Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) & Carnie (Non Party)

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

RAGLESS v IPA HOLDINGS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) & CARNIE (NON PARTY)

[2012] SASC 203

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice White

6 November 2012

CORPORATIONS - MEMBERSHIP, RIGHTS AND REMEDIES - MEMBERS' REMEDIES AND INTERNAL DISPUTES - PROCEEDINGS ON BEHALF OF COMPANY BY MEMBER - STATUTORY DERIVATIVE ACTION

The plaintiff was granted leave under s 237 of the Corporations Act 2011 (Cth) to bring proceedings on behalf of the defendant - the grant of leave was confirmed on appeal - the plaintiff commenced proceedings in the name of the defendant against the applicant and his company ("the 2009 Action") - the applicant and his company then issued a third party notice to the plaintiff and his company.

The applicant now seeks an order revoking the grant of leave, contending that the plaintiff is not acting in good faith or in the best intersts of the company, as required by s 237.

He contends the plaintiff has now caused the defendant to make claims of a materially different kind from those contemplated by him when seeking leave; that the plaintiff is conducting the 2009 Action in a partisan way and in pursuit of interests other than his interest as a shareholder; and that the plaintiff is conducting the 2009 Action for an ulterior motive based on personal animus and malice.

Held (dismissing the application): 

(1)  the present application is not an occasion to re-agitate complaints about the Master's decision to grant leave, nor to determine issues of construction of a deed which are at the heart of the issues to be determined in the 2009 Action (at [13]-[16], [41], [53]-[54]);

(2) the plaintiff obtained leave as a shareholder of the defendant, in accordance with s 236(1) of the Act, and the plaintiff retains standing in that capacity (at [44]);

(3) the claim which the defendant may have against the plaintiff and his company can be heard and determined in the third party action (at [51]-[52]);

(4) when derivative proceedings are to be brought for a proper purpose, the fact that the applicant for leave may be motivated by some personal animus is not decisive (at [57]);

(5) it has not been shown that the plaintiff is not acting in good faith nor in the best interests of the defendant in the 2009 Action (at [61]).

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 236, s 237, s 241; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006  (SA) r 242, referred to.
BP Chemicals ANZ Pty Ltd v Manildra Starches Pty Ltd [1997] FCA 1189; Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd (2008) 227 FLR 43; Fiduciary Ltd v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd [2005] NSWSC 442; Iliopoulos v BM 2008 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2010] FCA 787; Maher v Honeysett & Maher Electrical Contractors [2005] NSWSC 859; Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (in liq) v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 927; Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) (2008) 254 LSJS 225; Swansson…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) & Carnie (No... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 203
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in Liquidation) & Carnie (Non Party) involved a legal dispute between Mr. Carnie and Mr. Ragless over the legitimacy of a statutory derivative action brought by Mr. Ragless on behalf of IPA Holdings Pty Ltd, a company in liquidation. The court was tasked with deciding whether the leave granted to Mr. Ragless under Section 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) was valid, particularly in light of Mr. Carnie's contention that the action was not in the best interests of the company and that Mr. Ragless was not acting in good faith.

Mr. Carnie argued that the proceedings were not in the best interests of IPA Holdings Pty Ltd, a company in liquidation, and that Mr. Ragless did not act in good faith. He also raised the issue that Section 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) might not apply to companies in liquidation. The court examined these arguments and assessed whether there was sufficient evidence to support Mr. Carnie's claims.

