Rail Commissioner (Formerly TransAdelaide) v Warner (BY Her Next Friend Airs)

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

RAIL COMMISSIONER (FORMERLY TRANSADELAIDE) & ANOR v WARNER (BY HER NEXT FRIEND AIRS) & ANOR

[2011] SASCFC 90

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Sulan, The Honourable Justice Vanstone and The Honourable Justice Peek)

16 August 2011

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH JUDGE'S FINDINGS OF FACT - FUNCTIONS OF APPELLATE COURT - WHERE CONFLICT OF EVIDENCE

Appeal against decision of District Court Judge awarding damages to Dennis Martin, deceased father of the plaintiff/first respondent, for injuries sustained to him on 21 November 2001 on train operated by fourth defendant/first appellant (TransAdelaide) and driven by third defendant, Mr Paterson – Martin was ejected by the second defendant/second appellant, Mr Haynes, a conductor, and the first defendant/second respondent, Ms Kernke, a security guard, when he was found not to have a ticket – Martin was injured on attempting to re-board train – trial Judge held Haynes and TransAdelaide liable in negligence – Judge also held TransAdelaide liable on the wider basis that it was in breach of its duty of care to Martin in failing to have in place an adequate system of ensuring that trains would only leave the platform when it was safe to do so – Judge found Kernke not liable and considered it unnecessary to find whether Paterson was or was not liable.

Whether trial Judge’s finding as to position of Martin at the time of the train starting to depart should be interfered with – whether Judge’s findings were based on evidence that is glaringly improbable or opposed to established facts or incontrovertible evidence – whether Judge erred in concluding that safety system was unsafe.

Held (Peek J, Sulan J agreeing): appeal as to liability dismissed – trial Judge’s findings as to Martin’s position should not be disturbed – Judge fully appreciated that evidence of passenger McAlpine was inconsistent with that of Paterson and rejected the latter’s assertion that no one was adjacent to the train when it started to leave Bowden station – Judge was entitled to prefer McAlpine’s evidence for a number of reasons – not necessary to consider fully the appeal against trial Judge’s findings of liability on alternative basis that safety system in place was unsafe.

(Vanstone J dissenting): appeal as to liability allowed – Judge’s failure to explain why he rejected Paterson’s evidence means that his reasons for decision are inadequate – his decision cannot stand – Judge’s finding that Martin was “immediately next to the doors” when the train moved off cannot stand with Paterson's evidence – there is no apparent reason for rejecting Paterson's evidence – Judge’s reliance on McAlpine’s evidence is not free from difficulty.

Undesirable to send the matter back to the District Court for a retrial – this Court should dispose of the action – finding that Martin moved away at least three steps beyond the white line and was continuing to move away when Paterson engaged the throttle – trial…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Rail Commissioner (Formerly TransAdelaide) v Warner (BY Her... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] SASCFC 90
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a District Court Judge's decision to award damages to the estate of Dennis Martin for injuries sustained when he was ejected from a TransAdelaide train and subsequently injured while attempting to re-board it. The trial judge found TransAdelaide and its conductor, Mr Haynes, liable in negligence. TransAdelaide also faced liability for allegedly failing to implement an adequate system to ensure trains departed platforms safely. The security guard, Ms Kernke, was found not liable.

The primary legal issues before the appellate court were whether the trial judge's findings regarding the position of Mr Martin at the time the train began to depart should be disturbed, and whether those findings were based on evidence that was improbable or contradicted established facts. Additionally, the court considered whether the trial judge erred in concluding that TransAdelaide's safety system was inadequate. The appeal also addressed the quantum of damages awarded and the order for TransAdelaide to pay Ms Kernke's costs.

A majority of the court, comprising Peek and Sulan JJ, dismissed the appeal on liability. They held that the trial judge's findings concerning Mr Martin's position were entitled to be upheld, as the judge had properly considered conflicting evidence and was justified in preferring the evidence of a passenger, Mr McAlpine, over that of the train driver, Mr Paterson. The majority found it unnecessary to definitively rule on the appeal concerning the adequacy of the safety system. Vanstone J dissented, finding the trial judge's reasoning inadequate due to a failure to explain the rejection of Mr Paterson's evidence and concluding that the finding of Mr Martin being "immediately next to the doors" was not supported. Vanstone J also found that the safety system was not unsafe and that the driver acted reasonably.

