Nelson v Commissioner of Highways (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Land and Valuation Division)

NELSON v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS (No 2)

[2023] SASC 7

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Blue  

19 January 2023

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - OCCUPATION OF ACQUIRED LAND

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - MARKET VALUE

The respondent compulsorily acquired land pursuant to section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA). The land was owned by the first applicant and was subject to an equitable lease in favour of the second applicant, which was a company owned and controlled by the first applicant and the trustee of his family trust, and which carried on a barbecue and heater retail business on the land.

The market value of the land as at the date of acquisition was previously determined to be $2,330,000: Nelson v Commissioner of Highways [2020] SASC 109.

These reasons for judgment address other claims for compensation by the applicants.

The claims by the second applicant are:

1Goodwill of the business.

2Discounted future maintainable earnings of the business.

3Closing down costs of the business.

4Warehousing costs for unsold stock and equipment of the business.

5Loss of profit of the business in the 2013/14 year.

6Special value by reference to employment in the business of the first applicant’s family members.

The claims by the first applicant are:

1Lost opportunity to earn a wage as the manager employed by the business.

2Lost/reduced rent and salary for 2013/14 year (in the alternative to the second applicant’s claim).

3Rates and taxes on the land.

4Time spent as a consequence of the acquisition.

Held in respect of the claims by the second applicant:

1The market value of the business was $236,844 from which must be deducted the value of stock and equipment, leaving goodwill valued at $106,305 (at [233]).

2In relation to the claim for compensation by reference to the present value of the future maintainable earnings of the business:

(a)the claim is open to be advanced by the second applicant having regard to its pleadings and the manner in which it ran its case (at [257]); but

(b)the second applicant failed to establish the claim on the merits (at [273]).

3The second applicant is entitled to compensation of $37,749.73 for closing down costs (at [280]).

4The second applicant is entitled to compensation of $19,042 for warehousing costs for unsold stock and equipment (at [304]).

5The second applicant is entitled to compensation of $106,876 for loss of profit in the 2013/14 year (at [331]).

6In relation to the claim for compensation for special value by reference to employment of the first applicant’s family members:

(a)the claim is open to be advanced under the Act (at [421]); but

(b)the second applicant failed to establish the claim on the merits (at [430]).

7The second applicant is entitled to compensation totalling $269,972.73 (at [466]).

Held in respect of the claims by the first applicant:

8In relation to the claim for compensation for loss of opportunity to earn…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nelson v Commissioner of Highways (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Nelson v Commissioner of Highways (No 2), the court was tasked with determining compensation claims made by Mr Nelson following the compulsory acquisition of his land by the Commissioner of Highways. The primary legal issues revolved around the assessment of compensation for various claims including lost wages, reduced rent and salary, rates and taxes on the acquired land, and the time spent by Mr Nelson as a consequence of the acquisition.

The court examined the validity of Mr Nelson's claims for lost wages, reduced rental income, and additional costs incurred due to the compulsory acquisition. It was determined that Mr Nelson was entitled to compensation for SA Water charges and rates and taxes on the acquired land for specific periods. However, the claim for lost wages as the manager of his business was dismissed as there was no evidence of such a role or income. The court also found that the claim for reduced rent and salary was not substantiated by the evidence provided.

Regarding the time spent by Mr Nelson as a consequence of the acquisition, the court accepted that he was entitled to some compensation for time spent in activities such as performing a stocktake, closing the business, and searching for alternative sites. However, the court reduced the claimed amount from $20,910 to $10,000, based on a broad assessment of the reasonable time spent on these activities. The court concluded that some of the claimed time, such as that spent by an employee who was not a claimant, was not compensable.

