Republic of Croatia v Snedden

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FRENCH CJ,
GUMMOW, HAYNE, HEYDON, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ

REPUBLIC OF CROATIA  APPELLANT

AND

DANIEL SNEDDEN  RESPONDENT

Republic of Croatia v Snedden [2010] HCA 14
Date of Order:  30 March 2010
Date of Publication of Reasons:  19 May 2010
S24/2010

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed with costs.

2.Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 2 September 2009 and the further orders of that Court made on 4 September 2009 and, in place of those orders, order that:

(a)In addition to the order made by Justice Cowdroy on 3 February 2009, it be ordered that the orders made by Deputy Chief Magistrate Cloran on 12 April 2007 are confirmed;

(b)Subject to paragraph (a), the appeal be dismissed with costs.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

M A Perry QC with H Younan for the appellant (instructed by Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions)

B W Walker SC with C D Jackson for the respondent (instructed by Schreuder Partners Lawyers)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

  1. The respondent was born in the former Yugoslavia in 1954 and migrated to Australia in 1969, taking up Australian citizenship in 1975.  He was named Dragan Vasiljkovic at birth but changed his name to Daniel Snedden when assuming Australian citizenship.  He is said to have been the commander of a Special Purpose Unit of Serbian paramilitary troops during the Croatian-Serbian conflict in the early 1990s following the fall of communism in Yugoslavia[1].

    [1]For a brief review of the relevant history of the conflict see Travica v The Government of Croatia [2004] EWHC 2747 (Admin) at [7]-[10].

  2. On 20 January 2006, the Republic of Croatia ("the Republic") issued a request to the Australian Government for the extradition of the respondent to Croatia.  The respondent's extradition was sought so that he could be prosecuted for offences against Arts 120 and 122 of the Basic Penal Code of the Republic of Croatia.  The Republic alleged, in its request, that during June and July 1991 in Knin the respondent did nothing to prevent members of the Unit who were his subordinates from mistreating captured members of the Croatian army and police and mistreated one such person himself.  It also alleged that, in February 1993, he commanded subordinate members of the Unit to interrogate and then execute two Croatian prisoners of war.  Those allegations formed the basis of the claimed contraventions of Art 122.  In relation to the alleged offence against Art 120, he is said to have commanded members of the Special Purpose Unit and a tank unit of the Yugoslav People's Army to fire on a church and a school.

  3. In proceedings before a magistrate under s 19 of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth) to determine his eligibility for surrender, the respondent contended, inter alia, that there were substantial grounds for believing that if surrendered to Croatia he might…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Republic of Croatia v Snedden and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal concerning the extradition of Daniel Snedden (formerly Dragan Vasiljkovic) to the Republic of Croatia. Croatia sought Snedden's extradition to face charges of war crimes allegedly committed while he commanded Serbian paramilitary troops during the conflict in the Krajina region between 1991 and 1993. Snedden opposed his extradition, arguing that there were substantial grounds for believing an extradition objection existed under section 7(c) of the *Extradition Act 1988* (Cth), which states an objection arises if a person may be prejudiced at their trial by reason of their political opinions.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether Snedden had demonstrated substantial grounds for believing he would be prejudiced at his trial in Croatia due to his political opinions, as contemplated by section 7(c) of the *Extradition Act*. This required the Court to consider how prejudice by reason of political opinions was to be determined under the Act, specifically whether a person's participation in armed forces during a conflict could be ascribed to a class of persons holding particular political opinions, and whether this could lead to prejudice at trial.

