Scott v Northern Territory of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Scott v Northern Territory of Australia & Anor [2003] FCA 658

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – multiple proceedings – abuse of process – action commenced in Northern Territory Supreme Court apt to comprehend causes of action and fresh particulars sued on in Federal Court – Commonwealth sued colourably to attract Federal jurisdiction for action against Northern Territory – embarrassing pleadings – whether any cause of action apparent

TERRITORIES – Northern Territory not mere agent or delegate of Commonwealth – Commonwealth not vicariously liable for alleged acts of Northern Territory prison officers

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – police decisions to investigate – whether amenable to judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) – whether reviewable by prerogative writs or otherwise

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)

Compensation (Fatal Injuries) Act 1979 (NT), ss 7, 8

Coroners Act 1993 (NT)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth), s 44

Limitation Act 1981 (NT), s 12

Racial Discrimination Act 1975 (Cth)

Royal Commission Act 1902 (Cth)

The Constitution (Cth), s 75

Capital Duplicators Pty Ltd v Australian Capital Territory (1992) 177 CLR 248, referred

Commonwealth v Connell (1986) 5 NSWLR 218, referred

Deatons Pty Ltd v Flow (1949) 79 CLR 370, referred

Fittock v The Queen [2003] HCA 19, applied

General Steel Industries Inc v Commissioner for Railways (NSW) (1964) 112 CLR 125, applied

Henry v Henry (1995-1996) 185 CLR 571, applied

Hinchcliffe v Commissioner of Police of the Australian Federal Police (2001) 118 FCR 308, applied

Jago v District Court (1989) 168 CLR 23, referred

Sea Culture International Pty Ltd v Scales (1991) 32 FCR 275, referred

LETTY MARIE SCOTT & ANOR v NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA & ANOR
N518 of 2002

LETTY MARIE SCOTT v COMMISSIONER FOR THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE & ORS
N519 of 2002

LETTY MARIE SCOTT & ORS v DAVID R MOORE, AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE & ORS
N916 of 2002

MADGWICK J
1 JULY 2003
SYDNEY


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

N518 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

LETTY MARIE SCOTT
FIRST APPLICANT

NATHAN WILLIAM SCOTT
SECOND APPLICANT

AND:

NORTHERN TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA
FIRST RESPONDENT

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
SECOND RESPONDENT

N519 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

LETTY MARIE SCOTT
FIRST APPLICANT

AND:

COMMISSIONER FOR THE AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
FIRST RESPONDENT

COMMISSIONER FOR THE NORTHERN TERRITORY POLICE
SECOND RESPONDENT

N916 OF 2002

BETWEEN:

LETTY MARIE SCOTT
FIRST APPLICANT

NATHAN WILLIAM SCOTT
SECOND APPLICANT

ROBERT J S DOW
SECOND APPLICANT

DANIEL R TAYLOR
FOURTH APPLICANT

AND:

DAVID R MOORE, AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
FIRST RESPONDENT

AARON APPO, AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
SECOND RESPONDENT

PAUL JEVTOVIC, AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
THIRD RESPONDENT

AUSTRALIAN FEDERAL POLICE
TENTH RESPONDENT

DAVID R MOORE
ELEVENTH RESPONDENT

AARON APPO
TWELVTH RESPONDENT

PAUL JEVTOVIC
THIRTEENTH RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

MADGWICK J

DATE OF ORDER:

1 JULY 2003

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.In each matter, the principal proceeding is dismissed.

2.The respective applicants in the respective cases are to pay the respondents’ costs.

Note:   Settlement and entry…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v Northern Territory of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2003] FCA 658
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Scott v Northern Territory of Australia, the applicants sought to discontinue proceedings without the Supreme Court's approval, raising questions about procedural validity. The court examined whether the proceedings had been legally terminated, particularly in relation to Nathan Scott, an infant at the time of the events. Additionally, the court reviewed fresh evidence presented, including an account from Mr. Bindai, a former inmate, who claimed to have witnessed Mr. Scott being beaten the night before his death. Mr. Bindai alleged threats from a Royal Commission officer, which the court considered in the context of the Royal Commission's thorough investigation.

