COWIE v O'BRIEN

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master)

COWIE & ANOR v O'BRIEN

[2019] SASC 203

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Kelly

22 November 2019

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - MOTIONS, INTERLOCUTORY APPLICATIONS AND OTHER PRE-TRIAL MATTERS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES

EVIDENCE - ADMISSIBILITY AND RELEVANCY - OPINION EVIDENCE - EXPERT OPINION

PROCEDURE - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - DISCOVERY OF DOCUMENTS - ORDERS FOR FURTHER AND BETTER DISCOVERY

Where plaintiff-respondent made a request for discovery of expert reports – where an email communication between a neonatal medical expert and the appellant-defendants’ solicitors was not disclosed until after the written expert report was prepared – where the Master ruled that the email communication constituted an expert report.

Whether the Master erred in determining that the email communication met the definition of expert report pursuant to r 4 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 – whether the Master ought to have heard the matter in circumstances where the appellant-defendants had admitted liability – whether the Master erred in concluding that r 160 applied to the email communication prior to the preparation of the written expert report.

Held: no error has been established. The appeal is dismissed.  The matter is remitted to the Master to finalise orders consequential on the respondent’s application as determined on 11 September 2019.

Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 4, r 160, referred to.
Expense Reduction Analysts Group Pty Ltd v Armstrong Strategic Management & Marketing Pty Ltd (2013) 250 CLR 303, applied.

WORDS AND PHRASES CONSIDERED/DEFINED

"expert report"

COWIE & ANOR v O'BRIEN
[2019] SASC 203

Civil:  Appeal from a Master

KELLY J.

Introduction

  1. The appellants in this matter are the defendants in an action for damages brought by the respondent, as plaintiff, for physical and intellectual injuries suffered during her birth.  The appellants are doctors who were involved in the respondent’s birth. 

  2. The appellants appeal against the decision of a Master of this Court, made on 11 September 2019, that an email communication from Associate Professor Nick Evans, a neonatal medical expert, dated 18 March 2015 (‘the Evans email’) is an expert report within the meaning of r 4 and r 160 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) (SCR).  That decision followed an application by the respondent for the Court to rule on the specific question of whether or not the Evans email is an expert report.

  3. On appeal, the appellants contend that the Master erred by permitting a hearing to proceed on the limited issue of whether the Evans email constituted an expert report in circumstances where the appellants had already admitted liability and where there was therefore no utility in bringing the application.  The appellants further contend that the Master erred in concluding that the Evans email itself was an expert report within the meaning of SCR 4, and in finding inferentially that SCR 160 therefore applied to the Evans email prior…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read COWIE v O'BRIEN and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] SASC 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Cowie v O'Brien, the respondent sought discovery of expert reports from the appellants. The dispute arose after an email communication between a neonatal medical expert and the appellants' solicitors was not disclosed until after the written expert report was prepared. The Master ruled that the email communication constituted an expert report. The appellants argued that the Master erred in various respects, including in determining that the email communication met the definition of an expert report under the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006, and in concluding that Rule 160 applied to the email communication prior to the preparation of the written expert report.

The legal issues before the court were whether the Master erred in permitting the hearing to proceed on the limited issue of whether the email communication constituted an expert report, in concluding that the email was an expert report within the meaning of the rules, and in finding that Rule 160 applied to the email communication. The appellants also argued that the Master erred in not distinguishing between an 'expert report' and a 'communication between an expert and a party relevant to the preparation of a report', and in consequently finding that the email was not privileged.

The court found that the appellants had not established any error on the part of the Master. The court held that the respondent's application had utility, as it was necessary to determine the admissibility of the email as an expert report. The court also found that the Master did not err in concluding that the email communication was an expert report within the meaning of the rules, and that Rule 160 applied to the email communication prior to the preparation of the written expert report. The court further held that the Master did not err in finding that the email was not privileged.

The court dismissed the appeal and remitted the matter to the Master to finalise orders consequential on the respondent's application as determined by him on 11 September 2019. The court will hear the parties as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

On appeal, the appellants contend that the Master erred by permitting a hearing to proceed on the limited issue of whether the Evans email constituted an expert report in circumstances where the appellants had already admitted liability and where there was therefore no utility in bringing the application. The appellants further contend that the Master erred in concluding that the Evans email itself was an expert report within the meaning of SCR 4, and in finding inferentially that SCR 160 therefore applied to the Evans email prior to the preparation of the formal expert report of Associate Professor Evans dated 4 September 2018. The appellants further contend that the Master erred in not distinguishing between an ‘expert report’ and a ‘communication between an expert and a party relevant to the preparation of a report’, and in consequently finding that the Evans email was not privileged. Background The history of the proceedings and the state of the pleadings from time to time are relevant to an understanding of the basis of the respondent’s application before the Master. The respondent filed her summons and statement of claim on 28 March 2017. Prior to that, the respondent gave notice by way of the pre-action protocol requirements. The issue of liability remained in dispute until 19 December 2018 when both appellants admitted liability in their respective fourth defences. Prior to that, in the first,[1] second[2] and third[3] defences of each appellant, the issue of liability continued to be a live one.[1] Filed on 3 and 12 May 2017 respectively.[2] Filed on 15 and 16 November 2017 respectively. [3] Both filed on 27 November 2018. At the time when discovery was required of any expert report in mid-2017, liability and causation were still in issue. Neither the list of documents filed by the first appellant on 31 January 2018 nor the list of documents filed by the second appellant on 5 February 2018 contained any reference to a report from Associate Professor Evans. However, as the respondent had become aware that Associate Professor Evans had been consulted by the appellants in relation to the matter, on 18 June 2018, the respondent issued an application to investigate whether such a report had been prepared. That application was heard before the Master on 21 June 2018. At that hearing, counsel for the second appellant advised the Court that Associate Professor Evans had not provided an expert report and that that fact would be confirmed in writing. In a letter dated 22 June 2018 and addressed to the respondent’s solicitors, the second appellant’s solicitor confirmed that no expert report from Associate Professor Evans had been provided. By email on 28 June 2018, in response to an email from the respondent’s solicitor sent earlier that same day, Associate Professor Evans advised the respondent’s solicitor that he had not prepared a report on the matter. Subsequently, the first appellant did obtain a written expert report from Associate Professor Evans, dated 4 September 2018. That report was shortly thereafter provided to the second appellant’s solicitors and to the respondent’s solicitors on 7 September 2018, along with various correspondence and hand notes of conversations had with Associate Professor Evans since January 2015, including the Evans email dated 18 March 2015, which was addressed to the solicitors for both the first and second appellants. The Evans email is reproduced in full below:Dear Andrew, John,Had a look through the neonatal notes. It’s a bit hard to judge from the Whyalla notes but what information there is doesn’t point to oxygen levels that would be a dominant cause of Georgia’s brain injury. Her first gas at Flinders was mildly acidotic but again not to a degree that would point to severe tissue hypoxia. Her blood pressure measures after she got to Flinders were all normal.Her postnatal course was a symptom of her antenatal compromise. I can’t exclude a contribution but likely to be minor compared to antenatal. Again there’s no way this can be quantified.Nick Evans

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

KELLY J
To my mind, if the appellants’ contention were to be accepted that would be the likely result. To that extent, it cannot be said that the respondent’s application lacks any utility. The appellants have not established that the Master made any other error which would justify this Court’s intervention. Conclusion No error has been established. The appeal is dismissed. The matter is remitted to the Master to finalise orders consequential on the respondent’s application as determined by him on 11 September 2019. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: KELLY J