Noonan v XYZ Security Services Pty Ltd trading as Advent Security Services

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Noonan v XYZ Security Services Pty Ltd trading as Advent Security Services [2023] FedCFamC2G 666

File number: MLG 3354 of 2018
Judgment of: HER HONOUR JUDGE C.E. KIRTON KC
Date of judgment: 27 July 2023
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – alleged contraventions of ss 340 and 352 of the Fair Work Act2009 (Cth) - adverse action - termination of employment - whether employee exercised workplace rights - whether complaints or inquiries made fall within with s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) – temporary leave of absence – reverse onus enlivened - reasons for termination decision – whether prohibited reasons substantive and operative reasons for dismissal - multiple reasons - employer failed to rebut presumption - one finding of adverse action – compensation ordered.

INDUSTRIAL LAW – CONTRACT LAW – reasonable term of notice – whether written employment agreement had implied term – employment agreement had express notice period and payment in lieu of notice – no breach of contract.

CONSUMER LAW – misleading and deceptive conduct – pre-employment negotiations – representations as to the future – whether representations made in trade or commerce – whether representations induced applicant into accepting offer of employment - no proof of reliance – claim dismissed.

Legislation:

Australian Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) Schedule 2, ss 4(1), 18 and 31

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 97(a), 117, 236(1), 335, 340, 341, 342, 352, 360, 361, 386, 545(2)(b), 546 and 793

Occupational Health and Safety Act 2004 (Vic) s 21

Cases cited:

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) v Dukemaster Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 682

Alam v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCAFC 178; (2021) 288 FCR 30

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical & Further Education v Barclay & Anor [2012] HCA 32

CFMWU v BHP Coal Pty Ltd [2014] HCA 41; (2014) 253 CLR 243

Cigarette & Gift Warehouse Pty Ltd v Whelan [2019] FCAFC 16

Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337

Con-Stan Industries of Australia Pty Ltd v Norwich Winterthur (Australia) Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 226

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Clermont Coal Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 1014

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v De Martin & Gasparini Pty Limit (No 2) [2017] FCA 1046

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Pilbara Iron Co (Services) Pty Ltd (No 3) [2012] FCA 697

Gloria Bowden v Ottrey Homes - Cobram and District Retirement Villages Inc (t/as Ottrey Lodge) [2013] FWCFB 431

Haley v Public Transport Corporation of Victoria [1998] VSC 143

Maritime Union of Australia v Fair Work Ombudsman [2015] FCAFC 120

Miller v Sunland Park Pty Ltd [2014] FCCA 89

Moss v Lowe Hunt & Partners Pty Ltd [2010] FCA 1181

Murrihy v Betezy.com.au Pty Ltd (2013) 238 IR 307.

PIA Mortgage Service Pty Ltd v King [2020] FCAFC 15

Quinn v Jack Chia (Australia) Ltd [1992] 1 VR 567

Rakic v Johns Lyng…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Noonan v XYZ Security Services Pty Ltd trading as Advent Sec... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 666
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Circuit Court, the Applicant, Mr. Noonan, brought an action against the Respondent, XYZ Security Services Pty Ltd trading as Advent Security Services, for various claims including unfair dismissal, breach of contract, and misleading or deceptive conduct. The primary issue before the Court was whether the Respondent had contravened the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by dismissing the Applicant for exercising his workplace right to make a complaint. Additionally, the Court needed to determine if the Respondent breached the employment agreement by failing to provide reasonable notice of termination and whether the Respondent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law.

The Court found that the Respondent did contravene the Fair Work Act by dismissing the Applicant for exercising his workplace right to make a complaint. The Court concluded that the dismissal was influenced by the Applicant's complaint and his poor performance, though it was not the sole reason for the dismissal. Regarding the breach of contract claim, the Court determined that no term of reasonable notice was implied in the employment agreement, and the Applicant did not provide sufficient evidence to support such a claim. Furthermore, the Court found no evidence to support the allegation of misleading or deceptive conduct under the Australian Consumer Law.

The Court awarded the Applicant compensation of $93,500 for economic and non-economic loss, along with interest and the right to seek penalties for the contravention of the Fair Work Act. The Court also made an order for the filing and service of submissions regarding interest, penalties, and the costs of the proceeding.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