The legal issues before the court involved the validity of the proceedings, the credibility of fresh evidence, and the applicability of the Royal Commission's findings. The court scrutinized the procedural steps taken to discontinue the proceedings and evaluated the credibility and weight of the fresh evidence. The key question was whether there was credible evidence of criminal wrongdoing by the Commonwealth or the Royal Commission officers. The court also assessed the overall approach and judgments of the Royal Commission, considering its thoroughness and the potential for bias or misconduct.

The court found that the proceedings had not been satisfactorily discontinued and that the fresh evidence, while compelling, did not establish credible evidence of criminal wrongdoing. The Royal Commission's investigation was deemed thorough and credible, and the threats alleged by Mr. Bindai were considered unlikely. The court concluded that the claims against the Commonwealth and the Northern Territory were frivolous and vexatious, amounting to an abuse of process. The court dismissed the principal proceedings and ordered the applicants to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. In each matter, the principal proceeding is dismissed.

2. The respective applicants in the respective cases are to pay the respondents’ costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In the course of the hearing before me, the applicants indicated that they had sent a letter to the Northern Territory Supreme Court seeking to discontinue the proceedings. Question arise as to whether Mrs Scott could do this in respect of Nathan Scott, without the assent of the Supreme Court, and as to whether in procedurally valid terms the proceedings had been discontinued. In the end, it was not satisfactorily proven that any of the Northern Territory proceedings had been terminated. It was noted that the proceedings also included Nathan Scott (an applicant in two of the current proceedings), an infant at the time, and to that extent the limitation period had not commenced.Fresh evidence: Mr Bindai and related material A friend of Mrs Scott and an applicant in one of the cases before me, Mr Dow, a former Northern Territory police officer, interviewed Mr Bindai on 12 April 1995. Mr Bindai said that he saw prison officers enter Mr Scott’s cell the night before he died; one of them was carrying a big black stick. He heard Mr Scott being beaten with the stick and calling for help. This continued for about two hours. Mr Bindai said that he had given this account to the Royal Commission officers who interviewed him. However he was threatened by one of them, Mr Mick Dodson, who said words like “if you don’t shut up mate, you’ll be next”. Mr Dodson was junior counsel assisting the Royal Commission and was and is a well-known and outspoken Aboriginal activist and leader. In a statutory declaration of 27 September 1996 prepared by Mr Rodney Lewis, a Sydney solicitor acting for Mrs Scott, after he spoke to Mr Bindai, Mr Bindai confirmed the story of the beating but said that one of the prison officers had come over to his cell and said “If you don’t be quiet you will be next”. That man had an eagle tattooed on his arm. He said that he had been visited at Turkey Creek (a remote location) by people from the Royal Commission and that he had told them the same story. Apparently he did not repeat to Mr Lewis the allegation about Mr Dodson. In 1996 Mr Lewis spoke to Mr Laurie Percy and his brother Geoffrey Moreen. Mr Percy said that he and his brother Geoffrey had to clean up the cell after the deceased was hanged. He said he saw blood on his sheet and pillow and on the floor. There was “little bit – big mobs” on the sheet, a “little bit” on the pillow and “little bit – big mob” on the floor. There was also a ball of toilet paper with blood on it. Mr Moreen said he heard the deceased calling out loudly in the night “somebody help me”, but he thought he was dreaming and didn’t do anything. In the morning he saw his brother (I assume from the record) and Geoffrey Bindai carrying the mattress out. There were “spots of blood”, a “big mob” of it, on the mattress. Mr Barbaro’s recollections of events in the Royal Commission On 13 March 1995 Mr Lewis interviewed Mr Barbaro, by then attached to the Mental Health Legal Service in Melbourne.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ROBERT J
The photographs (and Mrs Scott’s recollection of her very brief look at the last photographs) at best raise only a possible inference that, as the US experts thought, the integrity of the death scene might have been disturbed. Such a disturbance might obviously be accounted for by stupidity at least as well as by malignity. Why would murderers be likely to re-hang a body any more than innocent persons who might have realised that they or someone else had prematurely lowered the body of a man found dead by hanging? So, in my opinion, might reasonable police officers consider the matter.(v) The weight to be given to the Royal Commission’s approach and judgments by its officers Among the reasons for reproducing here so much of the Royal Commission’s report is to indicate the evident thoroughness and care that attended the investigation and the Commissioner’s consideration of the evidence. It is true that no evidentiary suggestion of murder was made to the Commissioner, and notably not by counsel for Mrs Scott. Of course, counsel are bound ethically not to advance positive suggestions of serious wrongdoing by someone unless they believe there is a proper basis for such a suggestion. Nevertheless, it is clear, if only from recorded interjections by Mrs Scott, that at least she strongly suspected murder and that her attitude must have been communicated to the Commissioner. It is inconceivable that a retired judge of such long and broad experience, necessarily alive to the established realities and allegations of the then recent violence by some prison officers in various parts of Australia, as well as to the realities of violence between prisoners, would not have been keeping a capable and keen eye out for any sign of foul play towards any Aboriginal prisoner who died in custody. For that and other reasons, the police authorities of the Commonwealth and the Northern Territory would be and were well entitled to credit the Royal Commission’s findings with great respect. Having regard to experience in these matters, it is equally inconceivable that the Commissioner’s evident attitude of thorough investigation, letting the cards fall where they may, would not have communicated itself to and have activated those assisting the Royal Commission, if, which all the circumstances would make one doubt, they needed any such activation. Working relationships in such an inquiry are very close. In these circumstances, if, contrary to the contemporaneous record, Mr Barbaro recalled Mr Bindai making some allegation such as he has since made, the view would readily be open that, when he expressed it, Mr Barbaro’s recollection was likely to be mistaken. If it were thought that his recollection might be correct, the view would be well open that there was, during the currency of the Royal Commission, good reason to disbelieve Mr Bindai. There is nothing to indicate that police officers would not be perfectly justified in considering that there is no credible evidence to suggest any criminal wrongdoing by any Commission lawyer. The allegation that Mr Dodson seriously threatened a potential Royal Commission witness with death or a beating, on its face, invites disbelief. The police were, in my opinion, unarguably entitled so to conclude.(vi) Overall

