Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 927

CORPORATIONS – substitution of individual assignee of non-trade practices claims as first plaintiff – substitution of personal trustee for corporate trustee as second plaintiff –application under s 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) to bring derivative action in name of first plaintiff in respect of trade practices claims – first plaintiff company in liquidation – whether Pt 2F.1A of the Act has application to a company in liquidation – alternatively application to bring derivative action under inherent power of court.

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – company created for the sole purpose of acting as trustee of a family trust – company deregistered – substitution of new trustee in the proceedings – Order 13 rule 2(6) Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth).

Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 52, 75B, 82
Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA), ss 10, 79
Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth), O 13 r 2(6), O 4 r 4(1)(b)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 237, Part 2F.1A

Aliprandi v Griffith Vintners Pty Ltd (in liq) (1991) 6 ACSR 250 cited and discussed
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Marlborough Gold Mines Ltd (1993) 177 CLR 485 cited
BL & GY International Co Ltd v Hypec Electronics Pty Ltd (2001) 164 FLR 268 referred to
Brightwell v RFV Holdings Pty Ltd [2003] NSWSC 7 not followed
Cadima Express Pty Ltd (in liq) v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (1999) 33 ACSR 527 discussed
Carpenter v Pioneer Race Pty Ltd (in liq) (2004) 211 ALR 457 not followed
Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 52 followed
Charlton v Baber (2003) 47 ACSR 31 not followed
Kamper v Applied Soil Technology Pty Ltd (2004) 50 ACSR 738 not followed
Magarditch v Australia & New Zealand Banking Group Ltd (1999) 32 ACSR 367 referred to
Park v Allied Mortgage Corporation Ltd (1993) ATPR Digest 46-105 cited
Partnership Pacific Ltd v Aliprandi (1990) 4 ACSR 51 referred to
Promaco Conventions Pty Ltd v Dedline Printing Pty Ltd (2007) 159 FCR 486 discussed
Roach v Winnote Pty Ltd (in liq) [2001] NSWSC 822 not followed
Russell v Westpac Banking Corporation (1994) 12 ACLC 278 cited
Salfinger v Niugini Mining (Australia) Pty Ltd (No. 3) [2007] FCA 1532 cited

Scarel Pty Ltd v City Loan & Credit Corporation Pty Limited (1998) 12 ACLR 730 referred to
Scuteri v Lofthouse (2006) VSC 317 not followed
Vagrand Pty Ltd (in Liq) v Fielding (1993) 41 FCR 550 referred to
Vintage Developments Pty Ltd v GHD Pty Ltd (No 2) [2006] FCA 1437 discussed

PEARL COAST DIVERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) AND LIQUID INVESTMENTS (WA) PTY LTD v COSSACK PEARLS PTY LTD, DAMPIER PEARLING COMPANY PTY LTD, LINDSAY KEVIN BRADY AND PAUL JOHN THOMAS
WAD208 OF 2004

GILMOUR J
19 JUNE 2008
PERTH

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WAD208 OF 2004

BETWEEN:

PEARL COAST DIVERS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
(ACN 009 374 752)
First Plaintiff

LIQUID INVESTMENTS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] FCA 927
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd involves a dispute between the plaintiffs, Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (in liquidation) and Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd, and the defendants, Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd, Dampier Pearling Company Pty Ltd, Lindsay Kevin Brady, and Paul John Thomas. The plaintiffs are seeking various orders, including substitution of parties in the proceedings, to pursue claims arising from alleged misleading and deceptive conduct and breaches of contract under the Trade Practices Act 1974 and the Fair Trading Act 1987. The primary legal issues before the court were whether Colin Andrew Sharp should be substituted as the applicant in place of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd and Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd and whether Sharp should be granted leave to bring the proceedings on their behalf. The court had to consider the validity of the proposed substitutions, the implications for the defendants, and the appropriate conditions under which such substitutions should be permitted.

