Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 520

File number(s): SYG 878 of 2021
Judgment of: JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS
Date of judgment: 14 April 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Judicial review – Partner visa – whether Tribunal properly reached a state of satisfaction that compelling reasons did not exist to waive the application of certain Schedule 3 criteria – whether Tribunal failed to give proper, genuine and realistic consideration to submissions and evidence – whether Tribunal failed to actively and intellectually engage with arguments– jurisdictional error established – application allowed.
Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) Sch 3 cl 3001

Cases cited:

AXT19 v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCAFC 32

Babicci v Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 141 FCR 285

Carrascalao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 252 FCR 352

CDD23 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 276

Hands v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 225; 364 ALR 423

MZYPZ v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2012] FCA 478

Plaintiff M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs (2022) 275 CLR 582

Singh v Minister for Home Affairs (2019) 267 FCR 200

Tickner v Chapman (1995) 57 FCR 451

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 51
Date of hearing: 20 February 2025
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr N Poynder
Solicitor for the Applicant: Phillip Silver & Associates Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr M Cleary
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz Lawyers

ORDERS

SYG 878 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

HOANG QUYNH NGUYEN

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS

DATE OF ORDER:

14 APRIL 202514 APRIL 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the second respondent is amended to ‘Administrative Review Tribunal’.

2.A writ of certiorari shall issue, removing the record of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal decision made on 21 April 2021 into this Court for the purposes of quashing it.

3.A writ of mandamus shall issue, requiring the Administrative Review Tribunal to re‑determine, according to law, the application for review before it.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE PAPADOPOULOS

INTRODUCTION

  1. Before the Court is an application seeking judicial review of a decision made by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) on 21 April 2021. By this decision, the Tribunal affirmed a decision of a delegate (delegate) of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nguyen v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Nguyen, a Vietnamese national, sought judicial review of the Tribunal's decision to affirm the delegate's refusal to grant him a Subclass 820 visa based on his relationship with an Australian permanent resident. The delegate refused the visa on the basis that Nguyen did not satisfy certain criteria in Schedule 3 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) and that compelling reasons for not applying those criteria were not established. The Tribunal upheld the delegate's decision, leading Nguyen to seek judicial review on the ground that the Tribunal failed to give proper, genuine, and realistic consideration to his submissions and evidence.

The central legal issue in this case was whether the Tribunal constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction by not properly considering the material before it. Specifically, the Court examined whether the Tribunal failed to actively and intellectually engage with the evidence and submissions presented by Nguyen, particularly those relating to the needs of his stepson, who suffers from chronic schizophrenia, and the applicant's role in supporting his stepson and the family.

The Court found that the Tribunal did not properly consider the compelling reasons presented by Nguyen regarding his stepson's mental health condition and the critical role he plays in managing that condition. The evidence, including letters from psychologists and psychiatrists, and statutory declarations from Nguyen and his wife, highlighted the necessity of Nguyen's presence in the family unit for the well-being of his stepson and the overall stability of the family. The Tribunal's decision did not adequately address these points, leading the Court to conclude that the Tribunal failed to engage with the particular circumstances of Nguyen's relationship and the specific needs of his stepson.

