DLFCMS Nominees Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

DLFCMS NOMINEES PTY LTD & ANOR v COMMISSIONER OF HIGHWAYS

[2024] SASC 140

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Kimber  

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - MARKET VALUE - CAPITALISATION OF INCOME

REAL PROPERTY - COMPULSORY ACQUISITION OF LAND - COMPENSATION - ASSESSMENT - SPECIAL VALUE

The first applicant was the registered proprietor of land (the land) which it leased to the second applicant, a childcare business. The land was subject to a ten-year lease with four rights of renewal each for five years. On 16 April 2020, the land was compulsorily acquired by the respondent under s 10 of the Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) (the Act).  As a result, the business of the second applicant was extinguished.  On 16 July 2020, the respondent paid the first applicant interim compensation of $7,535,000 plus interest and disturbance.  On 1 December 2020, the respondent paid the second applicant interim compensation of $2,000,000 plus interest in respect of the extinguishment of the second applicant’s business.  

The applicants referred to this Court the question of their entitlement to compensation pursuant to the Act. 

The first applicant contends, inter alia, that it should be compensated based on ‘special value’ and that, notwithstanding the lease in place, the land should be valued based on a lease term of 20 years.  The respondent contends that compensation should not be based on ‘special value’ and that the land should be valued based on the lease in place. 

The second applicant contends, inter alia, that the business should be valued based on an occupancy rate of 95 per cent and that the compensation should include an amount of $55,000 because of the COVID-19 pandemic.  The respondent contends that the valuation should be calculated based on an occupancy rate of 82 per cent and that the amount of $55,000 should not be included. 

Held, inter alia:

1.      The first applicant is not to be compensated based on ‘special value’.

2.The land acquired from the first applicant is to be valued based on the lease in place on the date of the acquisition of the land. 

3.The business of the second applicant is to be valued based upon an occupancy rate of 86 per cent.

4.      The second applicant is not entitled to the amount of $55,000 sought.

5.      The issue of the proper approach to the applicants’ legal costs and disbursements is deferred. 

Land Acquisition Act 1969 (SA) ss 10, 22B, 25, 25(1), referred to.

Arkaba Holdings Ltd v Commissioner of Highways [1970] SASR 94; Boland v Yates Property Corporation Pty Ltd (1999) 74 ALJR 209; [1999] HCA 64; Director of Buildings and Lands v Shun Fung Ironworks [1995] 2 AC 111; Emerald Quarry Industries Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways [No 2] (1976) 18 SASR 438; Nelson v Commissioner of Highways (No 2) [2023] SASC 7; Spencer v Commonwealth (1907) 5…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read DLFCMS Nominees Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] SASC 140
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of DLFCMS Nominees Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways, the dispute involved the valuation of land and business assets for the purposes of determining compensation for their compulsory acquisition by the Commissioner of Highways. The applicants, DLFCMS Nominees Pty Ltd and KKM Early Learning Centre, argued for a higher valuation of their property and business based on certain assumptions about future occupancy rates and business performance, while the Commissioner contended for a lower valuation. The court was required to determine the appropriate valuation methodology and factors to consider in assessing the compensation payable.

The key legal issues before the court were the appropriate methodology for valuing the land and business, the correct occupancy rate to be used in calculating the business's value, and the extent to which the business's future performance could be considered in the valuation. The court had to weigh the evidence and submissions from both parties to determine the market value of the land and the value of the business at the time of acquisition.

The court found that the first applicant had not established that the land should be valued on the assumption of a 20-year lease, as this would result in an overvaluation. The court concluded that the land should be valued based on a 10-year lease term, as both valuations were based on the same methodology and the difference between them was limited. The court further determined that the second applicant was entitled to compensation for the loss of its business based on an 86 per cent occupancy rate, a daily fee per child of $121, and an earnings multiple of 4.3. The court also awarded compensation for lost profits, redundancy payments, and ordered that certain amounts be deducted from the second applicant's compensation. The issue of legal costs was deferred for further consideration.

In summary, the court ordered that the land be valued at $7,510,000, the second applicant be compensated for the loss of its business based on specific occupancy and fee rates, and that lost profits and redundancy payments be awarded. The court deferred the issue of legal costs for further consideration by the parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

