Southern Adelaide Health Service Inc v C

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

SOUTHERN ADELAIDE HEALTH SERVICE INC v C & ORS; CASE STATED ON ACQUITTAL (NO 1 OF 2006)

[2007] SASC 181

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Debelle, The Honourable Justice Anderson and The Honourable Justice White)

22 May 2007

CRIMINAL LAW - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL AND INQUIRY AFTER CONVICTION - APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - PRACTICE: AFTER CRIMINAL APPEAL LEGISLATION - MISCELLANEOUS MATTERS - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - CASE STATED AND REFERENCE OF QUESTION OF LAW

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE – SOUTH AUSTRALIA - SUBPOENA

Subpoena of documents - case stated and appeal by non-party - appeal by non-party to criminal proceedings who sought to set aside subpoena – whether appeal competent – whether authorisation of Governor pursuant to s 64D of the Health Commission Act operated to prevent disclosure of documents the subject of the subpoena – whether subpoena should have been set aside for reason that it served no legitimate forensic purpose - whether s 350(2) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act prevents court from refusing to refer stated case where Attorney-General has applied to have questions reserved for determination by Full Court – questions as to meaning of s 64D answered.

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 s 350, s 351, s 352; Crown Proceedings Act 1992 s 9(2); Evidence Act 1929  s 21, s 22, s 50; Juries Act 1927  s 56; South Australian Health Commission Act 1976 s 64D; Statutes Amendment (New Rules of Civil Procedure) Act 2006 s 94; Supreme Court Act 1935 s 35, s 50, s 63, referred to.
Attorney-General’s Reference (No 1 of 1975) [1975] QB 773; Alister v The Queen (1984) 154 CLR 404; Carter v Hayes (1994) 61 SASR 451; Commissioner of Taxation v Tang (2006) 96 SASR 55; Director of Public Prosecutions v B (1998) 194 CLR 566; Merchant Service Guild of Australasia v Newcastle & Hunter River Steamship Co Ltd (1913) 16 CLR 591; R v Allen (2002) 81 SASR 434; R v Foggo; ex parte Attorney-General [1989] 2 Qd R 49; R v Garrett (1988) 49 SASR 435; R v Rigby (1956) 100 CLR 146; R v Salem (1989) 16 NSWLR 14; Witness v Marsden (2000) 49 NSWLR 429, applied.
Alliance Petroleum Australia NL v The Australian Gas Light Company (1983) 34 SASR 215; Application for Reservation of Questions of Law (No 2 of 1999) (1999) 106 A Crim R 423; Australian National Railways Commission v Beesley (1999) 73 SASR 414; Bill Williams Pty Ltd v Williams (1972) 126 CLR 146; Hayes v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1956) 96 CLR 47; Hope v Bathurst City Council (1980) 144 CLR 1; Industrial Equity Ltd v Commissioner for Corporate Affairs [1990] VR 780; Mack v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) (1920) 28 CLR 373; National Employers’ Mutual General Association Ltd v Waind [1978] 1 NSWLR 372; R v Bingapore (1975) 11…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Southern Adelaide Health Service Inc v C and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] SASC 181
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Southern Adelaide Health Service Inc v C, the appellant sought to appeal a decision of the Supreme Court of South Australia concerning a subpoena issued for the production of documents. The appellant, not a party to the underlying criminal proceedings, argued that the subpoena should be set aside as it served no legitimate forensic purpose. The case involved questions regarding the interpretation and application of Section 64D of the Health Commission Act, which pertains to the disclosure of confidential health information under specific circumstances.

The legal issues before the court included the competency of the appeal by a non-party, the scope of authorisation under Section 64D, and whether the subpoena should be set aside for lack of a legitimate forensic purpose. Furthermore, the court had to determine whether Section 350(2) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act precluded it from refusing to refer the stated case where the Attorney-General had applied to have questions reserved for the Full Court.

The court found that the appeal was incompetent because the Flinders Medical Centre, which was the successful party in the lower court, had no grounds to appeal. Additionally, the court ruled that Section 64D of the Health Commission Act was intended to protect disclosures of confidential information to authorised persons and committees, thereby encouraging more frank communication. The court clarified that authorisation by the Governor under Section 64D could apply to either an individual or a group of persons. The questions posed by the Attorney-General were deemed relevant, and the Full Court was obligated to address them. The questions were answered to provide clarity on the scope and operation of Section 64D.