The High Court reasoned that the application of a mitigating factor in Croatian law for service in the Croatian armed forces during the conflict did not, in itself, demonstrate that the Croatian courts considered the political opinions of those who did not serve. The Court found no logical connection or causal link to support the Full Court of the Federal Court's conclusion that the mitigating factor operated "by reference to" Snedden's political beliefs. The Court determined that the Full Court's factual conclusions were not supported by the evidence.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court. The High Court confirmed the orders made by Deputy Chief Magistrate Cloran on 12 April 2007, which had previously confirmed the extradition, and dismissed the appeal to the Full Court with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 2 September 2009 and the further orders of that Court made on 4 September 2009 and, in place of those orders, order that:

(a) In addition to the order made by Justice Cowdroy on 3 February 2009, it be ordered that the orders made by Deputy Chief Magistrate Cloran on 12 April 2007 are confirmed;

(b) Subject to paragraph (a), the appeal be dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

This appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Bennett, Flick and McKerracher JJ) ("the Full Court") concerns an extradition request from the Republic of Croatia ("Croatia") in relation to the respondent, Daniel Snedden. Formerly known as Dragan Vasiljkovic, the respondent is accused of having committed criminal offences against the Basic Penal Code of the Republic of Croatia ("the Croatian Code").Background The respondent is a citizen of the former state union of Serbia and Montenegro and of Australia. He emigrated with his family to Australia from Serbia (then part of the former Yugoslavia) as a teenager and took his current name when he became an Australian citizen. He is said to have been the military commander of a "Special Purpose Unit" of Serbian paramilitary troops which fought in the Krajina area in the periods of June and July 1991 and February 1993. On 28 November 2005 the Sibenik County Public Prosecutor's Office in Croatia submitted a request to a magistrate of the County Court in Sibenik for investigation into war crimes against prisoners of war and civilians allegedly committed by the respondent. On 12 December 2005 the County Court in Sibenik decided that there was a "well-founded suspicion" that the respondent had committed such offences. On 10 January 2006 the County Court in Sibenik ordered a warrant for the respondent's arrest to be issued. On 19 January 2006 the respondent was arrested in Sydney pursuant to a provisional arrest warrant issued under s 12(1) of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth) ("the Extradition Act"). On 20 January 2006 he was remanded in custody pursuant to s 15 of the Extradition Act. On 17 February 2006 the Attorney-General's Department of the Commonwealth of Australia received a request dated 20 January 2006 from the Minister of Justice of Croatia seeking extradition of the respondent. That extradition was sought for the respondent's prosecution before a court in Croatia in respect of two offences of war crimes against prisoners of war pursuant to Art 122 of the Croatian Code and for one offence of a war crime against the civilian population pursuant to Art 120, pars 1 and 2, of the Croatian Code. The request enclosed a copy of the Sibenik County Court decision and order. The request set out the particulars of the offences alleged. The two Art 122 offences allegedly took place during armed conflict between the armed forces of Croatia and what was described as "armed … Serbian paramilitary troops" in Knin in June and July 1991 and in the village of Bruska near Benkovac in February 1993. The Art 120 offence allegedly took place in Glina in July 1991. The armed conflict which took place in the territory of Croatia in the period from 1991 to 1995 is referred to as the "Homeland War". The Art 122 offences were particularised as the mistreatment, including torture, of Croatian prisoners of war by the respondent personally, and as a commander of a paramilitary unit of Serbian forces. The Art 120 offence was particularised as the planning and execution of an attack upon civilian objects, including a church and a school, and forcing civilians to flee their homes.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH CJ GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ HEYDON J
The application of the mitigating factor of service in the Croatian armed forces during the relevant conflict does not evidence any advertence by the Croatian courts to the political opinions of those who are not able to invoke its benefit. That is to say, no factual inference can be made that the non-application of the mitigating factor implies consideration by the sentencing court of the political opinions of the offender. Nor, independently of any such consideration, is there any necessary logical connection. It cannot be said that commitment to the establishment of an independent Serbian republic of Krajina was the other side of the coin of service in the Croatian armed forces. The other side of that coin is non-service in the Croatian armed forces. That does not confer the character of an aggravating factor upon service in the Serbian forces nor thereby upon a political commitment to a Serbian republic advanced by such service. The causal connection was not made out. There is no justification for the finding of the Full Court that the mitigating factor operated "by reference to" the political beliefs of the offender[46]. In any event the range of connections covered by the words "by reference to" is wider than those covered by the term "by reason of". The conclusions of the Full Court were factual conclusions which were not supported by the evidence.[46](2009) 178 FCR 546 at 559 [53].Conclusion For the preceding reasons I joined in the orders allowing the appeal. This appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Bennett, Flick and McKerracher JJ) ("the Full Court") concerns an extradition request from the Republic of Croatia ("Croatia") in relation to the respondent, Daniel Snedden. Formerly known as Dragan Vasiljkovic, the respondent is accused of having committed criminal offences against the Basic Penal Code of the Republic of Croatia ("the Croatian Code").Background The respondent is a citizen of the former state union of Serbia and Montenegro and of Australia. He emigrated with his family to Australia from Serbia (then part of the former Yugoslavia) as a teenager and took his current name when he became an Australian citizen. He is said to have been the military commander of a "Special Purpose Unit" of Serbian paramilitary troops which fought in the Krajina area in the periods of June and July 1991 and February 1993. On 28 November 2005 the Sibenik County Public Prosecutor's Office in Croatia submitted a request to a magistrate of the County Court in Sibenik for investigation into war crimes against prisoners of war and civilians allegedly committed by the respondent. On 12 December 2005 the County Court in Sibenik decided that there was a "well-founded suspicion" that the respondent had committed such offences. On 10 January 2006 the County Court in Sibenik ordered a warrant for the respondent's arrest to be issued. On 19 January 2006 the respondent was arrested in Sydney pursuant to a provisional arrest warrant issued under s 12(1) of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth) ("the Extradition Act"). On 20 January 2006 he was remanded in custody pursuant to s 15 of the Extradition Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH CJ, GUMMOW, HAYNE, CRENNAN, KIEFEL AND BELL JJ, HEYDON J