As a result, the Court found that the Tribunal made a jurisdictional error by not giving proper, genuine, and realistic consideration to the evidence and submissions. The application for judicial review was therefore allowed, and the decision of the Tribunal was quashed. The case will be remitted to the Administrative Review Tribunal for reconsideration in light of the Court's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This case requires the Court to consider whether the Tribunal constructively failed to exercise its jurisdiction to review the decision of the delegate by failing to actively and intellectually engage with, or by failing to give proper and realistic consideration to, the material before it.BACKGROUND The applicant, a male national of Vietnam, first arrived in Australia on 26 October 2014, as the holder of a Visitor (Subclass 600) visa. On 26 January 2015, his visitor visa ceased.[1][1] Court Book (CB) 407. On 20 December 2017, the applicant applied for a Subclass 820 visa on the basis of being in a spousal relationship with an Australian permanent resident.[2] The applicant’s wife is the mother of five children. Her eldest child is a son who was diagnosed with a mental health condition in 2012, while her youngest child is a daughter.[2] CB 1 to 32. At the time when the Subclass 820 visa application was made on 20 December 2017, the applicant was not the holder of a substantive visa. He had not held a substantive visa since his visitor visa ceased on 26 January 2015. On 8 July 2019, a delegate refused to grant the applicant the Subclass 820 visa because:(a)the applicant did not satisfy criterion 3001 in Schedule 3 to the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (Regulations) as the Subclass 820 visa application had not been made within 28 days of the date he last held a substantive visa; and(b)the delegate was not satisfied that there were ‘compelling reasons’ for not applying certain criteria within Schedule 3 including criterion 3001.[3][3] CB 403 to 412. On 25 July 2019, the applicant sought review of the delegate’s decision by the Tribunal.[4][4] CB 413 to 414. On 6 April 2021, the Tribunal convened a hearing, by way of telephone, at which the applicant and his wife appeared to give evidence and present arguments.[5][5] CB 835 to 837. On 21 April 2021, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate’s decision not to grant the applicant a Subclass 820 visa.PROCEEDINGS IN THIS COURT By way of an amended application, filed on 17 September 2021, the applicant relied on two grounds of review. As confirmed by the applicant’s written submissions, filed on 6 February 2025, only ground 1 is pressed. Following the hearing, the applicant was granted leave to further amend the application, so as to include a further particular, particular (h). The applicant filed the further amended application on 21 February 2025. The Minister was afforded the opportunity to respond by way of supplementary written submissions in relation to particular (h). The Minister did not avail himself of that opportunity. Accordingly, the sole ground of review is as follows (reproduced without alteration): 1.The Second Respondent (Tribunal) made a jurisdictional error of want of proper, genuine and realistic consideration.a. The Tribunal was required to give proper consideration to the Applicant’s case, in the sense of active intellectual engagement with the same. The Applicant’s case for this purpose extended to matters arising from the Tribunal’s own findings of fact: GBV18 v Minister for Home Affairs (2020) FCAFC 17 at (301, (321 and (39) per Flick, Griffiths and Moshinsky JJ; AYY17 v Minister for Immigration (2018) FCAFC 89; 261 FCR 503 at (181, (26) per Collier. McKerracher and Banks-Smith JJ;b. The Tribunal at paragraph 24 of its decision accepted “the submissions that indicate that the applicant provides emotional and practical support. However, the Tribunal finds that this is not unusual in a genuine relationship and that parties would support each other in their day to day lives and it is not unreasonable to expect that the applicant would provide support to the sponsor and the two children who live at home, notwithstanding that the sponsor’s son is 30 years of age”;c. The Tribunal thereby failed to engage with the particular circumstances of the relationship of the applicant and the sponsor. including the needs of her schizophrenic son;d. The Tribunal at paragraph 24 of its decision stated that it had “regard to the management of the sponsor’s son’s mental health issues” and that it was “satisfied that the sponsor’s son has access to the appropriate health professionals as required and that this has been ongoing since before the parties first met”.e. The Tribunal thereby failed to engage with the nature and limits of the professional help provided to the sponsor’s son, the extent to which the presence was meant of the applicant aided management of the schizophrenia of the sponsor’s son and whether the difference provided by the presence of the applicant was compelling;f. The Tribunal at paragraph 24 of its decision noted that “the applicant