I have determined the following:(a)The Respondent contravened s 340 of the FW Act by dismissing the Applicant for exercising the workplace right pursuant to s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the FW Act to make a complaint;(b)The Respondent did not breach the employment agreement between the Applicant and the Respondent and there was no implied term of reasonable notice of termination of the employment agreement;(c)The Respondent did not engage in misleading and deceptive conduct pursuant to s 18 of the ACL, and the representations made to the Applicant during the pre-employment negotiations did not induce the Applicant into commencing employment with the Respondent; and(d)The Applicant is entitled to compensation pursuant to 392 of the FW Act in the sum of $93,500 and a declaration in relation to one (1) finding of adverse action.BACKGROUND On 19 March 2021 the parties filed a Joint Chronology of Facts (Joint Chronology), which outlined the accepted and disputed facts and documents. The Respondent is engaged in the business of providing security services and is comprised of three (3) divisions headed by a regional manager. The Respondent’s business is operated as follows:(a)Manned services - South West Region, which provides services to clients in Victoria, Tasmania and Western Australia;(b)Manned services - North East Region, which provides services to clients in New South Wales, Queensland and the Northern Territory; (c)Manned services to New Zealand, served by both the South West Region and the North East Region; and(d)A national electronics division, which provides electronic access control, alarms, CCTV and related technology (Electronics Division). The Electronics Division also prepares plans, maps and quotes for large warehouses and builds to present to clients on Greenfield sites.[1] [1] Court Book (CB) 134; Affidavit of Peter Benney, sworn and filed 12 December 2019 (P Benney Affidavit), [2] and [3]. The following individuals and their roles at the Respondent are relevant to these proceedings:(a)Mr Peter Benney (Mr P Benney), the sole director of the Respondent and the Chief Executive Officer and Managing Director of the Advent Security Group.[2] Mr P Benny was the Applicant’s manager during the Applicant’s period of employment;(b)Mr Hilary Carswell (Mr Carswell), the General Manager of the Advent Security Group and was employed by the Respondent during the Applicant’s period of employment;[3](c)Mr Justin Dylan Benney (Mr J Benney), the son of Mr P Benney, and a director of the Advent Security Group and head of the Electronics Division, and was employed by the Respondent during the Applicant’s period of employment;[4] and(d)Mr Michael Hill (Mr Hill), the Business Manager employed by the Respondent during the Applicant’s period of employment.[5][2] CB 134; P Benny Affidavit, [1].[3] CB 215; Affidavit of Hilary Carswell, sworn and filed 12 December 2019 (Carswell Affidavit), [1].[4] CB 205; Affidavit of Justin Dylan Benney, sworn and filed 12 December 2019 (J Benney Affidavit), [1] and [2]; Affidavit of the Applicant, filed 25 September 2019 (Applicant’s First Affidavit), [6].[5] CB 212; Affidavit of Michael Hill, sworn and filed 12 December 2019 (Hill Affidavit), [1].

