suspected that her report to the KPU had leaked. She hid at a friend’s place but was then told to leave the house because of the fears her friend held as a result of offering a safe haven to the appellant. The appellant departed from Indonesia. She feared that she would suffer serious harm if she returned to Indonesia and that the authorities would not protect her. The appellant’s application for a protection visa indicated that:·The appellant spoke, read and wrote Indonesian and spoke Hokkian but did not otherwise speak, read or write English; ·The appellant required an interpreter in the Indonesian language;·The application was prepared with the assistance of Erwin Marzukie, a registered migration agent, who was the appellant’s migration agent. Mr Marzukie agreed to receive all written communications in respect of that application; and·The appellant’s residential address was nominated as 45/2-8 Brisbane Street, Surry Hills. The application indicated that she had been residing at that address since November 2004. The appellant’s postal address was nominated as Suite 201, Level 2, 78 Liverpool Street, Sydney. This was Mr Marzukie’s postal address as identified in the application itself. On 26 May 2005 a delegate of the Minister refused to grant the appellant a protection visa. The delegate found that the appellant’s fears were not well-founded because the latest US State Report for Indonesia indicated that, notwithstanding the Indonesian government’s poor human rights record, observers monitoring the elections considered the elections were largely free and fair. Accordingly, the delegate found:While it is not impossible that there may have been some irregularities, based on the independent country information it cannot be found that the applicant’s claim would result in a real chance of Convention based persecution should she return to Indonesia in the foreseeable future.APPLICATION FOR REVIEW BY TRIBUNAL On 28 June 2005 an application for review by the Refugee Review Tribunal (‘the Tribunal’) was filed on the appellant’s behalf. That application recorded no further claims. The application indicated that the appellant’s residential address and address for correspondence was 45/2-8 Brisbane Street, Surry Hills, New South Wales and indicated a mobile phone number as the appellant’s. No adviser was nominated by the appellant as authorised to act for her in relation to the application for review. The appellant appeared to have signed the declaration herself on the application form, and there was no indication that an interpreter was used in the preparation of the application for review. This was the last piece of correspondence with the Tribunal that was initiated by or on behalf of the appellant.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MIDDLETON J
In my view, the reference to the receipt of the several letters could not impact upon the conclusion of the Federal Magistrate that there was no jurisdictional error on the part of the Tribunal. The Tribunal exercised its discretion to proceed in the absence of the appellant, no error has been demonstrated in it adopting that course, and its decision affirming the decision of the delegate must remain.CONCLUSION In my opinion, for the reasons given above, the appeal should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MIDDLETON J

The second affidavit was affirmed on 1 December 2007, where the appellant deposed as follows:1.I like to add this Affidavit to the filed Affidavit that I affirmed on 11 October 2007.2.Since affirming the Affidavit on 11 October 2007, I have had a chance refresh my memory, and as a result if there is any conflict between this Affidavit and the Affidavit that I affirmed on 11 October 2007, this Affidavit will contain the true information and not the other Affidavit.3. I arrived in Australia on 22 November 2004, and commenced work with Mr. Erwin Marzukie on 29 November 2004, as a live-in-nanny.4.I commenced work with Mr. Marzukie on the basis that he was looking for a live-in-nanny.5.When I commenced work with Mr. Marzukie, I did not know that he was a Migrant Agent until several days after commencing work, when on about 3 December 2004, Mr. Marzukie inquired about my Visa while in Australia.6. When on about 3 December 2004, I told Mr. Marzukie about my Visa, Mr. Marzukie referred me to another Migrant Agent.7.Later on about 3 December 2004, before the other Migrant Agent commenced his work, that Migrant Agent informed me of his fees, which I could not afford as I have just arrived in Australia, and had little money with me.8. When I explained to Mr. Marzukie that I could not afford the fees of the other Migrant Agent, he said he will do the work for me, for free.9. The following conversation took place when Mr. Marzukie told me that he will act as my Migrant Agent for free:I said: Thank you very much.He said:I will be your Migrant Agent provided you promise not to tell anyone that you are working for me as a live-in-nanny, otherwise we could get in trouble with the government. Can I trust you to do this?I said:Why would we get into trouble with the government if they found out that I was working with you as a live-in-nanny?He said:Don’t ask questions. If I cannot trust you that you will not mention that you are working