indicated to the Tribunal that he had concerns for the sponsor’s safety because of the size of the sponsor’s son”. However. the Tribunal stated that it was “not satisfied that this evidence suggests that the sponsor is in imminent danger if the applicant was not present whilst awaiting the processing of this partner visa application”;g. The Tribunal thereby failed to engage with the history of violence of the sponsor’s son and the scope for the presence of the applicant to provide help to the sponsor in resisting or controlling that violence. which could reduce the risk to the sponsor, imminent or otherwise. presented by such violence.h. The Tribunal failed to engage with the evidence and submissions of the applicant with regard to the applicant’s stepdaughter, [omitted]; namely, that she had been born out of a casual relationship and had no relationship with her biological father, but treated the applicant as her own father and needed him.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In so doing, my attention was drawn to specific parts of documentary and oral evidence which the applicant maintains was relevant for the Tribunal’s consideration of his family circumstances, particularly the nature of his involvement with and support of the sponsor and her two children, when determining whether there were ‘compelling reasons’ not to apply the Schedule 3 criteria. A summary of the applicant’s submissions in relation to relevant aspects of that evidentiary material follows.Documentary evidence In terms of the documentary evidence, my attention was drawn to the following documents before the Tribunal:(a)Letter from Mr Nguyen, Psychologist, dated 10 November 2017: Mr Minh Nguyen of M.T.N Psychological Services wrote a letter in relation to the mental health of the applicant’s stepson. By this letter, provided to the Minister’s Department on 20 December 2017 in support of the Subclass 820 visa application, Mr Nguyen states:[6][6] CB 102 to 103.[The applicant’s stepson] is a client of MTN psychological service since 12/12/2014. He also has been treated by Psychiatrist Dr and has still been consulted with him.…[The applicant’s stepson] has delusional ideas about usual thing around him. For instance, when the neighbour dog barking he thought that the dog “trying to inform other neighbour dogs to be against him” His psychotic and depressive symptoms still exacerbated even he takes his medication daily. [The applicant’s stepson] stated that [the applicant] was very supportive to his otherwise his condition might be worse. [The applicant’s] care and comfort is essential for him to function as it is. [The applicant] took part of care for him with [the sponsor] for a year now.[The applicant’s stepson] even often prefers to be care by [the applicant] than [the sponsor] as he got along well with [the applicant]. [The applicant’s stepson] is always tortured by the thought if [the applicant] is leaving him to go back to Vietnam.…Impression[The applicant’s stepson] presents with significant symptoms Depression symptoms (DSM IV). He also has psychotic symptoms mainly paranoid and delusional symptoms.(b)Letter from Dr McPherson, Psychiatrist, dated 30 November 2017: Dr McPherson, a Consultant Psychiatrist, wrote a letter in relation to the applicant’s stepson’s mental health. By this letter, provided to the Minister’s Department on 20 December 2017 in support of the applicant’s Subclass 820 visa application, Dr McPherson states:[7][7] CB 107.[The applicant’s stepson] suffers with chronic schizophrenia for the last 5 years. His condition has fluctuated and has not been completely controlled. He has been quite disabled by his condition. He lives with [the sponsor] who has provided a lot of necessary support and supervision.As [the sponsor] has been single coping has been difficult for her. She now has a new husband who is supportive and who will be able to help her providing for the needs of the family and supervising [the applicant’s stepson]. [The applicant’s] presence will strengthen the whole family and help to improve [the applicant’s stepson’s] situation.(c)Further letter from Dr McPherson, Psychiatrist, dated 13 March 2018: Dr McPherson wrote a further letter in relation to the applicant’s stepson’s mental health and the nature and significance of the support derived from the applicant. This letter was provided to the Tribunal on 30 March 2021. Dr McPherson relevantly states:[8][8] CB 443 to 445.[The applicant’s stepson] continues to suffer with chronic schizophrenia that has been difficult to treat recently although he has improved over the last few months since returning to treatment with the anti-psychotic medication….[The applicant’s stepson] continues to be severely disabled by his illness with delusional ideas, hallucinations at times and impaired motivation and social functioning. He has no activities outside the family home and interactions with close relatives. He needs to begin a rehabilitation process to develop some vocational direction. Recently he has been going daily to the gym with [the applicant] and this is very helpful as initiating him into a more active and engaged life. {The applicant] has been able to assist with general supervision of [his stepson] and supporting the family in general. [The sponsor] also has a nine-year-old daughter who needs to be looked after. I believe that [the applicant’s] presence in the family in Australia is generally of great assistance to [his stepson] and is helping with his recovery.