The primary dispute with respect to the valuation of the business relates to what should be used as the occupancy rate of the childcare centre; that rate then informing the valuation. The second applicant submits that the occupancy rate used should be 95 per cent, a rate which it says would have been achieved by February 2020. The primary submission of the respondent is that the occupancy rate used should be 82 per cent, being the average occupancy in the 52 weeks to 15 December 2019. In the alternative, the respondent submits that the occupancy rate used should be no greater than 86 per cent. Background Mr D Fitch is the principal of DBRB Investments, a group of companies with diverse interests in property and other investments. Mr D Fitch is the sole shareholder and director of the first applicant. Prior to acquisition, the first applicant held the land as trustee of the DLFCMS Property Trust. Mr D Fitch may be described as the driving force behind the establishment of KKM on the land. In about 2005, an investment vehicle part owned by Mr D Fitch owned undeveloped land at Golden Grove. With the help of others, the investment company established a childcare centre on that land. That childcare centre opened in 2007 and was known as Iddy Biddy Kids (IBK). In 2013, G8 Education Ltd (G8), an ASX listed provider of early childhood education, offered to acquire IBK. Mr D Fitch and the equity investors, his brother (Mr Matthew Fitch) and Mr Brian Carr, sold IBK. That sale was completed in about November 2013. At the time of the sale, Ms Joanne Heron (Ms Heron) and Ms Mikaeli Foster (Ms Foster) were working for IBK as the director and assistant director respectively. After the sale, Ms Foster and Ms Heron continued working for G8 at the childcare centre at Golden Grove which was rebranded as Golden Grove World of Learning (GGWOL). The land was purchased on 7 September 2015 with the intention of building and operating the childcare centre which became KKM. Ms Heron and Ms Foster were involved in the design of KKM. In 2016, KKM was established to operate a childcare centre on the land which would be leased from the trustee. Since the incorporation of KKM, the shareholders and directors have been Mr Brian Carr, Mr Richard Fogarty, Ms Foster, Ms Heron, Mr Bill Papaioannou and Mr D Fitch. All shareholders contributed only nominal capital of $1 per share. An L class share has no right to receive dividends but provides certain voting rights at shareholder meetings. Initially, and in the context of the establishment of KKM, it was the position of both Ms Foster and Ms Heron that they only wanted to work in a childcare centre owned by Mr D Fitch. Mr D Fitch was nonetheless adamant that both women should have equity. Mr D Fitch valued both women, their prior relationship, and their performance at IBK. Mr D Fitch arranged for entities related to him to loan KKM the startup capital without interest. With respect to KKM, Mr D Fitch was nominated as the ‘provider’ for the centre pursuant to the Education and Care Services National Law (SA).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Later, I will set out some of the evidence with respect to the above factors. For the moment, it can be observed that all of the above had been in place since KKM opened. These were all matters that had, subject to the business decision with respect to KKGG, been in place throughout the life of KKM. Any business decision with respect to KKGG was not a consideration in the period 1 July 2019 to 15 December 2019. As set out above, in the period 1 July 2019 to 15 December 2019, the average weekly occupancy had reached 86 per cent, significantly below 95 per cent. In short, in the time that KKM had been open it had not grown its occupancy to 95 per cent. The submission of the second applicant is that it has established KKM would have done so by February 2020, bearing in mind that the occupancy had only reached 86 per cent in the period just mentioned. Other evidence about occupancy rate As set out above, Mr Holmes was prepared to accept a budget forecast prepared by KKM which set out an occupancy in February 2020. The witness who prepared the forecast occupancy of KKM was Ms Foster, but her evidence must be viewed in light of all the evidence, including the evidence of Ms Heron and Mr D Fitch. Ms Foster As set out earlier, KKM was able to provide daycare to 152 children at a time each day, but it was possible to have more than 152 children attend on a single day. Ms Foster gave evidence that it was expected the occupancy rate would rise throughout the 2019/2020 financial year and reach 95 per cent by February 2020. That projection was said to be based upon ‘our operating methods and experience’. In particular, ‘years of previous experience managing Iddy Biddy Kids at a high occupancy level’. On the evidence of Ms Foster, KKM had advantages which would drive the occupancy rate well above that of the average childcare centre. Her evidence included the following:[50] The building was designed by [Ms Heron] and me to maximise its effectiveness, it was new and attractive, and was located in a highly prominent location with easy vehicle access and egress. We intensely managed room numbers and booked places to above “ratio levels”. We managed room places by individual transitioning and flexible age ranges within rooms. We had the support of the owners to use our discretion to intensively manage out staffing to ensure compliance. We used a primary caring philosophy which encourages carer continuity for the child and builds confidence with parents, making them more likely to pick up extra days and to recommend the centre. Our opening hours were long (6:30am to 6:30pm) and we catered to all pre‑school age groups (whereas some centres do not take babies). [50] Affidavit of Mikaeli Kelda Foster dated 13 April 2022, Exhibit A5 [59.1]–[59.4] (JTB vol 1, 43). As above, Ms Foster also relied upon the performance at IBK where she said that high occupancy rates were achieved and sometimes exceeded 100 per cent occupancy. The evidence of Ms Foster also included that KKGG achieved, or exceeded, a 95 per cent occupancy rate in the latter half of 2020.[51] Ms Foster also gave evidence that in November 2023, KKGG had achieved an occupancy of over 100 per cent on two days a week.[52] [51] Affidavit of Mikaeli Kelda Foster dated 13 April 2022, Exhibit A5 Annexure MKF12 (JTB vol 1, 464). [52] T146.31-37.