The court examined the application in light of the Federal Court Rules and relevant case law, particularly focusing on the nature of the claims and the potential impact on the defendants. It noted that the liquidators did not oppose the application, provided there was no personal liability for adverse costs orders. The court concluded that Mr Sharp should be allowed to substitute as the applicant but imposed certain conditions to protect the interests of all parties. Firstly, Mr Sharp was required to indemnify Pearl Coast against any costs and expenses incurred, with a potential for reimbursement if Pearl Coast succeeded in recovering damages. Secondly, Mr Sharp was to provide security for any costs ordered against Pearl Coast that were not satisfied. Additionally, the court granted the application to substitute Mr Sharp for Liquid as trustee for the Sharp Family Trust, considering that Liquid was created for this purpose and had not engaged in any other activities.

The court’s decision ensures that the proceedings can continue with the appropriate parties while safeguarding the interests of all involved, including the defendants. The orders reflect a balance between allowing the claims to proceed and mitigating potential risks associated with the substitutions. The court’s reasoning emphasizes the importance of procedural fairness and the need to protect the defendants from unjust costs orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

By its Amended Notice of Motion the plaintiffs seek orders that: 1.Colin Andrew Sharp be substituted as First Applicant in place of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (In Liquidation); 2.Colin Andrew Sharp as trustee of the Sharp Family Trust be substituted as Second Applicant in place of Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd; and 3.Colin Andrew Sharp have leave to bring the proceedings on behalf of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) the subject of the Substituted Statement of Claim filed 4 September 2007 in respect of the claims against:3.1The First Respondent pursuant to sections 52 and 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974; 3.2The Second Respondent pursuant to sections 52 and 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974; 3.3The Third Respondent pursuant to sections 52, 75B and 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974 and sections 10 and 79 of the Fair Trading Act 1987; and 3.4The Third Respondent pursuant to sections 52, 75B and 82 of the Trade Practices Act 1974; and sections 10 and 79 of the Fair Trading Act 1987. BACKGROUND The defendants’ written outline of submissions correctly sets out the relevant background to this motion. It is convenient to repeat that history here. The plaintiffs’ Substituted Statement of Claim lodged 4 September 2007 can be divided into claims made on behalf of the first plaintiff, Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (In liquidation) (“Pearl Coast”) and claims made on behalf of the second plaintiff, Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd (“Liquid”). It should be noted that this pleading contains both in its heading and in the text of the statement of claim the purported substituted parties. That is obviously premature. Whilst acknowledging that difficulty, it is nonetheless convenient for present purposes to refer to its contents in these reasons. In summary, Pearl Coast’s claims are:(a)a claim against Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd (“Cossack”), Dampier Pearling Company Pty Ltd (“Dampier”), Lindsay Kevin Brady (“Brady”) and Paul John Thomas (“Thomas”) under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) (“TPA”) for loss or damage suffered by Pearl Coast as a result of alleged misleading and deceptive representations made in 1997 and 1998; (b)a claim against Brady and Thomas under the Fair Trading Act 1987 (WA) (“FTA”) for loss or damage suffered by Pearl Coast as a result of alleged misleading and deceptive representations made in 1997 and 1998; (c)a claim for breach of contract against Cossack for loss and damage arising from an alleged breach of a term of the 1997 Agreement; (d)a claim for breach of contract against Dampier for loss and damage arising from an alleged breach of a term of a the Dampier Pearling Agreement; (e)a claim for breach of contract against Cossack in relation to of the 1999 Pearl Fishing Agreement; and (f)a claim for wrongful repudiation against Cossack in relation to of the 1999 Pearl Fishing Agreement. In summary, Liquid’s claims are:(a)a claim against Cossack under the TPA for loss or damage suffered by Liquid as a result of alleged misleading and deceptive conduct occurring in 2001; and (b)a claim against Brady and Thomas under the FTA for loss or damage suffered by Liquid as a result of alleged misleading and deceptive conduct occurring in 2001.SUBSTITUTION OF PARTIES

