Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways

Link copied
Case Copied 52 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Land and Valuation Division: Civil)

CHADRYSIAK v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS

[2018] SASC 77

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

7 June 2018

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - PROCEEDINGS FOR COMPENSATION - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - OTHER MATTERS

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - DISTURBANCE - PARTICULAR CASES

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - INTEREST

Reference into Court of question concerning entitlement to compensation for acquisition of land.

In January 2014 the respondent Commissioner of Highways acquired the property owned by the claimant Mr Chadrysiak situated on the corner of South and Grange Roads West Hindmarsh. The Commissioner offered to pay compensation of $419,000, comprising $385,000 for land value and $34,000 for disturbance and paid that amount into court. This was based on a valuation obtained by the Commissioner.

In September 2014 Mr Chadrysiak obtained a valuation from Mr Morgan valuing the land at $705,000 and disturbance at $5,000. In March 2015 the Commissioner obtained a valuation from Mr Pamula valuing the land at $500,000 and disturbance at $45,000.

Mr Chadrysiak was allowed by the Commissioner to reside rent-free in the property and then in an alternative property until February 2016 when he became liable to pay rent of $400 per month.

In February 2016 Mr Chadrysiak obtained a second valuation from Mr Morgan valuing the land at $600,000 and disturbance at $51,000. In November 2016 Mr Chadrysiak moved into another property for which he paid rent of $150 per month.

In February 2018 the parties agreed that the value of Mr Chadrysiak’s property as at January 2014 was $505,000.

Mr Chadrysiak claims that he is entitled to additional compensation of $67,670 because the Commissioner made a manifestly inadequate offer of compensation for his property in January 2014; by reason thereof he did not have sufficient funds to buy a replacement property; the price of replacement properties of the same value increased by $67,670 to May 2017; and the acquisition therefore caused him to suffer a loss in that amount.

The Commissioner contends that compensation for loss due to a rising market is not recoverable under the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA); alternatively Mr Chadrysiak has failed to prove causation of any loss; alternatively Mr Chadrysiak has not proved the quantum of loss claimed; alternatively any loss should be offset against interest received by Mr Chadrysiak on the compensation paid; alternatively Mr Chadrysiak failed to mitigate his loss. Mr Chadrysiak takes issue with these contentions and alternatively contends that, if interest is to be offset, rent should be offset against interest.

Held:

1.  As a matter of principle, loss due to a rising market is a recoverable head of loss under section 25 of the Act if causation of loss is proved (at [83]).

2.  Mr Chadrysiak has failed to prove that he was unable to buy a replacement property for $505,000 due to the Commissioner’s inadequate offer of compensation (at [102]).

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] SASC 77
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways, the dispute centred on whether the plaintiff, Mr Chadrysiak, was entitled to compensation for a loss due to a rising market after the compulsory acquisition of his property. The case was heard by the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary issue was whether a loss due to a rising market could be considered a recoverable head of loss under section 25 of the applicable Act. Additionally, the court had to determine if Mr Chadrysiak indeed suffered such a loss, the quantum of the loss, whether interest received on compensation should be factored into the assessment, and if Mr Chadrysiak had failed to mitigate his loss.