Decision

Reasons for decision

In the circumstances, the first applicant has not established on the balance of probabilities that the land should be valued on the assumption that it was subject to a lease period of 20 years. To proceed on that basis would be to give the land a value greater than market value. The market value of the land – conclusion The difference in the two valuations on the basis of a 10‑year lease term is very limited. Both valuations are based upon the same methodology. I am unable to favour one over the other. It follows the first applicant should be compensated for the land at the figure of $7,510,000 determined by Mr Schwarz. I so find. Orders I make the following orders: 1.The value of the first applicant’s freehold interest in the land is to be determined by reference to the terms of the lease in place at the date of acquisition. On that basis, the land value is $7,510,000.00 plus interest calculated from the date of acquisition. 2.The second applicant is entitled to compensation on account of the loss of the value to it of the business extinguished by reason of the compulsory acquisition of the land on the basis of: a) an occupancy rate of 86 per cent;b) a daily fee per child of $121;c) an earnings multiple of 4.3.3.The second applicant is entitled to lost profits arising from its decision to inform clients on 16 December 2019 of the impending acquisition and to cease trading on 21 February 2020. 4.As to the amount of compensation to which the second applicant is entitled for lost profits:a) the appropriate methodology is a comparison of EBITDA in fact earned between 16 December 2019 and 16 April 2020 as against the counterfactual revenue that should have been earned in the same period; b) the occupancy rate to be used to calculate revenue is 86 per cent; c) the daily fee used to calculate revenue is $121; d) the calculation of lost profits is not impacted by the COVID‑19 pandemic. The amount of $55,000.00 should not be included. 5.The second applicant is entitled to an amount of compensation in respect of redundancy payments to staff of $104,461.81. 6.A reduction of $9,920.00 is to be made from any further compensation to the second applicant. 7.Pursuant to s 33 of the Act, interest is calculated on any amounts payable to the first and second applicants and from the date of acquisition. 8.The issue of whether the applicants’ legal costs and disbursements (legal and expert valuers) are part of the compensation under the Act payable to one or both of the applicants and, if so, the basis on which each applicant is entitled to calculate its claim for legal costs and disbursements is deferred until the parties have considered orders 1–7 above. Specifically, the following issues are deferred:a) Does compensation under ss 22B and 25(1) of the Act include fees to lawyers and expert valuers? b) Are legal costs incurred by the applicants prior to the referral of questions into Court to be assessed differently from legal costs incurred by the applicants after the issue of proceedings, and if so, how?

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Ms Heron also said that the primary care model also benefits staff. Ms Heron said that childcare centre managers and staff are sometimes resistant to implementing a primary care model because they think it will be too hard. Ms Heron acknowledged that this model requires close attention to staffing. However, in the view of Ms Heron, properly implemented, once relationships are established, a primary care model makes staff members’ lives easier. It also devolves a greater degree of responsibility for decision making about the child to the primary carer. Operation hours of the business KKM offered childcare between 6.30am to 6.30pm. Principles of compensation Section 22B of the Act confers a right to compensation for the divestment of a person’s interest in land when the freehold estate is acquired. It provides: 22B—Entitlement to compensation Subject to this Act, a person is entitled to compensation for the acquisition of land under this Act if— (a) the person's interest in land is divested or diminished by the acquisition; or (b) the enjoyment of the person's interest in land is adversely affected by the acquisition. Section 25 sets out certain principles governing the determination of the amount of compensation. They include the following: 25—Principles of compensation (1)The compensation payable under this Act in respect of the acquisition of land shall be determined according to the following principles: (a) the compensation payable to a claimant shall be such as adequately to compensate him for any loss that he has suffered by reason of the acquisition of the land; and (b) in assessing the amount referred to in paragraph (a) of this section consideration may be given to— (i)the actual value of the subject land; and (ii)the loss occasioned by reason of severance, disturbance or injurious affection; and (c) compensation shall be fixed as at the date of acquisition of the land; … In assessing what an applicant has lost by reason of the acquisition of the land, the Court is to assess what price would be reached by a ‘willing but not anxious seller and a willing but not anxious buyer, bearing in mind all material business considerations’.[11] The Court is to have regard to the views of both the person in the position of the seller and also the approach of the willing but not anxious buyer. [11] Emerald Quarry Industries Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Highways [No 2] (1976) 18 SASR 438, 477. The valuation methodology set out in Spencer v Commonwealth is to be applied:[12] … the test of value of land is to be determined, not by inquiring what price a man desiring to sell could actually have obtained for it on a given day, ie, whether there was in fact on that day a willing buyer, but by inquiring ‘What would a man desiring to buy the land have had to pay for it on that day to a vendor willing to sell it for a fair price but not desirous to sell?’ It is, no doubt, very difficult to answer such a question, and any answer must be to some extent conjectural. The necessary mental process is to put yourself as far as possible in the position of persons conversant with the subject at the relevant time, and from that point of view to ascertain what, according to the then current opinion of land values, a purchaser would have had to offer for the land to induce such a willing vendor to sell it, or, in other words, to inquire at what point a desirous purchaser and a not unwilling vendor would come together.[12] (1907) 5 CLR 418, 432 per Griffith CJ.The value of the business – introduction