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Court has also read and reviewed the transcript of the Final Hearing prior to finalising these Reasons for Judgment.Evidence of the Applicant The Applicant gave evidence in chief by way of the Applicant’s First Affidavit and the Applicant’s Second Affidavit and was cross-examined. In addition to deposing to the events described under the heading ‘Background’ herein, the Applicant deposed to the following. The Applicant alleged that upon the Applicant’s successful negotiation of his salary package, Mr P Benney told him not to continue his job application with ESS and also said, “I fucking hate it when people get what they want”.[77][77] CB 66; Applicant’s First Affidavit, [9]; Transcript P43:L23-33. The Applicant described the Respondent as “a bit of an ad hoc operation” and explained that he introduced weekly meetings for management where he took down notes.[78] The Applicant also made notes about areas of improvement for the Respondent and its employees.[79] The Applicant explained that his work notes did not detail the ‘unprofessional’ conduct of Mr P Benney as the Applicant did not deem it appropriate to include this in work records.[80][78] Transcript P60:L16-20; Applicant’s Exhibit 3. [79] CB 71; Applicant’s First Affidavit, [27]-[29].[80] Transcript P50:L16-17. The Applicant deposed to Mr P Benney disliking employees taking personal leave. The Applicant deposed that during a meeting on his first day of employment on 4 September 2017 the Applicant raised the topic of paid personal leave, to which Mr P Benney replied, “we don’t have sick days here so fucking forget about that”.[81] The Applicant deposed that throughout his employment with the Respondent taking entitled leave was made difficult and required planning. The Applicant referenced his period of leave in February 2018 which was required for dental work, in support of his contention that the Respondent did not support employees taking paid leave.[82][81] CB 69; Applicant’s First Affidavit, [18].[82] Exhibit R1 and R2. The Applicant described the language used by Mr P Benney on 23 April 2018 as insulting and meant to be a “put down”.[83][83] Transcript P55:L4-26. From the commencement of his employment the Applicant deposed that he would interact with Mr P Benney on a daily basis and that they would usually have a daily meeting (by phone or in person) or catch-up over coffee. The Applicant explained how Mr P. Benney changed his demeanour, conversation and interactions with the Applicant after the Name Complaint on 24 April 2018.[84] The Applicant described how Mr P Benney went from communicating with the Applicant on a daily basis to rarely speaking to the Applicant.[85] The Applicant explained that after the Name Complaint he was ‘frozen out’ by Mr P Benny.[84] Transcript P59:L20-P60:L7.[85] Transcript P60. The Applicant denied that any issues with his performance had ever been raised by Mr P Benney or any other employees of the Respondent. The Applicant gave evidence that Mr P. Benney discussed with him why the business could not win work but stated that they did not discuss the Applicant’s lack of progress. The Applicant had arguably performed his role and made achievements during his employment.[86] The Applicant acknowledged that his contacts were better suited to a different sector than the Respondent’s desired clientele, but contended that he had secured many existing clients and saved many contracts that the Respondent would have lost. The Applicant explained the Review Email as follows:[87]MS BINGHAM: I will suggest to you that that is not correct and that what happened is that Mr Peter Benney said to you, “You responded to my email regarding WIP and you said you have nothing”. That’s correct, isn’t it?MR NOONAN: No. Again, that email, if you read it correctly says I have no – guarding contracts going to drop in the next 30 to 90 days. I had two electronics jobs that should be included in the figures. So you’re being selective on what you picked out of that email.[86] CB 68; Applicant’s First Affidavit, [17]; CB 217; Carswell Affidavit, [11].[87] Transcript P71:L11-16.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, I accept the Respondent’s evidence that Mr P Benney had decided to dismiss the Applicant prior to the Paid Personal Leave taken on 6 and 7 September 2018. The Respondent has established that on the balance of probabilities the Applicant was not dismissed for reasons including the Applicant’s temporary absence from work on 6 and 7 September 2018.Conclusion FW Act Claim Adverse action was taken against the Applicant by reason of the Dismissal by the Respondent. The Applicant established that he had exercised workplace rights. The Respondent established that on the balance of probabilities the Applicant’s temporary absence on 6 and 7 September 2018 was not a substantive and operative reason for the Applicant’s Dismissal. The Respondent has established on the balance of probabilities that the underperformance of the Applicant was a reason for his dismissal, but it cannot be said to be the only operative and substantial reason for his dismissal. The Respondent has not discharged the onus to prove on the balance of probabilities that a substantial and operative reason for Mr P Benny deciding to terminate the Applicant was not the Name Complaint. The Name Complaint as well as the Applicant’s poor performance (whether well-founded or not) formed the substantial and operative reasons for Mr P Benney’s decision to terminate the Applicant. The Respondent (through Mr P Benney) took adverse action against the Applicant for a prohibited reason in contravention of s 340 of the FW Act.BREACH OF CONTRACTRelevant legal principles The common law may imply terms based on the actual or presumed intentions of the parties. The conditions necessary for a term to be implied into a contract were set out in Codelfa Construction Pty Ltd v State Rail Authority of NSW (1982) 149 CLR 337 at [9] as follows:(a)The term must be reasonable and equitable;(b)The term must be necessary to give business efficacy to the contract, so that no term will be implied if the contract is effective without it;(c)The term must be so obvious that ‘it goes without saying’;(d)The term must be capable of clear expression; and(e)The term must not contradict any express term of the contract. The common law implies standard terms into certain categories of contracts on the basis that they are a normal incident of that type of contract. The implication of standard terms is subject to any express term or clear intention in the contract not to include the term. The Court in Con-Stan Industries of Australia Pty Ltd v Norwich Winterthur (Australia) Ltd (1986) 160 CLR 226 at [8] explained that any presumed intention of the parties or implied term “must yield to their actual intention as embodied in the express terms of the contract”.Can a term of reasonable notice be implied? The Applicant in [26] to [28] of the Statement of Claim claimed that the Respondent breached the Employment Agreement by failing to provide reasonable notice for his dismissal. A period of six (6) moths is claimed as reasonable notice. The Applicant contended that a term of reasonable notice is implied by law into the Employment Agreement which required that parties could only terminate the employment relationship by providing ‘reasonable notice’. Citing Haley v Public Transport Corporation of Victoria [1998] VSC 143, the Applicant submitted that reasonable notice is determined by an employee’s age, seniority and remuneration, and the employee’s prospects of finding other suitable employment.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the absence of medical evidence I am disinclined to find the amount sought as appropriate. I am satisfied the dismissal would have had an adverse impact on the Applicant’s mental wellbeing and has resulted in some limitation on his ability to re-enter the same job market, but it did not prevent the Applicant from actively pursuing and securing another position, albeit in positions at a lower base salary. I consider an amount of $10,000, which equates to an appropriate compensation for non-economic loss.Declaration I propose to make the declaration that the Respondent has breached s 340 of the FW Act by dismissing the Applicant from his employment on 10 September 2018. The Respondent has committed one contravention of the FW Act.Penalties The Applicant sought the imposition of pecuniary penalties for contraventions of the FW Act. These Reasons for Judgment are a liability judgment concerning the Applicant’s dismissal from employment with the Respondent and therefore no order for penalties will be made. In accordance with the usual practice of this Court, the parties will be heard on the issue.CONCLUSION As discussed in these Reasons for Judgment, I find that the Respondent dismissed the Applicant for reasons which included the exercise of his workplace right to make a complaint pursuant to s 341(1)(c)(ii) of the FW Act. The Respondent therefore committed one contravention of the FW Act. All other causes of action in the Application are dismissed. The Applicant is entitled to compensation pursuant to s 392(1) of the FW Act for economic and non-economic loss in the total sum of $93,500 and interest thereon and a declaration and a right to seek penalties in respect of the single contravention of the FW Act. Orders will be made for the filing and service of submissions with respect to interest, penalties and the costs of this proceeding.