Sadler v Director of Public Prosecutions

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Criminal)

SADLER v DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS & ANOR

[2021] SASCA 20

Judgment of the Court of Appeal  

(The Honourable President Kelly, the Honourable Justice Livesey and the Honourable Justice Bleby)

8 April 2021

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - RIGHT OF APPEAL

EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY - EXCLUSIONS: PRIVILEGES - CLIENT LEGAL PRIVILEGE - SCOPE OF PRIVILEGE - LITIGATION OR ADVICE

EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY - EXCLUSIONS: PRIVILEGES - CLIENT LEGAL PRIVILEGE - LOSS OF PRIVILEGE - IMPLIED WAIVER

This is an appeal from a judgment of the District Court of South Australia at the pre-trial stage, determining an application by the second respondent, the Commissioner of Police.

The appellant is currently charged on Information with one count of dishonest dealings with documents, contrary to s 140(4) of the Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA). The appeal concerns claims of legal professional privilege made by the appellant over particular documents in her solicitor’s file, which the Commissioner had seized and subsequently returned on a subpoena that the appellant had caused to be issued. The Commissioner sought an order that legal professional privilege had not been established, had been waived, or was excluded by reason of fraud. On 24 September 2020, the trial judge upheld the appellant’s claims of legal professional privilege over some of the documents, but ruled that a number of the documents were either not privileged, or that any legal professional privilege over them had been waived by the conduct of the appellant.

The appellant’s Notice of Appeal complained, in relation to a selection of the documents, that the trial judge erred in ruling that the documents were not subject to legal professional privilege. The Commissioner raised a preliminary issue concerning the competency of the appeal. He did not ultimately submit that the appeal was incompetent, but contested the basis of right on which the appellant purported to appeal.

Held, per Bleby JA (Kelly P and Livesey JA agreeing), granting an extension of time to file the Notice of Appeal, allowing the appeal in relation to Documents 23, 350 and 353 and dismissing the appeal in relation to Document 26:

1.  An application by a non-party to proceedings, putting in issue a substantiative right of privilege of a criminal defendant, has necessarily engaged the Court’s civil, declaratory jurisdiction, rather than that application arising incidentally in the criminal jurisdiction.

2. The orders of the District Court were made in the exercise of its civil jurisdiction to make declarations of right, obligations, entitlements and power, pursuant to s 8(1) of the District Court Act 1991 (SA) (DCA) and s 31 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA). Section 43 of the DCA governs the right of appeal. Section 45 of the DCA does not purport to abrogate that right. The appeal is competent.

3.  Documents 23, 350 and 350a are subject to legal professional privilege.

4.  There is a prima facie basis for concluding that Document 26 was made…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sadler v Director of Public Prosecutions and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASCA 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal before the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia concerned the appellant's claims of legal professional privilege over certain documents that had been returned by the Commissioner pursuant to a subpoena. The dispute arose from an application made by the Commissioner, the nature of which was central to the appeal, following the return of documents that comprised the appellant's solicitor's file in relation to a personal injury claim. The District Court had made orders determining claims of legal professional privilege made by the appellant over these documents.

The legal issues before the Full Court included whether the District Court's orders were made in its civil or criminal jurisdiction, the competency of the appeal, and the extent to which legal professional privilege attached to specific documents. The Court was required to determine if certain documents were subject to legal professional privilege, and if so, whether that privilege had been lost. A further issue was whether a particular document was created in furtherance of an alleged fraud, thereby vitiating any claim to privilege.

The Court held that the Commissioner's application, by putting in issue a substantive right of privilege of a criminal defendant, engaged the Court's civil, declaratory jurisdiction, rather than arising incidentally in the criminal jurisdiction. Consequently, the orders of the District Court were made in the exercise of its civil jurisdiction to make declarations of right, and the appeal was competent under section 43 of the District Court Act 1991 (SA). The Court found that Documents 23, 350, and 353a were subject to legal professional privilege. However, in relation to Document 26, the Court found a prima facie basis for concluding it was made in furtherance of, or as a step preparatory to, an alleged fraud, and therefore legal professional privilege did not attach to it.

The Full Court granted an extension of time to file the Notice of Appeal. The appeal was allowed in relation to Documents 23, 350, and 353a, with the Court holding that legal professional privilege existed and was maintained over these documents. The appeal was dismissed in relation to Document 26.

