T.G Bullen Nominees v Bullen

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal to a Single Judge)

T.G BULLEN NOMINEES v BULLEN & ANOR

[2024] SASC 95

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Bleby  

25 July 2024

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - DISCOVERY AND INTERROGATORIES - DISCOVERY AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - PRODUCTION AND INSPECTION OF DOCUMENTS - GROUNDS FOR RESISTING PRODUCTION - IRRELEVANCE

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - RIGHT OF APPEAL - WHEN APPEAL LIES - ERROR OF LAW - PARTICULAR CASES INVOLVING ERROR OF LAW - FAILURE TO GIVE REASONS FOR DECISION - ADEQUACY OF REASONS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - IN GENERAL

Appeal before a single judge against orders of an auxiliary master of the Supreme Court.

On 31 August 2023, a master made orders on an Originating Application as well as on an Interlocutory Application filed by the respondents requesting the production of trust documents by the Trustee T.G Bullen Nominees.

The main issues arising on the appeal were whether the master erred in finding that the Originating Application had been resolved by consent, whether the master’s ‘implicit’ finding that the appellant had not complied with s 84B of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) (‘Trustee Act’) such as to permit an exercise of the Supreme Court’s inherent supervisory jurisdiction was erroneous, and whether the master erred in making orders on an interlocutory application that ‘did not conform’ with the statutory duty imposed by s 84B of the Trustee Act.

Order 1 of the master’s orders, which appeared to have been made on the Originating Application, was in exhaustive terms, requiring production of all Trust records dating back to May 2012. The appellants contended, however, that certain of the documents were subject to claims of privilege and that some documents the matter of dispute were not trust documents at all. They submitted that the making of the order left no room for a trial of all the issues that it wished to raise in respect of certain records.

Order 2 required production of a list of documents in certain categories and if no document existed of a given description, to state ‘Nil held’. Order 3 provided that to the extent that the appellants claimed privilege on any of the documents listed in Order 2, they were to furnish to the Court, with a copy to the respondents, a list specifying each document effectively in the form of a Kadlunga list.

Ultimately, the respondents did not seek to defend Order 1.

Held, granting leave to appeal insofar as necessary, allowing the appeal on Grounds 1 and 4.2 and setting aside Orders 1, 2 and 3:

1.Order 1 had the effect of denying the appellant a trial on whether it was required to produce any documents beyond those which it had already produced.

2.It was first necessary that the remaining issues be defined in the proceeding. That could be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read T.G Bullen Nominees v Bullen and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 95
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by T.G Bullen Nominees against Bullen, concerning a dispute related to the discovery and inspection of documents under the Trustee Act and Trustee Regulations. The central issue was whether certain documents should be produced and inspected under the regulatory framework governing trustees. Specifically, the dispute centred on whether the documents in question were relevant and whether there were grounds to resist their production. The appeal also questioned the adequacy of the reasons given by the master for the decisions made.

The court examined the legal principles regarding the discovery and inspection of documents, the relevance of documents in such proceedings, and the adequacy of reasons provided for decisions. It was determined that the master had erred in making certain orders without sufficient justification. The court found that the master had not adequately considered the relevance of the documents in question and had not properly exercised the discretion to resist production. Furthermore, the court held that the master's reasons for the decisions were inadequate, as they did not sufficiently explain the basis for the orders made.

In light of the findings, the court granted the appeal on the grounds that the master had erred in law and the reasons provided were inadequate. The orders made by the master were set aside, and the matter was remitted for reconsideration. The court emphasised the importance of careful consideration and adequate reasoning when making decisions about the discovery and inspection of documents in trust administration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a sufficient description of the issues arising for introductory purposes. However, it is necessary to understand the history that led to the making of the orders of which the appellant now complains.Background Section 84B of the Trustee Act provides:84B—Records to be kept by trustee(1)A trustee shall keep such records relating to his administration of the trust property as may be prescribed.Maximum penalty: $500.(2)A trustee shall, at the request of—(a) the Public Trustee; or(b) another trustee of the trust; or(c) a beneficiary under the trust,produce the records kept by the trustee in pursuance of this section for inspection and permit the Public Trustee, the other trustee or the beneficiary (as the case may be) to examine and make copies of those records.Maximum penalty: $500. Regulation 5 of the Trustee Regulations 2011 (SA) (‘the Regulations’) provides:5—Records to be kept by trustee(1)For the purposes of section 84B of the Act, the records that a trustee must keep relating to administration of the trust property are as follows:(a) each document authorising the trustee to act as trustee;(b) each letter received by the trustee and a copy of each letter sent by the trustee;(c) a copy of each statutory declaration and each affidavit made in the course of the administration of the trust;(d) each deed, agreement or other instrument varying distribution of the trust property or a stamped duplicate of any such deed, agreement or instrument;(e) a copy of all returns made as to any form of duty, charge or tax imposed on the trust by the Commonwealth or any State or Territory of the Commonwealth (including trust income tax returns and personal tax returns for beneficiaries where applicable);(f) all written instructions for the sale or transfer of any trust property or any asset which forms or formed part of the trust property and any independent valuations obtained in relation to those assets;(g) minutes of the proceedings of all meetings relating to administration of the trust at which the trustee was or was entitled to be present;(h) a record of any insurance cover in respect of the assets which form or formed part of the trust property;(i) any report received from an investment adviser and a record of all decisions made in relation to such report;(j) a record of all reviews of investments;(k) other records that would enable the receipt and disposition of trust property to be conveniently and properly audited, including the following:(i)a register of securities recording the following information in respect of all securities received and disposed of:(A) the date of receipt or disposition;(B) a description of the securities;(C) the consideration passing for receipt or disposition;(D) brief particulars of the purpose of the transaction;(ii)a property register recording the following information in respect of all other property received and disposed of:(A) the date of receipt or disposition;(B) a description of the property;(C) the consideration passing for receipt or disposition;(D) brief particulars of the purpose of the transaction;(iii) a register of all investments of income and capital funds (including redemptions and income accretions) recording the following information in respect of each investment:(A) the date of investment;(B) the amount of the funds invested;(C) brief particulars of the investment;(iv)a cash receipt book recording the following information in respect of each receipt of trust money:(A) the date and reference number of each receipt;(B) the name of the person from whom the money is received;(C) the trust name or reference to which the transaction relates;(D) brief particulars of the purpose of the receipt;(E) the amount of the receipt;(F) the date the cash receipted is deposited in an ADI account q (where applicable);(v)a cash payments book recording the following information in respect of each payment of trust money:(A) the date of the payment;(B) if the payment was made by cheque—the cheque number;(C) the name of the payee;(D) the trust name or reference to which the transaction relates;(E) brief particulars of the purpose of the payment;(F) the amount of the payment;(vi)each ADI statement and passbook issued in relation to trust ADI accounts;(vii)trust statements, prepared not less than annually, showing the following for the period from the end of the last period for which a statement was prepared:(A) cash receipts and payments;(B) other property received or transferred;(C) assets and liabilities as at the last day of the statement period.(2)Where the trustee administers more than 1 trust, separate records must be kept, in accordance with this regulation, in relation to each trust administered by the trustee.(3)All records referred to in this regulation must be retained by the trustee, in a legible written form or so as to be readily convertible into such a form, for at least 5 years after the termination of the trust.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that in my view, in making Orders 2 and 3 on FDN 18, the master erred.Conclusion I grant leave to appeal insofar as is necessary. I allow the appeal on Grounds 1 and 4.2. I set aside the master’s order of 31 August 2023.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established