Rouse v IOOF Australia Trustees Ltd (No 5)

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

ROUSE & ORS V IOOF AUSTRALIA TRUSTEES LTD (NO. 5)

[1999] SASC 294

  1. LANDER J.       This is an application brought by the defendant seeking orders;

  2. That the time within which it may apply for leave to appeal against an order made by me on 30 March 1999 that the defendant deliver up all copies of exhibit “LJH10” not otherwise delivered up in accordance with the Chief Justice’s order of 23 July 1998 be extended.

  1. That it be granted leave to appeal from that decision.

  1. The orders from which leave to appeal is sought were made on the plaintiffs’ senior counsel’s oral application for delivery up of copies of Exhibit LJH10 to the affidavit of Lindon John Huxtable sworn on 16 July 1998 in the possession of the defendant or the defendant’s legal advisers.

  2. That oral application followed an earlier application made by the plaintiffs’ senior counsel to the Chief Justice on 20 and 23 July 1998.

  3. On the later date the Chief Justice ordered by consent:

    “1..... That the defendant by close of business on Wednesday 29 July 1998 delivered to my associate/chambers all copies of the document LJH10 to the affidavit of Mr Huxtable sworn on 16 July 1998.

    2.That the defendant’s solicitors, Johnson Winter & Slattery be permitted to retain one copy of that document and counsel, Mr Abbott QC, be permitted to retain a further copy of the document but that the content of the document is not to be communicated by the solicitors or by counsel to any other person except to the extent that it is necessary to do for the purpose of obtaining instructions from their client in connection with the application for the return of the remaining documents.”

  4. It can be seen therefore that at the time that senior counsel for the plaintiffs made the oral application to which I have referred all of the copies of Exhibit LJH10 should have been delivered to the Chief Justice’s associate, except for the two copies referred to in paragraph 2 of the Chief Justice’s order.

  5. The documents which were contained in Exhibit LJH10 were copies of the plaintiffs’ documents which had been inadvertently left by the plaintiffs’ legal advisers in the premises of the defendant when the plaintiffs’ legal advisers were taking inspection of the defendant’s documents.

  6. Most, although not all of the documents were documents to which legal professional privilege would ordinarily attach, being communications between the plaintiffs and the plaintiffs’ legal advisers.

  7. When the documents came to the attention of the defendant, the defendant gave them to its solicitors who retained those documents in their possession.  Subsequently they copied those documents to other solicitors and counsel acting for the defendant in another action and to counsel in these proceedings and to various other parties.

  8. The defendant retained the originals of these documents and later the copies because it wished to use the documents for the purpose of supporting an application for a stay of the plaintiff proceedings upon the ground that the proceedings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rouse v IOOF Australia Trustees Ltd (No 5) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] SASC 294
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Rouse v IOOF Australia Trustees Ltd (No 5) concerns an application by the defendant, IOOF Australia Trustees Ltd, for leave to appeal against an order made by the court on 30 March 1999. The order required the defendant to deliver up all copies of exhibit "LJH10" not previously handed over as per the Chief Justice's order of 23 July 1998. The legal issues at hand revolve around the criteria for granting leave to appeal and the implications of the decision on the substantive rights of the parties.

The court had to determine whether the defendant met the criteria for leave to appeal from an interlocutory order under Rule 94.01 of the Supreme Court Rules. The criteria for such an appeal generally require the applicant to demonstrate that the matter involves sufficient doubt to warrant reconsideration on appeal and that the applicant will suffer substantial injustice without leave. The court also considered whether the defendant's application was made within the prescribed time frame and whether the documents in question had any relevance outside the context of the stay application.

In delivering the judgment, Lander J concluded that the defendant failed to meet the criteria for leave to appeal. The decision involved a straightforward assessment of the documents in question and did not raise any significant legal issues or matters of general importance. Even if the decision had been different, it would not have necessarily led to a different outcome in the stay application, as the stay application had already been dismissed. Additionally, the documents in question had no relevance outside the stay application and would not be relevant on the substantive issues. Therefore, the court dismissed the defendant's application for leave to appeal and refused the request for an extension of time to bring the application.

Background

Background to the litigation

The plaintiffs' documents, inadvertently left by the plaintiffs' legal advisers in the premises of the defendant, were discovered by the defendant. These documents, contained in Exhibit LJH10, were copies of communications between the plaintiffs and their legal advisers. The defendant retained the originals and copies of these documents and intended to use them to support an application for a stay of the plaintiffs' proceedings on the ground of abuse of process. The defendant argued that these documents showed evidence of a collateral purpose for which the proceedings had been brought, thereby negating legal professional privilege. The plaintiffs sought the delivery up of all copies of Exhibit LJH10 not previously delivered up. The Chief Justice had ordered the defendant to deliver up all copies of the document except for two retained by the defendant's solicitors and counsel. The defendant did not seek leave to appeal from the decision but filed a notice of appeal against the order. The plaintiffs applied for the notice of appeal to be dismissed as incompetent, and the appeal was subsequently dismissed.

This case involves an application by the defendant, IOOF Australia Trustees Ltd, seeking an extension of time to apply for leave to appeal against an order made by the court on 30 March 1999. The order required the defendant to deliver up all copies of Exhibit LJH10, which were not previously delivered in accordance with the Chief Justice’s order of 23 July 1998. The defendant did not seek leave to appeal from the initial decision but filed a notice of appeal against the order. The plaintiffs applied for the notice of appeal to be dismissed as incompetent, which was granted by the court on 20 May 1999. The defendant subsequently applied for leave to appeal from the decision of 30 March 1999 and the orders made on 31 March 1999 and 1 April 1999.

Decision

Reasons for decision

LANDER J
Issues
1. Whether the time within which the defendant may apply for leave to appeal against the order made on 30 March 1999 should be extended.
2. Whether the defendant should be granted leave to appeal from the decision of 30 March 1999 and the orders made on 31 March 1999 and 1 April 1999.

Held
1. The court refused the application for an extension of time within which to bring the application for leave to appeal.
2. The court dismissed the application for leave to appeal from the decision of 30 March 1999 and the orders made on 31 March 1999 and 1 April 1999.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LANDER J

The court considered the statutory provisions and rules governing appeals from interlocutory orders, noting the legislative intent to limit appeals from such decisions. It highlighted the broad discretion courts have in granting leave to appeal, with guidelines suggesting that the matter must be of sufficient doubt or involve an error in principle to warrant reconsideration. The court also emphasized that appeals from interlocutory decisions are less likely to be granted if they involve pure practice and procedure. In this case, the court found that the decision from which leave to appeal was sought involved a straightforward assessment of the evidential value of certain documents, without raising any significant questions of law or matters of general importance. The court concluded that the defendant could not show any potential for injustice if leave were not granted, as the decision would not necessarily lead to a different outcome in relation to the stay application or the proceedings against the remaining plaintiffs. Additionally, the court noted that the defendant had already exhausted its appeal rights by filing an incompetent notice of appeal, which was subsequently dismissed. Thus, the application for leave to appeal was dismissed, and consequently, the application for an extension of time was also refused.