Sharp v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Sharp v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1477

Citation: Sharp v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2011] FCA 1477
Parties: COLIN ANDREW SHARP and COLIN ANDREW SHARP ATF THE SHARP FAMILY TRUST v COSSACK PEARLS PTY LTD ACN 009 212 015, DAMPIER PEARLING COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 061 740 145, LINDSAY KEVIN BRADY and PAUL JOHN THOMAS
File number WAD 208 of 2004
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 20 December 2011
Catchwords:

TRADE PRACTICES – pearling agreements – loan agreement - misleading and deceptive conduct alleged

CONTRACT – termination of pearling agreement – breach alleged – rectification sought

Legislation: Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth)
Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA) s 10
Pearling Act 1990 (WA)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) ss 51A, 52
Cases cited: Bolton v Mahadeva [1972] 2 All ER 1322 referred to
Commissioner of Stamp Duties (NSW) v Carlenka Pty Ltd (1995) 41 NSWLR 329 compared
Demagogue Pty Ltd v Ramensky (1992) 39 FCR 31 cited, discussed
Effem Foods Pty Ltd v Lake Cumberline Pty Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 599 cited
Fraser v NRMA Holdings Limited (1995) 55 FCR 452 cited, discussed
General Newspapers Pty Ltd v Telstra Corporation (1993) 45 FCR 164 cited
Hoenig v Isaacs [1952] 2 All ER 176 referred to
Hornsby Building Information Centre Pty Ltd v Sydney Building Information Centre (1978) 140 CLR 216 cited
Johnson Tiles Pty Ltd v Esso Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 104 FCR 564 cited
Lake Cumbeline Pty Ltd v Effem Foods Pty Ltd [1995] FCA 1340 cited, discussed
McGrath v Australian Naturalcare Products Pty Ltd (2008) 165 FCR 230 cited, discussed,
Parkdale Custom Built Furniture Pty Ltd v Puxu Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 191 cited
Pearl Cost Divers Pty Ltd v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 927 referred to
Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315 cited
Zamperoni Decorators Pty Ltd v Lo Presti [1983] 1 VR 338 referred to
Date of hearing: 4, 5, 6, 7 and 11 April 2011
Place: Melbourne (heard in Perth)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 130
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr P G Clifford with Mr A P Rumsley
Solicitor for the Applicants: Alan Rumsley Commercial Disputes Lawyer
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr G R Donaldson SC with Ms D M Bradley
Solicitor for the Respondents: Freehills

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 208 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

COLIN ANDREW SHARP
First Applicant

COLIN ANDREW SHARP ATF THE SHARP FAMILY TRUST
Second Applicant

AND:

COSSACK PEARLS PTY LTD ACN 009 212 015
First Respondent

DAMPIER PEARLING COMPANY PTY LTD ACN 061 740 145
Second Respondent

LINDSAY KEVIN BRADY
Third Respondent

PAUL JOHN THOMAS
Fourth Respondent

JUDGE:

TRACEY J

DATE:

20 DECEMBER 2011  

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE (HEARD IN PERTH)

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1. The application be dismissed with costs.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Sharp v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1477
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Sharp v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the parties over alleged breaches of contract and misleading or deceptive conduct under the Trade Practices Act. The primary contention was whether the respondent, Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd, had wrongfully terminated a pearling agreement and subsequently breached the contract by failing to provide necessary tags for pearl collection. The applicant, Sharp, sought rectification of the contract and damages for the alleged breaches. The court was tasked with determining if any misleading representations had been made by Cossack and whether the termination of the agreement was lawful.

The key legal issues before the court included whether Cossack had made any misleading or deceptive representations regarding future conduct, and if the termination of the pearling agreement was justified under the terms of the contract. Specifically, the court examined if Cossack was obligated to provide all necessary tags for the pearling quota and whether their failure to do so constituted a breach of contract. Additionally, the court considered the applicability of sections 51A and 52 of the Trade Practices Act in determining the existence of misleading conduct.

The court concluded that no misleading representations were made by Cossack, as there was insufficient evidence to substantiate the applicant's claims. The court found that Cossack had fulfilled its obligations under the contract to provide tags, even though there was a shortfall. The termination of the contract was deemed lawful, as the applicant had not met the contractual requirement of catching and delivering 80% of the quota by the specified date. The court emphasised the importance of objective evidence and commercial probabilities in resolving the dispute, given the long-standing nature of the commercial relationship between the parties.

The court dismissed the application and ordered that the applicant pay the respondent's costs. The decision highlighted the necessity for clear contractual obligations and the importance of evidence in substantiating claims of breach and misleading conduct under the Trade Practices Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed with costs.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

This case involves a dispute between Mr Sharp, the owner of Pearl Coast Divers (PCD), and Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd. The dispute arises from a series of pearling agreements and a loan agreement related to the purchase and refit of a pearling vessel, the Anzac Pearl. The agreements involved included the 1997 Agreement and the 1999 Agreement, which outlined the terms of pearling operations and the obligations of both parties. Mr Sharp alleged that Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd made various representations that induced him to enter into the agreements. These representations included promises regarding the purchase price of the Anzac Pearl, terms of financing, employment for at least five years, and other related services. Mr Sharp further claimed that Cossack breached the agreements by failing to provide sufficient tags for pearling and wrongfully terminating the 1999 Agreement. As a result of these breaches, Mr Sharp sought damages and other remedies.