(d)Applicant’s statutory declaration made on 5 July 2019: This statutory declaration was provided to the Minister’s Department in response to an invitation to provide further information in support of the Subclass 820 visa application. Relevantly, the applicant made the following declarations:[9][9] CB 391.Why I am not able to lodge the visa from outside Australia8.In June 2013, [my stepson] was diagnosed with chronic schizophrenia. Since the beginning of our relationship, I have been a big part of [my stepson’s] life. He is like my own son. He suffers from severe psychotic episodes regularly. During these episodes [my stepson] only listens to me and I am the only person in the house who can control him. He is very big, and [the sponsor] does not have control over him physically.9.[My stepson] requires regular treatment from his doctors and specialists. Sometimes when he is stubborn, he only listens to me to take him to his medical appointments. He currently receives treatment from Dr Andrew McPherson, Psychologist Minh Tuan Nguyen and Dr Nguyen Van Vinh.10.… I then give [my stepson] his medication as he does not take the medicine if [the sponsor] or anyone else gives it to him. On hard days, it takes a lot of time and effort to convince him to take his medicine, this is mainly due to his delusions that he has about the medicine. Normally I would also take him outside or to the gym to exercise. …11.[My stepson] sometimes suffers from very bad episodes for instance recently he has started running to the road in front of cars and I need to be there to pull him off the road. [The sponsor] is not able to do this as [my stepson] is physically big and [the sponsor] can’t control him. I am not working because [my stepson] requires someone around the clock to look after him.12.… [the sponsor] would find it difficult to take care of him and her daughter [omitted] at the same time. She needs my support in attending [my stepson’s] care. She will not be able to take care of the household by herself. [My stepson] also does not listen to [the sponsor] and [the sponsor] will not be able to take him to his specialist appointments and give his medicine.(e)Letter from the applicant’s stepdaughter dated 18 March 2021: The applicant’s stepdaughter wrote a letter that was provided to the Tribunal on 30 March 2021 and contains the following statements:[10][10] CB 468.…. My dad… my mum… and my brother… all live together. I don’t want anyone to separate. My dad helps my mum to look after my brother and me. I don’t want [him] to leave. I want him to stay as a family with all of us. My dad takes me out on weekend. I want my family to be happy and have fun.(f)Report to the Mental Health Tribunal by Dr Roper, Psychiatrist, dated 4 June 2020: [11] This report was written to ‘assist the Mental Health Tribunal in making a decision regarding the Involuntary Patient Order application for 12 weeks of the treating Psychiatry Team’ at the Professor Marie Bashir Centre in the Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. In relation to the applicant’s stepson’s admission to the Professor Marie Bashir Centre, voluminous clinical reports were provided to the Tribunal.[12] In her report, Dr Roper refers to an incident in early May 2020 when the applicant’s stepson threatened to kill the applicant and sponsor with a knife. Following that incident, the applicant’s stepson was sectioned from 8 May 2020 until 12 June 2020 pursuant to s 32(3) of the Mental Health Act 2007 (NSW).[13] Dr Roper also notes that the applicant’s stepson had been untreated for at least six to eight weeks prior to this incident and that he is unwilling to follow a voluntary treatment plan ‘unless persistently coerced at present by the mental health act and close supervision in hospital’. Dr Roper described the impact on her patient’s recovery if there is failure to comply with the treatment plan in the following terms:[11] CB 462 to 463.[12] CB 484 to 834. [13] CB 604.ongoing untreated psychosis, misadventure when interacting with members of the public as he tries to convert them to Falun Gong, and possible violence toward his parents, who he threatened to kill recently for questioning him about his medications.(g)Report from Mr Rodriguez, Psychologist, dated 29 March 2021: On 29 March 2021, Mr Rodriguez, a psychologist, authored a report in relation to the applicant and the sponsor. This report was provided to the Tribunal on 30 March 2021 and relevantly states:[14][14] CB 469 to 475.