The majority (Peek and Sulan JJ) also dismissed the appeal regarding the quantum of damages and the costs order, finding the awards for past economic loss and voluntary services to be moderate and not excessive, respectively. They also found no error of principle in the order for TransAdelaide to pay Ms Kernke's costs, given the factual and legal connection between the claims against both defendants. Vanstone J deemed it unnecessary to consider these matters. The court also addressed the issue of delay between the trial and judgment, with Peek J stating that delay alone does not invalidate a judgment unless error is demonstrated, while Sulan and Vanstone JJ noted that such delays can erode confidence in the justice system.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

TransAdelaide and the conductor, Haynes, now appeal against the finding of liability, aspects of the award of damages and the order that they pay Kernke’s costs. In respect of the liability question they argue that, unless the driver’s evidence was rejected, it was not open to the trial judge to accept the passenger McAlpine’s evidence that the plaintiff was immediately next to the train doors at the time when the train started to move from the station; and that there was neither any reason to reject the driver’s evidence, nor any explanation given for rejecting it, nor indeed any explicit rejection of it.Background The events giving rise to the action were proved, in part, by electronic evidence in the form of a videotape generated by security cameras within the carriage and also by electronic records associated with the controls of the train. The latter proved the movements of the train, including that it was stationary at the Bowden Station for ten seconds. The plaintiff gave evidence of the events. Due to his state of extreme intoxication at the relevant time – found to be 0.31 grams of alcohol per 100mls of blood – his recollection of the event was very limited. A number of eye-witnesses gave evidence on behalf of the defendants, including Kernke, Haynes, the driver, and passengers McAlpine, Rees and Kiosowski. It was proved that the plaintiff boarded the train in company with an acquaintance, one Woodley, whom he apparently met by chance on the platform. The plaintiff was carrying two plastic bags containing groceries. The plaintiff claimed that he had earlier purchased a ticket but that he gave it to Woodley. When he was approached by the conductor he was unable to produce a ticket and was told that he would have to buy one. That led to the plaintiff swearing at the conductor and Kernke and, on the defendants’ case, trying to strike her. McAlpine, Rees, the conductor and Kernke all attested to the plaintiff having attempted to strike Kernke, but the judge specifically rejected Kernke’s evidence to that effect and, it follows, must have rejected McAlpine’s, Rees’ and Haynes’ similar evidence. Anyway, that confrontation led to his ejection. It appears that, upon leaving the train, Woodley picked up the two bags of groceries which the plaintiff had placed on the floor of the carriage in the course of the confrontation with the conductor and Kernke. The video shows that Woodley left the train at Bowden and was followed by the plaintiff, who was escorted to the front doors and released there by Kernke and the conductor. The plaintiff’s recollection of the events included running after the train because he thought he had left his groceries behind. Early in his reasons for judgment, the judge set out what he referred to as the issues for determination. He referred to the questions of liability of the defendants and contributory negligence and then nominated the following matters:13The issues for determination include whether the plaintiff was travelling lawfully on the train, whether the plaintiff was intoxicated, the nature of the discussion between the plaintiff and Haynes, whether Haynes was entitled to request information from the plaintiff, whether Haynes and/or Kernke were entitled to use force to eject the plaintiff, and whether a duty was owed to the plaintiff.From that point the judge turned to the evidence. He made a number of findings about the matters just set out, under the appropriate headings.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Moreover, the author of the proceedings has died. In these circumstances the interests of the community dictate that the matter is finalised sooner rather than later. In all these circumstances I consider that this Court should dispose of the action.Evaluation of the evidence The driver, Paterson’s evidence should be accepted. I can find no valid reason to prefer McAlpine’s evidence to the broadly similar, and certainly compatible, versions of Paterson, the conductor and Kernke. The plaintiff’s evidence is self-evidently unreliable. That means that, prior to engaging the throttle, the driver saw Woodley and the plaintiff move away beyond the white line, out of his vision, apparently in the process of departing from the platform. I find that, consistent with the conductor’s and Kernke’s evidence, the plaintiff moved away at least three steps beyond the white line and was continuing to move away when the driver engaged the throttle. I find that after the train started to move away, the plaintiff turned and moved towards it, ran alongside it, and then lunged or launched himself at the train with a view to gaining entry and recovering his parcels. The risks involved in this activity were obvious, even to an intoxicated man. I consider that a reasonable person in the position of the driver is unlikely to have foreseen such conduct. Even if such a person had known of recent events on the train, I think such foresight unlikely, although certainly the actions of an intoxicated man are likely to be seen as more unpredictable. It is convenient to now consider whether, bearing in mind that the train was carrying a conductor, there should have been in place a system whereby the conductor was required to advise the driver when it was safe to leave the platform. On