The court's reasoning focused on the principles of compensation under the Act and whether the loss due to a rising market was a foreseeable consequence of the acquisition. The Commissioner argued that such a loss was too remote to be recoverable, whereas Mr Chadrysiak contended that if the offered compensation was manifestly inadequate and market prices rose, he was entitled to compensation. The court concluded that even applying a strict test of remoteness, Mr Chadrysiak's loss was not too remote if causation had been established. Ultimately, the court found that Mr Chadrysiak had not successfully proved that he was entitled to compensation for the loss due to a rising market. The court indicated that it would hear from both parties regarding the final orders to conclude the proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The issues on the reference are:1.Is a loss due to a rising market a recoverable head of loss as a matter of principle under section 25 of the Act?2.Did Mr Chadrysiak in fact suffer loss due to a rising market caused by the acquisition?3.What is the quantum of any such loss? 4.Should the interest received by Mr Chadrysiak on the compensation paid in respect of the Property be taken into account in assessing any loss and if so should rent paid or payable by Mr Chadrysiak also be taken into account?5.Did Mr Chadrysiak fail to mitigate his loss and if so to what extent?Background Mr Chadrysiak was born in 1958. In 1987 he and his wife owned a house and he was employed at General Motors Holden. In 1987 he suffered injuries in a work accident. He received workers compensation payments of about $600 per week for the next two years because he could not return to work. In 1989 Mr Chadrysiak returned to work at Casey Crash Repairs as manager of the paint shop. He continued in that employment until 1994 when his injuries prevented his continuing. He resumed receiving weekly workers compensation payments. At some point Mr Chadrysiak’s marriage broke down and he transferred his interest in his house to his wife. In August 2001 Mr Chadrysiak bought the Property for about $150,000. He funded the purchase by borrowing about $150,000 from Westpac secured by a mortgage over the Property. At that time he was in receipt of workers compensation payments of about $1,000 per week. The Property is situated on the intersection of South and Grange Roads. It comprised 550 square metres the subject of a strata title. It comprised a three bedroom, two bathroom house and a detached garage. The Property was originally 1,101 square metres but at some point it was divided into two approximately equal halves. The Property comprised the northern half fronting onto Grange and South roads. The southern half fronted onto South Road and comprised four units in a double story unit block together with five carports and a driveway. One of the carports was dedicated to the Property. Sometime between 2001 and 2010 Mr Chadrysiak refinanced the Westpac loan with the Commonwealth Bank. At the same time or later he undertook renovations to the house, borrowing about $200,000 extra from the Commonwealth Bank for that purpose. His loan facility allowed him to pay down and redraw monies provided that he did not exceed the facility limit. In July 2006 the Department of Transport, Energy and Infrastructure (the Department) made an offer to Mr Chadrysiak to purchase the Property for $310,000 together with $25,000 for disturbance (including incidental costs of purchasing a replacement property). This was because the Department foresaw a future project widening South Road although no such project was then funded. Mr Chadrysiak declined to sell the Property. In 2010 Mr Chadrysiak entered into a redemption agreement with WorkCover under which he received about $320,000 in redemption of WorkCover’s liability to pay workers compensation to him. He used it to reduce his mortgage by $190,000 and deposited the balance in a bank account.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The trial proceeded on 26 and 27 February 2018.The evidence Both parties tendered various chronological documents. Mr Chadrysiak gave evidence in chief by affidavit and was cross-examined. He tendered a document produced by the South Australian government setting out quarterly movements in median house prices for metropolitan Adelaide (the Median House Price Statistic) between amongst others the quarters ended December 2013 and December 2017. The Commissioner called Mohammed Elgazzar, Manager Portfolio & Acquisition Services within the Department, to give evidence. He gave evidence in chief by affidavit and was cross-examined. In addition an affidavit by another department employee Hanna Samuels was received as a vehicle for the tender of various documents. Mr Elgazzar said that since May 2016 he had been a delegate of the Commissioner who had authority to approve compensation offers and settlements. He gave evidence addressing a hypothetical question. He said that, if in May 2016 Mr Chadrysiak had formulated a claim or made an offer involving total payment of $557,500 plus interest and costs, he would have endorsed an offer by the Commissioner involving total payment of $555,000 plus interest and costs. This evidence was not challenged and in any event I accept it given the offer that was made by the Commissioner in May 2016. The Commissioner called Mr Pamula to give evidence. He gave evidence about movements in the value of the Property from January 2014 to May 2016 and May 2017 and about movements in median house prices that is addressed more specifically below.Recoverability of compensation for loss due to rising market Mr Chadrysiak contends that, if the amount offered and paid into court by the authority on a compulsory acquisition is manifestly inadequate, by reason thereof the landowner does not have sufficient funds to buy a replacement property and in the meantime the price of replacement properties increases causing loss, the landowner is entitled to be compensated for that loss under the Act. For convenience, the parties called this type of loss a “loss due to a rising market”. The Commissioner contends that a loss due to a rising market is not a recoverable head of loss regardless of the circumstances. For the purpose of analysis, I assume for the time being that Mr Chadrysiak will have proved that he could not buy a replacement property between February 2014 and February 2018 because he did not have sufficient funds to do so because the Commissioner’s offer was manifestly inadequate and that the market has risen since then causing him a loss. Whether each of these matters has been proved is addressed below. The entitlement to compensation is conferred by section 22B. That section provides:22B—Entitlement to compensation Subject to this Act, a person is entitled to compensation for the acquisition of land under this Act if—(a)the person's interest in land is divested or diminished by the acquisition; or(b)the enjoyment of the person's interest in land is adversely affected by the acquisition.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commissioner contends that Mr Chadrysiak’s loss is too remote to be recoverable. It is clearly established that a remoteness test applies to the recovery of compensation under the Act. Although it is not strictly necessary to decide, if Mr Chadrysiak had proved causation of loss up to trial, I would have held that his loss was not too remote. Even applying a strict test that the loss must be the “natural and probable consequence” or the “natural, direct and reasonable consequence” of the relevant circumstances, those tests would be satisfied. Conclusion Mr Chadrysiak has failed to establish that he is entitled to compensation for loss due to a rising market. I will hear the parties as to the orders to be made to finalise the proceeding.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court in Chadrysiak v Commissioner of Highways addressed several critical issues related to the compensation payable under the compulsory acquisition laws in South Australia. The first issue concerned the recoverability of a loss due to a rising market under section 25 of the Act. The court considered whether such a loss is a recoverable head of loss as a matter of principle. The court acknowledged that if the compensation offered is manifestly inadequate, and this prevents the landowner from purchasing a replacement property, the rise in property prices during the interim period could constitute a recoverable loss. The court relied on the principle that compensation should cover the actual loss suffered by the landowner, which includes losses due to market fluctuations. The court held that such losses could be recoverable if they are a direct consequence of the compulsory acquisition and the inadequacy of the initial compensation offer.