[The sponsor’s] psychological profile…I assessed [the sponsor’s] current emotional profile… She obtained the following results:Depression: … (Extreme)Anxiety: … (Extreme) Stress: … (Extreme)Based on my assessment of [the sponsor] I concluded that she has been subject to symptoms of depression and anxiety that have fluctuated depending on circumstances throughout her adult life. After commencing living with [the applicant], he has been assisting her running the house and caring for [the applicant’s stepson] and [the applicant’s stepdaughter], which [the sponsor] finds very beneficial and supportive, causing her symptoms to be more bearable. I understand that [the applicant] has become very close to the children. [The applicant’s stepdaughter] calls him ‘dad’ and [the applicant’s stepson] has formed strong attachment with him. [The sponsor] said that she is particularly grateful that [the applicant] has assisted greatly in the management of [the applicant’s stepson’s] chronic schizophrenia condition. [The applicant’s stepson] can become unduly violent when his symptoms flare up, and [the sponsor] said that [the applicant] has offered both physical and emotional support to keep [the applicant’s stepson] under control.…During the course of the marriage, [the applicant] has taken responsibility for assisting [the sponsor] with the running of the home and caring for the children. I understand that [the applicant] has become the primary carer for [the applicant’s stepson], assisting him with medication, visits to doctors and normal daily activities. [The applicant’s] caring of [the applicant’s stepson] became particularly important after [the applicant’s stepson’s] father passed away in October 2020, rendering [the applicant] as the sole father figure in his life.I believe that [the sponsor] and both children have become dependent on [the applicant] for physical, emotional, moral and financial support. This has been a main reason compelling [the applicant] to remain in Australia to lodge his visa application from here.…I believe a that a major problem, if [the applicant] were to be forced to relocate temporarily to Vietnam, would be removing the main source of support for [the applicant’s stepson]. There is a history that [the applicant’s stepson] has become violent and dangerous in the past, and that [the applicant] has assisted to avoid these incidents. (h)Applicant’s statutory declaration made on 30 March 2021: This statutory declaration was provided to the Tribunal on 30 March 2021. Relevantly, the applicant made the following declarations:[15][15] CB 477 to 479.Compelling reasons why I should not be required to leave Australia.5. [The sponsor], [my stepson] [my stepdaughter] and I are a close family unit…6. [My stepdaughter] has never known her father and calls me Dad. I am the only father figure for both these children. Thay are like my own children and I am a big part of their lives.…9. I am the only person in the house who can control [my stepson]. He is big and weighs around 80kg. [The sponsor] cannot control him physically. I accompany [my stepson] to medical appointments, take him for social outings and support him emotionally. I make sure [he] takes his medication. [He] must take medication 3 times a day and get an injection once a month. (i)Sponsor’s statutory declaration made on 30 March (year not specified): This statutory declaration was provided to the Tribunal on 30 March 2021. Relevantly, the sponsor made the following declarations:[16]7. [My son] tried to kill himself on the 8th May 2020 with a knife. Both [the applicant] and I were at home when this incident happened. When we stopped [my son], he wanted to kill us and we called the mental health hospital. [My son] continually tells us he wants to kill himself. He currently seems stable and [the applicant] makes sure he takes his mediation and attends the clinic whenever required. [The applicant] is the best person to calm [my son] down whenever he gets anxiety.…12. [The applicant] is younger than me. He is 41 and more able to exert control over [my son] (including physically). I am now 49. I also have my own medical condition where I require acupuncture every week. I also have weak bones. [The applicant] is the primary carer with us both caring for [my son] together.13. [My son] is a lot bigger than me. He is stronger than me. If [the applicant] is not at home with my and [my daughter], I cannot control [my son] physically. I fear for my safety if [the applicant] is not here. I fear for [my-son’s] welfare if [the applicant] is not here.14. We have a good living arrangement now, where we are all safe, healthy and happy together…15. [My daughter] was born out of a casual relationship. She has no relationship at all with her father who has never been present in her life. [My daughter] is close to [the applicant] and calls him Dad.[16] CB 480 to 482.Oral evidence

Decision

Reasons for decision

Accordingly, no jurisdictional arises in relation to the Tribunal’s consideration of the stepdaughter argument.CONCLUSION For the above reasons, the application before this Court is successful. Finally, as a consequence of the passage of the Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No 1) Act 2024 (Cth), the name of the second respondent is to be amended to ‘Administrative Review Tribunal’. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established