The court concluded that the appeal was incompetent and should be dismissed. However, it provided guidance on the interpretation of Section 64D, clarifying that the authorisation applied to both individuals and groups, and that technical, administrative, or secretarial assistance providers need not be trained in Root Cause Analysis. The Full Court answered the reserved questions to assist in understanding the legislative intent and application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J
In addition, the point of law on which the determination is sought should be identified with precision: Director of Public Prosecutions v B (supra). In this case, Questions 1, 2 and 3 were not entirely clear and were tantamount to questions asking what the terms of s 64D might mean. There is a real question whether that is a suitable form of question on a case stated. If the question is expressed in vague or ambiguous terms, the court may decline to consider it or at best send it back for amendments pursuant to s 351(2): R v Douglas (1991) 1 Qd R 386. Either course is manifestly wasteful of time and money. Conclusions For the reasons already expressed, I determine the issues in the following terms.1The appeal from Sulan J was incompetent and should, therefore, be dismissed. 2Subject to the incompetence of the appeal, a person served with a subpoena to produce documents who has made an application to set aside the subpoena or limit its operation is entitled to apply for leave to appeal for an adverse order on that application.3All of the questions the subject of the Attorney-General’s application, including Question 4, were relevant questions within the meaning of s350(a1) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act.4Sulan J was bound by the terms of s 350(2) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act to reserve to the Full Court for its consideration and determination all of the questions the subject of the Attorney-General’s application made pursuant to s 350(2). 5The questions reserved for the consideration and determination of this Full Court should be answered as follows1.A disclosure will be protected by s 64D if it is made to a person who, at the relevant time, is a member of the Clinical Review Committee and is conducting either or both of the activities described in paragraphs (a) and (b) of s 64D(1) on behalf of the Committee or to a person providing technical or administrative assistance to a member of the Committee engaged on behalf of the Committee in the performance of either or both of the activities referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b) of s 64D(1).2. Not necessary to answer.3.Yes, but it is not a requirement of s 64D(1) of the Health Commission Act that the person providing technical, administrative or secretarial assistance in the performance of the functions referred to in paragraphs (a) and (b) of s 64D(1) be trained in the conduct of Root Cause Analysis.4. Yes. On a natural reading, the sub-section contemplates that it may be either an individual person, or a group or body of persons, who may be given the relevant authority. It seeks to have the section operate in both such cases. When it is a group which is authorised, it is the members of the group from time to time who are subject to the protections and prohibitions contained in s 64D. Secondly, this view is consistent with the purpose of s 64D outlined by the Minister at the time of its introduction in the SAHCA. Section 64D in its present form was introduced into the SACHA by the South Australian Health Commission Act Amendment Act 1989 (SA). Hansard records the Minister making the following statements to the House of Assembly on 5 April 1989 in the course of the second reading speech.… The amendments will permit specified persons and groups to be authorised by the Governor to have access to information for the purpose of assessing and improving the quality of specified health services. This will allow for quality assurance committees to be so authorised.Confidential information may still be disclosed to a person to whom the provision applies without breach of any law or any principle of professional ethics. However, a person must not divulge the confidential information, whether obtained directly or indirectly, in any circumstances, including proceedings before any court, tribunal or board. This will provide a statutory protection to persons giving information to authorised persons and committees. It will encourage them to be more frank about the information they supply than they might have been had the protection not been there. In order to prevent any abuse of such privilege it is proposed that any person or committee seeking protection must first be authorised by the Governor.It is intended that such authorisations would be gazetted and would extend to Government funded hospitals, private hospitals and any other properly constituted body carrying out quality assurance of clinical practice or competence. In granting an authorisation the Governor would need to be assured that a committee was properly established for the purpose of quality assurance and reported to the board of directors of the hospital or other appropriate body. [Emphasis added]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J

For these reasons, a person served with a subpoena who seeks to appeal against an adverse order made on an application in respect of that subpoena may apply for permission to appeal. However, for the reasons already given, because the Flinders Medical Centre was the successful party, there was no ground on which it was able to appeal in this case. The appeal is incompetent. The Operation of Section 64 It is convenient to deal next with s 64 D of the Health Commission Act. Section 64D provides:(1) This section applies to a person, or the members from time to time of a specified group or body, authorised by the Governor, by instrument in writing, to have access to confidential information for the purpose of – (a)conducting research into the causes of mortality or morbidity; or (b)assessing and improving the quality of specified health services, and to any person providing technical, administrative or secretarial assistance in the performance of such functions. (2) Confidential information may be disclosed to a person to whom this section applies without breach of any law or any principle of professional ethics. (3) Subject to this section, a person must not in any circumstances (including proceedings before any court, tribunal or board) divulge confidential information obtained directly or indirectly as a result of a disclosure made pursuant to this section. Penalty: Division 5 fine. (4) Subsection (3) does not prevent a person to whom this section applies disclosing confidential information to another person to whom this section applies. (5) A person must not, when appearing as a witness in any proceedings before a court, tribunal or board, be asked, and, if asked, is not required to answer, any question directed at obtaining confidential information obtained by that person directly or indirectly as a result of a disclosure made pursuant to this section and any such information volunteered by such a person is not admissible in any proceedings. (6) In this section – “confidential information” means information relating to a health service in which the identity of the patient or person providing the service is revealed. The purpose of s 64D is threefold. First, it permits the disclosure of confidential information to persons or members of bodies or groups authorised to receive it for the purposes identified in s 64D(1): see s 64D(2). Secondly, it prohibits a person to whom confidential information has been disclosed pursuant to subsection (2) from divulging it in any circumstances including proceedings before a court: s 64D(3). Thirdly, it prohibits a person to whom confidential information has been disclosed from being asked or required to answer, when a witness in any proceedings, any question directed at obtaining confidential information disclosed to the witness pursuant to subsection (2): s 64D(5). It will be noticed that the definition of “confidential information” means information relating to a health service in which the identity of the patient is revealed as well as information relating to a health service in which the identity of the person providing the service is revealed: s 64D(6).