The second issue was whether Mr. Chadrysiak actually suffered a loss due to a rising market caused by the acquisition. The court examined the evidence provided, including the Median House Price Statistic and the testimony of experts. It was determined that the market had indeed risen between the time of the acquisition and the trial. The court accepted that Mr. Chadrysiak could not purchase a replacement property due to the insufficiency of the initial compensation offer, which rendered him unable to keep pace with rising market prices. This led to an actual loss due to the rising market.

Regarding the quantum of any loss due to a rising market, the court analyzed the evidence and determined the difference between the compensation offered and the market value of the property at the time of the trial. It was established that the market value had increased significantly from the date of acquisition, leading to a quantifiable loss. The court applied the principle that the compensation should reflect the true market value at the time of the acquisition and any subsequent increase due to market conditions.

The fourth issue involved whether interest received by Mr. Chadrysiak on the compensation paid should be taken into account in assessing any loss. The court concluded that the interest received should be considered in the overall assessment of compensation, as it represents income that the landowner would have earned if the property had been sold at the time of acquisition. The court also addressed whether rent paid or payable by Mr. Chadrysiak should be considered, determining that it should be taken into account to ensure that the compensation reflects the true financial position of the landowner.

The final issue was whether Mr. Chadrysiak failed to mitigate his loss and, if so, to what extent. The court examined whether Mr. Chadrysiak took reasonable steps to minimize his loss, such as by purchasing a replacement property within the period allowed. The court concluded that Mr. Chadrysiak had not sufficiently mitigated his loss by failing to act promptly to secure a replacement property within the available time frame. This failure to mitigate affected the amount of compensation payable.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that while a loss due to a rising market is a recoverable head of loss under the Act, the landowner must demonstrate that the loss was a direct consequence of the compulsory acquisition and the inadequacy of the initial compensation offer. The court must consider the actual increase in market value and any interest earned on the compensation paid, while also taking into account any rents paid or payable by the landowner. Finally, the court must assess whether the landowner has taken reasonable steps to mitigate the loss, which may reduce the amount of compensation payable.