The matter came before the court on an application by Mr Sharp against Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd. The application was based on allegations of misleading and deceptive conduct, breach of contract, and seeking rectification of the agreements. The case proceeded through several stages, including the filing of statements of claim, defence, and counter-claims. The primary evidence came from the testimonies of Mr Sharp and Mr Brady of Cossack Pearls, with documentary evidence also being tendered. The case was heard by the court, which considered the factual evidence and the legal arguments presented by both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The alleged representation was not made. Conclusions on Representations I am not satisfied that any of the representations alleged were made by the respondents or any of them. In so concluding I do not find it necessary to deal with Cossack’s further argument that the existence of the “entire contract” clauses of the 1997 and 1999 Agreements (respectively clauses 40 and 30) precluded a finding that the representations had been made. Nor is it necessary to consider the possible operation of s 51A of the TP Act.BREACH OF CONTRACT Mr Sharp complains that the respondents were not lawfully entitled to terminate the 1999 Agreement when they purportedly did so in October 2001. In purporting to terminate the contract Cossack relied on Clause 4.2 which provided for termination in the event that PCD failed to catch and deliver to Cossack at least 80% of the quota of 32,500 shells before 30 June 2001. It was common ground that PCD had not fished 80% of the quota by 30 June 2001. The applicants’ pleaded case was that Cossack had breached Clauses 2.1, 2.2 and 35 of the Agreement thereby making it impossible for PCD to meet the 80% of the quota in the 2001 season by failing to provide PCD with sufficient tags. A consequence was that Cossack had wrongfully repudiated the agreement. This wrongful repudiation had caused PCD to suffer loss and damage. The case opened for the applicants was that Cossack’s failure to provide all, or at least 80%, of the necessary tags to Mr Sharp prevented PCD from complying with Clause 4.2 of the agreement (when read with Clause 14.5). PCD had substantially performed its obligation to catch at least 80% of the quota notwithstanding Cossack’s refusal to provide the necessary tags. Mr Sharp had accepted the purported termination and the refusal to provide all the tags as acts of repudiation of the agreement. The first issue is, then, whether Cossack was obliged, by Clause 2.1 of the agreement, to furnish PCD with all tags which PCD required to catch the quota. Clause 2.1 imposed no such obligation. What it required Cossack to do by 31 December in each year during which the agreement operated, was to complete and lodge with the Fisheries Department the various documents identified in paragraphs (e), (f) and (g). This Cossack did prior to 31 December 2000 in respect of the 2001 season. It provided Mr Sharp with tags to cover 10,000 shell rather than the number needed to catch 32,500 shell. This was sufficient to allow PCD to commence fishing at the start of the 2001 season. Further tags were issued through until 19 April 2001, by which time PCD had received sufficient tags to catch 22,496 shell. The remaining tags were given to Mr Feeney in mid April. There was, therefore, a shortfall. 438 more tags would have been needed in order to allow PCD to catch 26,000 shell (80% of the quota). No submission was pressed at trial that Cossack had failed to use its reasonable endeavours to obtain the necessary approvals under clause 2.1 thereby contravening clause 2.2.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In applying s 52 it may be necessary to notice the requirements of s 51A. Its effect was explained by Emmett J in McGrath v Australian Naturalcare Products Pty Ltd (2008) 165 FCR 230 at 242 [44]. His Honour there said:“Under s 51A(1) of the Trade Practices Act, a representation is to be taken to be misleading if it is a representation with respect to any future matter and the maker of the representation does not have reasonable grounds for making the representation. Under s 51A(2), the maker of the representation with respect to any future matter is to be deemed not to have had reasonable grounds for making the representation unless it adduces evidence to the contrary. However, if evidence is adduced by a representor to the effect that the representor had reasonable grounds for making the representation, the deeming provision will not operate. Where the representor adduces such evidence, it is then a matter for the Court to determine, on the balance of probabilities in the ordinary way, whether or not the representor had reasonable grounds for making the representation.”See also at 283 [192] (per Allsop J).CONSIDERATION The principal witnesses on each side were, respectively, Mr Sharp and Mr Brady. They gave evidence about their commercial dealings and conversations which had occurred over a decade earlier. Unsurprisingly, their accounts differed in material respects. I formed the impression that these differences were not the result of any deliberate attempt, on either side, to mislead the Court. Rather they arose from failure of memory after such a long time and attempts being made to reconstruct what the witnesses considered it likely they would have said or done or understood in the circumstances then arising. Mr Sharp’s evidence was given through the prism of the failure of a commercial venture which he had entered into in the expectation of considerable financial gain. In such circumstances I consider that the proper approach is for the Court “to place primary emphasis on the objective factual surrounding material and the inherent commercial probabilities, together with the documentation tendered in evidence”: see Lake Cumbeline at [412], an approach subsequently endorsed by the High Court as being “orthodox and sensible”: see Effem Foods Pty Ltd v Lake Cumbeline Pty Ltd (1999) 161 ALR 599 at 603. The Purchase and Refit Conduct This representation was framed in different ways at different stages of the litigation. Mr Sharp also gave varying accounts of precisely what Mr Brady had said to him in the course of their discussions in which the representation was said to have been conveyed. The various formulations of this representation have been set out above at [56]. The applicants’ case relied, principally, on the evidence of Mr Sharp. In particulars provided in his statement of claim, Mr Sharp attributed to Mr Brady words to the effect that: “(a)If Pearl Coast wants to purchase the Anzac Pearl, Cossack would loan Pearl Coast the purchase price, which Pearl Coast could pay off over time, and would loan money to Pearl Coast to pay for the re-fit of the Anzac Pearl, with the payments to be made on each neap tide.(b)Cossack would engage Pearl Coast to fish the Cossack Quota for at least the next five years.(c)Cossack would also engage Pearl Coast to do the turning and transportation of shell harvested for Cossack.(d)Cossack would engage Pearl Coast to fish the Cossack Quota and provide turning and transportation services for at least as long as it took for Pearl Coast to repay Cossack through the income derived from providing those services.”