Scott v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Court of Appeal: Criminal)

SCOTT v COMMISSIONER OF POLICE

[2025] SASCA 83

Judgment of The Honourable Acting Chief Justice Livesey and the Honourable Justice David  (ex tempore)

30 July 2025

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT

MAGISTRATES - GENERALLY - STAY OF PROCEEDINGS AND ABUSE OF PROCESS

This is an application for permission to appeal against a decision by a Supreme Court judge (the appeal judge) to refuse permission to appeal from a decision by a magistrate.

The applicant is being prosecuted in the Magistrates Court.  A magistrate dismissed the applicant’s application for a permanent stay of proceedings, finding that the matters raised in support of the application comprised issues relevant to the trial and did not amount to an abuse of process.

The applicant then sought permission to appeal pursuant to s 42 of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA). The appeal judge refused permission to appeal. The applicant objects to a number of judges sitting on this matter.

The three questions that arose before this Court were:

1.Has the applicant demonstrated a proper basis for Livesey ACJ and David JA to conclude that they should not sit in this matter;

2.Is the refusal to grant a stay an “interlocutory judgment” within the meaning of ss 3 and 42(1a) of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), for which permission to appeal is required; and

3.Has the applicant demonstrated that it is in the interests of justice that permission to appeal be granted by this Court?

Held (Livesey ACJ and David JA), refusing the application to disqualify, refusing an extension of time and refusing permission to appeal:

1.The applicant has failed to demonstrate any proper basis upon which Livesey ACJ and David JA should refrain from sitting on this matter.

2.The applicant has failed to demonstrate that it would be in the interests of justice to grant permission to appeal.

3.      As permission to appeal should be refused, there is no utility in granting an extension of time.

Criminal Law Consolidation Act 1935 (SA) ss 20ab(1)(B), 20(3), S20AA(3); Joint Criminal Rules 2022 (SA) rr 193.1(3), 196.2; Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) ss 3, 42; Summary Offences Act 1953 (SA) s 6(2); Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 50(4)(a)(ii), referred to.
Contract Mining Services Pty Ltd v Adelaide Brighton Cement Ltd [2020] SASC 69; Fede v Police; Di Fede v Police [2023] SASCA 47; DT v Chief Executive of the Department for Child Protection [2021] SASC 138; DT v Chief Executive of The Department for Child Protection [2022] SASCA 28; Ebner v Official Trustee and Bankruptcy (2000) 205 CLR 337; Fletcher v Australian Health Practitioner Regulation Agency [2023] SASCA 36; Harris Scarfe Ltd (in liq) v Ernst & Young (No 2) [2005] SASC 168; Kharisteas v Kharisteas (2021) 273 CLR 289; Kowalski v Mitsubishi Motors Australia Staff Superannuation Pty Ltd & Anor [2017] SASCFC 17; McDonald v Attorney-General for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Scott v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] SASCA 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for permission to appeal to the Supreme Court of South Australia against an interlocutory judgment of a magistrate. The applicant, Mr Scott, sought a permanent stay of proceedings in the Magistrates Court, which the magistrate refused, finding the issues raised were relevant to the trial and did not constitute an abuse of process. The appeal judge also refused permission to appeal, concluding there were no special reasons to permit an appeal before the trial commenced.

The Supreme Court was required to determine whether the appeal judge erred in refusing permission to appeal. This involved considering the provisions of section 42 of the *Magistrates Court Act 1991* (SA), which governs appeals from the Magistrates Court. Specifically, the court had to assess whether the appeal judge correctly applied the criteria for granting permission to appeal against an interlocutory judgment, which requires the applicant to demonstrate "special reasons why it would be in the interests of the administration of justice" for the appeal to be heard before the trial.

The court noted that the applicant objected to several judges sitting on the matter, including the Acting Chief Justice and Justice David, on grounds including prior adverse decisions and previous professional associations. However, the primary focus of the judgment excerpt provided is the refusal of permission to appeal the magistrate's interlocutory decision. The appeal judge's reasoning, as described, was that no "special reasons" existed to justify hearing the appeal prior to the trial, a conclusion the Supreme Court was reviewing.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The magistrate refused to order a permanent stay, finding that the matters raised in support of the application comprised issues relevant to the trial and did not amount to an abuse of process. The decision of the appeal judge The applicant sought permission to appeal pursuant to s 42 of the Magistrates Court Act:42—Appeals (1) A party to a criminal action may, subject to this section and in accordance with the rules of the appellate court, appeal against any judgment given in the action (including a judgment dismissing a charge of a summary or minor indictable offence but not any judgment arising from committal proceedings). (1a) An appeal does not, however, lie against an interlocutory judgment unless— (a) the judgment stays the proceedings; or (b) the judgment destroys or substantially weakens the basis of the prosecution case and, if correct, is likely to lead to abandonment of the prosecution; or (c) the Court or the appellate court is satisfied that there are special reasons why it would be in the interests of the administration of justice to have the appeal determined before commencement or completion of the trial and grants its permission for an appeal. As can be seen, the right to appeal depends upon the identification of a “judgment given in the action”. By s 3 of the Magistrates Court Act, the term “judgment” is defined to mean “a judgment, order or decision and includes an interlocutory judgment”. In the case of an interlocutory judgment, there are constraints on the right to appeal. In particular, in this case it was necessary for the applicant to satisfy the appeal judge that there were “special reasons why it would be in the interests of the administration of justice” to allow the appeal to be determined before the trial and, in addition, it was necessary for the applicant to obtain permission to appeal.[3] [3] Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), s 42(1a)(c). In the course of detailed reasons, the appeal judge found that there were no “special reasons”, and she refused permission to appeal.[4][4] Scott v Police [2025] SASC 64.The Disqualification Application The applicant objects to a number of judges sitting on this matter.[5][5] Apart from Livesey ACJ and David JA, the applicant objects to Kourakis CJ, Doyle and Stanley JJA sitting as well. In the case of Livesey ACJ, the applicant complains that he previously made a decision which was adverse to the applicant and, before his appointment, he had been briefed as counsel by the Independent Commissioner Against Corruption (SA), by the Office for Public Integrity (SA), and by the Crown Solicitor (SA) at a time when the applicant had filed complaints against each of these bodies. In the case of David JA, it is a little harder to determine the basis upon which the objection is made. Presumably, the application is also based on her Honour having previously made a decision adverse to the applicant, because both Livesey ACJ and David JA sat with Doyle JA in the matter of Scott v Scott, decided in 2022.[6][6] Scott v Scott [2022] SASCA 33 (Livesey P, Doyle and David JJA), an ex tempore decision made on 7 April 2022 concerning the making of provision out of the estate of the applicant’s deceased mother in favour of her disabled siblings, as well as other issues. The applicant’s appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established