behalf of the plaintiff it was suggested that the conductor had knowledge of the intoxication of the plaintiff and the fact that he was required to leave the train a stop earlier than planned. The judge found that “a prudent driver” in possession of that knowledge would have “taken steps to ensure that the plaintiff was clear of the train entirely before he commenced to move off”: [100]. The judge found that in circumstances where there was a conductor present on the train that conductor should have been required to take control of the carriage doors and advise the driver that the platform was clear before the driver moved off: [101]. The judge found that such a system of communication was in place on trains consisting of three or more carriages at night: [101]. I consider to be compelling the argument of the appellant that implementation of such a system would have made no difference in this case. As Mr R Harms, for the appellant, submitted, had such a system been in operation, then, having regard to the conductor’s observations of the plaintiff’s movements, he would have given the all clear to the driver. As mentioned, this was a single carriage train and the doors from which the appellant left the train were only a few metres from the driver’s position and immediately in view via his rear vision mirror. In fact, the conductor gave evidence of two mechanisms whereby he could have prevented the train leaving the station, in circumstances where he perceived danger. On his person he carried a key which could be used to override the driver’s locking of the train doors. That would have alerted the driver to a difficulty. There was also an emergency lever located at the end of the carriage, about six or seven metres from where the conductor was standing at the front doors. From the conductor’s evidence it is clear that he gave no consideration to use of either of these mechanisms to cause the train to remain in Bowden Station, since he perceived no need to do so. In my view the finding against the first defendant on the basis of inadequacies in its system cannot stand. There were adequate means available by which the conductor could have prevented the train from being put into motion in circumstances where he was aware of some danger or difficulty of which the driver was ignorant.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SULAN J (dissent) VANSTONE J (dissent) PEEK J
In view of my opinion that the plaintiff’s claim should have failed, it is unnecessary to deal with these matters.Conclusion I consider that the judgment and orders given in the Court below should be set aside and in their place an order dismissing the claim should be made. This is an appeal against findings and orders made at trial by a District Court Judge in relation to liability, quantum and costs following the now deceased plaintiff suffering serious injuries in a train accident.Introduction and background Although the evidence was somewhat more complicated, for the purposes of the appeal the relevant facts are that on 21 November 2001, at about 11.10pm, Dennis Martin (who was originally the plaintiff and will be referred to as “Martin”) was travelling from Adelaide to a station beyond Bowden in a train operated by the fourth defendant, TransAdelaide, who was also the entity in control of the Bowden station. The train was driven by the third defendant, Mr Paterson, who was directly employed by TransAdelaide. The second defendant, Mr Haynes (Haynes), a Passenger Service Assistant (PSA), or conductor, employed by TransAdelaide was checking tickets and found that Martin did not have one. Martin was in an intoxicated state. He responded aggressively when asked for identification and, after a scuffle, was ejected from the train at the Bowden station by Haynes and the first defendant, Kernke, a security guard; she was not employed by TransAdelaide, but rather by Group 4 Securitas, presumably under a contractual arrangement with TransAdelaide. Martin’s subsequent precise movements on the platform are highly contentious. His case was that he was immediately adjacent to the train and trying to open the door to re-board it as it began to move from the station, he then running alongside the moving train and then falling between the platform and the train, suffering serious injuries with his left leg being amputated. The extent of Martin’s intoxication Martin’s evidence was that he had ceased working at about 4.00pm, over the next hour or so consumed six stubbies of beer and had then walked to the Tattersalls Hotel in Hindley Street where he consumed more beer over a period of what appears to have been about three hours. The undisputed medical evidence was that when tested at the Royal Adelaide Hospital after the incident, the plaintiff’s blood alcohol reading was .31gm per 100ml of blood. The evidence of the passengers, and the defendants Haynes and Kernke, was that Martin smelled strongly of alcohol. His Honour’s finding that Martin was significantly intoxicated which state was, or should have been, apparent to those dealing with him, was not challenged.The pleadings The plaintiff’s allegations against Haynes and Kernke are essentially that they ejected Martin from the train, refused to allow him to re-board the train and permitted the train to move off from the station in circumstances which placed Martin at significant risk of harm. The allegation against Paterson, the driver, is essentially that he drove the train away from the station in circumstances where it was unsafe to do so. The allegations against TransAdelaide are couched in general terms of exposing Martin to risk of injury; failing to have in place a system which would ensure his safety; failing to provide plant and equipment to enable him to enter or leave the train safely including an allegation that it failed to provide adequate lighting at the station, and failing to ensure that its agent servants and employees did not act unreasonably towards members of the public including Martin.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PEEK J