Orders

Orders of the court

Held, per Bleby JA (Kelly P and Livesey JA agreeing), granting an extension of time to file the Notice of Appeal, allowing the appeal in relation to Documents 23, 350 and 353 and dismissing the appeal in relation to Document 26:

1. An application by a non-party to proceedings, putting in issue a substantiative right of privilege of a criminal defendant, has necessarily engaged the Court’s civil, declaratory jurisdiction, rather than that application arising incidentally in the criminal jurisdiction.

2. The orders of the District Court were made in the exercise of its civil jurisdiction to make declarations of right, obligations, entitlements and power, pursuant to s 8(1) of the District Court Act 1991 (SA) (DCA) and s 31 of the Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA). Section 43 of the DCA governs the right of appeal. Section 45 of the DCA does not purport to abrogate that right. The appeal is competent.

3. Documents 23, 350 and 350a are subject to legal professional privilege.

4. There is a prima facie basis for concluding that Document 26 was made in furtherance of, or as a step preparatory to, the alleged fraud. Legal professional privilege does not attach to the document.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Commissioner’s application, the character of which is an issue to be determined on this appeal, was made in consequence of the return of documents by the Commissioner on a subpoena that the appellant had caused to be issued. The substance of the District Court judgment was to determine claims of legal professional privilege made by the appellant over those documents, which comprised the appellant’s solicitor’s file in respect of a personal injury claim.Background The appellant owned and operated a small bookshop named Gawler Books in Willaston, South Australia. The prosecution alleges that between 30 September 2016 and 25 October 2016, she knowingly and dishonestly produced falsified timebooks to her solicitors, Radbone and Associates, with the intention of deceiving Allianz Australia Pty Ltd (Allianz), to benefit herself in respect of an ongoing claim for damages for personal injury. In February 2013, Radbone and Associates wrote to Allianz advising that it had been instructed to act for the appellant in respect of a claim for damages for personal injuries the appellant had suffered during a motor vehicle accident on 19 October 2012 (the CTP claim). The appellant claimed to have been thrown from her bicycle after being rear-ended by a motor vehicle driven by a Ms Riggs. Allianz were the claims manager for the Motor Accident Commission, the compulsory third party bodily insurer in South Australia at that time. Between 2013 and 2015, Radbone and Associates corresponded with Allianz about the claim. On 25 September 2015, the appellant commenced civil proceedings in the District Court against Ms Riggs, seeking damages for personal injury. In December 2015, Finlaysons Lawyers (Finlaysons) were instructed to act on behalf of Allianz in these proceedings. The parties continued to correspond in preparation for trial. However, on 20 October 2016, Finlaysons referred the matter to the Allianz Fraud Team to investigate. On 25 October 2016, Radbone and Associates sent a letter to Finlaysons enclosing the 2015 and 2016 time books, which recorded hours allegedly worked by the appellant’s partner, Richard Stow, at Gawler Books, a signed agreement between the appellant and Richard Stow, and various calculations made by a bookkeeper, Ms May, as to ‘back wages’.[7][7] R v Sadler [2020] SADC 133 at [68]. On 17 November 2016, the Allianz Fraud Team referred the matter to the South Australia Police (SAPOL) for investigation. On 24 January 2018, some 14 months later, the appellant was arrested and charged with the offence the subject of the ongoing proceedings in the District Court. On 10 April 2018, the appellant sent to Allianz a document signed by her and entitled ‘Notice of Demand’ that read as follows:The undersigned has not been presented with any material facts or evidence that John Radbone (solicitor) had written or verbal authority to present Allianz with confidential business documents (time books) and believes none to exist.The undersigned now demands that Allianz produce written evidence by way of Affidavit that the time books that they are quoting, and given to SAPOL was given to them with the full consent of the Undersigned.Failure to produce the evidence and facts by way of Affidavit within 14 days will confirm that the time books and material within were gained without proper consent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

In those circumstances, it is unnecessary to decide whether, by reason of sending the Notice of Demand, the appellant has waived privilege. There is a strong argument in favour of there being a relevant inconsistency between the contents of this document and the appellant sending the Notice of Demand. It is not necessary to decide that question, however, in circumstances where it is clear that privilege does not attach to the document.Conclusion I would grant an extension of time to file the Notice of Appeal. I would allow the appeal in relation to Documents 23, 350 and 353a, and hold that legal professional privilege exists and is maintained over those documents. I would dismiss the appeal in relation to Document 26.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established