Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division)

CHADRYSIAK v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS (No 2)

[2018] SASC 191

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

19 December 2018

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - PROCEEDINGS FOR COMPENSATION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - COSTS

PROCEDURE - CIVIL PROCEEDINGS IN STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS - COSTS - PARTIES AND NON-PARTIES - CROWN OR CROWN OFFICER

Application for costs.

Mr Chadrysiak made claims for compensation for market value and disturbance which were settled in January 2018 shortly before trial and a claim for loss due to a rising market on which he was unsuccessful at trial.

Mr Chadrysiak seeks an order that the Commissioner pay his costs of action. The Commissioner agrees to an order that he pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to May 2016 but contends that each party should bear their own costs thereafter.

Held:

(1) The exercise of discretion in relation to costs in a compulsory acquisition case under section 36 of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) differs from the exercise of discretion in ordinary civil litigation (at [22]-[26]).

(2) Wielding a broad axe, and considering both the conventional and rising market claims holistically, it is appropriate to order that the Commissioner pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to 26 July 2017 and that each party bear their own costs thereafter (at [32]).

Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) s 36, referred to.
Dillon v Gosford City Council [2011] NSWCA 328, (2011) 184 LGERA 179; Minister for the Environment v Florence (1979) 21 SASR 108, considered.

CHADRYSIAK v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS (No 2)
[2018] SASC 191

Land and Valuation Division

BLUE J:

  1. This is an application for costs. The background to the matter is set out in my principal reasons for judgment in Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways.[1]

  2. Mr Chadrysiak made conventional claims for compensation for market value and disturbance. These claims were settled in January 2018 shortly before trial. He also made a claim for loss due to a rising market which proceeded to trial and on which he was unsuccessful.

  3. Mr Chadrysiak seeks an order that the Commissioner pay his costs of action. The Commissioner agrees to an order that he pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to May 2016 but contends that each party should bear their own costs thereafter.

    Background

  4. On 30 January 2014 the Commissioner compulsorily acquired Mr Chadrysiak’s house property. The Commissioner offered and paid into Court compensation of $419,000 calculated as $385,000 for the value of the land and $34,000 for general disturbance (the costs of Mr Chadrysiak acquiring and moving to a replacement house property). The compensation offered was based on a valuation obtained by the Commissioner in December 2013.

  5. In September 2014 Mr Chadrysiak obtained a valuation from Mr Morgan of $715,000 for the land on the basis of commercial use and $5,000 for general disturbance.

  6. In February 2015 Mr Chadrysiak filed an interlocutory application seeking the assessment of compensation at $720,000.

  7. In March…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways (No 2) involved Mr Chadrysiak, who sought compensation from the Commissioner of Highways for the compulsory acquisition of his property. The Commissioner had acquired the property on 30 January 2014, offering and paying into Court a compensation of $419,000 based on a valuation obtained in December 2013. Mr Chadrysiak contested the amount of compensation, obtaining valuations from different valuers that varied significantly from the Commissioner's offer. The dispute included claims for both conventional and rising market compensation, with the latter being ultimately rejected by the court.

The legal issues before the court included determining the appropriate compensation for the property acquisition, the admissibility and weight of different expert valuations, and the entitlement to costs incurred during the litigation process. Specifically, the court needed to decide whether Mr Chadrysiak was entitled to additional compensation for the loss due to a rising market and the appropriate costs order given the progression of the litigation.

The court considered the valuations and expert opinions provided by both parties, concluding that while the Commissioner’s initial offer was inadequate, Mr Chadrysiak failed to prove causation for the rising market claim. The court also reviewed the procedural history and the timing of various offers and payments. Given the extensive litigation and the multiple offers and counteroffers, the court determined that the Commissioner should bear the costs up until 26 July 2017, the date when the Commissioner made a significant payment towards the settlement of the dispute. Each party was ordered to bear their own costs incurred after this date.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Chadrysiak seeks an order that the Commissioner pay his costs of action. The Commissioner agrees to an order that he pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to May 2016 but contends that each party should bear their own costs thereafter.Background On 30 January 2014 the Commissioner compulsorily acquired Mr Chadrysiak’s house property. The Commissioner offered and paid into Court compensation of $419,000 calculated as $385,000 for the value of the land and $34,000 for general disturbance (the costs of Mr Chadrysiak acquiring and moving to a replacement house property). The compensation offered was based on a valuation obtained by the Commissioner in December 2013. In September 2014 Mr Chadrysiak obtained a valuation from Mr Morgan of $715,000 for the land on the basis of commercial use and $5,000 for general disturbance. In February 2015 Mr Chadrysiak filed an interlocutory application seeking the assessment of compensation at $720,000. In March 2015 the Commissioner obtained a valuation from a second valuer of $500,000 for the land on the basis of residential use and $45,000 for general disturbance. In February 2016 Mr Chadrysiak obtained a further valuation from Mr Morgan of $600,000 for the land on the basis of home business use and $51,000 for general disturbance. On 3 May 2016 the Commissioner filed and served a formal offer to pay $548,000 comprising $500,000 for the value of the land and $48,000 for distrubance plus interest and costs. On 19 April 2017 Mr Chadrysiak filed a statement of claim in which he claimed $510,000 as the value of the land, $45,000 for general disturbance and $2,500 for extra disturbance. He also claimed $71,400 for loss due to a rising market based on appreciation in property values from January 2014 to April 2017. On 17 May 2017 the Commissioner filed a defence pleading that the market value of the land was $500,000, admitting the general and extra disturbance claims of $47,500 and denying the rising market claim. On 12 July 2017 the Commissioner made an informal offer to settle the action by payment of $555,000 plus interest and costs. On 28 July 2017 the Commissioner paid to Mr Chadrysiak the difference between $545,000 and the amount previously paid into Court plus interest. In January 2018 Mr Chadrysiak and the Commissioner agreed that the value of the land as at January 2014 was $505,000. This resolved all claims except the rising market claim. In February 2018 the loss due to a rising market claim proceeded to trial. In June 2018 I delivered reasons for judgment, holding that Mr Chadrysiak was not entitled to any compensation for loss due to a rising market. I held that such a loss could in principle be recovered but Mr Chadrysiak had failed to prove causation, ie that the inadequate compensation offered by the Commissioner was a cause of his not purchasing a replacement property.The parties’ contentions It is common ground that the Commissioner should pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs to 17 May 2016 being 14 days after the Commissioner’s offer of 3 May 2016.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Wielding a broad axe, and considering both the conventional and rising market claims holistically, it is appropriate to order that the Commissioner pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to 26 July 2017. Conclusion I order that the Commissioner pay Mr Chadrysiak’s costs up to and including 26 July 2017. I order that each party bear their own costs incurred after 26 July 2017.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established