The court's reasoning in the case of Republic of Croatia v Snedden was primarily focused on the interpretation and application of Section 7(c) of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth). The issue of whether the Full Court erred in concluding that the mitigating factor of service in the Croatian armed forces operated "by reference to" the political beliefs of the offender was central to the appeal. The court determined that the Full Court's conclusion was not supported by the evidence and that there was no necessary logical connection between service in the Serbian forces and a political commitment to a Serbian republic. The court held that the causal connection required to find the mitigating factor operating "by reference to" political beliefs was not made out, and the conclusions of the Full Court were not supported by the evidence.

The court also examined whether there is a necessary logical connection between service in the Serbian forces and a political commitment to a Serbian republic, such that it would constitute an aggravating factor. The court found that there was no such connection, and that service in the Serbian forces did not confer the character of an aggravating factor upon a political commitment to a Serbian republic. This was a critical point in the court's reasoning, as it directly addressed the Full Court's interpretation of the mitigating factor in question.

The court further considered whether the Full Court correctly interpreted the phrase "by reason of" in Section 7(c) of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth). The court found that the Full Court's interpretation was incorrect, as the range of connections covered by the words "by reference to" is wider than those covered by the term "by reason of". This distinction was crucial in determining the scope of the mitigating factor and its application to the facts of the case.

Another significant issue addressed by the court was whether the holding of a political opinion can be ascribed to a class of persons by reason only of their participation in the armed forces in a particular conflict. The court held that such an ascription was not justified and that there was no basis for finding that the mitigating factor operated "by reference to" the political beliefs of the offender. This was an important aspect of the court's reasoning, as it addressed the broader implications of the Full Court's interpretation of the mitigating factor.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Full Court's interpretation of the mitigating factor of service in the Croatian armed forces and its operation "by reference to" the political beliefs of the offender is not supported by the evidence and is incorrect. The court also established that there is no necessary logical connection between service in the Serbian forces and a political commitment to a Serbian republic, and that the phrase "by reason of" in Section 7(c) of the Extradition Act 1988 (Cth) has a narrower scope than "by reference to". The holding of a political opinion cannot be ascribed to a class of persons solely by reason of their participation in the armed forces in a particular conflict.