The final orders of the court granted Mr Nelson compensation for SA Water charges to the tune of $106.56 for the period 14 June to 30 June 2014 and for rates and taxes totalling $3,455.97 for the period after 13 March 2014. The court also awarded Mr Nelson $10,000 for time spent as a consequence of the acquisition, reflecting a reduction from the originally claimed amount.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claims by Mr Nelson are:1Lost opportunity to earn a wage as the manager employed by the business.2Lost/reduced rent and salary for the 2013/14 year.[2]3Rates and taxes on the Land.4Time spent as a consequence of the acquisition.[2] This claim is in the alternative to the Company’s fifth claim referred to above.Background I set out here matters of background relevant to the claims the subject of this judgment. More detailed background facts (particularly about the Land) are set out in my previous judgment.[3][3] Nelson v Commissioner of Highways [2020] SASC 109. Mr Nelson was born in October 1950. In May 1983 Mr Nelson and his then wife Ilona incorporated Colin Nelson Nominees Pty Ltd (the Company) to carry on a barbecue and heater business as trustee of the Colin Nelson Family Trust (the Trust). Mr Nelson and Ilona were the sole (equal) shareholders and directors of the Company. In February 1997, upon their divorce, Ilona transferred her share to Mr Nelson and ceased to be a director. In 1983 a trust deed for the Trust was executed. The trust deed cannot now be located. A deed of renunciation executed in April 1997 was tendered. It indicates that the Trust was a discretionary family trust and that Mr Nelson and Ilona were the primary beneficiaries. By the deed of renunciation, Ilona renounced any interest in the Trust. I infer that, following the renunciation, Mr Nelson was the sole primary beneficiary and the other eligible beneficiaries were his spouse (if any), his children and his remoter issue (if any). This is consistent with the Trust’s financial statements which show income distributions to Mr Nelson, his current wife Mechelle and his sons. In 1983 the Company as trustee of the Trust leased land at 59-61 South Road Torrensville and commenced carrying on business trading as “Bonza BBQ’s and Stoves” (the Business). Mr Nelson worked full time in the Business and after about 12 months also employed a sales assistant. In 1989, upon the premises burning down, the Company moved the Business into temporary premises directly across the road at Hindmarsh and searched for alternative long term premises. In February 1991 Mr Nelson settled on the purchase of the Land. The Land was about four kilometres by road south-west of the centre of the Adelaide central business district. It had a frontage onto the western side of South Road. Its area was 2,106 square metres.[4] [4] All areas in square metres are rounded to the nearest square metre unless otherwise indicated. In 1991 Mr Nelson constructed a showroom and offices on the Land as stage 1 of its development (the showroom). The gross lettable area (GLA) of the showroom was 552 square metres. At that stage Mr Nelson worked full time in the Business and also employed a sales assistant. In 2000-2001 Mr Nelson constructed a showroom addition on the Land as stage 2 of its development (the showroom addition).[5] The GLA of the showroom addition was approximately 195 square metres.[5] There was an issue the subject of my previous reasons for judgment whether this building was a combination showroom/warehouse or merely a warehouse. I used the term “showroom addition” in a neutral sense, taking it from the description of the development on the submitted plans.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Nelson is entitled to recover compensation in respect of SA Water charges in respect of the period 14 June to 30 June 2014 in the amount of $106.56.Conclusion Mr Nelson is entitled to recover compensation in respect of rates and taxes paid in respect of the period after 13 March 2014 totalling $3,455.97.Time spent Mr Nelson claims $20,910[73] as the value of time spent by him as a consequence of the acquisition.[73] In his second witness statement Mr Nelson claimed $28,710 including for time spent searching for alternative sites up to December 2015. However, in closing address he accepted that the claim for that time should be up to December 2014. The claim is for 697[74] hours at $30 per hour. The time claimed to have been spent comprises:1time spent performing the 2021 stocktake comprising an estimated 30 hours spent by Mr Nelson and an estimated 12 hours spent by Carlo;2time spent closing the Business and sorting and dumping items comprising an estimated 160 hours spent by Mr Nelson;3time spent in assisting and supervising the movement of stock from the Land to the Beverley warehouse comprising an estimated 50 hours spent by Mr Nelson;4time spent in discussions with the Department, Badge Constructions, valuers, the Council and the Ombudsman comprising an estimated 60 hours spent by Mr Nelson; and5time spent searching for alternative sites for the Business between July 2013 and December 2014[75] comprising an estimated 385 hours spent by Mr Nelson on the basis of an estimated five hours per week.[74] In his second witness statement Mr Nelson claimed 957 hours including for time spent searching for alternative sites up to December 2015. However, in closing address he accepted that the claim for that time should be up to December 2014.[75] In his second witness statement Mr Nelson claimed 645 hours spent searching for alternative sites up to December 2015 at five hours per week. However, in closing address he accepted that the claim for that time should be up to December 2014. The Commissioner contends that Mr Nelson is not entitled to compensation for some of the items of time spent, has not proved the time spent in respect of other items and is not entitled to compensation at a rate of $30 per hour. The Commissioner accepts that Mr Nelson is entitled to total compensation in respect of time spent of $10,000 based on a broad axe assessment. In relation to the 2021 stocktake, I accept the Commissioner’s submission that, because Carlo is not a claimant and there is no evidence that he was paid by the Company or Mr Nelson for working on the stocktake, compensation cannot be recovered for his time working on the stocktake. I am not persuaded that the stocktake should have been performed before the stock was moved from the Land on closure of the Business. However, it should have been performed shortly after the stock was moved to the Beverley warehouse. If it had been performed then, it should have been completed in substantially less time than was ultimately devoted.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.