[2013] FWCFB 431 |
FAIR WORK COMMISSION |
DECISION |
Fair Work Act 2009
s.604—Appeal of decisions
v
Ottrey Homes Cobram and District Retirement Villages Inc. T/A Ottrey Lodge
(C2012/6038)
SENIOR DEPUTY PRESIDENT ACTON | |
Appeal against decisions [[2012] FWA 6468 and [2012 FWA 9191] of Commissioner Cribb in matter number U2011/1147 - application for unfair dismissal remedy - compensation - decisions quashed - matter determined by Full Bench.
Introduction
[1] On 1 August 2012 Commissioner Cribb handed down a decision (first decision) in respect of an unfair dismissal remedy application made to Fair Work Australia (FWA) by Ms Gloria Bowden against Ottrey Homes Cobram and District Retirement Villages Inc. T/A Ottrey Lodge (Ottrey). 1 Ms Bowden was summarily dismissed from her employment by Ottrey on 27 May 2011. On 1 January 2013 FWA was renamed the Fair Work Commission (FWC).
[2] The Commissioner found Ms Bowden’s application had been made within the requisite legislative period, Ms Bowden was protected from unfair dismissal, the Small Business Fair Dismissal Code was not relevant to the application before her, the application did not concern redundancy and Ms Bowden had been dismissed by Ottrey. 2
[3] In respect of whether Ms Bowden’s dismissal was harsh, unjust or unreasonable the Commissioner concluded in her first decision as follows:
“[65] In all of the circumstances of this matter and, having taken account of each of the factors in s.387 of the Act, I determine, on fine balance, that Ms Bowden’s summary dismissal was harsh. Ms Bowden was summarily dismissed rather than dismissed with notice. As she was still being rostered to work, albeit, with difficulty, in a separate area to Ms Crocker, there would not appear to be any justification for dismissal without notice or pay in lieu of notice. Ms Bowden’s dismissal was also harsh as she had had no previous allegations/complaints made about her conduct and the allegations related to one occurrence (the Facebook exchanges/sending of the Workplace Politics document). As well, Ms Crocker participated equally in the Facebook exchanges and there does not appear to have been any disciplinary action taken regarding her “Fuck you all” Facebook post.
[66] It therefore follows that, pursuant to s.385 of the Act, Ms Bowden has been unfairly dismissed.” 3
[4] The Commissioner then turned to consider the issue of remedy. After setting out s.390 of the Fair Work Act 2009 Cth) (FW Act) concerning when the FWC may order a remedy for unfair dismissal, she said:
“[68] … I am satisfied that Ms Bowden was protected from unfair dismissal at the time of his dismissal (s.390(1)(a)) and that he has been unfairly dismissed (s.390(1)(b)). Further, Ms Bowden has made an application under s.394 of the Act (s.390(2)).
[69] Section 390(3) states that Fair Work Australia must not order the payment of compensation unless two conditions have been met.
[70] The first condition is that Fair Work Australia is satisfied that reinstatement…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Bowden v Ottrey Homes Cobram and District Retirement Village... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] FWCFB 431
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues that the Tribunal was required to decide included whether the decisions of Commissioner Cribb were correct, and if not, what the appropriate remedy and compensation should be. The Tribunal had to assess the merits of Bowden's claim of unfair dismissal, examine the fairness of the termination of his employment, and determine if the decisions made by Commissioner Cribb were in accordance with the relevant laws and principles. The Tribunal also had to consider whether the compensation awarded, or not awarded, was appropriate.
The Tribunal found that the decisions of Commissioner Cribb were incorrect. The Tribunal determined that Bowden's dismissal was indeed unfair, and that the compensation awarded was inadequate. The Tribunal quashed the decisions of Commissioner Cribb and substituted its own determination, finding in favour of Bowden. The Tribunal awarded Bowden compensation for the unfair dismissal, which included both the loss of salary and non-monetary losses. The Full Bench concluded that the correct approach was to grant Bowden the relief he sought, thereby setting aside the prior decisions and ordering appropriate compensation.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi