Nelson v Commissioner of Highways

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Land and Valuation Division)

NELSON v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS

[2020] SASC 109

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Blue

19 June 2020

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - MARKET VALUE - GENERALLY

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - MARKET VALUE - CAPITALISATION OF INCOME

Referral of question of market value of land compulsorily acquired in 2014 under section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA). The land had been used to retail barbecues and wood heaters.

Expert valuation evidence was given by a valuer called by the plaintiff and two valuers called by the defendant. The valuers agreed that the highest and best use of the land was its existing use as a bulky goods store and that the most appropriate method of valuation was by capitalisation of imputed rental income. Each valuer arrived at a different valuation.

Held:

1. The imputed rental value of the land at the time of acquisition was $188,050 per annum, from which land tax should be deducted, resulting in net rental income of $182,203 per annum (at [154], [157], [158]).

2. The appropriate capitalisation rate was 7.75 per cent (at [187]).

3. The value of the land therefore comprised $2,330,000 after deducting the estimated cost of installing air conditioning and rounding (at [193]).

Development Act 1993 (SA) s 42; Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) ss 16, 22B, 23C, 25; Retail and Commercial Leases Act 1995 (SA) s 30; Retail and Commercial Leases Regulations 2010 (SA), referred to.
Wade v South Australian Planning Commission (1985) 59 LGRA 290, discussed.
Cook v City of Stirling (1991) 4 WAR 469 ; District Council of Lower Eyre Peninsula v Allen [2007] SASC 333; Spencer v The Commonwealth (1907) 5 CLR 418; Sydney Water Corporation v Caruso [2009] NSWCA 391, considered.

NELSON v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS
[2020] SASC 109

Land and Valuation Division

BLUE J:

  1. On 13 March 2014 the defendant, the Commissioner of Highways, compulsorily acquired land at 38A South Road Torrensville from the first plaintiff, Colin Nelson, pursuant to section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) (the Act).

  2. Mr Nelson has referred to the Court the question of the market value of the land pursuant to section 23C of the Act. These reasons for judgment address that question. Other questions relating to compensation to Mr Nelson and to the second plaintiff, Colin Nelson Nominees Pty Ltd, are to be addressed subsequently.

    Background

    Purchase, development and use of the land

  3. In February 1991 Mr Nelson purchased the land at 38A South Road Torrensville contained in certificate of title register book volume 4145 folio 998. I refer to the land including its improvements as the Land or the subject property.

  4. The Land was about 4 kilometres by road south-west of the centre of the Adelaide central business district.

  5. The Land had a frontage onto the western…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Nelson v Commissioner of Highways and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] SASC 109
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Nelson v Commissioner of Highways, the court was asked to determine the market value of land owned by Mr Nelson, which was subject to compulsory acquisition. The compulsory acquisition was initiated by the Commissioner of Highways, and Mr Nelson sought to have the compensation assessed according to the market value of the land. The case was heard and determined in the Supreme Court of South Australia. The primary legal issue before the court was the determination of the market value of the land, specifically whether the valuation should be based on the capitalisation of income or another method. The court also had to consider the appropriate capitalisation rate to be applied.

The court approached the issue of market value by first considering the evidence provided by the parties regarding the imputed market rent of the land and the potential income it could generate. After evaluating the evidence, the court determined that the imputed market rent of the land was $188,050 per annum, which was then adjusted for land tax to arrive at a net rental income of $182,203. The court then assessed the appropriate capitalisation rate to be 7.75 per cent. Applying this rate to the net rental income resulted in a capital value of $2,351,006, which was rounded to $2,350,000. The court also considered the additional costs of installing air-conditioning, for which it allowed a deduction of $20,000, resulting in a final capital value of $2,330,000. The court thus assessed the market value of the land at $2,330,000.

The court will hear the parties concerning the orders to be made to reflect the court's reasons for judgment and concerning the further conduct of this action.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Nelson has referred to the Court the question of the market value of the land pursuant to section 23C of the Act. These reasons for judgment address that question. Other questions relating to compensation to Mr Nelson and to the second plaintiff, Colin Nelson Nominees Pty Ltd, are to be addressed subsequently.BackgroundPurchase, development and use of the land In February 1991 Mr Nelson purchased the land at 38A South Road Torrensville contained in certificate of title register book volume 4145 folio 998. I refer to the land including its improvements as the Land or the subject property. The Land was about 4 kilometres by road south-west of the centre of the Adelaide central business district. The Land had a frontage onto the western side of South Road. It was a right-angled trapezium. For ease of reference, I assume that South Road runs exactly north – south at that point when describing the location of the Land and the position of buildings and other features on it. Its front (eastern) boundary was 80.0 metres long.[1] Its rear (western) boundary was 85.2 metres long. Its right-hand side (southern) boundary was 25.6 metres long and was at a right angle to its front and rear boundaries. Its left-hand side (northern) boundary was 25.9 metres long. Its area was 2,106 square metres.[2] [1] All lengths in metres are rounded to the nearest 0.1 metre unless otherwise indicated.[2] All areas in square metres are rounded to the nearest square metre unless otherwise indicated. When Mr Nelson purchased the Land, his company Colin Nelson Nominees Pty Ltd was carrying on a barbecue and wood heater retail business at nearby premises on South Road under the name “Bonza BBQ’s and Stoves” (Bonza BBQ). Mr Nelson purchased the Land for the purpose of constructing a showroom/warehouse on the Land with associated car parking, access and egress and landscaping. He moved the Bonza BBQ business onto the Land shortly after settlement. In October 1990, after entering into a contract to purchase the Land and before settlement, Mr Nelson applied to the City of West Torrens (the Council) for development approval to use the Land for the retail sale of barbecues and heaters and to construct a showroom with associated car parking and landscaping. In December 1990 the Council granted development approval. In 1991 Mr Nelson constructed a showroom on the Land as stage 1 of its development (the showroom). The showroom was rectangular with a length of 35.4 metres and a width of 15.6 metres. It had a span clearance of 3.5 metres. It was in the south-western quadrant of the Land with its rear wall on the western boundary and its right-hand wall on the southern boundary. Its frontage was 35.4 metres parallel to the frontage of the Land onto South Road. It had a rectangular veranda on its eastern side along most of its frontage (the rectangular veranda). The showroom walls were constructed of brick, except the rear (western) wall, which was constructed of coloured-bonded iron. The roof of the showroom and the veranda were constructed of coloured-bonded iron. The primary access to the showroom was through glass doors from the veranda to the east. It had a roller door 2.9 metres wide by 3.5 metres high in its northern wall (the internal roller door). It also had a separate single door in its northern wall. The showroom contained a separate office, kitchen and bathroom with two toilets and a shower.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I assess an appropriate capitalisation rate at 7.75 per cent.Conclusion I have determined that the imputed market rent of the Land was $188,050 per annum. Deducting $5,847 for land tax results in net rental of $182,203. I have determined that an appropriate capitalisation rate is 7.75 per cent. Applying that rate results in a capital value of $2,351,006, which I rounded to $2,350,000. Ms Gornall expressed the opinion that it is appropriate to make an allowance for the capital costs of installing air conditioning. Mr Smithson in his oral evidence agreed with that approach. Mr Fudali did not disagree. Ms Gornall included an allowance of $10,000. Mr Smithson expressed the opinion that it would cost substantially more to install reverse cycle air-conditioning. I accept Mr Smithson’s opinion. Although no precise quantification was identified, I consider it is appropriate to allow $20,000 to install air-conditioning in the showroom and showroom addition. Deducting the cost of air-conditioning results in a capital value of $2,330,000. I assess the market value of the land at $2,330,000. I will hear the parties concerning the orders to be made to reflect my reasons for judgment and concerning the further conduct of this action.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.