The court found that Mr. Carnie had not substantiated his claims that Mr. Ragless was not acting in good faith or that the derivative action was not in the best interests of the company. The evidence provided by Mr. Carnie did not convincingly indicate that Mr. Ragless had ulterior motives or lacked a genuine belief in the merits of the case. Consequently, the court dismissed Mr. Carnie's application for revocation of the grant of leave under Section 237 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The decision affirmed that the original grant of leave was valid and that Mr. Ragless was entitled to proceed with the derivative action on behalf of IPA Holdings Pty Ltd.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Several of Mr Carnie’s submissions depended for their force on the construction of a trust deed to which I will refer shortly. An application of the present kind is not the appropriate occasion on which the proper construction of the deed should be addressed.Background The background circumstances to Mr Carnie’s application are unusual. They are set out in some detail in the reasons of Debelle J which comprised the reasons of the Full Court.[7] Although the parties in the present proceedings referred to additional features of the background, I did not understand them to contend that the summary contained in the reasons of Debelle J is inaccurate in any material respect. Accordingly, the following summary is substantially derived from the reasons of Debelle J.[7] Ragless v IPA Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) [2008] SASC 90 at [2]-[18]; (2008) 254 LSJS 225 at 255-8. Holdings was originally established as the vehicle by which Messrs Ragless and Carnie would conduct a joint venture manufacturing and selling pyrometers, ie, devices for measuring and controlling temperature in an industrial environment. They had originally conducted the business in partnership. In June 1982 they incorporated Holdings (then known as Industrial Pyrometers (Aust) Pty Ltd) to conduct the business as trustee for the Industrial Pyrometers (Aust) Pty Ltd Unit Trust (the IPA Trust). The IPA Trust has issued two units: one held by Manufacturing as trustee of the Ragless Family Trust, controlled by Mr Ragless; and the other held by Onetemp as trustee of the Carnie Family Trust, controlled by Mr Carnie. Onetemp has previously had different names, including the name “Industrial Pyrometers (Aust) Pty Ltd”, but it is convenient to refer to it throughout by its present name. Holdings has a paid‑up capital of $2 represented by two fully paid ordinary shares of $1 each. One share is held by Mr Ragless and the other by Mr Carnie. The IPA Trust Deed contemplated that the Trust would terminate in June 2003 (unless terminated earlier in accordance with the Deed (cl 10), but that did not occur). Upon termination of the IPA Trust, it was intended that the assets and goodwill of the business would be sold and the proceeds distributed to the unit holders (cl 12). Either unit holder was to be at liberty to purchase the assets and goodwill of the IPA Trust from the other. However, late in 1990 Messrs Ragless and Carnie made a further agreement to which effect was given in February 1991. Mr Ragless and his company Manufacturing took over the manufacture of the sensors used in the pyrometers, and Mr Carnie and his company took over the sales of the sensors as well as the controllers which also formed part of the pyrometers. That division occurred in 1991 but the agreement concerning it was not reduced to writing until 25 June 1999 when the parties (and others) executed a deed (the 1999 Deed). The 1999 Deed provided for the lease of Holdings manufacturing assets to Manufacturing and of its sales assets to Onetemp respectively, with a licence to each respectively to manufacture sensors and to sell sensors and controllers (cl 4). The consideration for the lease and licence was the payment by each company of $75,000 per annum to Holdings (cl 4.2). The 1999 Deed provided that the goodwill of the business was to remain with Holdings (cl 3).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It is not necessary to describe the content of the correspondence in any detail. It is sufficient to say that at least some of the correspondence provides a reasonable basis for the assertions which Mr Carnie makes with respect to the animus of Mr Ragless. However, five of the seven communications upon which Mr Carnie relies were made before the Full Court decision. It was open to Mr Carnie to adduce this evidence in the proceedings before the Master and, possibly, on the appeal. His omission to do so has not been explained. The remaining two communications may indicate some pleasure by Mr Ragless at the successes which he perceived he had had in the interlocutory proceedings in the 2009 Action but they cannot reasonably be understood as indicative of an ulterior motive for the whole of the 2009 Action, for example, to cause Mr Carnie embarrassment, personal pain or poverty. Nor can they reasonably be understood as indicating an absence of a belief by Mr Ragless that Holdings has a good cause of action against Onetemp.Conclusion For these reasons, I consider that Mr Carnie has not made good his claims that Mr Ragless is not acting in good faith and that the 2009 Action is not in the best interests of Holdings. That being so, it is unnecessary to address Mr Carnie’s submissions concerning the inapplicability of s 237 to companies in liquidation or the exercise of the Court’s inherent power in circumstances such as the present.[17][17] See Chahwan v Euphoric Pty Ltd [2008] NSWCA 52; (2008) 227 FLR 43; Pearl Coast Divers Pty Ltd (in liq) v Cossack Pearls Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 927; Iliopoulos v BM2008 Pty Ltd (in liq) [2010] FCA 787. Mr Carnie’s application for revocation of the grant of leave under s 237 is dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Carnie seeks an order revoking the grant of leave made on 2 July 2007. He contends that Mr Ragless is not acting in good faith nor in the best interests of Holdings as was required by s 237(2)(b) and (c) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) for the grant of leave. Mr Carnie points in addition to decisions since that of the Full Court in 2008 to the effect that s 237 is not applicable in the case of companies in liquidation, as is the case with Holdings. He accepts that this is not an independent ground for revocation of the grant of leave but contends that it is a matter to be taken into account if the Court is satisfied that one or other of his two principal grounds is made out.Preliminary Considerations Mr Carnie’s submissions were made primarily on the basis that the grant of leave by the Master on 2 July 2007 was an interlocutory decision, so that the principles relating to the revocation by the Court of one of its earlier interlocutory decisions are pertinent. In retrospect, this issue should have received more attention at the hearing as it is by no means plain that the Master’s decision and order should be characterised as interlocutory in nature. In New South Wales the contrary view is taken: Swansson v Pratt;[2] Fiduciary Ltd v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd;[3] and Maher v Honeysett & Maher Electrical Contractors.[4] On the other hand, the power vested in the Court by s 237(1) is to grant leave to bring proceedings or to intervene in proceedings. A decision concerning intervention is more obviously of an interlocutory kind than the former. If it is interlocutory, then a decision in the exercise of the same statutory power granting leave to bring proceedings may also be interlocutory. It may also be pertinent that s 237(1)(d) incorporates the standard for interlocutory injunctions.[2] [2002] NSWSC 583 at [24].[3] [2005] NSWSC 442 at [15].[4] [2005] NSWSC 859 at [12]. Counsel for Mr Carnie adverted, albeit briefly, to r 242 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 which permits this Court, in limited circumstances, to vary or set aside a final judgment. His submissions did not indicate, however, a circumstance in which r 242 could be invoked in the present circumstances. As the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) applies nationally, the courts in the various States and Territories should apply a consistent approach to its construction and application. That indicates that this Court should follow the approach taken in the New South Wales cases. On the other hand, Mr Ragless did not contest the view that the Court was being asked to revoke one of its own previous interlocutory decisions nor the view that the principles relating to such a revocation are appropriate. I consider that it is not necessary for me to reach a concluded view about the matter because, on the view most favourable to Mr Carnie, I am satisfied that his present application should fail. I will accordingly address his submissions on the basis that the Master’s original decision granting leave under s 237 was interlocutory in nature but without thereby implying that that is the proper view of the matter.