Decision

Reasons for decision

GILMOUR J
The liquidators do not oppose the application so long as neither they nor Pearl Coast are liable for any adverse costs orders. Mr Sharp has already paid from his own funds in excess of $21,000 on behalf of Pearl Coast, by way of costs and interest on those costs so that the action could proceed. By clause 4 of the Deed of Assignment it was agreed that Pearl Coast would not be liable for costs in connection with the action. I infer from this that Mr Sharp would be personally liable. That of course is no comfort to the defendants who, if successful, would likely obtain a costs order against Pearl Coast which in practical terms would be of no value. CONCLUSION I am satisfied that leave ought to be granted subject to the following further orders. First, there should be an order that Mr Sharp indemnify Pearl Coast against costs and expenses incurred, including any adverse costs orders, provided however that, in the event that Pearl Coast succeeds in recovering damages or other monies through the derivative action, he may apply to the Court for reimbursement of the expenses he has met. See by analogy Carpenter v Pioneer Park Pty Ltd (in Liq) (2004) 211 ALR 457 at [39]. Second, there should be an order that Mr Sharp indemnify the defendants in respect of any costs ordered as against Pearl Coast and which are not satisfied. Mr Sharp should also provide security for these costs. APPLICATION TO AMEND CAPACITY OF SECOND PLAINTIFF Mr Sharp also applies under O 13 r 2(6) of the Federal Court Rules to be substituted for Liquid as trustee for the Sharp Family Trust, the second plaintiff. Order 13 r 2(6) permits an amendment to alter the capacity in which a party sues if the new capacity is one which that party had at the date of the commencement of the proceeding or has since acquired. Liquid claims damages under the TPA and the FTA caused by its asserted reliance upon representations pleaded in the Substituted Statement of Claim as the “Continuing Representations”. It pleads that upon such reliance it purchased certain residential properties in the Perth metropolitan area between 1999 and 2001 and that in and after mid 2001, it entered into contracts to purchase further residential properties in the metropolitan area subject to finance approval. In his affidavit sworn 23 January 2008, Mr Sharp deposes that Liquid was created, in effect, for the sole purpose of acting as the trustee for the Sharp Family Trust and that Liquid was so appointed under the Sharp Family Trust Deed executed on 16 April 1998. Mr Sharp also deposes that the only activity which Liquid undertook was to act as trustee of the Sharp Family Trust. He says that it was in this capacity that Liquid purchased the properties identified in para 65 of the Substituted Statement of Claim and entered into contracts to purchase the properties identified in para 68 of the Substituted Statement of Claim. He also says that it was in its capacity as trustee of the Sharp Family Trust that Liquid commenced these proceedings by application dated 31 August 2004. He deposes that on 8 September 2005, he was appointed as the trustee of the Sharp Family Trust in place of Liquid and a copy of the minutes of the meeting so appointing him are in evidence. Liquid, it appears, was deregistered on 27 October 2005, not long after Mr Sharp’s appointment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GILMOUR J

The court considered the application to substitute Colin Andrew Sharp as the First Applicant in place of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (In Liquidation). The liquidators did not oppose the substitution as long as neither they nor Pearl Coast would be liable for any adverse costs orders. The court inferred that Mr Sharp would be personally liable for any costs and that if the defendants were successful, they would likely obtain a costs order against Pearl Coast, which would be of no practical value. The court decided to grant the application on the condition that Mr Sharp would indemnify Pearl Coast against costs and expenses incurred in the proceedings, including any adverse costs orders, with the possibility of reimbursement if Pearl Coast succeeds in recovering damages.

Regarding the substitution of Colin Andrew Sharp as the Second Applicant in place of Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd, the court found that Mr Sharp was appointed as the trustee of the Sharp Family Trust in place of Liquid on 8 September 2005. Liquid was deregistered on 27 October 2005, not long after Mr Sharp's appointment. The court concluded that the substitution was appropriate as Mr Sharp had the capacity to bring the proceedings on behalf of Liquid.

The court granted Colin Andrew Sharp leave to bring the proceedings on behalf of Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) and Liquid Investments (WA) Pty Ltd, subject to the conditions mentioned above. The court found that the application to amend the capacity of the Second Plaintiff was permissible under O 13 r 2(6) of the Federal Court Rules, as Mr Sharp had the capacity to act as the trustee of the Sharp Family Trust.

In summary, the court applied the legal principles outlined in the Federal Court Rules and in relevant case law to grant the plaintiffs' application to substitute parties and grant leave to bring the proceedings, subject to certain conditions regarding indemnification and security for costs.