for me as a live-in-nanny, I will find someone else instead.I said:I am very sorry, I will not do that again. You know that I cannot speak English, nor can I read and write English, and that there is nobody in Australia that can help me because I do not have any friends or relatives in Australia, and you are my only hope of escaping with my life from Indonesia, and even now that I am in Australia, I am still afraid because at any time I might be sent back to Indonesia.He said:Do not worry, leave it to me. In your application for the protection visa I will put your residential address being that of one of the staff that work for me, you understand, because I said, there will be problems if I put your residential address as my house. You just have to trust me.I said:You know better than me about these things, I trust you to do the right thing by me. You are the only one in Australia that is able to help me, I fully rely on you.He said:Good, I will pay you $450.00 per week, and you have half a day every Thursday off work. That is, you will work for me six and a half days per week as a live in nanny. Remember, if you tell anybody about working for me, then you would most probably be sent back to Indonesia, do you understand? You tell nobody about this.I said: Thank you very much, I promise I will tell nobody.10. I have worked for Mr. Marzukie from 29 November 2004 to 23 December 2005, as a live-in-nanny.11.As stated in paragraph 9 above, Mr. Marzukie paid me $450.00 per week, and I receive free board and lodging, worth about $100.00 per week.12.As stated in paragraph 9, above, I worked for Mr. Marzukie 6 days and a half per week, where I have half a day off work every week, every Thursday afternoon. The time I spent working per day is on average 17 hours per day. The following is a summary of the work I did at Mr. Marzukie’s house:a. I wake up at 6.00am, and start work about 6.10am.b.I then go to the kitchen and boil water for Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie, so that they can have hot water for their coffee when they come downstairs.c.I then prepare Hermione’s breakfast, who was about 2 years old.d.For 2 to 3 days per week I prepare breakfast for Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie, which includes fresh fried rice and noodles.e.By about 9.30am, I take a break of 30 minutes and go jogging outside the house.f.By 10.00am Hermione comes down from her parent’s bedroom which is upstairs.g.I then wash Hermione, and toilet her, and then feed her breakfast.h.I take care of Hermione while Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie go to the office in the city, and they return home by 8.30 pm.i.While Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie are at the office, I do the cooking for all, the Marzukie family, and I also clean the house. Most of the cooking I do when Hermione is sleeping in my bedroom between 1.30 pm and 3.30 pm.j.I also do all the laundry washing and ironing, for the whole house.k.When Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie come home from the office at about 8.30 pm, I unload their shopping from their car, and they go upstairs to their bedroom to change their cloth. l.While Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie are upstairs, I have to have the food heated so that it is hot when they come down stairs to have their dinner.m.I eat with Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie, and when we are finished eating, I do all the dishwashing and tidy up the kitchen.n.By about 10.15 pm, once the kitchen is all clean and tidy, I go to do the laundry and do the laundry for all the towels that were used during the day.o.I then empty all the rubbish bins in the house and take the rubbish outside.p.I am responsible for putting the garbage out every Thursday night.q.Every second weekend, Mr. Marzukie’s daughters from his previous marriage, Natasha and Sarah, come on Friday night and leave Sunday afternoon. I have to do extra work when they visit because they leave food all over the TV room which I have to clean up, and when they use the family bathroom they make a big mess which I have to clean up.r.When on the weekend Mr. and Mrs. Marzukie go shopping they take me with them so that I can be with Hermione and so that I can help them carry their shopping bags.s.On the weekends, Mrs. Marzukie will not feed Hermione because Hermione refuses to eat from Mrs. Marzukie, so Hermione only eats from me.t.By 11.00 pm all the work is finished, I go to bed to wake up the next day at 6.00 am and do the above all over again.13.Based from the above my income per week from Mr. Marzukie is $450.00 plus board and lodging worth about $100.00 per week, a total amount of being $550.00 per week, for working about 110 hours per week, which means my hourly rate while working for Mr. Marzukie is $5.00 per hour, and I am not entitled to sick leave or holiday leave. At $550.00 per week my annual total income from Mr. Marzukie would be $28,600.00.14.On or about 17 October 2007 or 18 October 2007, after Mr. Marzukie had been served with this Appeal’s filed documents, I received 3 phone calls from Mrs. Marzukie, which I did not answer, and an SMS message from her “Offering me part-time work”, which I did not respond to.CONSIDERATION