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ROBERT J

That list does not exhaust the orders sought. In substance the complete re-investigation of all the applicant’s allegations of murder, cover-up and wrongdoing in relation to the Royal Commission was sought.Consideration of N518/02(i) The issues In N518/02, the second respondent (the Commonwealth) filed a notice of motion on 8 July 2002 seeking orders that the amended statement of claim filed on 24 June 2002 (since further amended), as against it, be stayed or dismissed pursuant to O 20 r 2(1) of the Federal Court Rules on the grounds that “it does not disclose a reasonable cause of action; and/or is frivolous or vexatious; and/or is embarrassing; and/or is an abuse of process.” The first respondent (the Northern Territory) filed a notice of motion seeking that, as against it, the proceedings be stayed or dismissed on the basis that “no reasonable cause of action is disclosed; the proceedings are frivolous or vexatious; and the proceedings are an abuse of process”. Counsel for the Commonwealth submitted that the application was an abuse of process: the claims against the Commonwealth were said to be merely colourable, being designed to maintain an application in the High Court or this Court against the Northern Territory, when the proceedings in the Supreme Court pleading a similar claim for damages had been dismissed or stayed; it is an abuse of process to bring hopeless claims against one respondent (the Commonwealth) for the purpose of attracting jurisdiction to a court which would otherwise not have jurisdiction to hear proceedings against another respondent (the Northern Territory). Counsel point out that the pleadings suggest that the Commonwealth is liable in three respects:(i)conspiracy by unnamed servants and agents of the Commonwealth who:·agreed to influence the outcome of the Royal Commission so that individual prison officers would not be exposed to criminal charges; ·threatened witnesses and withheld testimony from witnesses; and·sought to corrupt and pervert the Commissioner’s findings in relation to Mr Scott’s death.(ii)breach of a common law duty which arose from a “common law duty to all prisoners in their care”. However, the applicant relies on the particulars provided in relation to the claim of conspiracy, which are claims of conspiracy relating to alleged misconduct in respect of the Royal Commission proceedings.(iii)breach of a statutory duty said to arise from the Royal Commissions Act 1902 (Cth). The Northern Territory supports the Commonwealth’s argument as to abuse of process by forum-shopping. Further, it is said that, even if the allegations made by the applicant that prison officers had murdered Mr Scott were true, the Northern Territory could not be held vicariously liable for such actions. A defendant can only be held vicariously liable for the actions of its servants and/or agents which arise out of or in the course of their employment. The commission of such gross criminal acts as murder could not be regarded as within the scope of the employment.